How OSIRIS-REx TAGged asteroid Bennu - and got away with it.

Tech Boss
138 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 7, 2022
This video is sponsored by Magellan TV.
Welcome back to Launch Pad, I'm Christian Ready, your friendly neighborhood astronomer.
And it's an amazing time here on planet Earth because NASA's OSIRIS-REx spacecraft
is bringing home a can of asteroid.
There's probably some other stuff going on, but this one really held my attention, I can tell you.
Anyway, OSIRIS-REx stands for Origins Spectral Interpretation
Resource Identification Security Regolith Explorer.
It's a mouthful, but the name symbolizes what the mission is all about.
Asteroids are the leftover rubble from the formation of our solar system,
and they've played a role in the formation of our home planet while at the same time
playing a role in the extinction of up to 99% of the species that ever lived on Earth.
To date, we know of roughly a million asteroids,
most of which are concentrated in a belt between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter.
But despite their reputation as being giant hunks of planet-killing debris,
many asteroids remain largely undisturbed since they formed over 4.5 billion years ago.
So having a sample of an asteroid gives us a look into our solar system's past.
And on October 20th, OSIRIS-REx went and grabbed a huge sample of the asteroid Bennu,
and will be bringing it home for us to study in unprecedented detail in 2023.
But doing so wasn't as easy as first thought.
Instead of the soft, sandy surface that the science team had expected,
Bennu turned out to be a world with large rocks and boulders strewn everywhere.
This required a lot of clever modifications to the mission.
So while we were waiting for OSIRIS-REx to return,
I thought it would be fun to talk a little bit about this mission,
and how a team of insanely talented scientists and engineers
came up with the largest celestial smash and grab since the Apollo program.
But first, I would like to thank Magellan TV, who are very kindly sponsoring today's video.
Magellan is a news streaming service featuring content on history, art, nature,
and of course, space and science.
I especially enjoyed Day of the Asteroid, an episode in Magellan's Cosmic Journeys series.
Now, I'm not really losing any sleep over an imminent asteroid impact,
but this episode dives into the risks asteroids pose to Earth,
and the methods scientists are developing to deflect a potential impactor.
New programs are added weekly, and can be watched on Roku,
Amazon Fire TV, Apple TV, Google Play, and iOS.
Best of all, Magellan TV has a special offer just for my viewers.
By signing up at the link below, you'll get an extra month of Magellan TV absolutely free.
Please make sure to use the link in the description of this video.
OSIRIS-REx marks the fourth sample return mission from a comet or asteroid.
The first was in 2004, when NASA's Stardust spacecraft flew to the coma of Comet Wild 2.
It extended what is essentially a tennis racket filled with a substance called aerogel.
As Stardust flew through the coma, tiny particles of dust got trapped in the aerogel,
and the samples were returned to Earth in 2006.
In 2005, the Japanese space agency JAXA sent its Hayabusa spacecraft to the asteroid Itokawa,
which is a small rubble pile about 350 meters across.
The mission was plagued with problems,
and they even lost communications with the spacecraft at one point.
But after they recovered the spacecraft, a small sample was collected,
and its return capsule landed in Australia in June 2010.
Hayabusa was deemed a successful failure in that they saved the spacecraft and managed
to return a sample, but the sample size was much smaller than hoped,
and that put a limit on the amount of science that could be done afterwards.
JAXA learned a great deal from the Hayabusa mission, and in 2018,
the much-improved Hayabusa 2 spacecraft arrived at the asteroid Ryugu.
Ryugu looks a lot like Bennu. Both asteroids have a shape that kind of resembles a toy top.
However, Ryugu is larger than Bennu and seems to have much less water.
Anyway, after deploying some rovers to recon the surface,
Hayabusa 2 collected samples from two separate regions of the asteroid.
It's currently on its way home, and will return its samples to Earth in December 2020.
But four years ago, OSIRIS-REx embarked on its journey to Bennu.
Like any piece of real estate, this particular asteroid was chosen for its location.
Bennu's orbit crosses Earth's, and yes, it qualifies as a potentially hazardous asteroid as
well. Although, there's really no chance of it hitting Earth any time soon.
