In the Second World War, in May 1940 the German Wehrmacht invaded The Netherlands, Belgium, and France, knocking France out of the war in just 6 weeks, something they had failed to do in the First World War. Yet despite the total defeat of the French Army, a zone in the south and centre of France remained a 'free zone' with its own government, army, and navy. So, why didn't the Germans take all of France in 1940?
Music Used: 1812 Overture - Tchaikovsky Sunday Dub - Kevin MacLeod
when it comes to historical memes about
France the surrender meme is probably at
the top of the most famous now we can
talk about whether that's warranted
another time but it might be more
interesting to ask why did France
surrender in the second world war
potentially this has become such an
internet sensation I say that as if it
happened recently because in 1940 it
came as such a shock as compared to the
first world war when from 1914 to 1918
the the French together with their
allies the British and the belgians on
the Western Front had stuck it out and
for four years had fought on despite
losing huge amounts of Manpower
resources and indeed territory to the
invading Germans it was on the basis of
a similar War being fought that the
French government in the 1930s invested
in a very heavily Fortified Area around
their borders with Germany this would
become known as the majino line further
south they would also create an Alpine
line thinking that a similar War of
Attrition might be fought and to make it
impossible for the Germans to invade
however when the Germans would invade it
would similarly as actually the first
world war not go through those
well-defended areas of the French border
but rather go through Belgium this time
different to the first world war also
going through the Netherlands
particularly through the area of Belgium
the Aden which the French believed would
be impassible thus catching the Allies
severely off guard they also used other
elements such as attack from the air and
the deployment of paratroopers to really
catch the enemy off guard and after
several weeks of fighting it was clear
that the French were in a terrible
position German Panza units using new
tactics known as The Blitz G were able
to go far further behind French lines
than had been thought and forced the
French to retreat the British as well
and what was left of the British
expeditionary force would Retreat from
Dunkirk after almost being encircled and
destroyed there it was clear at this
point with German troops hairing down
towards Paris that the war really was
already over for the French however
there were several ideas in the French
government about what they should do at
this point it seemed that Mainland
France was indeed lost but several
voices in the French government thought
that they should Retreat to the large
French Colonial possessions in North
Africa and continue the fight from there
bringing as many troops and resources
and crucially the Navy which was largely
still intact with it to continue
fighting while there they could draw on
the considerable resources of the French
Colonial Empire in particularly Africa
and Asia for its substantial Manpower as
well as resources in order to with the
British continue fighting against the
Germans and the Italians others in the
French government favored a more direct
approach a union with the United Kingdom
an angl French Union that could together
continue resisting this would be a huge
conglomerate of the world's two largest
Empires joining together and hopefully
being able to retake France at some
point from Dual locations in North
Africa and indeed in Britain on the 16th
of June even some legislation was being
prepared to this end for a declaration
of Union between the two which the
British hoped would allow the French
prime minister who was broadly in favor
of the plan of convincing the French
government to join this Union and thus
to continue the fight against the axis
it read France and Great Britain should
no longer be two Nations but one Franco
British Union the constitution of the
Union will provide for joint organs of
Defense foreign financial and economic
policy
every citizen of France will enjoy
immediately citizenship of Great Britain
every British subject will become a
citizen of France who knows how Henry V
would have felt about all this but in
the end the French government turned
down this proposal in favor of
surrendering to the Germans now there
were several points in favor three key
points that the French government hoped
that they could achieve by entering into
negotiation with the Germans rather than
simply going over and continuing the
fight from North Africa or joining into
a union with the British these were
number one the ability to maintain
control over at least part of
Metropolitan France number two was the
maintenance of the French Fleet and
number three was maintaining the French
Colonial possessions around the globe as
it happens the Germans in their
negotiations were not against the French
keeping all three of the
at least in part and with many provisors
and so the French government decided
that entering into negotiation and
indeed signing an Armistice with the
Germans was the best thing that they
could have done and so that is exactly
what they did it's also true that at
this point very many Frenchmen had been
taken prisoner by the Germans in their
