Could a black hole erase your past? Wipe out every memory, every detail, that makes you who you are?
That’s just one of the crazy questions we explore as we encounter the insane paradoxes of black holes.
Black holes don’t just trap matter. They trap information too. This is what makes them one of the greatest mysteries of our universe. They challenge our fundamental understanding of physics and our reality. Everything we know about our world breaks down when we confront their mystifying properties.
Today's guest, Marcus Chown, has spent years tracing the history of black holes—not just the science, but also the brilliant scientists who gave us the knowledge and insight into these marvels. From equations scribbled in the trenches of WWI to a vanishing dark star in the 1970s, Marcus takes us on a journey from discovery to understanding…of all that we know so far.
His latest book, A Crack in Everything, tells the astonishing story of how black holes went from absurd fantasy to perhaps the fundamental phenomenon that shapes our entire reality.
Key Takeaways:
00:00:00 Intro 00:01:09 The most terrifying object in the universe 00:03:05 Judging a book by its cover 00:05:10 Paradoxes and information in black holes 00:10:26 Historical figures and black holes 00:23:23 The future of black hole research 00:34:44 Are black holes responsible for our existence? 00:38:53 Do black holes create universes? 00:44:06 Human stories that didn’t make it into the book 00:59:37 Outro
Could a black hole erase your
past? Wipe out every memory, every
detail that makes you who you
are? That's just one of the crazy
questions we explore as we encounter the
insane paradoxes of black
holes. Black holes don't just trap
matter. They trap information, too. This
is what makes them one of the greatest
mysteries of our universe. They
challenge our fundamental understanding
of physics and of reality. Everything we
know about our world breaks down when we
confront their mystifying properties.
Today's guest, Marcus Chow, has spent
years tracing the history of black
holes. Not just the science, but also
the brilliant scientists who gave us the
knowledge and insight into these
marvelous behemoths of space and time.
From equations scribbled in the trenches
of World War I to a vanishing dark star
in the 1970s, Marcus takes us on a
journey from discovery to understanding
of all that we know so far and what we
do not yet know. His latest book, A
Crack in Everything, tells the
astonishing story of how black holes
went from absurd fantasy to perhaps the
most fundamental phenomena that shapes
our entire reality. Let's go, Marcus.
Soon I want to ask you if black holes
are actually creators, a type of force
that acts as a womb perhaps for new
universes, but certainly for solar
systems like our own. But first, let's
start where everyone starts, as black
holes. As destroyers of worlds. What
makes black holes the most terrifying
objects in the cosmos? Well, they're
regions of space where uh gravity is so
strong that nothing not even light can
escape. So, they do have this uh
reputation for sucking in material
relentlessly. Uh, and this was um really
a big mistake that that physicists and
astronomers made over the last century
because they thought that they just sack
in material. They're black. Okay, it's
the black of space and they'd be
actually impossible to see. But
actually, one of the most striking
features, well, first of all, black
holes, the black holes that we know of
in the universe are are include some of
the most luminous objects in creation.
So, that they're far from being black.
And although we can just about see
material disappearing down the the hole
of a black hole just about, the most
striking feature is often of material
coming out, you know, often along these
titanic jets of material which stab out
through galaxies for millions of light
years. So really, you know, the idea of
them sucking in material um is is kind
of they do, but but actually they kind
of defy that that picture. Uh, and
that's basically because they're they're
embedded in an environment and
physicists and astronomers assume that
that that they would be black because
they would be isolated. But in fact,
pretty much everything in the universe
is embedded in an environment. Most
stars are binary stars. Uh, you know, a
sun is quite unusual being a solitary
star. It's quite unusual. And being
embedded in an environment, having a
companion, having gas or dust around you
makes all the difference. And this leads
to these objects being in fact
incredibly luminous even though they're
black holes. One thing I really loved
about your writing. I always love your
writing, but uh but about the book is
that you kind of steer away from the
kind of pop culture mythology of, you
know, spaghettification. Yes, you
mention it. Of course you have to. It's
a it's a law of nature, right? But you
really get into the hard facts and
physics of it. And it's no surprise
because of your scientific training and
your past books as well. And speaking of
books, I like to do what you're never
supposed to do on the show, which is a
feature called judging books by their
cover. So, I actually bought the audio
book and rated it with an asterism of
five stars. Uh, nothing less would
suffice. It's got the encomium uh that
it well deserves from Richard Dawkins. A
pretty wonderful book. And from my um
one of my kids favorite astrophysicist,
also named Brian, Brian May, Marcus
Marcus Chs. Wow. You can't ask for a
better. So, so please, that's the back
cover, but judge the front cover, title,
subtitle, and this mysterious, monstrous
cover art that's so beautiful. Glad you
like it. But I I should point out that
there are two types of black holes. So
there are the theoretical black holes
which you you talk about which are
fantastically important because u you
know our major theories of physics
collide in black holes our theory of the
microscopic world quantum theory our
theory of big things general relativity
and thermodynamics our theory of heat
they clash uh and they're not melded
they they predict different things uh in
the same domain which is gold dust for
physicists because when when a theory is
shown to to break down an Einstein's
theory of orbiting breaks down in the
center of a black hole, then we we are
encouraged to look for a deeper uh
better theory. So there's the so there's
the theoretical black holes um and of
course Stephen Hawkings name is
associated with those and then there's
the real black holes which are the black
holes we've actually found out in the
universe and my book is essentially
about the real black holes because
incredibly not only do they exist but
they're relatively common and as you
said in your intro they play a role in
us us having this conversation today. I
need to really understand the nature of
black holes. Are they really, you know,
cosmic safes hiding away information
forever? Are they cosmic shredders
obliterating it beyond recovery? How do
you, as a as a, you know, as a
popularizer and an explicator,
exceptional explicator, par excalons?
How do you think of these things? How do
you think of their paradoxical nature
and hawking radiation, information
paradox, firewalls? Talk about how these
objects are fascinating in their own
right, but made even more so by the many
paradoxes that they bring up. They are
paradoxical as as I said the the the
real black holes in the universe are
paradoxical because they aren't black
you know they they are fantastically
luminous because of the the material
that falls into them and the friction
because it turns out that the nothing
everything in the universe is rotating
the earth is rotating the galaxy's
rotating which means material uh doesn't
fall directly into a black hole it kind
of swirls down onto it like water down a
plug hole friction caus it to heat to
millions of degrees and this is what
causes to shine. But I ought to just
point out that that black holes are the
simplest objects in the whole of physics
because there's nothing they're made of
nothing more than space and time as far
as we know. So I ought to tell you that
stellar mass black holes uh form when a
star gets to the end of its life uh runs
out of fuel with no fuel to to to burn
to generate heat to push outwards.
gravity crushes the star and as far as
we know it crushes it down to to a point
what we call a singularity and merely
the star as far as we know actually
vanishes and all that's left is a
bottomless pit in the fabric of
spacetime. This is Einstein's picture.
