Why is this black hole wobbling so fast?

Tech Boss
138 followers
25 Video Views·Dec 7, 2022
This video is sponsored by Magellan TV. A black hole less than 8,000 light years away is slowly
devouring its companion star. As it does so, it fires jets of plasma at nearly half the speed of
light. The system is V404 Cygni, and astronomers have discovered that the black hole is wobbling.
But if that weren't strange enough, it's actually dragging the fabric of the universe around with
Welcome back to Launch Pad, I'm Christian Ready, your friendly neighborhood astronomer.
And in this video, we're going to look at one of the strangest findings from a nearby black hole.
But first, I'd like to thank Magellan TV for sponsoring today's video.
Now if you're into black holes, Magellan TV has you covered. I've personally enjoyed the
birth of a black hole, black hole starships, and black holes the other side of infinity.
New programs are added on a weekly basis and can be watched anytime,
anywhere on your television, laptop, or mobile device. It's compatible with Roku,
Amazon Fire TV, Apple TV, Google Play, and iOS. You can even cast from your phone to your TV.
Magellan offers a wide selection of programs, including beautiful 4K content at no additional
cost. Best of all, my viewers can enjoy a one-month trial absolutely free, so make sure
you check them out. V404 Cygni lies about 7,800 light-years in the constellation Cygnus the Swan.
It's a binary system that's home to a black hole about nine times the Sun's mass.
The black hole was likely formed in a core collapse supernova. If a star's core reaches 2.8
solar masses or greater, there's no force in the universe that will prevent its complete
and utter collapse into oblivion. To form a nine-solar-mass black hole, the original star
would have had to have been gargantuan, probably around 40 solar masses. As we learned in our
previous video on how stars work, the more massive the star is, the shorter its lifetime. So this
black hole probably formed some billions of years ago. However, its companion star couldn't be any
more different. It's a K-type subgiant star that's 70% the mass of the Sun. It exhausted its supply
of hydrogen fuel and is in the process of swelling up to become a red giant. The star orbits the
black hole in just six and a half days. They're so close together the black hole siphons off material
from the star. Because of the star's sideways motion relative to the black hole, matter spirals
inward to form an accretion disk around the black hole. As matter in the disk draws closer to the
black hole, it moves faster until it reaches nearly the speed of light. As slower matter in the
surrounding disk grinds against the faster material, friction heats the disk to millions
of degrees. This causes the disk to become incredibly bright, especially at x-ray wavelengths.
In fact, it's this intense x-ray signature that made it possible to detect the stellar-mass black
holes that we know of today. After all, black holes don't radiate, so we rely on their accretion
disks to reveal their presence. As their name implies, accretion disks are thought to feed
black holes, causing them to grow. But exactly how this happens isn't completely understood.
But we do understand that the spinning disk generates a powerful magnetic field. This field
rips matter off the disk and launches it along the black hole's spin axis as a jet.
But from time to time, the jet becomes unstable and unleashes violent bursts of plasma.
These eruptions are extremely powerful. In 2015, NASA's Swift satellite detected a powerful x-ray
surge coming from V404 Cygni. It was its first outburst since 1989. Over the next several days,
Swift detected x-rays echoing off the surrounding dust.
V404 Cygni quickly became the brightest x-ray source in the sky, becoming 50 times brighter
than the Crab Pulsar. It got so bright that even optical and radio telescopes could see it.
Astronomers began a worldwide campaign to study the outburst in unprecedented detail.
One team of astronomers used the Very Long Baseline Array to make high-resolution radio
images of the outburst. VLBA is a series of radio telescopes that make simultaneous observations.
When their signals are linked together via interferometry, they act as a telescope nearly
the size of the Northern Hemisphere. They hoped they'd catch the jets moving away from the black
hole, but what they found was really weird. As expected, the black hole was ejecting blobs of
plasma, each about a thousand times brighter than the Sun. But instead of firing perpendicular to
the disk, the jets' directions were changing rapidly, shifting back and forth in just a couple of hours.
