A major new history of the eastern Roman Empire, from Constantine to 1453.
In recent decades, the study of the Eastern Roman Empire, also known as Byzantium, has been revolutionized by new approaches and more sophisticated models for how its society and state operated. No longer looked upon as a pale facsimile of classical Rome, Byzantium is now considered a vigorous state of its own, inheritor of many of Rome's features, and a vital node in the first truly globalized world.
The New Roman Empire is the first full, single-author history of the eastern Roman empire to appear in over a generation. Covering political and military history as well as all the major changes in religion, society, demography, and economy, Anthony Kaldellis's volume is divided into ten chronological sections which begin with the foundation of Constantinople in 324 AD and end with the fall of the empire to the Ottoman Turks in the fifteenth century. The book incorporates new findings, explains recent interpretive models, and presents well-known historical characters and events in a new light.
— CHAPTERS — 00:00 Intro 00:40 What is your book about? 03:15 Did you get to focus on the everyday people? 05:15 How could the Empire sustain for so long? 07:38 Why did you write this book now? 08:39 Did you find anything surprising during your research? 10:50 How did you approach your book? 15:20 On the bad reputation of the Byzantine Empire 22:50 Outro
hello and welcome to world history
encyclopedia my name is Kelly and today
I am joined by author and Scholar
Anthony celis Anthony is a professor in
the department of Classics at the
University of Chicago and his research
explores the history culture and
literature of the East Roman Empire from
Antiquity to the 15th century today we
get to chat to Anthony all about his new
book The New Roman Empire a history of
Byzantium published by Oxford University
press
[Music]
yes thank you so much for joining me
today um I can't wait to talk to you all
about your new book thank you for
inviting me Kelly uh so let's start off
with what your book is all
about yeah it's all about the history of
the Eastern Roman Empire uh also known
as Byzantium from beginning to end so
this is from the 4th Century to the 15th
it's a story of almost 1200 years um and
the book is a fairly traditional history
in that it has a narrative but that
narrative is embedded within an analysis
of you know political economic and
social structures that were you know
dominant at every time um there's also
significant element of religious history
um Byzantium is the kind of Matrix of
the Orthodox Christian religion um so um
all of those elements come together in
that story it's a very long story um it
does take you know 900 pages to tell in
proper detail so that's what the book is
right so you've not sort of just done a
a general introduction um to the Empire
but you've really gone deep into all of
the aspects of it that's right um
so there's only one book every
generation or two of this sort that
comes out in my field that is a single
author monograph history um usually we
tend to produce short introductions
concise histories you know and obviously
those are easier to um produce and they
kind of encapsulate you know what that
historian was trying to you know do at
that particular moment but it's very
difficult in 150 pages to do anything
more than just kind of skim the
highlights and you're kind of jumping
from Peak to Peak and you know famous
Emperor to famous event and it's very
difficult to see how all these things
are interconnected on the
ground U like you don't have the the
space right the the the capacity to um
talk about the terrain below the heights
you know right where everything is
interconnected in all the valleys and
Crags and so forth um so in a history of
this size you can do that absolutely
because I feel like definitely I've
noticed maybe in the last 20ish years
there's been that that sort of shift
from looking at only um the rulers and
the highest people um in you know
ancient history and trying to focus more
on the everyday people did you get that
opportunity as well in this book so
you've been able to really look at sort
of the um banum as a whole rather than
just um those High people absolutely and
we all are trying to do this more and
more um it is difficult to do obviously
most of our sources are about the high
and mighty um but there's a considerable
emphasis in the book on demography and
economy and how the whole kind of super
structure of the East Roman State um
depended on and rested on the
productivity and the taxes and the
contributions of people just across the
territories from Southern Italy to the
caucuses this is a uh and and in the
early period down to Syria Palestine and
Egypt um so I do try to keep in mind the
circumstances under which these people
were living um the majority of the
population and also why they were
willing to go along with what this state
was asking them to do at any time uh so
I'm one of those historians who believes
that there is a kind of ex back and
forth is a kind of dialectical exchange
between rulers and subjects even in
Empires um and there limits on what
either side can do without sort of
jeopardizing the whole project there's a
kind of delicate balance that they have
to maintain um and I think that this is
one of those states that managed to
maintain that balance for the longest
period I mean in history is is 1,200
years of You by the way this is some
