The LOST Fighting Knives of Medieval Ireland

Ancient Swords
6 followers
5 Video Views·Feb 26, 2026
The Irish Skean was the traditional fighting knife of Ireland until at least 1700 and I was inspired to make some from reading 'The Skean' by Robert Gresh simply because they are so strange and unusual and frankly because in 30 years of making knives I haven't made one of these. Whilst talking to Robert he asked if I could make a Tod Cutler version and here we are.
So this was a fighting knife and so little is known about them.
Hi, it's Tod of Tod's Works. I'm Tod Cutler here and today we're going to talk about
the Irish scheme. So these are fantastically interesting and mysterious fighting knives.
15th, 16th, 17th centuries in Ireland. So it's a Gaelic fighting knife that was everywhere.
You see it in the pictures, you read about it in the literature, but there are so few of them left.
But before we carry on and we talk about the knives themselves, we're going to have a little
bit of background about why I'm making them and what it's all about. Last year a great new book
came out and it is The Scheme by Robert Gresh. And one of the things that makes this a really
good book is the information in it is basically not replicated anywhere else. So this was a
fighting knife, a massively important fighting knife of Ireland for the best part of 300 years.
So this book covers 1500 to 1700, but they would have gone a little bit earlier than that. And so
little is known about them. You can't find this information in other places. So if I look for a
book on bollock daggers or something, I'll see the same dagger in several of the books that I have.
Rondel daggers, the same thing. The scheme, there is nothing, and I'm telling you now,
of any importance that is not in this book. Anyway, this is not a book review about that,
but the thing is what we did do is we had a quick chat about these things and he asked if I would
make a Todd Cutler version, basically an accessible version of the scheme for the masses.
And that is what I have done. So we have ourselves a long one and a short one. Skenefada
Meardog. Pronunciation is probably hideous, but I am not 16th century gay. Scheme came in two
varieties. And first of all, we're going to talk about the Schemefada and later on the Meardog.
Make no mistake about it, Schemefada were big knives. So this one here has got a 14 and a half
inch blade, 38 centimetres, eight millimetres thick, which is I think five sixteenths of an
inch, something like that. But this isn't the biggest. So we've got a good example here,
12 millimetre thick, half inch spine. Absolute monster. So when you're talking about a knife
like that, that's like part sword, part dagger, part bar mace. It's going to be one heck of a
piercer, but it's also going to be one heck of a club as well. And this Todd Cutler piece here
is a formidable fighting knife. It really is. But the long blade is twinned with a fairly short
handle. And that is exactly as the originals were. Now, if we look at this Dirk here, you can see
that there's striking similarities between the blade form. Very broad, single edged, relatively
thick, relatively long. And the thing is, there's cultural ties, very strong cultural ties between
Scotland and Ireland. So you can imagine, and it's not unreasonable that there would be
similarities between the two. But then when it comes to the grips, actually, they've gone really
in quite different directions indeed. So the Dirk itself clearly has developed on from the medieval
bollock dagger. It has the bollocks on the bollock dagger and it has those same bollocks here on the
Dirk. Later on, shortly after this, let's say by 1700, that's stylised out of the picture and it's
no longer clearly a bollock dagger. But at this period, they are. But let's forget about the Dirk
now, because this is about the scheme. Now, when it comes to the long and the short schemes, they seem
to be decorated in two distinctive styles. One is decorated like the short schemes, the other is
decorated like the long. So the long schemes have this distinctive spiral that runs around the grip.
They have a grip that's wasted in this form, in this shape, and wasted in that way as well. A little
bit of decoration, top and bottom, a band of it. But then above and below that decoration are these
really distinctive metal rings. Now, the one at the bottom creates fantastic reinforcement for the
grip, because these are long, heavy knives. They're going to put a complete battering onto the grip
and actually there's a real chance that these things are going to fracture away.
And so that bottom ring gives you really good support there. The top ring again, I'm not sure
really what the purpose of it is, but it is certainly decorative and it is certainly there.
That is then fixed with a series of wedges. You can see the wedges, like hammer wood,
are driven in, push the wood apart, lock the ring into place. Very unusual, very strange, and I don't
know any other knives that have been constructed quite like this. So I made a short film last
summer when I was making the samples for these pieces, and just have a look at this. It shows
how they're put together, the role of the wedges and the rings and everything else. I'm going to
cut and bend the brass for the ferrules. In some examples, these wedges are really uniform. In
others, they're a little bit random. So you can see here that this particular example is using
the wedges in a very decorative way. The function is still the same, but it is now, well, added
detail. Whereas we have another one here from a short scheme, where you can see that the wedges
are pretty random and they've just been slammed in there haphazardly. So they're not acting as
decoration, but they are functionally doing exactly the same job. Really intriguing way of
approaching it. The grip rings themselves are also interesting. Now I've actually cast these in brass
for cost reasons, but the originals were made in steel. They brass plated them. So the Irish seem
to have a thing for brass plating all sorts of bits and pieces, like arrowheads, spearheads, sword
components, and as it turns out, skein components. So let's look at the shape. So what we have here
is thick leather, single layer, and it's structured in such a way that it comes well up over the
handle. So it secures the knife very well, encompasses, protects the handle. The sheath
itself was incredibly highly decorated. Every single skein example there is has an incredibly
complex sheath. Now again, for the money, I can't deliver that kind of thing. So we've given a
decoration that's evocative of the original pieces. So that's all kind of fairly normal in a way.