It was as if they were being fired from a black hole-powered x-ray water sprinkler.
The obvious question then is why were the jets wobbling so fast? Well, it took a while to know
for sure, but astronomers have figured out that the inner disk is precessing like a gyroscope.
And the disk is precessing so rapidly because, get this, the black hole is dragging spacetime
around it. This is an effect predicted by Einstein's theory of general relativity.
Massive objects distort spacetime, kind of like the way a bowling ball distorts a mattress.
But as the object rotates, it drags the surrounding spacetime along with it. This is known as the
Lenz-Thiering effect, named for the two Austrian physicists who derived it. But it's better known
as frame dragging. It's kind of like spinning a ball in a bowl of syrup. As the ball spins,
the syrup forms a slow-moving whirlpool around the ball. The syrup closer to the ball moves
faster than the syrup farther away. Relativity predicts that spacetime should behave the same
way. This effect was directly measured by NASA's Gravity Probe B. The spacecraft was fitted with
a freely spinning gyroscope. As the space closer to the Earth moved faster than the space farther
away, the spin axis of the gyroscope drifted sideways to point back to the Earth over time.
Although the effect was real, it turned out to be a very difficult measurement to make
because the Earth has such low mass and rotates kind of slow. But a black hole is much more
massive and rotates a lot faster. Instead of a subtle twist, it forms a tornado of spacetime.
In V404 Cygni's case, the black hole isn't just spinning, but it's doing so at an angle with
respect to the orbit of its sub-giant companion. Matter flowing from the star into the disk stays
in the same plane as the star's orbit, but as it draws closer to the black hole, it gets caught up
in the spacetime tornado and gets tilted with respect to the outer disk. The intense radiation
from the eruption puffs up the inner disk, forming a tall donut of plasma. This plasma
donut grinds against the outer disk at an angle, creating friction. The friction between a spinning
object and the surrounding surface causes the object to precess. It's the reason a spinning
top wobbles due to friction with the tabletop. In fact, Earth precesses once every 26,000 years
because of its axial tilt and the constant gravitational torque from the Moon. But the
near the black hole precesses in just a couple of hours, 2.6 hours at the most, but that is a
very conservative estimate. It's probably much quicker, perhaps on the order of minutes. We've
never seen this effect happening on such short timescales. The companion star exerts a torque
on the black hole, but it's just one billionth of the torque required to produce the observed effect.
On the other hand, frame dragging by the black hole avoids torque altogether.
It just twists the spacetime around it, precessing the disk. The jets wobble by about 36 degrees back
and forth, which suggests that the black hole's spin axis must be tilted by about 18 degrees.
So the next question is, why is the black hole tilted in the first place?
Well, the most likely reason is that it was kicked during the supernova that formed it.
Supercomputer simulations show that supernovae are messy and not perfectly symmetrical. It's
very possible that this was the case in 404 Cygni's supernova as well. That could have
knocked the black hole off by about 18 degrees, creating the misalignment that we see today.
The 2015 outburst was extremely short-lived, and hopefully in a couple of decades it'll
erupt again and we'll be able to see if this black hole's precession has in fact changed.
Like I said, there's a lot we don't yet understand about how black holes accrete
matter from their disks, and how these jets are launched. Observations like these provide
critical insights into understanding how black holes work. Oh, and you probably heard the news
that astronomers took the first ever image of a black hole last year. I mean, it was in all the
papers, right? Anyway, I made a video on that which you may want to take a look at next.
My thanks once again to my patrons for keeping Launch Pad Astronomy going,
and I'd like to welcome my newest patrons Sebastian and Hiroshi, along with a shout
out to my cosmological patrons Michael Dowling and Steven J. Morgan. If you'd like to support
Launch Pad for the price of a cup of coffee, check out my Patreon page. And if you want to
join me on this journey through this incredible universe of ours, well please make sure to
subscribe and ring that notification bell so that you don't miss out on any new videos.
Until next time, stay curious my friends.