very dangerous years to live through
like the whole Middle Ages in a part of
the world that's also a very dangerous
place to be right this is like right
where Africa Europe and Asia meet and
like that's where it's situated and this
is like a Crossroads of peoples and
cultures and armies and just going
religions is going back and forth so the
fact that they managed to keep it
together for that long is an interesting
lesson in
itself so was there sort of one main
factor that you found that enabled it to
continue on for so long or was there
numerous factors working
together the latter obviously uh but if
I had to pick one one that is relatively
unique in the book that is it hasn't
really been highlighted that much in the
field so far but it's the picture that
emerged as I looked at the sources again
and all the recent scholarship and I
think it really was this kind of um back
and forth communication between the
authorities in Constantinople and the
provincial population um where the
authorities projected this Persona of
accountability and responsiveness that
is we are here to do things for you and
also constantly reminding their subjects
that that the taxes were being collected
for the common good for you know um
public you know for defense and you know
reasons like that and not for the
private enjoyment of the ruling class
ruling class is not a hereditary
aristocracy for the most part I mean you
do have families that you know maintain
their power for a long time obviously
but um so it's not like this cast system
or feudal system or anything like that
um and so and on the other hand um the
you know provincial the productive
population um remember in these
societies it takes about eight or nine
people working the land or with animals
to support one person who doesn't right
so the vast majority of the population
is agricultural um and they're having to
pay these taxes so they can resist and
so there are lots of moments of
resistance when Emperors go too far uh
provincial armies often reflecting their
communities or local communities just
resist and put another Emperor on the
throne so this happens pretty often
emperor who became
unpopular um you know were deposed or
murdered uh about 40% of
them yes yes because there's no right to
the throne
either so being in charge is like an
ongoing referendum you know you start to
get unpopular and anyway so there was
this there was this back and forth in
terms of power it wasn't um all top
down right brilliant and so did you
decide to write this book now because
it's been a while since the last time
that a book like this has been come that
has been
published I mean that justified writing
the
book I the reason the reason I wrote it
is because an editor at oxer asked me
to yes and I said No at first because it
was just like there's no way um it took
me about a year to come around uh to the
decision to do it once I realized that
so much had changed since the last book
that anyone thought was like a statement
in the field and anyway it's a
complicated that I won't get into the
bibliography but many um in institutions
and schools and Scholars were using a
book that was essentially from
1940 or 1952 was the a second edition of
it that's the one that we were using so
it's like 70 years ago and everything
had changed in the
meantime anyway so yes it it was time
yeah if I saw that in the bibliography
of one of my students essays I'd
probably be like oh maybe find something
a little bit more recent than than this
yes um well so did you obviously you
realized that there was a whole lot of
changes that had happened since that
that last book whilst you were
researching did you find anything
surprising that you didn't realize um
during that sort of process well so I've
been trying to keep up with you know all
12 centuries of my field uh on and off
you know during the you few decades that
I've been working in this field um so I
don't think I was surprised by anything
specific that I
found U I did have to research some
areas that I wasn't so up to speed on
but it's not like I was terribly
surprised by that what I did find
striking probably the what made the
biggest impression on me was how much
good work so many of my colleagues have
been doing um in this field and I
I'm referring specifically to younger
Scholars who are you know often they're
like overturning the you know the
pieties of the past or you know
conventional wisdom they're doing a lot
of good work and this is surprised me
that they're continuing to do that under
professional conditions that are not
ideal right precarious work um you know
lacking benefits not knowing where
you're going to be employed next year
I'm I'm one of the very lucky ones who
you know got a good academic position
out of grad school and and had and have
had one ever since um and so I really
really feel for the younger generation
and relied on their work and cited it
you know where wherever I could uh but
uh I you know I don't know how
sustainable this model is for much
longer I mean the the the what sort of
neoliberal austerity is doing to
universities around the world is is sort
of sad to see so I was very proud of all
my especially Junior College that's
brilliant that's that's really nice to
hear um obviously that you were able to
incorporate this incredible research
that that younger Scholars are doing um
so often with um Empires and kingdoms we
get this Narrative of rise and fall or
rise Decline and fall um but that's not
something that you have employed uh in
