I Never Understood Why Black Holes Slow Down Time...Until Now!

Truth exists
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the intuition behind gravitational time dilation, moving beyond the simple idea that gravity \"slows time.\" By using Einstein's theories on acceleration and spacetime curvature, and utilizing a rotating spaceship as a conceptual model, it explains why clocks tick at different rates depending on their position within a gravitational field.
This video is sponsored by Brilliant.org. Do you remember that scene in the movie Interstellar
where Bran and Cooper decide to explore a planet very close to a black hole to see if it's
habitable but after a few hours, just few hours, they realize it's not so they turn back and even
though they come back in a few hours a lot of years would have passed for their friend Romilly
whom they left behind. So from their perspective the whole trip took only a few hours but from
his perspective he waited for years. How many years you ask? Well it's 23 years, four months,
eight days. And it's not just him, everyone on earth including his daughter Murphy would have
aged a lot. So the big question is why did this happen? Well the most common explanation,
explanation I should say, that I got is that gravity slows down time and therefore the time
very close to a black hole takes much slower, passes much slower compared to far away and that's
why they did not age much. But guess what? That's not an explanation. You said the same thing just by
using the words gravity and time now. It's kind of like saying apple is red because apple emits
red color. That's not an explanation. So for a long time I thought I wouldn't get any intuition behind
what's really going on over here until I read this book by the author, surprise surprise, Albert
Einstein. The book is called Relativity the Special and General Theory. It's a very thin book and
there is a section in this in which Einstein describes a beautiful way to think about this
which definitely gave me a lot of intuition and so I want to share that with you. So if you're ready
to understand what really happened over here instead of just saying gravity slows down time,
well let's begin. So where do we start? Well Einstein asks Mahesh what is gravity exactly?
Well I say you know gravity is the force of attraction between any two masses. It's the force
that the earth puts on us because of which the apple accelerates down and it's also the force
because of which I feel my own weight. And Einstein says cute, very cute Mahesh. But that is a Newtonian
model and in this model obviously you will not get any intuition for why clocks slow down close to
the planet. But remember according to Einstein's model there is no force of gravity at all. Nothing
is pulling down on us. Then why does the apple fall down? Why do we feel our weight? Well that's
because Einstein says it's the ground that is instead accelerating up to meet the apple. And
just like how when you are in a bus that suddenly accelerates forward you feel a backward jolt,
a jolt in the opposite direction, similarly on this accelerating ground we feel a downward jolt,
a jolt in the opposite direction which we think of it as gravity. But it's a fictitious force.
So in Einstein's model gravity is an artifact of being in an accelerated frame and guess what?
In an accelerated frame like this clocks will tick at different rates. But wait a second,
wait a second, we're getting ahead of ourselves. At this point immediately a question that should
come to our mind is Einstein if the ground is accelerating up and earth is round shouldn't
the same thing happening on the other side as well? Which means these two patches of earth
should be moving away from each other so the earth must be expanding. But clearly the earth
doesn't expand so I call this explanation baloney. And Einstein says here we go again. All right
Mahesh for a second completely forget whatever I just said and instead imagine we are in deep
intergalactic space where there's no gravity, no planets, nothing let's say. We just have these
two patches of you know ground accelerating towards each other. What's going to happen to
them? Well I say well if you accelerate them towards each other like say by putting rockets
well they'll eventually bump into each other right like. Well Einstein says of course that
would be the case if you use like rockets to accelerate them but there's another way to do
that. What if we attach them to a ring and make it spin? Okay what happens when you make it spin?
Well Einstein reminds us that when something is rotating they they experience a centripetal
acceleration, an acceleration towards the center. So both of them are accelerating towards the
center and yet look the distance between them is not decreasing. They're not coming closer to each
other and I'm like okay. All right let's look at it a little bit more closely. At this point
everything over here is moving to the right. So if you were to drop an apple then that apple would
also have a velocity to the right and so if you drop it it will continue moving to the right with
constant velocity because remember there are no forces over here. There's no gravity, there's no
planets, there's nothing right. So if you let go of an apple it should go to the right but at the
same time this whole patch of space and this whole patch of ground curves upwards. So see what happens
as the apple goes to the right eventually it'll be blocked by the ground and so notice from her
perspective it just feels like the apple fell down but notice the apple did not accelerate. The apple
is just following its straight line inertial path, Newton's first law. It is the ground that accelerated
up to meet the apple. The same thing is happening with her as well. Because of her inertia she
also wants to travel straight to the right but because the ground is accelerating up it's the
ground that's pushing her up and deviating her from a straight line path. So clearly you can see
it's the ground that's accelerating her up towards the center and as a result if there was a weighing
scale over here that weighing scale would get pressed and as a result she will feel her own
weight. So they will feel all the effects of gravity even though it's not there. So if you
were to zoom out a little bit just like how when a car takes a turn we experience an outward push,
a centrifugal force we call it, it's not that's not real. In a similar way look they're all the
both of them are experiencing an outward push which they will attribute as gravity. So we have
simulated gravity by accelerating them towards each other and look in that accelerated frame
they are at rest. Remember from their own perspective they are at rest with respect to
each other and it's the rest of the universe that's moving. So look there we have it. So if
