Markus Lanz und Richard David Precht erwähnen, reagieren und loben mich in ihrem ZDF-Podcast. Doch ganz einverstanden bin ich mit ihrem Lob nicht. Besser gesagt stimme ich Richard David Precht nicht ganz zu in seiner Analyse, dass guter Journalismus immer häufiger von Leuten wie mir auf YouTube gemacht wird. In meiner Reaktion auf ihren Podcast gehe ich auf ein paar ihrer Punkte ein und erkläre euch auch, warum ich der Meinung bin, dass YouTuber wie @AliciaJoe, @Parabelritter (und viele mehr) von Journalismus der „alten“ Medienhäufer profitieren.
Marvin Neumann ist Redakteur und Journalist. In Deutschland lebend, berichtet er über gesellschaftliche und politische Themen. Mal aktuell, mal Vergangenes, aber immer mit Respekt und Anstand. Der Drang nach Ausgewogenheit und Fairness ist fundamentaler Bestandteil der Inhalte. Für geschäftliche Anfragen folgende E-Mail verwenden: [email protected]
________
Netiquette-Kommentarsektion: Die Kommentarsektionen unter meinen Videos oder Community Tab-Posts sind dazu da, um mit euch zu kommunizieren und zu interagieren. Immer respektvoll, mit Anstand und Blick auf die Gefühle des Gegenüber. Kritik darf, soll und muss geäußert werden. Letztere Aussagen/ Kommentare müssen aber auf Grundlage des deutschen Rechts stehen, als auch international vereinbarte Menschenrechte wahren.
Ich behalte mir vor bei Nichteinhaltung eines respektvollen Umgangtons oder rechtswidrigem Verhalten Kommentare zu löschen oder einzelne Kommentatoren zu blockieren.
Respekt ist Grundbaustein für eine nachhaltige und gesunde Diskussionskultur. Bitte beherzigt dies! _________
Patreon-Unterstützer:
Achim Reiser DrRush Mr. Koalabär Torsten Scheithauer Andre Rütgers Mathis WIchmann David Sophie Walther Der Fellmacher Emilia Kirner Christopher Stahl Emilia Kirner
I think there is someone on YouTube who made an effort to record all of this in silence.
I watched it. Marvin Neumann. Greetings at this point.
By the way, also to Atze. I completely forgot about that earlier.
I don't know what to say. Markus Lanz and Richard David Precht reacted to my video about them.
To this video here, which has now received more than 160,000 views and went pretty viral.
This video here by Markus Lanz and Richard David Precht is going viral right now.
We have become such an incredibly sensitive society.
Yes, such a oat milk society.
And I haven't watched the video yet. I have no idea what they are saying about me.
And I thought I'd save that for this video here.
We'll watch the whole thing together and see what they have to say about me.
The only thing I know, because I received a message or two from you on Instagram,
that they are probably praising me.
My first reaction on Instagram was,
I'm not quite sure if I generally like it, if they praise me.
I'm definitely curious what they have to say.
Let's take a look together. Here we go.
Did you actually notice that we were part of the media summer lodge?
Yes, I noticed that on a summer trip.
And the theme was Precht and Lanz blabbering about young people.
And the occasion was a conversation, not a podcast at all,
but a conversation in March, I think it was, in Munich at the craft congress.
I can remember that conversation well.
Exactly. And I really liked it back then, because we both appreciate crafts very much.
And it was nice to get into a conversation with the people there.
And I have to say, I was irritated about this topic.
We blabber about young people and then a few people came out, young people.
We both made a whole episode about Generation Z.
And I myself said on TV how much I like them, how much I like them.
And then they go forward and fall over us in a way that I didn't like.
And the theme was always, we would have blabbered about them, so to speak.
And it was also related to this one sentence of mine.
We have become a really sensitive society, such a oat milk group.
I'll take a short break at this point.
Of course, it can annoy you when you have the feeling that your statements have been taken out of context.
Personally, I would have been happy if you would have gone to the points of criticism first.
But maybe that will still come.
To the points of criticism that were brought to you and that you are confronted with.
And then you can sort of clean it up from behind.
That's the way it is.
The demands of the generation today are no longer the same demands of the generation that we had
and not at all those that our parents or grandparents had.
But it is in fact the case that today you expect far less encouragement from your field of work
than you used to have to take for granted, whether you wanted to or not.
Right.
We, for example, are very happy that my children are saved.
Exactly.
So the kind of exploitation that I have experienced, for example,
I don't want any of my children to ever experience that.
We were good at exploiting because there were so many of us.
Right.
I am 64 years old, which is the age of birth.
And it's good that he mentions this again, Richard David Precht.
And that was also, among other things, or I also picked up on that in my video,
the reason why young people today can afford to make demands
and to say, we don't want it that way anymore, is because they are needed.
Because the labor market can no longer reach for people at will,
but the labor market now has to make an effort and say,
we can deliver that and we will come to you with what should actually be self-evident in parts.
That's exactly what I actually mentioned in my video,
but that's a point that actually came a little too short in their talk, I have to say.
And I described this process.
I said for our parents and grandparents life was not a wish concert.
Today it is much more of a wish concert, not for everyone, but for many.
And that's right, he also said that in the talk.
I think here, again, framing is just important,
because life is not a wish concert.
