How to know if Apollo 11's Lunar Module (aka Eagle) is still in orbit around the Moon 52 years later? An amateur space fan used NASA's GMAT software to know it. The GMTA software simulated the orbit of Apollo 11's Lunar Module and discovered that it may not have landed on the moon. Simulation software has shown that Eagle can fly in a stable orbit around the moon. This is an exciting finding because it is common for spacecraft to hit the moon since the 'lumpy' nature of lunar gravity tends to cause orbits to end up being so elliptical that they collide. Eagle is the name of Apollo 11's Lunar Module, which brought Neil Armstrong, and Buzz Aldrin to the lunar surface. This video explains the story in detail.
We greatly appreciate the video-creation team, so please allow us to upload this video to this channel in order to share knowledge and spread good values to all. The original video's source is credited below. Thank you very much
Cre: @scottmanley (YouTube)
Hello it's Scott Manley here. In 1969 Apollo 11 took Armstrong, Aldrin and Collins to the moon
for one of the most important flights in human history. The spacecraft on top were named Columbia
and Eagle and you know we know where Columbia is it returned to earth and I actually saw it in a
museum but Eagle the lander that actually carried them to the surface we know the descent stage is
on the surface of the moon because that was left behind but the ascent stage was dropped into lunar
orbit and many people had presumed that this capsule had eventually crashed into the moon
because the moon tends to do that to things left in lunar orbit. The lunar gravitational field is
non-spherical and if you put an object in a random circular orbit low around the moon what happens
is the orbit gets more eccentric and the perilune the point of closest approach
tends to get lower and lower until it hits the surface of the moon and the spacecraft crashes.
This happened to all five of the lunar orbiter spacecraft which were used to map the moon for
the Apollo program it happened to the two sub-satellites deployed on Apollo 15 and 16.
We know however that it didn't happen to the ascent modules for the later Apollo missions
because they were all intentionally crashed into the moon to provide data for the seismometers
that were landed there. In the case of Apollo 10 its ascent module named Snoopy was ordered to burn
its engine to depletion it pointed itself in deep space and kept going until it ran out of fuel
and it was then lost until recently when an asteroid named 2018 AV2 had an orbit which
brings it back to the right place and the right time so we believe that Apollo 10's ascent module
is still safe in deep space. But Apollo 11's ascent module is a far more important artifact
for human history and there's a chance that it may in fact still be orbiting the moon today.
A couple of years ago an amateur space fan based in Silicon Valley decided that he would go looking
for the impact site of the Apollo 11 capsule but to get an idea about where it could land on the
spacecraft and model it through time to figure out what parts of the moon it could very likely
end up hitting. And so he started out with an application called GMAT. This is a an open
source application developed by NASA called the General Mission Analysis Tool and it lets you
design missions. It has all sorts of tools for plotting orbits and calculating orbits so he
wanted to put the spacecraft in orbit around the moon and see where the orbit would carry it.
So this is what it looks like I just want to give you a quick idea of what's going on here.
This is my spacecraft here if I double click on it you can see the orbital elements here you know
the semi-major axis which is the radius of the orbit relative to the center. You have your
eccentricity which I've set to be actually extraordinarily low a circular orbit.