these were Newton they would say that hey there is gravitational force acting down here and there
is a gravitational force acting down here and if these are Einstein they say uh-uh it's an artifact
of our ground accelerating up and yet the two pieces of ground are not moving towards each
other. It's possible. So Einstein now says okay Mahesh this means it's possible to have two pieces
of ground accelerating towards each other without moving towards each other like we are seeing over
here. Now if that is possible can't you be open to the possibility that it's possible the two pieces
of ground can accelerate away from each other without moving away from each other. Don't you
think that's possible? At least can you be open to that possibility? And I'm like yeah now that
you put it that way maybe it's possible but how? Over there it's the spin that makes it possible
over here what makes it possible? Well Einstein says it's a slightly more complicated over here
turns out it took him a lot of time to figure this out but turns out the space-time itself is curved
that curvature allows it to happen. Now I know calling space-time curvature doesn't help and
doesn't explain anything but we have made a detailed video on this where we talked about
this and we built models and whatnot to understand this in great detail but I'm gonna link onto it
but don't click on it. I don't want you to click on it right now because let's not get distracted
from it. So coming back over here if we were to summarize what we just learned from Einstein's
perspective there is no force of gravity it's an artifact of the ground that's just accelerating
up and even though ground is accelerating up there's a way to conceptualize this without
earth having to expand okay. Now here's the thing just like how gravity is an artifact of this
acceleration there's another artifact and that is that time or clocks will take differently time
will pass at different rates but how how does time pass say more quickly at a height because of
acceleration well Einstein says that's kind of like how Mahesh time passes for you very quickly
when you're completely immersed using brilliant.org the sponsor of this video I'm super glad that you
watch my videos thank you for doing that but to be honest if you want to master concepts you need
something more active that's why I love Brilliant it has hands-on interactive lessons in math
science programming data and AI and if you didn't know this already Brilliant courses are curated
by award-winning professors from reputed institutions like MIT, Caltech, Google and
they will courses in collaboration with some of my favorite youtubers as well so I think it's super
awesome for building problem-solving skills and making a daily learning habit mostly because you
can use it on your phone as well so it's super handy take a course on vectors for example you
probably know that vectors are super important to master physics right well in Brilliant it starts
as a game and using Brilliant interactive simulations it will help you visualize it
gain intuition behind it and eventually master all the basic operations transformations and whatnot
and then pretty soon you'll be able to apply all of it so if you think this is cool you can try
Brilliant for free you'll get everything Brilliant has to offer for free for a full 30 days by
visiting the link www.brilliant.org slash floated physics or you can click on the link in the
description as well of course through this link you'll also get a 20% off on your annual subscription
so do check them out I've been recommending them to my students from way before they started
sponsoring me so do check it out all right back to the video okay seriously now why is it that
in an accelerated frame clocks tick at different rates time passes at different rates at different
heights well for that Einstein says think about a rotating disk and I'm like come on rotating
disk that's so mundane give me something more interesting something more and Einstein says
all right Mahesh how about rotating interstellar spaceship and I'm like that's what we are talking
about rotations have an interesting property if you were to concentrate at different points
there are different distances from the center notice as this as this ship rotates the points
which are very close to the center hardly move look at this this velocity is very low it's hardly
moving but the points that are very far away oh my god my cursor I can't even keep it up oh my god
it's moving so fast but this one look at that oh my god it's moving so slowly oh nothing oh my god
look at that oh wow that's moving so fast so points that are far away farther you go from
the center they move faster and faster and faster and why should I care about this Einstein
well Einstein says Mahesh remember time dilation in special relativity moving clocks tick slower
compared to the clocks that are at rest and an intuitive way to think about it is in terms of
photon clocks if you have a photon clock with you at rest it'll keep ticking at the maximum speed
but if the same clock is moving now the light has to travel a bigger distances between the ticks
and since its speed is the same in our reference frame it takes more time to tick
it slows down and if it's moving even faster time slows down even more there's nothing new over here
we've learned all this in special relativity normal time dilation when things move okay
but now we can apply it over here okay remember we are outside we are looking at this from far
away we can you can imagine we are at rest with respect to the center of this spaceship okay
now from our perspective look people over here are hardly moving they're pretty much at rest
they're hardly moving so their clocks are not dilated at all their clocks are ticking pretty
much at the same rate as our clock but look at the people over here oh my god because they're
much faster than people over here their clocks will be dilated a lot more and therefore their
clocks will be ticking much slower than our clocks so as we go farther and farther away
the clocks tick slower and slower again nothing mysterious over here that's all because they have
different speeds everything makes sense from our perspective but now comes an important question
what does it all look like from their perspective from people inside this spaceship here's the way
to think about it imagine the people over here they all were of the same age before they got
into the spaceship okay so now we know that the person over here would have aged the least because
their time ticked the slowest and the person over here aged the most therefore when they meet up
what should happen they should all agree on that age right regardless of whose perspective we think
when people meet up everyone should agree on who ages more and who ages less so it's an objective