Einstein realized that gravity was
actually the curvature of spacetime. You
know we can't visualize it because it's
a four-dimensional thing. That's why it
took genius of Einstein to realize. So
you know all there is left after the
star has collapsed is this bottomless
pit into from which nothing not even
like can actually climb out. But you
talked about Hawking radiation. Um you
you know a lot of people get puzzled by
this. Hawking in 1974 realized that
actually black holes glow. They they
have a temperature. They are of
thermodynamic objects and they they glow
with this stuff called Hawking
radiation. It streams outwards. And
people are often puzzled because they
say, "Well, surely black holes are
defined by by nothing ever getting out
of them." Well, a Hawking radiation
doesn't get out of them. It's created in
the vacuum just outside the perimeter of
the black hole. So, we we define a kind
of spherical membrane. Uh this is an
imaginary membrane called the event
horizon and it's the point of no return
for infalling light and matter and the
hawking radiation is generated on the
outside. But I mean I know the question
you're asking Lee and that is that as
far as we know in physics information is
not is never destroyed. This is quite
fundamental uh to to our laws of
physics. And so the question then is if
the star the massive star shrinks down
to nothing and vanishes leaving only a a
kind of bottomless pit in spaceime what
happened to the information that
described the star? tremendous amount of
information will be required to to you
know tell you the the the type of atoms
their location where their electrons are
you know you can imagine it's an
incredible amount of information. The
actual event horizon is not a perfect
sphere that it's probably got a a micro
structure. So if you were to zoom in on
in on it on a very small scale, you
would see it. It's kind of mountainous.
And this this actually impresses itself
on the Hawking radiation. You know, just
as your voice uh or if you're on the on
the radio impresses itself on the
carrier wave, the radio wave that
transmits the that your voice to the
listener, this kind of microscopic
terrain um actually impresses itself on
the Hawking radiation. And it's in this
microscopic terrain that the information
that describe the original star is
recorded. So that's that's kind of one
possible way. I think that's probably
the consensus. You know, you're an
astrophysicist, Brian. You must know
there's so much to unpack in this lovely
book. Um I I recommend the audio version
because it's I always like to hear the
author's voice. You didn't record the
audio book, but it's close enough to an
American's ear that uh it sounds like
you, Marcus. I have to say it's it's
wonderfully done. Although and the
printed book is as well. I've actually
recorded audio books before, so I didn't
get asked on it or I really really
enjoyed it. I mean, have you done it? I
bet you have. Yeah, I did it. Well, I
did it for uh seven or eight hours of
the dialogue between uh Galileo's world
systems with my friend Carlo Relli and
and others. So, yeah, we did it. We
actually recorded the first ever audio
book of Galileo. The last time I
recorded uh it was two days in a
recording studio and then the third day
we had 1 hour left. And when I got in
the recording studio in this studio,
they said, "Oh, yesterday when I
recorded eight hours, we had an an
unexplained hiss in the background and
and could you record it again?" And I
mean, I was in the studio for 10 hours
and I was kind of speechless at the end
because I thought it was all over. But
but but obviously there were harder jobs
like working down coal mines than
recording your your your audio book or,
you know, writing equations in the
trenches of World War I. And you know
soon I want to ask you what the next
great black hole discovery might be
whether it would be in theory,
observation, experiment, you know,
ranging from quantum gravity
breakthroughs to so-called multi-me
astronomy and observations that we
haven't dreamed of yet. But first to
really understand where we're going, we
have to look at how we got to our
understanding of black holes from the
first place because it's a it's a human
story too, not just about, you know,
cosmic monsters and and ruptures in
spaceime. And it involves people like
Carl Schwarzchild and and Submonian
Jeanja and and many many others. And I I
wonder of all these you know kind of
characters that you got to study which
is the most sympathetic or pathetic
perhaps uh there's a lot of sadness
there's a lot of debauchery or shall I
say you know kind of skull duggery um by
by some unsavory characters that goes
along with it including the ignorance of
underrepresented groups in astronomy to
get attention.
talk about the the history of of the
discovery, the theoretical predictions
and the experimental triumphs that led
us to the understanding that we have now
before we pave paths or to the future.
So the book begins with Carl Schwarz
Shield who was uh on the outbreak of the
he was German. He was the director of
the Berlin Observatory on the outbreak
of the first world war. He joined the
German army immediately. He had no need
to. He was 40 years old, but
anti-semitism was on the rise in uh
Germany and he was Jewish and he wanted
to show he could be a patriotic German.
He ended up running a weather station in
Belgium uh calcian shell trajectories.
He ended up at a place called Mole House
which was on the northern border of
France between France and Germany, the
only bit of the western front that was
mountainous. And in November 1915, he
went on uh leave to see his family in
Berlin. And on the 18th of November
1915, he attended a lecture by Albert
Einstein. And Einstein in four lectures
in November 1915 presented this
revolutionary new theory of gravity. And
and uh uh was completely captivated went
back to the front and he did something
that Einstein thought was impossible.