in your book um can you tell us a bit
about how you've sort of approached it
instead sure well The Narrative of rise
and decline it so the canonical model is
the Roman Empire right so when we're
talking about the fall of Empires we
mean Rome 90% of the time and 10%
everything else right um and the 10% is
usually are we like Rome in any period
of History it's like are we like Rome
okay the problem with my field is that
the period that I study has canonically
for the past two or three centuries been
ident identified as the period of the
decline and fall of
Rome so like in Enlightenment
historiography like Edward Gibbon or
montesque his model like Byzantium
literally was the decline and fall phase
right um not just for like political and
Military reasons and you know what you
would imagine but also like the whole
culture was a kind of
degenerate um either it was politically
despotic or oppressive and its religion
was superstitious and you know whatever
intolerant and so forth
so obviously yeah 20th century
historians dispense with a lot of that U
but we haven't put anything really in
its place so and I think it's it's not
enough to Simply protest and complain
Lodge your protest when someone uses the
word decline me obviously there were
phases of decline you can't avoid that
and if there weren't this thing would
still be with us and it's not
right um but in terms of the popular
perception of what this is what it what
it was what does it mean for us as as a
state among other things I mean it means
a lot of things to different people it's
as I said the kind of birth culture of
Greek Orthodoxy or the Orthodox church
and and its theologies and and so forth
it also created Roman law as we know it
it's a whole other story um you think of
AA Sophia also like the most magnificent
Church in the world or building in fact
uh for for very many centuries during
the Middle Ages fine um but I think a
case can be made that its sheer
resilience is the lesson to be learned
here there is the the fact that it
actually managed to survive for that
long in those circumstances which I
mentioned earlier right um so rather
than seeing it as Decline and fall I
think we should flip that on its head
and see it very precisely
um as a system that you know for its
time and the the circumstances and
political and religious ideologies that
were dominant at the time um was
extremely Adept at surviving crisis it
it and so in terms of resilience and
sheer endurance um it was doing
something right rather than wrong and in
fact I could make the
case that the periods of decline that it
saw that is the shocks that it suffered
that caused it to lose territories and
eventually disappear were largely
exogenous in other words things striking
it from the
outside but that often without warning
like the Arab conquest of the 7th
Century that wasn't something that
anybody could reasonably foresee or plan
for whereas when it wasn't being subject
to pretty intense outside pressure its
internal Tendencies were toward economic
and demographic growth and also cultural
you know
regeneration uh so that it's endogenous
factors tended toward you know growth
and stability um and so in that sense
perhaps you can fault them for not being
ready for these outside shocks that that
came their way at various times but in
terms of the the structure of the
culture and this kind of political
Arrangement between the um its root
ruling Elites and the population at
large I think it was fairly well
positioned for stability and and slow
growth slow growth not you know not
Alexander the Great kind of conquest or
anything like that which they weren't
terribly like impressed with but slow
growth right that's so interesting so
would you say then that this sort of um
connection with Decline and fall um is
the reason why Byzantium has such a
Negative sort of
reputation in Western scholarship or is
there something else going on
there yeah so there are two reasons why
that came about U and by the way many
people in your audience will know that
the term Byzantine just in the
dictionary refers to
something um you know that's very
complex and
convoluted um so complex that it's
designed to exclude people from
understanding it or or or working at
systems and that it's also somewhat
delicious in fact last year I had to
wage a battle with a different field
altogether this is computer programmers
who were using the term Byzantine in
their Professional Publications to refer
to malicious
software a yeah a particular type of
program that is not what it appears to
be but is acting in bad
faith um yeah so these associations and
connotations have sort of penetrated
pretty deeply so there largely two
reasons why this came about the first is
that for a long period in the Middle
Ages so medieval western Europeans so
we're talking about people in like you
know Italy north of R Roman north of
Rome and then also in France and the the
German
Empire they they were doing two two
couple things one is they were
appropriating sort of cultural practices
and Prestige practices from the Eastern
Empire things like the Roman Imperial
title and like how do you perform being
a Roman
Emperor um but also many uh you know
things like Roman law which as I said
was codified in the east in
Constantinople by Justinian in the 6th
Century rediscovered in the west later
in the later 12th century and sort of
appropriated right um also very many
aspect of the Christian religion from
practice to Doctrine to texts to