fact doesn't matter who looks at it but the second thing to understand is that remember
people never see themselves aging slower okay i will always regardless of where i am on the ship
i will always see my clock ticking normally and i will see myself aging at the same rate
and so putting this these two together we can now understand what they will see
in you know inside the spaceship so if you go inside the spaceship the person at the bottom
will say hey my clock is ticking normally but if they could somehow look at the person at the top
they will say oh my god you are aging so fast and of course there will be some light aberrations and
all of that but don't worry about it for now but they will eventually infer that oh my god that
person is aging so quickly on the other hand the person over here says uh-huh i am aging normally
buddy it's you who's aging very slowly that's what they will all infer but here is the most
interesting question why are the clocks die why are different people aging differently from
the perspective of the ship from the perspective of the ship look everybody is at rest nobody's
moving from our outside's perspective we had a simple answer special relativity time dilation
but what's the answer from inside the spaceship they're all wondering what's going on over here
why are we all aging differently because we are all at rest relative to each other look they're
all at rest it has to be gravity they will all infer that this must be due to gravity why why
do they infer that it's due to gravity well think about it this way if we had a remote control we
who are standing far away from the ship from outside the ship if we could somehow switch off
the rotation then of course all of their clocks will now start ticking at the same rate because
nobody's moving and therefore from inside the spaceship they will suddenly see hey gravity
has switched off and now they will see oh my god all of us are now ticking at the same rate oh
and when you switch on the rotation again gravity gets switched on and now look oh my god okay
clocks now again start ticking at different rate so the only thing that's making clock tick at
different rate they will infer is gravity fictitious gravity from inside this is how
gravity and clock ticking is connected to each other so if you put it all together being in an
accelerated frame gives you two effects one it gives you the illusion of gravity and two now
that we are seeing it is that it makes clocks tick at different rates at different locations
okay Einstein let's bring it home let's now answer our original question Einstein says we need one
last thing if you look at this from the outside perspective one more time remember because people
over here are traveling very slowly the acceleration that they feel will be very small and the people
over here are traveling very fast so the acceleration that they feel would be very large
this means from inside the spaceship if you look at people who are over here because they have very
small acceleration they will say that hey they feel very small gravity but if you go very far
away over here they will say that oh my god the gravity over here is much larger which means this
means the apparent gravity that they all feel that becomes bigger and bigger as they go farther and
farther away and if you connect it to the time the clocks now you can see that means the lower you go
in the gravitational field the slower the clock ticks this now explains why closer to the surface
of any planet or the star the clocks will take much slower so being over here where you experience the
maximum gravity it's kind of like being on the surface of the planet and being at the center
which is where you feel almost no gravity is like being infinitely far away from the planet so it's
a great model but of course it's a rough model the gravitational field does not increase in the
same way the gravitational field increases over here so don't don't look too much into the model
but it gives you gives us brilliant intuition now explaining why the clocks must be dilated closer
you know closer to the surface of the planet compared to clocks that are farther away now if
we are modeling earth since the gravitational acceleration is very tiny near the surface of
the earth that means we need we don't need a lot of velocities over here the people inside will be
moving at a very low velocity compared to us where we are you know we are standing outside of this
okay at such low velocities the time dilation is hardly anything so we don't need special relativity
and our clocks pretty much tick at the same rate that's why when you're dealing with regular planets
or stars we can use newtonian model and completely forget time dilation but if you're close to a
black hole the fields that we are dealing with over here are insanely high which means if you
want to model that over here using our spinning space station we need a huge space station and we
need to spin it very fast such that people over here are pretty much traveling close to the speed
of light as seen from us from the outside and people over here will not be traveling much at
all that means the clock discrepancy will be severe the clocks over here will be hardly ticking
this is the reason for the severe time dilation in our model we can think that brandon cooper
was somewhere over here traveling pretty close to speed of light from our inertial perspective
so their clocks didn't tick much at all romley on the other hand was pretty close to the center over
here and therefore his clock is ticking pretty much at the same rate as our clock so not much
dilated at all and therefore we had to wait a lot of time for them like years decades actually for
them to come back over here so what blows my mind away is that it all boils down to the fact that
the speed of light is a constant in every reference frame that's where we got the time dilation to
begin with and that's why in accelerated frames also clocks should be dilated i find that i find
that really incredible so do you now have a better intuition for what happened in the interstellar
scene can you now explain to somebody better than just saying gravity slows down time if you can i
want you to do me a favor no no don't like share subscribe i don't care about any of that but
instead in fact instead of sharing this video instead you try and explain it to them yourself
just do that right away it's because when you're trying to explain it to somebody that's when you'll
understand the gaps in your explanation and that's when you'll be learning a lot more i'm sure i had a
lot of gaps over here and i definitely learned a lot more than when i just started making this video
so yeah do that that's called the feynman technique and that's one of the best ways to learn
right that's all i got yeah that's all i got all right see you bye