And so what you have to realize is that
Einstein had shown, you know, Newton
said there was a gravity was effectively
an invisible tether that connected the
earth and the sun and kept the earth
orbiting forever. Einstein realized this
is incorrect. What gravity what uh a
mass like the sun actually does is it is
it kind of warps the spaceime around it
into a valley. I I said before you can't
actually see that valley and the earth
kind of goes around the the the upper
reaches of that valley rather like a
roulette ball in a roulette wheel. So
gravity is actually the curvature of
space. Now that what one thing you need
to know is that uh Newton used one
formula to characterize gravity and
Einstein used t. So actually finding or
curvature of space for any useful body
like a star was considered by Einstein
to be impossible. But within about a
couple of weeks Schwarz on the western
front found the solution sent it to
Einstein. Einstein was amazed to get a
letter from the Western Front and then
to find there was something in it that
he he considered to be impossible you
know and he presented this result at a
Prussian Academy of Sciences but
shortener not finished and realized that
if the basically he found the curvature
sorry around a spherical mass which was
the the shape of the valley of spacetime
and then he realized that if that mass
were to become more and more compressed
the valley would become steeper until
eventually it became a bottomless pit
from which light could not escape and
therefore or the object will be shut off
from the universe. It would be black. He
sent this to Einstein. Einstein
presented it again at the Prussian
Academy. Never believed in um black
holes until he died. Uh and there's an
obvious reason for that. It taken taken
10 years of blood and sweat to come up
with his new theory and to discover
within a few weeks of presenting it that
there was actually a place where it
broke down. I told you before that if a
star shrinks, there's nothing to stop it
shrinking down to a point. We call that
a singularity. When everything
skyrockets to infinity, the density or
whatever, when you get that in a
formula, when you get that in in a
theory, it it tells you your theory has
been stretched to a point beyond which
is it's got anything sensible to say.
So, Schwarz and then sadly, you know,
the story sadly had a disease called
Penagus Vulgaris in late December in
1915 when he was writing to Einstein. He
got these blisters in his mouth. They
spread all over his body. took a long
time for them to for him to be
diagnosed. But this is a disease in
which the immune system attacks the skin
and the skin of course is your barrier
against infection against
microorganisms. So he knew he was going
to die and he actually went back to
Berlin and died in May 1915. But his
idea did not die with him. And I just
there's a lot of things I could tell you
but you asked me about people who I I
would like to uh talk about and one of
them is Louise Webster who has been
entirely written out the history of
science. She was the current discoverer
of black holes with Paul Murdin in uh
1971. And of course, as if you've read
my book, you've read my book. Of course,
I was switched on to black holes at the
age of 12 because I was a member of the
Junior Astronomical Society and my dad
took me to a talk in London um by
someone called Paul Murden who hobbled
towards the stage um on crutches. He had
had childhood uh polio. And he proceeded
to talk about this object called Signis
X1 uh which was the first black hole
candidate. And uh it blew my mind. It
blew my 12-year-old mind, you know. So
uh but it's only recently I discovered
that he actually co-discovered it with a
woman called Louise Webster. Uh they
were both 30 years old. She was
Australian and she went back to
Australia. Um she had liver disease and
she had one of the very first successful
liver transplants in Australia, but
sadly got cancer and she died at 49 and
she's been completely forgotten. So if
you remember anything about this podcast
today, remember the name of the
co-discoverer of black holes, Louise
Webster. And I think you also know that
you know pulsars or or neutron stars,
these are another collapsed form of
stars. So if a star is not massive
enough to collapse all the way down to
singularity, it can form what we call a
neutron star, which is a star basically
um about the size of um I don't know,
half half the size of size of San Diego.
uh but but um but the mass of of the sun
and uh a you know sugar cube of material
of a neutron star would weigh as much as
a human race. So they're super dense
objects. They were discovered by Joslyn
Bell who was a um graduate student at uh
Cambridge in
1967 and there have been three Nobel
prizes for pulsars and none have gone to
her. So the two types of stars, what we
call relativistic stars, the two types
of stars or or end points of stellar
evolution um that require relativity to
understand black holes and neutron stars
were both discovered by women. I had
Dame Bell Bernell uh on the podcast. I
had her on uh December 10th in 2023,
which you'll recognize as the day the
Nobel prizes are given away. So I wanted
to make sure that at least you know we
celebrated the proper way. There's one
other object that plays um sort of might
have been a red herring or it might have
been kind of a a false start but but is
is integral to the story of black holes
and that's their you know kind of mirror
image white dwarves uh at least the
story that you weave so beautifully
starts off with a young uh Superman and
Shandra Secar uh traveling and then
ultimately getting undercut uh and that
delaying the progress of not only the
discovery of black holes but theoretical
astrophysics for decades to come. He
eventually did get recognition with a
Nobel Prize, but not until he was quite
old. So, talk about him, his
discoveries, why they're so important,
and how they segue into the black hole
narrative. Well, of course, nobody who
thought about it wanted to believe in
black holes. I mean, this is the story
of people over the last century being
dragged kicking and screaming having to
consider these objects because no one
wanted to think about the singularity at
the center where everything breaks down
and certainly Einstein didn't want to
believe it. So anyone after about 1915
who thought about it which which were
very few people thought there's got to
be some other force that intervenes that
stops a massive star or the core of a
massive star at the end of its life from
shrinking down to an infinitely dense
point to a singularity. There's got to
be something that stops it. And in the
1920s that something turned up which was
of course what we call quantum theory.
Quantum theory is our very best
description of the microscopic world and
their of atoms and their constituents.
You know, it's given us lasers, nuclear
reactors, iPhones, you know, basically
created the the modern world. There's a
a principle called the Heisenberg
uncertainty principle. And all you
really need to know is that if you try
and compress something like a a proton
or electron or whatever into a small
volume, it resists. And this is not
anything to do with its temperature.