A lot of what you would expect for a knife that period. But then we come to the shape. So the
descriptions and what you can kind of make out of any existing pictures of the time show a shape
that looks like it's made of twisted copper or bronze wire. So almost as a spiral going around
the tip. And I have to say actually at this point that many of the sheaths in fact do not have shapes
but the ones that do seem to have something that's constructed much like this. A very peculiar way
of making a shape. But it's also very distinctive. So when you want a knife that stands out from the
others, although I suppose in Ireland it's not going to, but in the modern sense on a reenactment
place, you have a long knife with a decorated sheath, a twisted wire shape, a twisted handle,
carved handle, rings on it, wedges. If you want something distinctive, this is going to be it.
So that's the skein fader or the long skein. So let's have a look at the Miyadogo or Miyadog.
Not sure exactly how to pronounce it, but the short skein. It has many similarities. In the case of
this one here, there is just a slight faceting on the back of the blade. One of the short ones had
that as an example. Otherwise, single edged, stout blade, thick and the handle rings on it and the
wedging. But the handle decoration is quite different. We've gone from this twisted spiral
going around the grip to basically a sort of a Scottish salt air almost. It's slightly unusual.
It's offset. So these limbs are offset from each other. And you might think that that was just an
accident, a bit of bad carving, because I did copy one particular example. But there's another
example where the carving is very distinctive on it and it has exactly that same offset to the salt
air. Why? I don't know. Who knows? But anyway, other than that, the construction of the knife
is basically the same. It's a shorter version made in exactly the same way as the longer one.
So it has the rings. It has the wedges. It has the wasted grip going in that orientation there.
And again, the stout and strong broad blade. So although these are coming in at nine or 10 inches,
so 23, 25 centimetres, again, they can go up to half an inch thick on the blade. So it's going
to be like a pry bar at that kind of thickness. I've gone to one of the thinner ends of the
examples. Again, it's about eight millimetres, but it makes for a very substantial fighting knife,
just like its bigger brother. And the sheath itself is constructed in a very similar way as
well. So it comes high up the handle. It's got decoration on it. And the twisted wire
shape at the bottom. Now, there is a little bit of reference to skeins in the literature.
And these short ones particularly, I think there are two references where in both times
they're talked about being thrown. Now, I would read that to be that they were thrown as part of
that story, part of that situation, part of that event. I do not believe that these are specifically
throwing knives. As much as anything else, this handle construction, it'll last a while, but it's
just not tough enough to be a repeated throwing knife. All of this hard work that's been put into
some really nicely, beautifully made carving is going to get chipped off and knocked off.
Yeah, you can throw it, but you can throw any kind of a knife. I don't believe that that's
what these were. But there's another mention about skeins that I think is really interesting,
really intriguing, and that is Bristol Docks 1526. Now, there is an established trade in shipping
knives from England out to Ireland, but there are two references to shipping knives from Ireland
to England. Now, there was plenty of international trade in arms and armour and all sorts of other
goods in Europe at this period. So, for instance, you might get a suit of armour that is made in
Germany, but it's for the English market, so it's styled for English people, the things that English
people liked, but it was made in Germany. Now, I don't think, and I might be doing a disservice to
Ireland at this period, but I don't think Ireland was sophisticated, advanced enough as a manufacturing
base that it could make knives in the English style to be sold to English people, but making
them in Ireland. Correct me if I'm wrong. So, what I suspect is, in fact, they were exporting Irish
knives. They were exporting skein into England, and that makes it really interesting as well,
because suddenly you have the possibility of guys in London, in Bristol, in Liverpool, walking down
the street with Irish skein, which is not something that I'd really consider. It comes back to the
really interesting aspect, which is that these things are almost nowhere in the record. In this
whole book dedicated to the skein, there are seven examples. That's all Robert has been able to find,
seven examples, but these should be everywhere. This was the standard fighting knife for Kern
and Gallaglass. Maybe they were exported to England as well. They should be all over the
archaeological record, and yet they're not. Throw your hat in the ring. Tell us why you think that
might be the case, because it doesn't seem right to me that there is so little evidence left behind
of a knife that was around for the best part of 300 years. But the other thing that we can conclude
from all of this, is that Todd Cutler makes skein. The short meerdog, the skeinfather, the long one,
and they're available right now. But also, if you enjoyed this, go and check out our website, because
it'll be full of all sorts of things that you're interested in. Go and have a look at our secondary
channel, toddcutler.com, because it's got lots of little niche content about all sorts of stuff.
But again, things you'll be interested in, and if you want to help support us, go and have a look at
the Patreon page. But anyway, Irish skeins, courtesy of Robert Gresh's book. Thank you very much.
