The Curious Case of Aikido's "Fakeness"

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
I was scrolling through Facebook a while back and came across a video of an Aikido guy doing
a breakfall drill. Forgive my pronunciation, but I believe his name is Mihaly Dobroka.
Dobroka? Dobroka? I don't know. Again, forgive me for butchering that. He's on YouTube though,
and I'll put his channel in the description of this video. What stood out to me was how
he was getting absolutely flamed in the comments of his posts. Some of these comments are on screen
for your viewing pleasure. For a long time now, I've been fascinated by this kind of reaction to
Aikido, and I really do mean that I find it morbidly interesting from an almost academic
perspective. Because, well, it's really weird, right? I follow a lot of different sports and
participate in a lot of different hobbies. I just don't see other sports or athletic pursuits
getting absolutely dogged on the same way Aikido does. No one goes into martial arts tricking
comments, for example, and lights up the practice because the kicks aren't really for fighting.
No one complains about volleyball not being quote-unquote real, it's just volleyball. I
suspect Aikido in particular gets this sort of attention because people interpret it as a kind
of deception. Aikido calls itself a martial art, and martial arts are for fighting, and what people
are seeing in that Facebook video clearly isn't for fighting, therefore it's fake and deserves
all the public shaming it gets. The problem is that this position, of course, is just
an assumption from beginning to end. Long-time viewers will know that I've spoken about
how to martially express Aikido in the past, and despite mainstream trends, I think we are living
in an exciting time for the practical development of Aikido. Way back in 2017, I believe,
Rokas posted his Flashpoint video about MMA vs Aikido. Now, to be clear, I was, at that time,
training Aikido in Japan more seriously than I ever had before, and Rokas' video neither surprised
me nor deterred me from my training. I even showed the video to a few Japanese Aikido friends at the
time, and they sort of laughed, saying, yeah, this is the outcome I would expect, it's not what
Aikido is for. Now, I have no ill will for Rokas at all, just so it's on record. I know some Aikido
people, I think somewhat irrationally, really dislike the guy. I don't. I only bring this up
to illustrate that Aikido is, from a martial perspective, moving in a positive direction.
Something the popular commentary seems to conveniently forget about Rokas' initial post
was that he asked for video evidence of Aikido working. Evidence that we now, I am pleased to
say, have in spades. I'm showing a few examples on the screen now, and even Rokas, the man himself,
has contributed to this catalog. So, it is interesting that now-detracting commentary
has shifted away from the show-me-video proof to now claiming what I just showed you doesn't
look like Aikido or that it would never work in pro-MMA. The point of this video isn't really
to focus on the irrational moving of goalposts in Aikido detractors, though. Instead, I want
to point out the irrationality of the assumption that Aikido, even practiced for aesthetic purposes,
is somehow fake. First and foremost, the term martial art is extremely new, seemingly coming
into existence in the late 1950s to 1960s, largely as a translation of the Japanese word
Budo. As is typical with translations, however, a lot of nuance was lost. Budo, in Japanese,
was popularized by Judo's founder, Kano Jigoro, who conceptualized it as a form of education.
Meanwhile, the West has a similar tradition of seeing martial arts through a lens of character
building, but it is much less overt and mostly forgotten. A quick browse through old manuals from
the 1800s and 1900s, however, will very quickly reveal that this idea is not at all foreign to
the Western tradition. The usual criticism brought against Kano's idea of martial arts as education
is that plenty of martial artists are sort of assholes, even long after they started their
training, and this is true. There really isn't any indication that knowing how to fight suddenly
makes a person more moral. If that were the fact, then lots of champions would be really good people,
and I can think of a dozen champions just off the top of my head who absolutely are not good people.