It's not the fact that it's flying
around because it's because it's got
temperature. this is a fundamental uh
this is a fundamental thing and so
anyone who thought about it thought well
actually and there were people at
Cambridge in in England like Ralph
Fowler who thought about this thought
well actually this runaway catastrophic
gravitational collapse will be stopped
uh and then a n as you say a 19-year-old
Indian from Madras uh which is now
Chennai I believe in India uh was on his
way to Cambridge to to be to do a degree
and he was sitting on the deck of his
ship as it went through the u sewis
canal and he was thinking about the
death of stars and he he happened to
know the beta quantum theory and he knew
a bit about stars and he realized that
everyone who thought about this problem
had missed out one key element and that
was Einstein's theory of relativity
which basically gives an upper limit to
the speed of anything so if you compress
as uh a star gets the end of its life
and it it shrinks and its electrons get
pushed together. They can push back
through the Heisenberg uncertainty
principle. They push back, you know,
rather like uh you know, raindrops on a
on a roof, you know, spattering on a
route. Uh but there's a pushing New
Yorkers. Yeah. Limit there's a limit to
how fast they can push back because they
cannot move faster than the speed of
light. Henny realized that there was
actually um if the star was more massive
what we called it what we his name was
supermanion chandraka we now call it the
chandra seca limit if a star is more
than about one and a half times the mass
of the sun this Heisenberg uncertainty
principle what we call degeneracy
pressure could not prevent the star from
collapsing. So if the star at the end of
his life was more massive, a black hole
would be the outcome. And as you say,
probably the greatest one of the
greatest astronomers of his day, Arthur
Edington, the one of the two people who
had understood Einstein's theory of
gravity in 1915, the other was William
Ditter, who was a a Dutch physicist. Uh
but Edington um understood it and and
and presented it to the English-speaking
world. He was I mean I remember there
was a poll um I think it was in the 20s
or 30s in America of who was the uh you
know the top 10 astronomers in the world
and he was ranked by American
astronomers as the number one astronomer
and Edington just did not believe in
this limit this this chandle limit and
and it's very hard to understand why he
didn't because he just said the world
does not work this way nature does not
work this way which is not really much
of an argument and he did his best to
completely undermine Chandrao and in
fact humiliate him Chandrao gave a pre
presentation at the Royal Astronomical
society in London and um he did not know
that Edington well Edington was going to
give the talk after him and he did not
know that Edington's talk was to
entirely undermine him and poor Chandra
Sika had to even move to another field
of of astronomy because he knew He he
could not compete with Edington because
Edington was such a powerful figure. But
as you just say in in 1983 he was
vindicated. He got the Nobel Prize. Uh
Edington died I think in the Second
World War. Uh never got the Nobel Prize
but but Sean Bkart did. Uh and he was
very hurt all of his life although he
was always said that he admired
Edington. And I was there actually uh on
the spot at Caltech when Willie Fowler
got the Nobel Prize in 1983 and Chantra
Secar shared the physics Nobel Prize
that year. So given the fact that I see
the black hole story as sort of a a
relay race not not a marathon but uh
bold ideas you know kind of first
promulgated by theorists outpacing
experimentalists and instrument
builders. that kind of you know trickles
down when when we reach the limit of
measuring you know massive and super
massive black holes. We went as I
understand the the trajectory that this
subject took thanks to your book white
dwarves u then followed by neutron stars
and then eventually pulsars and then
black holes and and theory was always in
front and even it was in front for a
long time with gravitational waves. I've
spoken to, you know, all three Kit
Thorne, Barry Barish, and Ray Weiss on
this podcast, as well as people like
Shep Dolman from the Event Horizon
Telescope. What do you see as the future
of this marriage between theory,
phenomenology, observation, instrument
builders of chasing down the impossible?
What's going to be the next frontier? Is
it some new developments in theory or
have we reached the end of theory? Is it
some new technological uh device that we
don't have yet? Uh or is it some huge
budget to build larger and larger
instruments to the kind of which we do
have? Where do you see the future of
this field going? Well, I mean it's it's
incredibly exciting. So, first of all,
you just mentioned gravitational waves
which are like ripples in the fabric of
spaceime. I mean basically a tsunami in
the fabric of spaceime. But of course,
by the time we we pick up these these
signals, they filled a huge volume of
space and become massively diluted. that
they were detected in on the 14th of
September 2015 predicted by Einstein in
1916 because you know mass or energy can
warp space it can also ripple it can
also jiggle it and and knows what
gravitational waves are the first
discovery uh was of two black holes
which had merged and I think they were
something like one was about 35 times
the mass of the sun the other one about
50 something like that this was much
much bigger than anyone had expected and
we're now seeing mergers we've seen
about a hundred now including uh neutron
star mergers and black hole neutron star
mergers. Uh and we're seeing uh black
holes which are much more massive than
actually could possibly exist. Uh so
there is actually a gap um a mass gap
where we do not expect to see mass black
holes and that is because uh when a star
is massive enough we get what was called
a pair instability supernova and the
star blows itself completely apart. So
there is no implosion at the center to
form a black hole. But we shouldn't see
any black holes in a particular range.
Yet we do see them. So what we we're
learning is that the black holes we're
seeing merging pairs that we're seeing
merging, spiraling together and merging
individually had actually merged before.
So this process of merging is quite
common. That's going to continue and and
we're going to be surprised by what we
actually discover. I I think probably
one of the most amazing things is is the
James Web Space Telescope which is you
know showing us the pretty newborn
universe when it was maybe 2 or 3% its
current age and we're beginning we're
seeing these super massive black holes
or we're seeing evidence of these super
massive black holes very very large very
early on. So we're seeing billion solar
mass uh super mass with black holes
within you know three or 4 hundred
million years of the big bang and and
that's quite difficult to understand but
I think there's some evidence I mean
there are these things called red dots
you've probably heard about which have
been seen and they may well be black
holes enshrouded in a in a very very
dense shell of material and so sucking
in material at a rate greater than they
ought to be able to do. So the we may
get the pretty soon I hope the solution
to where these super massive black holes
come from. Now I ought to just say what
I haven't told you is there's probably a
complete spectrum of of black holes from
stellar mass up to uh really large ones
but but we we we basically see two
populations. One is stellar mass black
holes which we believe form when in
supernovi a star blows itself apart.
Paradoxically the core implodes. In
fact, it's the implosion that drives the
explosion. Um, and then we see these
super massive black holes and and the
biggest ones are something like 60
billion times the mass of the sun and
their origin is a complete mystery.
We're seeing them very very early on in
the universe. So, so we believe that
black holes start off quite small. I
mean, they could have been an early
generation of stars uh that form very
shortly after the big bang. There's a
lot of evidence that they would have
been more massive than stars today. So
it's quite possible they would have gone
through their livestock storage their
life quite quickly exploded up for
produced black hole. Those black holes
maybe would have merged sucked in
material. But it's quite difficult to
see how a black hole could grow from
stellar mass to a billion times the mass
of the sun in the available time. So
that's that's a really big mystery. I
mean it could be conceivably that they
are spawned in some way in the in the
big bang itself in the turbulent
conditions in the big bang. That would
be very interesting. So I think you know
to answer your question I think the
origin of super massive black holes
would be that would be that's an
incredibly important question to answer.
So let's face it there's one Hubble
Space Telescope discovers in the 1990s
that there's actually a super massive
black hole in the heart of pretty much
every galaxy. In fact essentially every
galaxy so we don't know what they're
doing there. Did they come first? Were
there super matter black holes formed in
the universe and then maybe they
gathered material around them which then
collapsed to form stars? So were they
the seeds around which galaxies form or
were the galaxies formed first and then
maybe there were very dense clusters in
the center that ended up forming super
massive black color. So we don't
understand anything really about the
origin of super massive black holes. So
the story of my book basically is how
black holes have come in from the cold.
