In the Second World War the Germans invaded the Netherlands in 1940 and annexed it to their expanding Reich. This is well known. But did you know that after the end of the war, the Netherlands tried to annex part of Germany and make it Dutch?
Music Used: 1812 Overture - Tchaikovsky Eine Kleine Nachtmusik - Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Hungarian Rhapsody - Franz Liszt William Tell Overture - Rossini Midsummer Night's Dream - Felix Mendelssohn Sunday Dub - Kevin MacLeod
at the end of the second world war
Europe's borders changed quite a lot but
it wasn't the first
time first
time in fact in 1919 following the
Treaty of versailes Germany in
particular had many of its border
territories given to several existing
and several new States something I
talked about when this channel was still
in its infancy now the Netherlands
wasn't one of the big players in the
second world war it was invaded in 1940
by the Germans and after about a week of
resistance the Army surrendered and the
queen fled to England there to continue
the fight with several of the soldiers
that made it over the channel those
being involved uh fighting alongside the
British at D-Day and in other various
engagements as well as against the
Japanese in Asia particularly in their
colony of the Dutch East Indies as it
was then however in 1945 the Allies
would Liberate the Netherlands and after
the feeling of Jubilation at being
liberated from several years of German
occupation there were also some darker
feelings mixed in feelings of Revenge
some of this was against the Dutch
population who had collaborated with the
Germans others were against those German
soldiers and particularly SS members who
the Dutch could get their hands on who
were forced to clear minefields in 1946
the German civilian population was
targeted in
opari or operation black tulip the F
under or hostile subjects in the
Netherlands that being some 25,000
German citizens in the Netherlands were
targeted for deportation in the end only
3,691 or about 15% of the German
population living in the Netherlands
were actually deported however there was
a lot of angry feeling against Germany
because of what had happened in the war
in particular the 1944 hunger winter or
hunger winter a famine that was
exacerbated by the Germans following a
Dutch rail strike that had happened in
connection with the Allied attack in
operation Market Garden meant that
around 20,000 people starved to death
and many millions went without food for
the winter suffering health problems for
the rest of their lives my grandparents
included this as well as the fact that
the Netherlands had been bombed and
occupied many of its ports sabotaged by
the Germans and also by the allies
during the fighting meant that the
Netherlands was in a pretty bad economic
state in 194 45 as well as the fact that
they would soon be embroiled in a
conflict known as the pich oxis in their
colony of the Dutch East Indies that
meant that in 1945 the Dutch government
decided to ask the Germans for
reparations reparations to the tune
of $ 100
billion or 25 billion gilders now they
knew already they weren't going to get
this in monetary form this had been
decided at the Alta conference one of
the lessons learned from the Treaty of
Versa and the reparations so the Dutch
decided there was perhaps another way
that Germany might pay them back in kind
or actually in land rather than in cash
and this is the bakut Blan named after
the Dutch civil servant Fritz Baker
schut he was clearly having a
particularly good time in Amsterdam
because this plan is absolutely nuts
when you go into it basically the plan
was something concocted by several Dutch
government uh committees one was the
Dutch committee for territorial
expansion another the state commission
for the study of the annexation question
and the study group for territorial
expansion who came together in the Years
following the war and decided that the
reason the Netherlands was lagging
behind was because Germany owed them big
time in terms of land and this was the
only way that they could be repaid for
what had gone wrong in the war
the Bak plan as suggested by the re for
National plan came back to the
government with three different plans
one of very ambitious scope and two of
slightly reduced scope the most
ambitious plan saw several large German
cities such as mster cologne and aan
become part of the Netherlands as well
as around 41 border regions a slightly
reduced version of this plan would
ignore those those larger cities but
still have a large belt surrounding the
Dutch border and an even more reduced
version would see incorporated into the
Netherlands those bordering regions of
ostrand and a belt down the reinland now
why on Earth was this plan suggested
well first was as reparations because
the Dutch realized they weren't going to
receive financial reparations from the
Germans anytime soon so they thought
we'll take a bit of land
there was a lot of Dutch animosity