attacks at this point some 2 million
Frenchmen were prisoners of War to the
Germans and this was quite an effective
bargaining chip for the Germans to use
as well as the fact that at this stage
what was left of the French army and
indeed their military equipment was in
no real situation to really offer any
solid resistance against the Germans who
had completely overrun the north of the
country which resulted in the creation
of what became known as vishi France
this was the center and south of France
as a semi-independent entity while the
North and the Western Seaboard of France
would come under direct German
occupation note as well that vichi
France proper would maintain control of
French Algeria while French Tunisia and
French Morocco would be protectorates of
vichi France given that this is quite a
large area indeed of North Africa and of
France itself a more pertinent question
maybe to ask why did the Germans allow
the French to maintain control when they
could easily have taken taken over the
rest of France as we've just mentioned
well as it turned out many of those
French three reasons that they wanted to
enter into negotiations were also
important to the Germans but for
slightly different reasons one of those
is that the Germans of course would need
many men in order to Garrison and to
maintain order in the parts of France
that they had actually captured if they
were to capture the rest of France as
well then that would mean that they
would need many more troops that could
have been employed elsewhere
particularly in their operation to try
and take Britain or in their
preparations for further pushes in
Eastern Europe against the Soviets by
having the southern part of France being
maintained by French troops French
police French administrators and French
resources it freed up men and resources
for attention else where the Germans as
mentioned had also taken many French
prisoners which they could then use in
labor particularly in construction and
Mining but also in German agriculture
which was severely underand at this
point because so many German men were
off fighting in the military they could
also pressure this Southern French state
which really would be hardpressed to say
no against its powerful German neighbor
in order to send more workers and then
use these prisoners these French
prisoners that they had in captivity as
bargaining ships for releasing a few of
those prisoners in order to get more
workers or more resources and other
favors from this southern region at the
same time they could also rely on this
southern area to police the south of
France hunting down Communists
resistance Fighters and indeed Jews with
the creation of the milise a kind of
militia as well as allowing them a small
army that would be used to defend
against any Allied attacks on French
soil again this freed up men for the
Germans that they could use on other
fronts and for other tasks while these
Southern Frenchmen would do their dirty
work for them another key point in the
Germans accepting a French state to the
South was the French navy which was
really powerful in the second world war
and sometimes doesn't get the credit and
indeed the potential that perhaps it
should should be
recognized another factor in why the
Germans may have wanted to create aishi
French state to the South was the French
navy which had been largely undamaged by
the German invasion given the places
where they were in Port now the French
navy was very large even this is before
the outbreak of war in January 1939 they
had five battleships a battle cruiser 18
Cruisers several carriers 58 destroyers
13 torpedo boats 76 submarines and
several smaller vessels too making it
one of the largest navies in the world
at that time and indeed one of the most
modern now if the Germans had continued
to occupy the rest of France and there
had been no armis between the French
government that the French navy of
course was adhering to their commands
then it's very likely that the French
navy May well have gone over and joined
the Allies elsewhere particularly the
British indeed some French ships
actually did this anyway but their
official orders were to remain in Port
until these negotiations were finished
these ships then together with the
British would seriously have altered the
balance in the battles such as the
battle of the Atlantic and indeed other
Marine combat with the Germans on the
high seas instead with vishy France
officially being a neutral country
although really under the thumb of the
axis it meant that the French navy would
remain in Port and not be involved in
the war this being part of the armistice
that they signed they wouldn't be taken
over by the Germans or the Italians even
though both sides actively plan to do so
at some point they would remain out of
the war now the British were very
worried nevertheless thinking that the
Germans and the Italians would actually
try and take over the French navy and
use it against them this is why shortly
after the negotiations at the French
Algerian port of M El the British would
attack the French Fleet sinking and
damaging several ships and killing over
a thousand French Sailors in their
attack to try and stop these ships
falling into the hands of the Italians
and the Germans in a similar vein the
French Colonial Empire was also at stake
by having an official negotiation or
Armistice with the French government it