So as you said in your introduction
Brian at the very beginning they were so
ridiculous as to not not even be
considered the preserve of science
fiction but gradually last century they
moved more and more into the center of
of science when um we realized that they
had to exist because we discovered
Martin Schmidt at Caltech discovered
quazars um which are often pump out 100
times the amount of of light of a normal
galaxy from a volume maybe the size of
the of the solar system. So that was
1963. Uh within a year, theorists had
realized there was only one possible
source of that energy and that was
material swirling down like water down a
plug hole, you know, on onto a black
hole being heated to millions of degrees
and shining that way. But not a black
hole of a few times the mass of the sun,
a black hole of billions or or tens of
billions times mass. So super massive
black holes. But then we thought, well,
quazars, they are what we call active
galaxies. There's a there's a whole lot
zoo of them, but basically they're
galaxies. We define them as galaxies
that are um generate most of their light
not from stars but from a accretion disc
what we call around a super massive
black hole. And at that point, you know,
only 1% of of galaxies were active
galaxies. So we could think, well,
they're not really important. We can
sweep them under carpet. They're
anomalies. And then we discover there's
one in every single galaxy. And and the
reason that we only see them in only 1%
of galaxies are active is because in
only 1% of galaxies are they being fed.
So in 99% of galaxies they've sucked in
all the gas and ripped ripped butt stars
and and and they're slumbering. You
know, they're slumbering and and of
course there's a super massive black
hole in the center of our own galaxy.
Although it's a tidler. That's right.
Compared to our big brothers in M87. I
want to quote uh a lyric uh from the
famous astrophysicist, not Brian May,
but from Leonard Cohen, and it goes like
this. Ring the bells that still can
ring. Forget your perfect offering.
There's a crack, a crack in everything.
That's how the light gets in. And I
interpreted your title of your book
along those lines. in that you present
black holes as this confluence between
all the major ideas of of physics,
modern physics, quantum mechanics,
thermodynamics, information theory,
general relativity, special relativity,
they all sort of break down at one level
or another. How important is that
narrative? You know, where the cracks
are what reveal the truth and and why we
shouldn't as physicists be afraid of of
flaws and cracks in our most cherished
theories and ideas. Well, you've put
your finger on exactly what the title
means. You know, because, you know, in
in physics, places where our known laws
of physics break down are are gold
mines. You know, they they're really
what we look for. You know, we look for
paradoxes. We look for places where
there are certainly where there are two
theories that predict for the in the
same domain different things. Then we
know that one or both of those theories
is wrong. And there is a great I saw
this survey a a psychological survey and
it was about people who were willing to
change their point of view. You know it
was talking about politics but people
willing to change their point of view
and the people who scored highest uh the
people who were most likely to change
their view were people of a scientific
background and that is because they
actually enjoy seeing you know that they
enjoy being proved wrong. So really, you
know, scientists get a lot of joy out of
out of finding out that their theories
don't work because they're constantly
looking for the deeper better uh theory
and and really our scientific theories
are provisional. You know, they are they
are the best description we have at this
moment. But we know they break down. So
you know to everyone but Einstein who
was not happy with uh black holes uh
black holes are of gold dust you know I
mean there there if we get
contradictions in physics and we are
challenged by nature to come up with a
better theory and the better theory we
expect but we could be wrong is what we
call a quantum theory of gravity where
we unite our our theory of the very
small uh which is quantum theory with
our theory of the very big which is
general relativity because in a in a
black hole something very big becomes
very small. You know, a star shrinks
smaller than an atom. So we we we need
to unite these to understand what
happens in the center of a black hole
and coincidentally
uh where the universe came from because
we believe that the universe also began
in a singularity although a singularity
in time rather than a singularity in
space but similar kind of thing. So, so
yeah, and I was I was saying about how
how how scientists actually revel in in
having to change their mind, you know,
uh because really, I mean, if you go
back um 50 years, I mean, our picture of
the of the of the universe is entirely
different to the portrait that we have
now. I mean, imagine how many objects
that we we know of now in the universe
that we didn't know about. I'm thinking
of things like gammaray bursters which
were actually they were known about but
the US military was keeping them a
secret discovered them because it was
trying to find the gamma rays produced
by clandestine Russian nuclear tests. It
it was it was using spy satellites to do
that and it discovered this you know a
burst of gamma rays once a day from
somewhere in the sky. Uh fortunately
those um satellites they could tell
where they were coming from otherwise it
would have they would have triggered a
nuclear war and they knew that they well
they're not coming from the Russians
they were coming from space. Black holes
are just really challenging us. Yeah
it's a unique uh laboratory for
understanding physics at the extremes.
Um I want to uh mention something you
hinted at before I get to the creation
of the universe uh from black holes.
Maybe we can touch upon an interesting
theory that you discuss in the book
which by the way you don't discuss
cosmic natural selection which we're
going to get to in a minute but you do
discuss uh how our existence might be
owed in fact to black holes. Can you
elaborate on that for listeners that
might be shocked again to hear such a
such a wild idea? This is the greatest
irony. So you know that they start off
uh you know as as really not even a
preserver of science fiction and they
move so far in the to to the center of
our picture that we actually think that
first of all they they play some key and
mysterious role still mysterious role in
generating the universe we see around
us. But specifically in us having this
conversation it comes down to I told you
every galaxy's got a super massive black
hole in its core and we've got one. It's
called Sagittarius A star. It was
discovered in 1974, so 51 years ago. Two
people in 2020, Andrea GZ, a astronomer
in California, and Reinhard Genzel in
Germany, won the Nobel Prize in 2024,
working out its mass. And its mass is
4.2 million times the mass of the sun.
But this is this is a mystery because
this is really really tiny. This is
thousands of times smaller than the
super massive black holes in active
galaxies like quazars. And if we compare
the Milky Way with Andromeda, Andromeda
is the nearest big galaxy, a galaxy
that's a spiral galaxy and very very
similar to the Milky Way. It's super
massive black hole is 50 times bigger.