towards Germany and a certain desire to
have a degree of payback perhaps this
was that opportunity now of course this
seems ridiculous when thinking about
Western Europe but at the same time the
very same thing was happening in Eastern
Europe around half to a third of current
polish territory was German territory
Before the War of course bearing in mind
that this had been polish for several
centuries before that and the population
was incredibly mixed between polls and
Germans not to mention several other
ethnic groups the same cannot be said
for those regions being claimed by the
Dutch however um the vast majority of
people there were German and spoke
either low German or German as a first
language and so it's quite a different
situation however this was enough for
Dutch politicians to suggest the plan
there was some historical president for
a uh Dutch rule over parts of what they
were claiming particularly parts of the
region of OST fand of course the Dutch
have their own fian minority in uh the
province of fron and in 1806 when the
Netherlands was ruled by Napoleon the
kingdom of Holland was actually granted
ostland as part of its territory however
following the end of Napoleonic rule
that was overturned and they were
separated once again although today in
mden you can still see traces of the
Dutch past in its Cathedral there
another factor that the Dutch were
relying on was the fact that most people
in ustand and several of these border
regions spoke low German um dialects of
a language that were very close to other
dialects of the same language in the
Netherlands particularly in areas like
Cronan and the Eastern Netherlands so
across the border they were able to
communicate in the same language a
language which was somewhat closer to
Dutch than it was to German and the
Dutch government hoped that this would
make it easy to assimilate them into
speaking Dutch Dutch rather than German
however this plan was not unanimously
agreed upon in Dutch society and in the
Dutch government in general Catholics
and more conservatives were in favor of
the plan conservatives because it would
enhance the power and Prestige of the
Netherlands and Catholics because most
of the areas that would be incorporated
into the Netherlands were majority
Catholic and so it would mean that
Catholics would make up a a majority of
the Netherlands however the Socialist
and the Liberals were largely against
this plan to incorporate so many Germans
into the Netherlands it also hinged a
lot on the fact that there were
obviously millions of Germans living
there and of these the majority would be
deported others would be given a chance
to either accept Dutch citizenship they
could do this by showing that either
they were a speaker of low German as
their main language instead of high
German or that they had actively sought
to help the Netherlands in the Second
World War the rest would be forced to
leave and the rest would be populated
with Dutch
citizens yeah some something about
having laan's realm in the East this is
a very uncomfortable suggestion and
clearly the lessons from several years
earlier had not been learned at this
point so you can see why it made many
people in the government uncomfortable
to suggest such a plan that included the
Dutch prime minister Vim Schermerhorn
however the queen V helmina was an
Ardent support
of the bakut plan and so the government
came with something of a compromise in
1946 they laid official claim on
4,980 square kilm of German territory
largely in ostland and several other
border regions which was home to around
550,000 Germans that were living there
they might have claimed it but they had
to wait for permission permission which
in 1947 was granted by the Allied High
my commission those are the British the
French and the Americans and they
allowed the Dutch to Annex this region
of Germany it became part of the greater
Netherlands and the dreams of the
burgundians were finally
[Music]
fulfilled yeah that straight up just
didn't happen the Allied High commission
basically
said How about new you crazy Dutch
bastard and told them to bucker shut it
down that was terrible the reason being
that there were already some 14 million
displaced German refugees coming into
Western Germany particularly those who
had been ousted from territory that
would now belong to Poland as well as
several other emerging countries in
Eastern Europe what was happening was
that German minorities some of whom had
lived there already for centuries were
either being forced out or had already
fled in the wake of the Red Army in the
Dying Years of the second world war and
so this contributed to millions and
millions of uh people ethnic Germans and
Germans that were coming into Western
Germany many of these folks duts had
actively supported the Germans supported
the Nazis during the war but others had
been caught in a very uncomfortable
position where really they weren't able
to deny the Germans that were coming
