Building the Bouchie Dory - Part 37 - Sea trials

Nomad Boatbuilding
98 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 20, 2022
My website: https://www.nomadboatbuilding.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nomadboatbuilding/
It's not about the money but living isn't free...
Buy some merch: https://www.nomadboatbuilding.com/shop/
Support these videos with monthly or annual pledges at Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/nomadboatbuilding
Or make a one time donation: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/nomadboatbuilding
Hi, I'm Mark Rutten. Welcome back to Nomad Boatbuilding. Now here we are. We're at the
last episode of our Bushi Dory series. The dory is done. I'm just going to take it out and take
it for a little spin and see how it handles in the water. This has been a fairly long project,
longer than I expected it to be. In this case I was planning to build a boat that I was going to
knock out in about 160 hours. Well, I went way over that. I put in about 260 hours, give or take
a little bit. Now that's not really an unreasonable length of time for an average boat of about this
size. The main difference in that time is level of finish. I put a lot more effort into little
details, trying to make artistic decisions that will enhance the boat, and all that takes time.
If I wasn't concerned about a lot of that stuff, yes, we could have gotten it built a whole lot
faster, but it would have looked a lot rougher. It wouldn't be the same boat by any means.
I have to say I really enjoyed this. The boat went together pretty good without too many hiccups.
There were a few, there always are, but we got over them. If I were to build this again,
there's certain things I could do to build it simpler. Doing these thole pins, for instance,
it seems like such a simple thing to just drill a couple holes in the shear line of a boat,
but you need to have enough meat in that shear line in order to take those holes and to be strong.
For those thole pins to be long lasting, they need to be fairly robust, in my opinion,
and in order to keep them in place, they need to be tapered. If you put straight thole pins in,
they're going to wobble around and you might not like that when you're rowing. So making tapered
thole pins was certainly an extra effort. Now we found a pretty fast and easy way to do that,
but that's not always the case. Sometimes you don't come up with those fast and easy ways.
And certainly it took a little bit of thinking and a bit of time in order to come up with that
fast, easy way. So sometimes it's a zero-sum game when you're coming up with new ideas
that are innovative and functional and give you a result that you desire.
Now doing this fully capped rail was a huge amount of work. I don't know if it was worth it.
There's a lot of ways I could have done it differently, and doing the full blocking all
the way through to the both ends of the boat, that was also a lot of work. I don't regret doing it,
but it certainly took up a lot of time. I really have to question whether I would do it again.
I could have probably achieved a similar thing by just doing a long mid-section cap through here,
made out of hardwood, to carry these full fins. We could have also put on conventional oarlocks,
which would have made things a lot faster as well. The thwart riser is a good example of
someplace where we put in time and effort. We didn't absolutely have to. I think the results
are really attractive, and I'm happy about that. But if I wanted to do this simpler,
I would not have tapered it. I would not have beveled the top. I would not have bothered with
the little details, like rounding the ends nicely, chamfering the edge nicely. You could
have just done a quick and dirty sort of knock the corners off, call it good, slap in something
that's square. The thwarts, we took the time to notch it around these frames. We didn't absolutely
have to do that. We could have stopped them short of the frames, and just had them riding on the
thwart riser. It wouldn't look as good, but it would have been fine. We could have built this
boat without sawn frames running throughout. Now, I know those do take the place of temporary molds
when we're building, so one can argue that it's time well spent. In other ways, using temporary
frames would have sped things up a little bit. I wouldn't have to spend the time fairing these out.
If I had added frames later on, they would have probably sat square to the planking, which is fine,
but you wouldn't have been able to do things like drop the thwarts nicely around those frames.
You could do it with the center thwart, with the fore end and aft end. You couldn't do that because
the frame is sitting at a funny angle, and you'll never get it so that the thwart drops onto them
cleanly. You always end up having to sort of do an enlarged hole to get it to work around the bevels.
Now, this boat didn't absolutely need floorboards, but I put them in. I think it's a nice detail. I
think it's a nice way to keep the boat clean. It keeps your feet out of the water if there happens
to be water inside. Now, if I had just used some premium stock that didn't have knots in it, I
could have gotten this done maybe a little bit faster. I wouldn't have had to bore out the knot
holes and plug them. That wasn't really a big deal, but all these little things add up. However, I was
able to use more economically priced material that I had on hand, and that's an important detail right
there. I had it on hand. It had been sitting in the shop for a few months, so it was really good
and dry. If I'd gone out shopping for material, I might have ended up with green stuff. Even if I
got it premium, or if I'd gone and tried to shop for the same economical material, it would have
been right off of the pile, and guaranteed it wasn't going to be well seasoned. So, this was a
good choice, even though it took a little bit of extra time. Personally, I don't mind the texture
of the knots and the flat sawn wood. Having all edge grain wood would have been a little bit better
to have, but this isn't the end of the world, and you got to think of these a little bit as a
disposable item. And of course, we didn't necessarily need to put in floorboards. We could have just
left this thing alone, especially if I had put frames in later, instead of at the beginning. I
could have had a clean, uncluttered bottom, and that would have worked really well without floors.