So why have we got such a tiny tiny
super massive black hole connected to us
being here? Because in I I said in the
beginning in the galaxy with big black
holes, they have these tremendous
titanic jets that stab outwards from the
north and south poles of the spinning
black holes. step out was often not only
millions of light years through space
but sometimes hundred million lighty
years through space. I mean it's it's
shockingly how they how they stay
columnated how they stay narrow for that
long is is still a mystery. But what in
in the galaxies with the big massive
black holes these jets can push away
drive away all the gas in the center of
galaxies. Now that's the raw material of
new stars. So in these galaxies, the
star formation is is kind of snuffed out
after one generation, but that didn't
happen in our galaxy because we got a
tidler of a black hole. We've probably
never had any powerful jets at all. And
and so we've had multiple generations of
stars. And our sun is a third generation
stop. And in each successive generation,
which forms from the raw material, you
know, the exploding stars of the
previous generation, in each successive
generation, more heavy elements are
forged. So, more carbon, more oxygen,
more iron, more calcium. That brings up
this this little uh artifact that I give
away to my listeners. If you go to
briankane.com/list, this is a meteorite,
which is a fragment probably of a
population 2 star that eventually coales
to be a part of our solar system as a
bridge between the earlier and later
generations. So, these stars give they
give their lives to make our lives
possible. Right. Yeah. and and in and
out because of our small black hole, it
has been possible for there to be
multiple generations of stars. And and I
I just listed those elements and those
elements that have been forged because
we've had multiple generations because
we have a small super mass black hole.
Those elements are precisely the ones
needed to make your meteorite, to make a
rocky planet like the Earth, and to make
biological life like you and me. We
could not be having this conversation in
for instance M87. You mentioned M87.
This is a nearby galaxy with a 6.5
billion solar mass black hole image was
habitized in 2019. The first ever image
of a black hole and we could not have
arisen in that galaxy. So we believe
that that galaxy is probably a
biological desert. It's remarkable that
we've come from thinking that these
objects were so ridiculous as not to be
the preserver of fiction to thinking
that we're having this conversation
because of a black hole Sagittarius or
star. And that brings me to this
provocative question I've been teasing
the listeners about since the first few
seconds. We we started off the
conversation with a description of black
holes as predators, as paradox machines.
And I I promised I'd come back to this
idea that the black hole might not be
the end of the story when it comes to
producing life on Earth. What about if
it's uh the cause not only of our
existence on this wonderful podcast, but
of entire universes uh like our own
within the multiverse? And just for the
readers and listeners that are not uh
familiar rather Lee Small in past guest
on the podcast proposed that black holes
might actually spawn new universes each
one with slightly mutated laws of
physics a kind of cosmic natural
selection. He calls it that in fact CNS.
Now I noticed in the book I didn't see
it and that was a little bit surprising.
I don't believe you mentioned cosmic
natural. You mentioned Lee. Lee is in
there I think one or two times. But I'm
curious first of all why didn't you
mention it? Was it a little bit uh of a
bridge too far? Or is there actually
some justification for treating these
black holes not only as you know fertile
fertilization within galaxies for life
like us to exist but also uh for
universes unto themselves to exist in
other words within the multiverse to
explain the peculiar qualities of our
own. Is this a bridge too far or are
black holes not tombstones but rather
cosmic universal cradles? I think it's a
bridge too far and the reason is that my
book is principally about real black
holes you know black holes that we've
actually discovered. So it's it's the
you know it culminates with you
mentioned the event horizon telescope
getting the first ever images of
Sagittarius star and M87 the black
holes. My last chapter is about
speculative ideas but I didn't mention
this one and one of the reasons is that
we really don't know what it's like
inside a black hole. So I've got the the
stories from people like Paul Murdin who
was the co-discoverer of stellar mass
black holes and Roy Kerr who was a
really interesting character. He's now
91 years old. He basically came up with
the first development in Einstein's
theory of gravity for 47 years and he
did something which people thought was
impossible. He discovered the shape of
the spacetime around a spinning black
hole. Now I told you everything in the
universe is spinning. So actually
Schwarz shoulder come up with the the
shape around a static black hole. So
that wasn't very realistic. So he came
up with a a description which describes
every single black hole in the universe.
He was 29 at the time. He himself gave
up on working out what the spaceime was
like within inside a black hole because
the problem was just too difficult to
solve. So we really don't know what it's
like inside a black hole. Not only can
we not solve Einstein's equations to
find out what the shape of the spaceime
is inside a black hole, but we certainly
don't know what it's like near a
singularity because the singularity is
is doesn't exist. By the way, I should
tell you that uh when a singularity
appears in a in a theory, it's territory
theory is broken. You need a better
theory. So, we need a quantum theory of
gravity to tell us what exactly is at
the center of a black hole. And we don't
know what that is. So saying that that
you know it connects to another another
region of spaceime that it's a time
machine it generates another another
black hole or another universe this is
so so far removed from what we can
confidently talk about that I didn't
really experienced it other books about
black holes most books about black holes
are about theoretical black holes about
Hawking radiation I love Lee Sm's idea I
hope he's correct but but again it's not
very wellounded. And the problem is once
you start admitting not very wellounded
ideas into this, you have a book which
is hundred times longer than the book
that you were writing and people get
lost. You know what what do we know and
what that we don't know. My thought is
really that the things that we know are
so fantastic and so amazing that we we
don't need to really speculate
anymore. Again, you know, I mean if if
you take I mean I'm thinking of
something else like dark matter. So with
dark matter, which was this invisible
stuff that that fills the univer
outweighs the visible stars and galaxies
by about a factor of six, we can
speculate and there's literally hundreds
of speculations as to what that dark
matter could be. But it doesn't really
get us anywhere and the reader then gets
confused by all these hundreds and
hundreds of possible suggestions, none
of which are constrained by physics
because we've never detected any. So
yeah, now I think Lee because Lee
Smoling wrote a wonderful book, didn't
he? It was called uh what was it called
now? And the life of the life of the
cosmos. Yeah. About black. Yes. So
basically he says that the conditions
necessary to create black holes, the
laws of physics necessary to create
black holes are also the laws of physics
necessary to create biological life. So
that the two are hand in hand. So So the
universes that create the most spawn,
the most black holes, I think that's
correct, isn't it? produces constants of
nature and and laws of physics that are
compatible. It's an anthropic what's
called a weak. Yeah. I mean that you
know I mean obviously as Einstein said
the most incomprehensible thing about
the universe is it's
comprehensible which is a fantastic
remark isn't it really. One thing I
appreciated with bittersweetness was
you're mentioning the bicep 2 affair
which I played not insignificant role in
and it made me think of some of the more
again there's a lot of you know paos in
these our mutual friend Jan 11 who you
write about in the book has written you
know black hole blues about the you know
kind of stories of of the unsung heroes
the lovable losers and so forth and one
of them you know which I resonate with
no pun intended actually pun intended it
was a good pun is Joseph Weber. So he of
course was, you know, claiming that he
had detected gravitational waves, you
know, three or four decades before Igo
actually did it. And it was only because
of a slight amount of hubris, I think
it's safe to say that on his part that
he never really gave up the belief that
he had discovered these first. And it
made me think about all the false starts
and the and the curious characters in
this book. you know, you mentioned
Louise and you mentioned um Johnson Bell
and and others, but are there other
stories maybe that didn't fit into the
book or or perhaps would be in in an
additional book? Are there other, you
know, sort of human stories uh that that
were neglected? You know, because we
look at the black hole and it it's none
like a black mirror. We we learn about
the subtrifuge and the chicainery and
the stolen credit and the stolen valor
uh in this book very delightfully. Were
there other characters that you didn't
get a chance to disclose that maybe the
public has a would have a desire in
knowing more about? Popular science
writers tend to write science as if it's
like a you know one-way street.