into countries many of them having been
there for centuries and so then they
were scapegoated following the end of
the second world war some of these
so-called Germans were actually a whole
mix of different Germanic speaking
peoples many of whom had left Germany
already in the 17th or 18th centuries
but they were still sent packing to
Germany and so the Allied High command
decided that now was not the time to be
getting even more refugees coming from
some crazy Dutch annexation plan of
Western Germany it's also true that in
1947 Germany was still in ruins and the
Americans and the other allies more
generally wanted a strong resurgent
Germany that would stand up in the face
of Soviet aggression across in East
Germany as it would become and the
developing warsa pack block by further
dividing Germany and giving a large part
of it to the Netherlands this would help
to destabilize and weaken Germany and
instead they decided that it was better
to just shelf this plan so that was it
the Netherlands didn't get any German
territory and bakar never got what he
wanted but not for long in 1949
following the London conference Dutch
troops Mass on the German border and
with one Fell Swoop at around noon they
cross and the annex part of Germany the
Border posts are changed the Netherlands
has done it the bakash plan has it come
to fruition will Germany greatly be
reduced in size and the Netherlands take
a huge bite out of its neighbors
territory no not exactly the Netherlands
have taken over around 69 square kilm of
German territory a lot of it quite
uninhabited um that's around 10,000
people that will now be added into the
Netherlands hardly anyone is deported
and a few Dutch signposts are hung up
the main habited area is being taken
over were Elton selfon which is normally
referred to by its largest Village of
tud in German which then became the
Dutch Place d uh there was also cvic
which is bordering with a Dutch town on
the other side of the border which
became the Dutch z um however it didn't
really last very long in 1957 the German
government the West German government as
it was then started to negotiate with
the Netherlands about getting back this
territory and in 1960 they reached a
deal that in
1963 the territories would be handed
back to the West German government for
280,000 deut Mark which is about €
143,000 in today's money it's fair to
say that the inhabitants were relieved
to become German again and not have to
deal with eating cheese and bread every
lunchtime there are only two things I
can't stand in this world people who are
intolerant of other people's
cultures and the Dutch but one exception
of territory that wasn't handed back to
the Germans was the devil's B known in
German as the Tob or for the Devil's
Mountain a nature reserve of around 3 km
squared that the Nan politician who
lived nearby marinus
F insisted that the Dutch government
kept and was successful so technically
the the total ground that the
Netherlands won in World War II was 3 km
squared territorial change another
interesting case is the case of the road
the N
274 which is highlighted in green there
at the bottom now it look looks like it
disappears into Germany but the road
keeps going and for the longest time
this road was part of the Netherlands
because it was looked after by the ra re
vat the Dutch Highway commission and
there were no turning off points into
Germany you can only drive from the
Netherlands to the Netherlands and back
on this one road even though it is in
Germany this state of affairs was
changed in 2002 when the road was
officially handed back to the Germans
uh and they renamed it l410 as part of
the broader roads and you can now drive
off that road onto other roads into
Germany a little post-war example of
crossborder shenanigans following World
War II between the Netherlands and
Germany now let me know in the comments
below because I think it might be fun if
people have enjoyed this video to do a
little what if uh what if this buckers
cut plan had actually been accepted by
the Allies let's say uh someone answered
the wrong Telegram and they decided okay
uh this can go ahead what would history
have looked like what would the
Netherlands have looked like in terms of
its demographics and Germany um what
would the place names be in this new
area the Dutch had drawn up a whole list
so there's definitely more that I can
say about this if you are interested in
such a video being made now if you are
new to the channel check out some of my
other videos about the history of the
Netherlands and the history of Germany
I've got quite a few videos stacked up
at this point about them and let me know
in the comments below if you enjoyed it
any more information about this um and
any other videos you'd like to see in
the future huge thank you to the patrons
for making it possible for me to
continue making videos and I will see
you all in the next one I have been
Hilbert and this has been the history Al
Fe in