Now, if you remember, we had some trouble with the transom. I had some fasteners blow through
the transom, because I didn't make the transom heavy enough in the first place. That was
regrettable, but the result now, I think, looks pretty good. Using the book-matched
heavy half-inch veneer, I think, looks nice. It makes that feature look much more furniture-like.
The sculling knots in the transom. Well, we put a fair bit of effort into making those ears look
really pretty and sculptural. We didn't absolutely have to do that. We could have cut these off here,
and I think that would have looked just fine. In fact, in some ways, I could envision this boat
without those ears sticking up and looking just great. I like the sort of bare simplicity,
especially since we don't have a stem head projecting through. Going without ears would
have been just fine, but I like the ears. I think they add character. We put the rope
strops in the ends. I like those quite a bit. I think they're attractive, especially in a dory.
I think they're sort of a key detail that really says Grand Banks Dory. They were used, of course,
in the fishing trade, and those strops were used to lift the boats in and out of the ocean and onto
the deck of the schooner, and they would have stacked these boats up. The becket in the back, I think,
looks really good. If you want to do some sculling, you can use it to wrap around the top of your oar.
You just slip your oar through there, and then it helps as a keeper to keep your oar from rising up
while you scull with it. It's also, of course, a really great handle for grabbing the back end of
these boats. The nature of these boats with this really raked transom makes them very hard to grab
onto. There's nothing that really presents itself nicely, so the becket is an awesome little addition
there. I like sculling notches no matter what, partially because if you ever want to put a boom
tent on, or you want to just put a winter tarp on, the sculling notch is just a natural place to put
a ridge pole. Now the material for the forks is really nice and robust. I had really nice five
quarter inch cedar stock on hand to do it with. I made the center fork just a little bit thicker
by about an eighth of an inch, so it's actually about a full one and an eighth inch thick right
now, whereas the thorn aft seats are both a full solid one inch thick. It adds a ton of stiffness
to the to those forks, and you don't have to have little stanchions in the bottom. Now the bilge
drain was something that I'm glad I put in. I was kind of waffled a little bit. I think it's sort of
a must, but it does, again, it takes time, and these bilge drains are always made a little bit too chunky
for these small boats, so you always have to put some extra effort into putting some pads on the
backside to hold the fasteners and to allow for the thickness of the part. I did an epoxy wet out
of that area in the bilge back there to make sure that any standing water doesn't cause any
long-term damage. In hindsight, I wish I'd put a layer of fiberglass on the inside of the planking
of the bottom and on the inside of the garbage as well. That would have made a really, really nice
waterproof boat that could stand up to abuse in the long term, especially if we talk about abuse
that comes just from storage. Sometimes you don't pay attention to what's going on with your boat
and you open up and pull the tarp back to find out something's been leaking in there, and you've got
a pool of water in there, and I've done that myself too. It'd be nice to know that you basically have
a fiberglass swimming pool to contain all of that. However, again, this project wasn't priced
to accommodate that sort of treatment. Now we fiberglassed the outside of the garbage, and I'm
glad I did that as well. That's going to make for a good robust hull that can take a lot more abuse,
and of course it makes for a completely dry ride when you go to use this the first time after a
few months of being out of the water. Now I haven't taken all the surface finishes up to what I would
call a yacht quality. For the most part, things are sanded out to roughly 120 grit, which is perfectly
fine for taking paint. There are places where if you were to use varnish, a little bit of scratch
marks would show through. I don't think that's the end of the world, because this isn't intended to
be a tickety-boo boat. This is for someone to play around with and row. I don't want it to be so
precious that they're afraid to get into it. I think that's a really important detail. If you
drop something in your boat and it makes a ding, if you're crying about it, maybe you've got the
wrong boat. I like a boat that can take some knocks and bangs and still look good at the end
of it, and I think this boat will fit that bill perfectly. Here we are. The workshop is empty,
except for the strong back, which I still need to break down. And there we've got the boat sitting
on this little utility trailer. This is for lawnmowers and stuff. And this is one of the
things I love about flat-bottom boats, is you can get away with using just about anything for a
trailer. They'll slide into the back of the pickup just fine, they'll slide onto this thing just fine,
whatever you've got available. So we're going to strap this down and take it down to the harbor
and take it for a spin. Well, here we are. We've got the Dory on the trailer and we're up to the
marina to go and take it for a splash. And I'm really excited about this. I don't know how it's
going to go. On one hand, I worry about the boat being a little bit tiddly and sort of light and
too jumpy. On the other hand, it feels like it's got some pretty good weight to it.