But not only is Bennu close, it's also thought to be relatively primitive and unprocessed.
That makes it rich in carbon, organic compounds, and water-bearing clays.
Exactly the stuff that astronomers believe asteroids may have brought to Earth a couple
of billion years ago. Finally, Bennu was chosen because it was thought to be
sandy and therefore easy to sample. There were several reasons for this assumption.
Infrared data from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope showed that its surface rapidly heats up when
exposed to sunlight and quickly cools at night, much like beach sand here on Earth.
Additionally, radar observations from the Arecibo and Goldstone telescopes
suggested the surface was smooth, and its equatorial ridge was thought to be caused
by loose material piling up at the equator as the asteroid spun. So, by every remote
sensing measurement, Bennu should have been covered in loose, easy-to-grab regolith.
It wasn't. When OSIRIS-REx arrived at Bennu in August 2018, they found it looked an awful
lot like Ryugu, but much smaller, about the size of a tall building. That meant Bennu would have a
much weaker gravitational field than Ryugu. So weak, in fact, that solar radiation pressure
can push OSIRIS-REx off course if not corrected. So orbiting the asteroid was going to be trickier
than thought. But as OSIRIS-REx surveyed Bennu, the real challenge of the mission became apparent.
Instead of a sandy beach with a few boulders here and there,
Bennu was a pile of spacecraft-killing boulders with a handful of small sand traps.
However, spectroscopy of the surface revealed that the rocks contained water, which makes
Bennu a hydrated asteroid. Despite Bennu's hazardous terrain, OSIRIS-REx had come to
the right place. The mission team were caught by yet another surprise. They noticed small
particles less than a centimeter across were ejecting off the surface. This was either due
to outgassing as it was warmed by sunlight, or by small micrometeoroid impacts. At first,
there was concern this could pose a hazard to the spacecraft. But the velocities of the particles
were so slow, it soon became clear that there was no danger the spacecraft would get obliterated
by debris. But the fact that Bennu was an active asteroid turned out to be a good thing.
Some of the ejected particles settled into a slow, lazy orbit around the asteroid. By tracking the
precise motions of those particles, the team could map out Bennu's gravitational field to a much
higher level of precision than they thought would be possible. That turned out to be critical for
navigating to a much smaller sample area than planned. The spacecraft used its laser altimeter
to make a highly detailed map of the surface all the way down to an elevation of about 5
centimeters. That allowed the team to identify four possible landing sites. A small crater
called Nightingale turned out to have the greatest abundance of fine-grained material.
Starting in early 2020, OSIRIS-REx made a series of low-altitude passes to image Nightingale at
a resolution as low as 3.5 millimeters per pixel. By examining Nightingale from multiple phase angles,
the team built up a robust 3D model of the landing site, down to individual pebbles less than a
centimeter across. This would be the site of the Touch-and-Go Maneuver, or TAG. In this maneuver,
the spacecraft's Touch-and-Go Sample Acquisition Mechanism, or TAGSAM arm, is extended. Upon
contact, TAGSAM fires a canister of nitrogen gas that stirs up regolith which gets trapped in the
outer rim. It's kind of like a reverse vacuum cleaner. It seems simple enough, but Nightingale
is much smaller than the mission bargained for. Instead of the planned 50-meter TAG zone,
Nightingale's sample area was just 8 meters across. That's about the size of a few parking spaces.
So the team had to come up with an all-new method of autonomously navigating to the site,
making sure it was in the right place, and collecting a sample without hitting a boulder.
The system was called Natural Feature Tracking. During approach, NFT compares images from the
navigation cameras to a detailed map of the target area to identify all possible hazards around the
When the spacecraft reaches an altitude of 5 meters, the NFT system would predict the contact
point of the surface and compare it to the hazard map. If it found that it was going to come down
in an unsafe area, the spacecraft could execute a wave-off burn. In order to navigate the very
subtle changes in Banu's gravitational field, the team also fine-tuned OSIRIS-REx's maneuvering
to make velocity changes with a precision less than 1 millimeter per second. As a result,
OSIRIS-REx would be able to make a safe contact with an area 10 times smaller than originally
designed. At least, that was the plan. To make sure the system could work, the team conducted
two TAG rehearsals, first in April and then again in August 2020. Each rehearsal brought
the spacecraft closer to Nightingale than it had come before. These rehearsals allowed the team to
test and verify all of the systems necessary for a successful TAG attempt. Finally, after nearly
two years of surveys, modeling, and rehearsals, OSIRIS-REx attempted its TAG maneuver on October
20, 2020. From its 1 kilometer orbit, TAG began with a propulsive burn to break orbit and transit
toward the vicinity of the Nightingale site. At an altitude of about 125 meters, the spacecraft
performed the checkpoint burn to put it on an intercept trajectory with the surface.