Everything you know we it's a logical
timeline but in fact scientists are
human beings. They propose the existence
of things for the wrong reasons.
Progress of science is like a drunkard's
walk. You know a few steps forwards a a
few backwards. it I mean your subjects I
know is the uh is is the cosmic
background radiation which the after
it's the afterlow of the big bang my
first popular science book was called
afterlow of creation and I went to
interview lots of people who are now
unfortunately now dead I talked to
Robert Wilson who discovered the
microwave background uh to people like
Bob Dicki and David Wilkinson all these
kind of people but I mean interestingly
I mean one of the one of the great great
figures was George Gamoff he basically
came up with the idea of the hot big
bang, you know. I mean, I mean, common
sense, I suppose, tells you that if the
universe was was smaller, it would have
been hotter because if you know, squeeze
the air in a bicycle pump, it gets
hotter. But, but no one had really
thought seriously about that. So, Hedwin
Hubble discovered the universe was
expanding in 1929, which meant that if
you ran the history of the universe back
in your mind's eye, like a movie in
reverse, you would come to a point when
it was all compressed into a small
space. You now call it Big Bang. But no
one really thought more about it. It was
so ridiculous to think that they could
think about physics then. But then then
we get George Gamov who was a Ukrainian
um American physicist and he was very
interested in when where the chemical
elements had came from. There there was
a lot of evidence from the early 20th
century that the universe had begun with
the simplest element and all the other
elements 92 naturally occurring ones had
been assembled by these these atoms or
nuclei coming together but that required
a lot of heat. Turns out that the the
nuclei the cores of atoms are positively
charged and when you try and thrust
together two positively charged nuclei
that they really repel ferociously. So
you really have to smash them together
at very high speed and that means high
temperature. We just mentioned by the
way Arthur Edington and one of the
greatest one of the greatest British
astronomers but he had made a mistake
and he thought that that the well he he
had a idea that elements could not be
built in inside stars. By this time they
knew in the by about the
1930s that hydrogen nuclei that the
cause of hydrogen atoms if they were
glued together uh in a multi-step
process to make the second heaviest uh
element helium this would liberate
enough energy to explain sunlight or
starlight. But he he thought Edington
that as the sun rotated there would be
currents what we call meridional
currents which would kind of spread out
that helium. So if you imagine the
helium is the ash. So so basically this
this would actually cause stars to to
fizzle out. He had managed to rule out
stars as the place where elements were
built. So Gamoth was thinking where else
you know and this is when he started
thinking about the universe. uh when it
was small it would have been very hot
and he thought that's just it that's the
place you know and he got his brief
students in Washington um Ralph Alfa and
Robert Herman to work out the details
because Scamov was not a details man he
came up with a lot of brilliant ideas in
his life but he was not a details man
and they worked it all out and they
realized that incredibly you could
actually end up with 10% of the
backgrounds in the universe there's
helium uh 90% hydrogen But you couldn't
get really beyond that at all. So you
could and it turns out that 10% of the
atoms in the universe are hydrogen. So
again, so he comes up with the idea of
the hot big bang for entirely the wrong
reason. But he's correct you know and
then again when they when when people
started searching for this uh afterglow
there was a team uh at Bell Labs in uh
home in New Jersey and there was also a
team remarkably only about 20 miles away
in Princeton and they had a little
little uh radio dish or radio horn on
their roof. The leader of their team was
a guy called Bob Dicki and he had the
idea that the universe was uh pulsating.
You know, it was what we So he cyc Yeah,
like a like a cyclic universe, like a
giant beating heart. So they would there
would be a big bang. It would expand uh
gravity would eventually crack it down
to a big crunch and expand again. And he
realized that this this beating heart
universe would have radiation o over you
know there would be something like a
billion 10 billion photons for every
particle of matter or so. So his team
was looking for this this afterglow for
entirely the wrong reason because the
universe we don't believe the universe
is pulsated like that. This has happened
with the discovery of planets. I mean
the first planets were found around a
pulsar weren't they? I can't remember.
Yeah. There's a planet around a pulsar.
Yeah. Obviously they couldn't be there
couldn't be any life on them because a
pulsar is a super dense object with a
lot of radiation around it. that this
triggered people to actually look at
real stars, you know, because they
detected, they detected it by the wobble
of the stars. So the star, the uh pulsar
was moving backwards and forwards
because it was being periodically tugged
from one side and the other side by a
planet. And this got people looking at
real stars and sure enough they began to
find planets. And now we probably got
five or 6 thousand extra solar planets
that have been found. So again, you
know, there's all these accidental
things that actually happen. I really
love this the way the way this work. One
of my heroes is Fred Hy who was at
Caltech, but he he in fact quacked the
problem of where all the all the
elements in your body come come from. He
found the about eight or nine processes,
nuclear processes in stars that made all
the elements. They put together some
pieces of information. He was working on
radar during the Second World War. He
came to America in that time. He was
supposed to be doing war work but he
went went to California he met an
astronomer for water ber who was at
Caltech bard gave him some uh papers on
supernovi stars that explode and on his
way back he got delayed in Montreal
because of bad weather and he bumped
into a lot of people that he knew from
Cambridge and he knew they'd been
working on a project called tube alloys
which was the British project to build
an atomic bomb you know so he he knew
and he He gathered from reading between
the lines that there was a problem.