It sounds a little different like, hey, the labor market,
or vice versa, there are no longer so many people on the labor market.
At that time you couldn't make demands,
although you should and should have made them.
And today it works.
I think that has a completely different tone than when you say,
life is a wish concert, is not a wish concert, and somehow it is today.
So I think it has a completely different tone.
And then I can read in the press,
I would have celebrated the good old days, so to speak.
Yes, we didn't do that.
Of course you ask yourself, you know,
I sometimes stand on my feet with journalism.
If you write something like that,
and then you also write a very long article on Spiegel Online.
And with the whole context of the story,
not even researched, not even the whole conversation is heard.
And then write a judgment together.
I mean, that doesn't even meet the smallest minimum standards of journalism,
where you have to look at what they were talking about,
in what context, how was the whole conversation.
I think there is someone on YouTube
who has made an effort to work it all out in peace.
Yes, I looked at him, Marvin Neumann.
Greetings at this point, also to Atze, I completely forgot earlier.
Marvin Neumann has seen it for the first time and has taken it apart.
Yes, okay.
I think that's really ...
So, yes, greetings back to Mr. Lanz and Mr. Precht.
And I do my work here as well as I can,
journalistically on YouTube.
But when it really leaves a mark
and people really talk about it,
it's always a very strange feeling for me.
He made the effort to work it all out in peace.
Yes, I looked at him, Marvin Neumann.
Greetings at this point, also to Atze, I completely forgot earlier.
Marvin Neumann has seen it all for the first time and has taken it apart
and has also dealt with us critically, as it should be.
But he came to a completely different conclusion.
I liked that.
The other thing was partly from the department,
too much research also destroys the beautiful story.
Yes, but it is also a sign for our time
that we often find stories or representations on YouTube
that are more elaborated, more precise and more honest
than what so-called quality media do to journalists.
You have to say that in this clarity.
There was another thought.
I have to stop there and pause for a moment,
because I don't think I can leave it that way.
Many YouTubers and people like me who do their work here,
but also many journalists from the different media houses,
newspapers, television and so on and so forth,
all benefit from each other, from each other's work.
Things that I also mentioned in my video,
I came across them, among other things,
because I found them in, as Mr. Precht says here,
in quality media, or as he describes them, whatever.
So because I found them there and I continued to look into them,
I continued to research them and then looked,
okay, is that right?
What can you do with it?
And so on and so forth.
So in my video, I talked about this aforementioned quality journalism.
I benefited from it.
And I used information that was also given there for further research.
Secondly, I have to put my cell phone aside.
It's nothing new at all that we find well-done journalism
on YouTube-TikTok-Instagram these days.
I don't think he means it as blatantly as I might now represent it.
So in the case of the defendant, of course, now.
But I think there is still a basic understanding of YouTube-online.
It's still a rusted bubble somehow.
It's not like that anymore, and it hasn't been like that for a long time.
Since, I would even say,
at the latest since the introduction or at least since the presence of Funk,
it's not like that anymore.
And don't get me wrong,
I don't want to say that Funk has put the quality standard of journalism
on a non-plus-ultra.
No, that's not what I mean.
But Funk has shown at least once, no matter how you look at it,
that journalism can work on the social media platform of large media houses.
And it was and is still one of the great role models for many, many media houses.
Many out there.
And I also notice on my channel and also in the competition that I see on YouTube
that the quality standard on YouTube has increased dramatically in recent years.
That the market is struggling hard in journalism, also on YouTube.
So I don't think you can necessarily say that it is indicative
that we can expect more from people like me or even see better pieces on YouTube
than from, quote-unquote, quality journalists.
Because, as I said, I, I also believe, without knowing exactly now,
but also someone like the Parable Knight or Alicia Joe
or a few others who will be mentioned, who are not all members of Funk now.
I think we all benefit from journalists,
as well as from the SZ, from the FAZ,
in my opinion also from the Spiegel or from the ARD, from the Tagesschau and so on and so forth.
I don't think you should forget that.
But it came to a completely different conclusion.
I liked that a lot.
The other thing was, in part, from the department,
too much research then destroys the beautiful story.
I would just like to know what the other conclusion was, to be exact.
Because at the end of the day, my conclusion was,
you are not really right in what you say,
but you have to look at it in a differentiated way and then see the whole context
and maybe let it come to the language again.
I don't know what that means now.
I don't think anything for me.
I think it's nice or interesting that a video like this from me
somehow even reaches the people you address somewhere.
I mean, things like that are made especially for you,
to understand such things better.
Also made for me, so that I understand these things better.
I mean, you have to consider, I look at something like this and don't know the answers right away.
Or of course I don't know the numbers to what they said right away.
I have to research that first, to understand it first.
So my basic idea was, I said that at the beginning of my video,
hey, I saw that, but I know that something like that has happened a thousand times,
that such small snippets were taken, which were torn apart.
And if you look at it before and after, look at the context,
then you could possibly get a different picture.
And that's what I tried to do in the video and then started researching.
So these things are just for me, for you and maybe also for the people you address.
That's why it's exciting to see that something like this will arrive at Markus Lanz and Richard David Precht.
Greetings go out.
Otherwise, thank you for watching.
Feel free to watch the original video for it and like this video or subscribe if you liked it.
You don't have to do that, however you like.
We'll see you again next time.
Your Marvin and until then.