11 degree inclination I've set the date to be like 1971 because why not. And then we have
the propagator. Now the propagator is the thing that does the math and so you know you have all
these different integrators these algorithms for doing it. I've just picked this one here
and you can tell it what kind of gravity model and how much resolution you want in your gravity
model. They have up to 165 orders that's it's a bit like saying the number of pixels you have in
your image. This is like a 16 by 16 pixel image as opposed to 165 by 165. This is just the sort
of resolution at which the gravity field is understood and down here you can select the
number of planets that are going to be applying point gravitational forces so you know earth,
jupiter, mars, sun, venus. We can add them all if we want but yeah if you then take this and run it
you get these nice outputs. So this graph down here shows you the altitude of the spacecraft
over time and it starts out very close to its static altitude but over time it starts to go
up and down every orbit. And what you're seeing of course is the outside here this is your apogee
or apolune anyway and this is your perilune down here this is the closest point. You see where the
zero point is here if this perilune point gets down to the surface then we're pretty sure the
spacecraft is going to actually have an interaction although there are actually places on
the moon below the sea level. But yes bang there you go it's doing a bit of rendering here and it
tells us that it probably hit in this region of the moon although I haven't gone and done all the
detailed calculations for the altitude I just want to show what this looks like. Now it might be
better if I change this just to show the altitude of the perigee so I can do this right I can modify
this I want to go in here and I want to look for a radius of the perigee here rad peri make sure
it's a central body of the moon otherwise you'll get the distance relative to the earth. Let's take
this out but also let's add in the altitude at which the the surface of the moon is right so
let's add that in there and we'll have a new plot next time so apply that okay and we're also going
to change the inclination of this right what I'm going to do is change the inclination to be you
know like 28 degrees apply this click ok and start it running so it's going to recalculate this now
this is only showing the closest point the thing gets to the moon on every single orbit and because
I've changed the inclination the way all those gravitational harmonics affect it are changed as
I haven't changed the altitude the thing's still going around the moon in the same period but the
high latitude effects affect it in different ways and this one actually keeps going a lot longer in
fact there are certain latitudes or certain inclinations where the orbits are much much
more stable these are called frozen inclinations or frozen orbits and if you once you understand
this about the moon you can actually very carefully put your spacecraft in these target orbits so that
you don't need to expend fuel to keep them in their target orbit and this is what the lunar
reconnaissance orbiter does it tries to stay in an orbit which is never going to hit the moon
even if you just let it go so now to figure out where Apollo 11's ascent module is you need to
figure out the orbital elements at the time the orbit it was in and you know we can see images
from mission control in that era showing that it was in a very low inclination orbit around the
moon but more detailed data is needed and that's found in the Apollo 11 mission report which
includes this line that tells you the latitude longitude altitude and the velocity vector
of the Apollo spacecraft when they released the ascent stage but they very quickly realized there
was a mistake in this table the space fixed heading angle that's more or less the heading
the bearing this was minus 97.81 and that meant that it was 7.81 degrees away from a perfect
retrograde orbit however Apollo was on a retrograde orbit that was within two degrees of perfect
therefore that number was impossible but digging through NASA's technical report server turned up
this paper and this paper is interesting because it's actually trying to look at the lumpiness of
the lunar gravity field by looking at Apollo's orbits and it did include orbital elements which
made much more sense so he built a simulation using this orbit using this time starting time
and you get the same effect you see the perilune dropping down towards the moon and then going back
up it does this oscillation every 22 days or so and it gets very close to the surface of the moon
and then it starts going back up again so this is a kind of oscillation that you will see a
libration as the moon moves through its orbit and the perturbing forces of the earth and the sun
change positions over time so the next thing was let the simulation run longer a lot longer like
51 years and he finds that it never gets close enough to the surface of the moon to hit it
but wait we know orbits can be chaotic they can be highly sensitive to their initial conditions
and the initial conditions are derived from documents that are really old so what do you do
well you take a guess at the error bars and you create hundreds of copies of the object in slightly
different orbits that all fit the parameters that you have derived from the material and for those
hundred objects none of those came close to the surface of the moon and then to be sure you can
take the worst examples from that set and calculate their orbits further for longer just to
see if there's a long-term effect that you might be missing sure enough none of those ended up
coming into orbits that ended up hitting the moon so this to me looks like he's really done his
homework and tested everything possible but you know if you think of something else he has all
the code online in github so i'm prepared to believe that apollo 11's lunar module is still
orbiting the moon there's a pretty good chance of that i mean there's things that we can't possibly
model at this point it might have it might have just exploded right there was propellant in those
tanks there might be some uh gas leak that has changed its orbit it might be spinning and the
arkofsky effect might actually be important but there's a good chance that it's there and i think
actually it's worth nasa's time to go out with uh planetary radar and see if they can find an object
in a low equatorial orbit around the moon that matches that of this incredibly historical object
but equally i want you to look at this story and see that space is for everybody and not in the way
that virgin galactic and blue origin are saying in that if you have tons of money you can fly
with them i mean you can do space research you can do space science because you have access to
all these free tools now you have the ability to download data from hubble from juno from all
sorts of cutting-edge world-class astronomical and at space instruments i know a space fan who
started out by downloading and processing data and sharing on the internet and now he's a mars
rover driver so the possibilities are there if you want to spend the time to answer questions like
this i'm scott manley fly safe