There was a problem that they they had a
problem trying to build an atomic bomb.
And he couldn't think what the problem
could be. He knew that one of the
elements that would be used was
plutonium. And he realized that
plutonium as you push two bits together
to to get a critical mass would generate
so much heat that it would push itself
apart. So the only way you could
actually create the nuclear reactions of
a of a nuclear bomb was to implode this
stuff.
Inb had realized that supernova were
exploded by the implosion of stars. And
he put the two ideas together and he
thought is it the implosion of a star at
the end of its life that creates the
billions of degrees necessary to meet
heavy elements. So the idea come from
the atomic bomb. So it's just weird the
way ordinary ideas come together and and
he was able to show in about 1946 that
you could uh in what we we would get
what's called nuclear thermodynamic
equilibrium basically um the the the
relative abundance of elements would
freeze out and he was able to show that
the relative abundance of these elements
like iron and nickel and all these these
was exactly what we'd observed and so
that was the information which came from
the atomic is just being delayed in
Montreal. that bit of information that
gave him he was able to predict the
relative abundances of some elements and
then he came to Caltech in 1953 and the
reason he came to Caltech was because he
was at a conference in Italy on galaxies
and Walter Ber had presented a result in
which he realized that the distance
indicators u there were two types of
what we call sephi variables uh and and
we had not realized there were two types
and If you realize this, you realize
that in fact the universe was twice as
old as we had thought. And he had
presented this in a paper, but there has
been there were two people in the
audience who then quickly published a
paper with Bard's result as if it was
theirs. and Hy had been sitting there
because they didn't have a secretary to
record the the results and he was able
to prove that Barta had had his idea
stolen and Bart was so pleased that when
he went back to Caltech he wrote to P
and said I've persuaded people here to
to have you come over would you like to
come over he went over he met Willie
Fowler who was a nuclear physicist uh
and he had a prediction uh you probably
know this prediction that the problem in
in building up the elements is when you
get helium if you stick two helium
nuclei together you get burillium 8 and
it's not stable. So how do you get to
heavier elements? So he thought maybe
occasionally three helium nuclei collide
at the same moment. It's like you know
in a in a supermarket car park three
people in their shopping trolley all
collide at the same time. And if this
reaction was what is called what we
would call resonant then then you would
get the formation of carbon and then you
could build all the heavy elements. And
he went to Willie Fowler and Willie
Fowler was a nuclear physicist and I
this there's something that physicists
will never admit to you and that but
they've only ever solved one problem
exactly and that's the twobody problem.
So they've only solved that problem of
an electron going around a proton in a
hydrogen atom, the moon going around the
earth. That's the only problem they can
solve exactly. Once you get to three
bodies or more, it's not possible to
solve it exactly. It turns out that a
nucleus of of carbon has 12 particles in
it, six neutrons and six protons. This
finding out anything about it like its
energy energy states was impossible. And
this guy from England with round
spectacles turned up in Willie Fowler's
lab at Caltech and he said something
that no nuclear physicist or he claimed
something that no nuclear physicist
would ever claim. He said it's got an
energy state at this particular level
because he knew it had to in order for
three helium nucleide to come together
and make carbon 12. And uh there was a
discussion and um and they realized that
they had measured the properties of
carbon 12 but if it had they might just
have missed something. 3 days later they
found the carbon 12. He's the only
person to have made a prediction ahead
of what you call an anthropic argument.
So his only argument was we are here
we're made of carbon therefore this
state of carbon must exist.
Sorry, the so-called oil oil mirror. The
other thing is because he actually
coined the term big bang and never
believed in it and uh he worked very
closely with my late great colleagues
Jeff and Margaret Burbage. Absolutely
right. He was considered to be a rather
difficult character and a bit of a loner
but actually history shows that he had
incredibly loyal colleagues that he
worked with over long periods of time.
You know, Margaret and Jeffrey Burbage
and Willie Fowler. Uh and then when we
we mentioned earlier that the Nobel
Prize Chandra Seiking in 83 and so did
Willie Fowler and that was very
desperately sad for Fowler and Hy
because they were such friends and Balor
knew that Hy should have shared the
prize with him because it had it not
been for that visit to Caltech in 1953
Fowler said I would have been be I would
have been a run-of-the-mill nuclear
physicist. In fact, he actually worked
out the uh he'd actually been able to
prove the the the what we call the
carbon nitrogen oxygen cycle which
generates heat in in massive stars. So
he had done something but the actual
discovery of of of where all the ele you
know all the elements came from that was
due to Fred Hy in 1943. So you know that
was so sad. Hy told me that he was very
very upset for three days and then go in
bell he said well I know the history
books will remember that I did this uh
but it was it was very very sad because
I mean there's a man called Jacob
Bronovski who did a big TV series in
Britain uh and he said a genius is
someone with two good ideas I had two
good ideas he
he theory which was wrong but it was
testable it was testable and it was it
turned out that the universe was born in
the big bang. Uh, and he was wrong, but
it but it made testable predictions and
of course he figured out where all the
he all the elements in our bodies come
from. So he he's certainly had two good
ideas. Marcus, this has been a delight.
I I think of you whenever I think of a
very clear crisp uh explanations that
turn math and mystery into meaning for
telling the human stories. And I think
black holes are in a sense the
universe's refusal to explain itself.
you can uh as as your late great friend
at at Caltech uh Richard Fineman said,
you can uh dance with nature, but she
won't let you dip her, lift her veil,
something like that. And I want to just
uh thank you for the great work that
you're doing. And where can people find
out more about you? Thank you very much.
I've really enjoyed our conversation.
Well, I've got a website called
www.
Marcus.marcus. So it's N A R C U S ch H
O WN.com co N and you can get my book if
you want from Barnes & Noble or Amazon
or or any of these places hopefully in
bookstores in America. Uh we had a real
problem recently. We had a cyber the
publisher had a cyber attack so they
weren't able to reprint but I think
they've reprinted by now. Maybe it fell
into a black hole. You know the the the
cyber attack. Marcus, thank you so much.
I'll let you uh get back to to your
evening and I just want to thank you
again for this wonderful book, A Crack
in Everything. And that's how the light
gets in. So now we'll ring the bells
that still can ring. Thank you, Mark.
He's very mad at Brian.