I didn't try to make it heavy, but when you start adding all the bits and pieces and you try and
make everything look a bit robust, well, that's just what happens. You get a bit of weight. And
I don't think weight in a small boat is a terrible thing. There's a point at which it's heavy and
what we call burdensome. That has a bit more to do with the hull form.
If it's too heavy and doesn't move through the water very easily, then that's not a good thing.
But on the other hand, if it moves through the water nicely and it's got a bit of weight to it,
that's not a terrible thing because you get some momentum. It's a little harder to get it up and
moving, but once it's moving, it keeps on going. Especially when you get into choppy water,
you want something with a bit of weight to it because nothing is more unsettling than a boat
that's too light jumping around in a light chop. So we're going to go see my good friend Ed,
the master of the harbour, and he's going to help us launch this thing and get some photographs of
it. I'm really excited. Ed hasn't seen this boat yet. I don't think he's seen it at all,
even from the start, but he's probably followed it a little bit on Instagram,
so I think he's going to be pretty excited to see it.
Yeah, why don't you just man the camera and I'll worry about helping this.
Is it going to be good? Can I lift by here? Yep.
She's got some weight to her, all right. What would you think, Carl? What do you think weight-wise?
Somewhere over 100, but probably much more.
I'm going to have to go a little step here because I've got a broken bone on my right
wrist. Oh, nice. Good to do that. Awesome, that's nice. There you go. Sit. Oh, that's perfect.
Well, a little tender at first to get into,
but it feels like nothing under oars. How's the trim?
Yeah, good. Bound just a hair out of the water? Bound the hair out. Perfect.
This is just fine as a 12-footer, but as a 14, it would be...
Another body. How's the trim now, man?
Way low by the stern? No, actually not that low at all. It looks really well balanced right now.
If you want, you can go about two, three meters in that direction. I can take a picture,
then you can clearly see. I'm not going far because Carl and I have a terrible
history with two of us in a small boat. Oh, capsizing? Especially in inclement weather.
This is a perfect little boat for gunk hauling for sure.
I have to say the maneuverability of this thing is fantastic.
Extremely impressed. It's definitely up to my expectations.
You know what? I like these full fins. There's something nice about them. It's like, you know,
they're not going to jump out of the oar locks on you, right? You've got this range of motion
that you don't have with oar locks. The ability to just sort of go through that and drop back in
in a heartbeat. Because you got to do that from time to time to scare away dolphins and stuff.
Get off some seals.
Well, we're finally finished. At least as far as I'm going to take this boat.
The customer is planning to paint it, and normally I would say, yeah, go right ahead. However,
this boat is looking awfully pretty the way it is, and I kind of hate to see paint going all over it.
Now, I would like to see paint going down on the garbage. I think that would look great.
On the inside though, I might be inclined to say, strike a line, maybe following the top of the
garboard plank, and paint that from that down. Cutting a nice clean line around all the frames.
I think that could look kind of interesting. Separating out the wood tones with a splash
of bold color. I think that can look really good. And I would be inclined to paint the sheer,
mostly because this wood that we've used for the sheer caps, this yellow cedar,
is actually flat sawn. It would do well to be well protected, keep that wood movement down
to a bare minimum. So I think another bold color on the sheer line could look good.
And for me, I'd be inclined to go with maybe cream for the sheer line, and something bright
for down inside. I personally like sage greens. I also like grays, but this customer likes orange,
so I think that could look really good. A nice red lead orange would look really nice in this boat.
Now early on, I was really concerned about having this yellow cedar cut water,
because it contrasted with the rest of the woods in the boat. Now that we have yellow cedar caps
on here, I feel much better about it. And if one were to varnish this whole boat, I think it would
look just fine. I really think it's important to have these details tie in together with some other
part of the boat. This was a hybrid construction, which means I didn't follow the traditional
methodology for building a Grand Bank Story. In some ways, I kind of wish I had. I think this
project would have gone a little bit faster if I'd gone completely traditional. However,
a completely traditional build would not have resulted in a boat that's particularly happy on
a trailer, and so that wouldn't have served my customer very well. I think we've struck
a really good balance, and we've come up with a boat that's unique, that is true to the character
of the style of the Grand Bank Story that was set out at the very beginning, and yet has some
elements of it that are all its own, that you wouldn't necessarily find on your typical Grand
Banks. Alright folks, that's it for the Bushidoori series. I hope you enjoyed that. I certainly had
fun putting it together for you. I want to thank you all for watching. I want to thank everybody
on Patreon who makes these videos possible. You can help us out there. I really appreciate it.
Links in the corners, down in the description. And until the next boat building adventure,
keep your stick on the ice!