But therein lies the issue. Kano never really conceived of his system as one that was for
fighting or even for competition, which is the typical assumption that Westerners make about
Judo and martial arts more generally. I'd argue, in fact, that Kano was actually quite successful
in making more holistic people, people who were more educated and more moral. Many of his students,
both Judoka and academic students, would go on to hold high offices and have prestigious jobs
in Japanese society. I largely believe the apparent failure of martial arts as education
is simply because the practice more or less died with Kano himself. Keep in mind, Judoka under Kano
weren't just learning Judo, but a slew of other disciplines as well, and many of his brightest
pupils had to have weekly meetings with him to give reports. Kano himself deplored excessive
competitive participation. To him, competition served only as a tool to measure growth.
Martial competition as a goal unto itself was empty because it wasn't applicable to society at large.
I'm taking you down this tangent to illustrate that while there is some debate in Japan,
practicing Ebudo is not synonymous with being a fighter. It never has been, and it still isn't
today. Most Aikidoka I train with will openly tell you they have no interest in fighting.
Most Judoka I train with, under no uncertain terms, declare their practice is a sport,
and they have no ambitions to move to MMA, nor do they really care about fighting
outside of their niche. This seems to be just utterly alien to Western audiences in a way that
I've always found extremely curious. Because Western audiences have no problems understanding
that sports are sports. Volleyball is volleyball. Tennis is tennis. But when it comes to martial
arts, suddenly we are discussing something that has nothing to do with sport or art,
but some illusionary realm of pure combative effectiveness, that everything is on a pipeline
to street effectiveness or MMA or both. No one really wants to judge a martial arts by its own
standard, by its own conception of itself. That's just not a thing that Western culture does for
some reason. Now, let's circle back to the initial Aikido Facebook post. What's so fascinating to me
is that Westerners, not that long ago, invented the term martial art, and packed it full of
Western cultural assumptions. By itself, there is nothing wrong with that. It is a very useful
shorthand. What is honestly an indictment of Western education, however, is that this purely
Western invention is erroneously attached to Aikido, which has no intention nor obligation
to abide by the assumptions within the term. And when Aikido fails to live up to that invented
standard, it is deemed as somehow fake, even though it's like the two cultures are reading
from two completely different scripts. Because they are. I've pumped out tons and tons of videos
on more practical expressions of Aikido, but really keen-eyed viewers will have picked up
on the fact that when I discuss this, I usually cite the same half-dozen or so Japanese Aikidoka.
Why? Because really only about a half-dozen or so prominent historical Japanese teachers
seem to have been truly interested in Aikido as a martial project. They are an extreme minority.
If you zoom out and read the literature more broadly, over and over and over again,
you are going to get hit with the same lines and trends about Aikido not being competitive,
but cooperative, and fundamentally not for fighting. It is often in the foreword of most
books. Right there, front and center. I bring this up because if people just read some books
before they decided to dogpile something they clearly have zero understanding of,
they'd realize there isn't really any deception taking place here at all. In fact, I think there
is an argument to be made that the push for a more martial Aikido is relatively new and relatively
western in origin, really only made possible through the communicative features of the internet.
Yes, there are some of those teachers in the Japanese tradition who are sort of
prototypes and predecessors, but as a broad movement, I think it's kind of an innovative
thing. In light of that, the fact that we've gone from Rokus' video in 2017 to an increasing number
of live sparring videos demonstrating Aikido in the span of about 8 years, well, I think that's
impressive. That is why, despite everything you might read or hear about in the popular
narrative surrounding Aikido, I'm actually fairly optimistic about the future of a
martially pragmatic expression of the art. Make no mistake, I do think it's probably going to
take another 10 or 20 years even, but I think we're on the right track.
I do want to talk about the aesthetic expression of Aikido here for a moment,
the sort you see in the initial Facebook post that inspired this video. I know for a fact that
Mihaly, the source of that post, trains with one Shirakawa Ryuji sensei. Now, I'm uncertain if he
is a direct student or not, but the influence is undeniable and he's absolutely been in some videos
with him. Shirakawa sensei is, without a shadow of a doubt, the most successful Aikido person
online today. The man has a channel of over half a million subscribers, which is genuinely
mind-blowing considering his is not an English-speaking channel, obviously.
Shirakawa sensei has never been deceptive about the muse behind his practice. Many of his videos
have titles like Beautiful Aikido, and in fact, that is also the name of his book.