About 10 minutes later, 45 meters above Nightingale, thrusters fired again to perform the matchpoint
burn. This burn zeroed out the spacecraft's horizontal velocity to the surface,
thus matching the horizontal velocity of Nightingale while descending vertically.
Ten minutes later, the TAGSAM made contact with the surface, the nitrogen canister fired,
and the spacecraft backed away from Nightingale exactly as planned. And there was much rejoicing.
The next step was to verify how much material was actually collected before making the decision to
either stow the sample or attempt another TAG maneuver at one of the backup sites.
OSIRIS-REx had two more nitrogen bottles on board in case the sample didn't have enough mass.
But measuring mass in space is a little tricky when you don't have a gravity field.
I mean, sure, Bennu has gravity, but it's about 1 ten-millionth of a G.
It's simply too weak to be of any use. So the team came up with an ingenious plan to
weigh their sample by measuring the change in the spacecraft's moment of inertia.
Moment of inertia describes how mass is distributed around a rotating body.
So, prior to the TAG event, the spacecraft extended its TAGSAM arm and rotated to measure
its moment of inertia while empty. Then the same maneuver was going to be performed a second time
after collection. The difference in the moment of inertia would reveal how much mass had been
collected. But things didn't work out that way, for a really good reason. Once the team got a
look at the TAGSAM head, they could clearly see that it was full. In fact, it was so full it was
actually leaking regolith. So the verification maneuver was cancelled, and TAGSAM was stowed in
the sample return capsule. After a small tug test to verify everything was secure, the arm detached
from the sampler head, and the return capsule was closed. So yay, sample collected! All they've got
to do now is return it to Earth. To that end, OSIRIS-REx is scheduled to depart Bennu in March
2021 and begin its two and a half year cruise back to Earth. On September 24, 2023, the sample
return capsule will jettison and re-enter Earth's atmosphere before landing in Utah. And hopefully,
we'll get a TAGSAM head full of asteroid. Some of the regolith will be shared with NASA's
international partners, including JAXA, who in turn will share some of its Ryugu haul with NASA.
Hayabusa2 is going to return its sample to Earth next month, so get your electron
microscopes ready! Now, if everything goes well with OSIRIS-REx's sample return, what then? Well,
the spacecraft will certainly be out of the sample collection business. But if it's otherwise
healthy, mission scientists propose placing it into orbit around the asteroid Apophis in 2029.
Apophis is a 370 meter near-Earth asteroid that's predicted to come as close as the ring of
geostationary satellites around Earth. After Apophis' flyby, OSIRIS-REx will be in a position
to rendezvous with the asteroid. Sending OSIRIS-REx on an extended mission to Apophis would
be a lot less expensive than launching a new spacecraft. You know, 2020 has been a really
awful year in many respects, but it's nice to see something like this just worked after some
very clever people figured out how to pull it off. It's amazing what we can accomplish
when we work together. My thanks as always to my Patreon supporters for keeping Launch Pad
Astronomy going, and I'd like to welcome Andrew Walby as my newest patron, as well as a thank
you to Anna for her intergalactic level support, and to Michael Dowling, Stephen J. Morgan, and
Morrison Wilde for their cosmological level support. If you'd like to support Launch Pad
for the price of a cup of coffee every month, please head over to my Patreon page. And if
you'd like to join me on this journey through this incredible universe of ours, well please
make sure you subscribe and ring that notification bell so that you don't miss out on any new videos.
Until next time, stay home. Yes, I know, we still gotta stay home for a bit as much as we can.
Stay healthy, and stay curious, my friends.