whatever and each time these things were
appropriated in the west they were they
were recast as belonging inherently sort
of naturally to Western Europeans and
these Eastern Romans whom they called
Greeks dismissively this was not a
flattering term in the western Middle
Ages were're no longer worthy of them
right I'll give you an example from a
bit later um classical Greek literature
right so all ancient Greek literature
that we have in Greek we have because it
was copied you know laboriously and
carefully throughout this East Roman
Millennium right they were the only
Greek speakers
around and in the 15th century mostly
kind of passed over to Italy and the
Italian humanists received it right
because only Eastern or Greek Scholars
could work with it at the time very few
people in Italy could even read
Greek well within a century the
classical Greek texts had been
appropriated as something that was kind
of inherent to Western scholarship
humanism and they were claiming that the
East is no longer worthy of it because
they've been barbarized like
completely right so in other words for
Europe to kind of invent itself as as
being being kind of Roman Imperial in
some way Christian Orthodox in some way
as having access to classical Greek
learning in some way they did it in a
way that denied that those easterners
had a right to
it and in order to do that they had to
present them as being sort of false
Romans but rather they were like
deceitful Greeks uh bad Christians they
either like didn't respect the pope or
their religion was superstitious or
whatever depending on the period um and
that their language their Greek was like
barbarized and
degenerate right so Byzantium had to
become this package it was like the dark
mirror of Europe it's where you take all
of the things that Europe later Europe
like like Enlightenment Europe and later
took pride in and and there was a
negative re reverse negative image like
everything that was wrong with those
things right
uh so that's that's one that's one way
that this that Byzantium was imbued with
all of these negative traits the other
one was simply that well I mean in the
enlightenment so a lot of these thinkers
um you political theorists and the
philosop and so
forth well they couldn't speak very
candidly about their own Kings and and
archbishops or popes or
whatever and so Byzantium at the time
they called it the Empire of the Greeks
Byzantium is a slightly later term it
just became a convenient way for talking
about all of these dysfunctions of
theocracy um or a society that lacks
civic virtue or is despotic or where
priests have too much power and so forth
so it just it was just kind of like a a
handy surrogate for
discussion yeah and it just kind of it
was left holding that image that's so
interesting so it's almost like using
that as like a a keyword you know like
oh we can't use the real names we'll use
them instead but you know what I'm
actually talking about and then it's
sort of just oh yeah and it became
established in like all the European
languages so I mentioned earlier what
Byzantium Byzantine means in
English uh but like I found that in
Italy in the 19 later half of the 19th
century and into the fascist period in
Italy Byzantium was a code word for all
the dysfunctions of the Italian
bureaucracy especially in like the south
of Italy so like what today we consider
like like the mafia land like all that
they just called it oh Byzantium like it
was their code for that yeah yeah and
there were periods where like in France
Byzantium was like a code word for like
Oriental decadence which was the French
wasn't always a bad thing
like like there honestly there was a
years ago there's a very prominent ban
as Charles deal and and he thought that
he was rehabilitating Byzantium by
identifying it with Oriental decadence
like isn't that nice and
exotic yeah wow yes thank
you so interesting and I guess that's
all things now that you're like well
let's refocus on what Byzantium actually
is which is not right no this is a real
history there are no dragons or elves in
here they're real people doing real
things there it's it's actually a very
sober you know sort levelheaded
civilization for the most part it anyway
they know they knew what they were doing
they're they're real people you can
understand and identify with uh they're
not it's not this exotic mystical land
of Domes and glittering gold I mean yeah
they had all that but you would you
don't identify them with that brilliant
okay well that's probably a great place
to leave off uh Anthony thank you so
much for joining me today it's been a
pleasure talking to you about your new
book Thank You Kelly for for willing to
speak with me about Byzantium um and I
hope uh people are willing to I mean
this civilization lasted for a thousand
years so give it some of your time and
and read some of the book I've tried to
make it very accessible to everyone so
thank you Kelly which is great to hear
so if you're looking to purchase the
book you will be able to find the link
down below to Oxford University Press
thank you so much take
care this episode was brought to you by
world history encyclopedia for more
great articles and interactive content
head to our website by the link below if
you like my sweater you can find this
design and a bunch more in our shop at
World history. store or you can find a
link for it down below thank you so much
for watching and we will see you soon
with another
[Music]
video