meant that all of the French colonies
also became part of the axis area of
control and would fight against Allied
attempts to take them over perhaps most
crucially for the these were the French
Colonial possessions in the northwest of
Africa French Morocco Algeria and
Tunisia as well as French West Africa if
the French had not signed an Armistice
with the Germans and these territories
had continued to fight against the axis
then perhaps the second world war in in
North Africa would have been very
different where the Italians and the
Germans had a safe Western flank being
controlled by the vishi French instead
they would have had a war on two fronts
immediately fighting the British in
Egypt as well as these then free French
continuing French forces fighting
against them in the west and so likely a
different scenario in the first place so
quite interesting to consider and as
mentioned at the time the Germans really
could not afford to be diverting forces
here to be fighting both against a
continuing French Resistance in French
northwest Africa as well as the British
in North Africa later the Americans also
when they were preparing everything for
their attacks on Mainland Britain in
Operation Sea Lion and the Battle of
Britain indeed the French Colonial
Empire is larger than just Africa as you
can see from this map they also had
several Holdings in Asia which actually
were mainly occupied by Japan and
Thailand in 1940 and 1941 but indeed if
all these territories had remained on
the Allied side and the Allies hadn't
didn't have to fight campaigns against
them to take them over Allied Forces and
resources and Logistics could have been
used against fighting the Germans and
the Italians rather than against the
vichi French thus freeing up those
resources and making it a more difficult
job for the axis to fight in the
theaters where they were already
fighting instead they had to commit
these men and resources and slowly from
1940 to
1943 take them back and indeed with the
help of the free French apart from in
Asia where the Japanese kind of ripped
up the whole access rule book and said
okay we're going to take over anyway the
German Navy would have had a very
difficult time in subduing the very
desperate and and far-flung French
colonies when they already had their
hands full fighting the British in the
Atlantic so sidelining the French navy
and indeed keeping the French Colonial
Empire on side was also a big help to
the German Navy and so for all of these
reasons it made sense for the Germans to
take over the north of France but to
keep an
assemblance of an official French
government in the South vichi France
which meant that they had access to
their colonial Empire that the French
navy remained out of the war and they
didn't have to spend so many resources
on occupying and Manning the south of
France however that would all change on
the 12th of November 1942 when the
Germans officially rolled up vishi
France and occupied It Anyway this was
because of the changing nature of the
war particularly in North western Africa
those vishi French colonies where the
Americans together with British help
would launch Operation Torch where
American forces landed in many of these
vishy French areas the Americans indeed
thought if they would land as American
troops that the French would welcome
them as liberators these vishi French
colonies however they fired on them with
machine guns and these areas all had to
be captured many of them with free
French support so those Frenchmen that
did not believe in the armor this and
would continue to fight on the Allied
side although in the end the Vish French
did fight against the Allies in North
Africa however following the success of
this campaign and the threat of an
invasion from North Africa across the
Mediterranean the Germans occupied the
rest of France also booting out the
small area that had been taken over by
the Italians in their 1940 Invasion when
Italy changed sides in
1944 so that is why the German didn't
take over all of France in the second
world war it's something I always found
quite curious um indeed when looking at
maps of occupied Europe and why there
were these two French States that had
existed and why didn't the Germans just
take over everything if they so
successfully trumped the French in the
Battle of France but having done the
research for this video it does appear
to me to make sense why they did it in
terms of the global picture in terms of
their resource and Manpower distribution
which they were of course already
preparing to be sending so much of to
the Eastern front for their fight
against the Soviets then indeed it does
make sense why they allowed vishy France
to continue as an entity uh which did
actually remain pretty loyal to the
Germans as we saw with Operation Torch
in North Africa um and indeed in not
really revolting against the Germans at
any point so anyway let me know if you
found this interesting if you already
knew about vishi France and if you had
anything to add
I have been Hilbert and this has been
the history oh yeah some people get
annoyed when I say I have been Hilbert I
mean technically I have only ever been
Hilbert I am Hilbert I will be Hilbert
so I don't know why the perfective tense
of that is irritating but you can
explain that in the comments Below in
any case I am Hilbert and I will see you
in the next one and this was the history