The aesthetics-based approach is front and center in his training and in his posts.
I know many people who dislike that, even within Aikido itself, but claiming his posts are somehow
fake or a deception is just flatly incorrect. All you have to do is read and you will realize
that's not the case. The reality is that you are free to dislike his approach and his expression
of the art, but you cannot argue that it is somehow inferior in respect to its accomplishments.
I understand websites that make these estimates are sort of suspect, but we can conservatively
say the channel generates about 2,000 USD a month before sponsorships. Converting that to yen,
that's about 2.5k in real spending power. Again, this is all before sponsorships. This is before
his book sales, and of course, before the profits of his actual business, which is, you know,
running an extremely successful Aikido dojo. While I do not know his annual salary, I'm willing to
bet he makes pretty close to six figures a year. And keep in mind, this is six figures doing the
thing that he loves the most every day. In any other setting, this is something that would be
celebrated openly. He is effectively winning at life. This is what everybody wants. Everybody
wants to make that kind of a living doing the things that they love the most. Yet, it isn't
uncommon to see people seething in posts about Shirakawa Sensei, or in posts that feature Aikido
similar to his. They'll say it's fake, that it isn't real Aikido, that learning it is a waste
of time. Even though the stated goal of Aikido is practically thrown in your face both in the
historical record and in the very titles of these posts. Even though this man probably makes more
money doing what he does than most of his detractors. But most of all, and this is what
really gets me, do you think most of those detractors could do what he does? Could they
make technique look that smooth? Could they fall 15 or 20 consecutive times without pain,
but with that much grace? Do they have the strength, the flexibility, the dedication?
What so much of this sort of commentary seems to miss is that they are witnessing feats of
genuine athleticism and skill, the result of genuine sacrifice and practice. People will
compare it to dancing, framing it as an insult, but frankly that has always read to me like a
compliment. Do these people really not know what truly high-level dancers are capable of pulling
off with their bodies? Have they never read about the sacrifices they make, the bloody feet,
the endless training? Since when has the fine art of dance been a shameful thing?
And in relation to martial arts proper, consider just how many professional fighters
and competitors did time in practices like ballet.
The wonderful thing about the original Facebook post though, is that it doesn't take much to
dig into the background of these posters. I won't publicly name and shame anyone here,
but I will report that many of the people declaring Aikido to be bullshit have yet
to liberate themselves of double chins. These are not people who would even remotely come close
to being able to achieve the athleticism and technical ability that they are judging so poorly.
And I really do just find this so interesting, but also sad. It probably surprises no one,
but I am very much an adherent of that old tradition of martial arts being coupled with
proper education. I increasingly see a broader martial arts audience whose understanding of
martial arts is essentially decided for them by 10-second viral clips or by copying the sentiments
of a popular podcaster. So many people are ready to speak martial arts opinions as fact,
but they've never touched the literature. They've never assessed the art along its own standards.
They will ignore genuine pragmatic development in an art when it happens, and then move goalposts
to maintain their insular worldview. Ironically, they also lack the self-awareness to call what
they are viewing a cult, but not realize their own extremely cultish behavior, which exists solely to
In many ways, so much of martial arts criticism is just projection.
While I do not want to end this video on a dour note, I just want to point out that martial arts
are relatively inconsequential in the grand scheme of things. The fragile balance of geopolitics
will not be tipped because of public opinion on Aikido. But if this is how people are approaching
their hobbies, things that they are ostensibly invested in, without studying them, without
knowing how to do proper critical analysis, and without a sliver of self-awareness,
then how are people approaching much more serious issues in society? How wrong are people about
things that actually do matter, simply because they are too lazy to commit to the most basic
of due diligence? In this sense, I don't think Kano could have been more correct.
Martial arts are a microcosm for life, and for the pulse of society at large. I just hope
what I currently see as an online martial arts curiosity isn't indicative of a grander societal
prophecy. Thank you, everyone, for watching. There is no channel without you,
and I will catch you all next time. Peace.
