The Tudors: Henry VIII - The King's Great Matter and the Quest for a Divorce - Episode 18

Henry VIII of England
2 followers
This is I'm Stuck and in this video we will be looking at the King's Great Matter and
his quest for a divorce. So first of all we will look at what is the King's Great Matter.
Because by the mid 1520s Henry had started to become dissatisfied with his marriage.
Now his wife was Catherine of Aragon and she was six years older than Henry VIII and she
was now past childbearing age. Now they had tried on multiple occasions for an heir to
the throne yet only one child had managed to survive infancy and this was Princess Mary,
obviously not the boy that Henry VIII wanted. Now Henry had even tried to make his illegitimate
son who was Henry Fitzroy who was born under the mistress Bessie Blount the heir to the
throne. Now matters were further complicated when Henry had become besotted with Anne Boleyn
in 1527. But unlike Anne Boleyn's sister Mary Boleyn who was previously Henry VIII's mistress
and was unwilling to become Henry's mistress and instead wanted his marriage with Catherine
annulled. So this meant that Wolsey was the man faced with this extremely difficult task.
And normally it would have been a lot easier to get an annulment however it was harder to obtain
due to the situation of Pope Clement VII and Charles V. Now Charles V was the Emperor and Clement VII
was the Pope at the time. Now at this time the Emperor had taken over Rome and the Pope was now
under control of Charles V and seeing as Catherine of Aragon was Charles V's nephew he was not
prepared to see his family insulted. Therefore Wolsey had to try many different methods to try
and get Henry VIII's marriage annulled and these are the methods that we will go through now.
So the first method he tried was based on the Bible and in Leviticus it states that a man should
not marry his brother's widow otherwise they will be left childless. And seeing as Catherine of Aragon
had previously been married to Prince Arthur who was Henry VIII's older brother this seemed a
valid point. However Catherine claimed that her marriage with Arthur had not been consummated
and therefore the biblical ban would not apply. Now many theologians also disagreed with the
meaning of the phrase as they believed it referred to when your brother was still alive
and seeing as Arthur had died many years earlier this would therefore not take into place. Now this
can be shown by Deuteronomy which says it is a brother's duty to marry their brother's widow
and have children on his behalf. Now the second method was about the diplomatic manoeuvres and
this was to directly attack Charles V who was the real inconvenience in the marriage proceedings.
Now therefore Wolsey tried to free the Pope from Charles' influence by using an alliance with France
to renew warfare in Italy. However this policy failed because Charles V has such great
control in the Italian peninsula. So finally Wolsey wanted to hold the divorce proceedings
in England to avoid the problems of Charles V and because Wolsey was a papal legate
he would be able to make the judgment. Now this meant that the Pope sent Cardinal Campeggio over
to hear the divorce hearings. However as he didn't want to upset Charles V he sent Cardinal
Campeggio with instructions to delay the hearing and make sure that a decision was never reached.
Now although Wolsey hoped that Campeggio would be cooperative he was genuinely unwell and he did
take months to reach England and then when he did reach England everything was done extremely
thoroughly and slowly. Now when the court met in June 1529 Catherine of Aragon refused to recognise
it and appealed to the Pope to move the hearing back to Rome and as the Pope wanted to delay this
hearing and he didn't want to upset Charles V as he was under control from Charles V
he agreed with his proposition as it would further delay it. Ultimately Henry realised that he would
not be able to secure a divorce under Wolsey and that a change was required and this is why next
video we will be looking at the end of Wolsey's reign and his fall and decline. So thank you and see you soon, bye.
