Miyagi Karate Styles & Kata Episode Update | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
hi everyone this video is kind of a
quick little update to a video we
released a few weeks ago
a few weeks ago we released the
different kata in the karate kid movie
series
and the tv show cobra kai and i thought
it was a fun exercise to try to pinpoint
the four kata we were able to identify
now you know anyone who's watched this
channel 4 knows i love the karate kid
and from time to time we do different
episodes based on the movie series and
the show
especially our series on what kind of
karates and cobra kai which
i'll put a link in the description below
but basically for those of you who
haven't watched we determined that
our theory is that miyagi do karate is
gojiru okinawan kante
and that cobra kai is tongsudo this is
not the place to debate that go check
out those videos
and we can talk more about that but the
point though is what's interesting
though is as i was working on this
update uh jesse encamp from the karate
nerd released his review of the cobra
kai tv series and he kind of brought to
the surface
a really interesting topic now for those
of you who are not familiar with jesse
end camp go check out his youtube
channel like right now
there's a link to that description below
as well but he has a wealth of knowledge
he has an authority and he is a scholar
when it comes to traditional karate
especially okinawan in japanese history
so definitely go check his stuff out
but what's fun though is in his video in
his review
he points out a mistake that he found in
the cobra kai tv show
but the reason i'm doing this a little
bit of a tag on update is because i
don't think it's a mistake so much as i
think jesse uncovers something
even bigger even more interesting in
that both of our theories can coexist
so this mini episode is kind of in two
parts first i just want to throw my hat
into the ring on this new debate
and then we're going to go into the
update to our previous episode
the reason that i said it was gojiru was
based on the clues they presented to us
in the movie series first of all we have
our main character mr miyagi who is
named after chojin miyagi who is the
creator and founder of the gojuru karate
system
now the screenwriter robert mark cayman
who wrote the karate kid
based a lot of the movie on his own
experience training in gojiru
and somewhat mr magi is based a little
bit on his own instructor
another sign that we see is that the
techniques in content that are taught in
the movies
are present in the goji root system
although they're not really performed
that well it's kind of the hollywood
choreographed version but they are
present in gojiru
and then finally in the karate kid part
2 when they go to okinawa
you see the character of chozin who is
the student of sato which was miyagi's
best friend who trained with miyagi
wearing a karate key with the gojiru or
goju kai patch on his uniform
now we are led to believe it's the same
family style of krate since miyagi and
sato trained both under miyagi's father
so they're both we have to assume
different branches of um miyagi do
karate
now with all this said those are some
small clues but after we released our
episode in season two of cobra kai
they are now hanging up the photo of
chojin miyagi
in the miyagido dojo which makes me
wonder if they've seen our episode
but no to be serious though there's a
lot of clues there to suggest goju
racrate
jesse points out an interesting theory
and i'm not going to spoil it i want you
guys to go watch this channel but
basically
he points out why it's not go guru and
yet a different system instead now one
of the reasons he says is not go drew
which is kind of ironic because that's
the update i was doing
for this week anyway is one of the kata
that's present
in the cobra kai tv series when daniel
is teaching
robbie and samantha on the water they
are performing part of the kanku or
kusuku
kata which is not present in gojiru but
it is another okinawan styles
and he goes to greater detail to break
down details and techniques and
performances as to why
it's a different style instead of gojiru
but here's where i think our theories
can coexist
gojiru was formally founded in 1930 by
trojan miyagi
in the cobra kai tv show we see on
miyagi's headstone that he was born in
1925 which means that mr miyagi would
have been five years old
at the establishment of his art now what
that means for the miyagi family style
of karate means is that
historically speaking the fam style
cannot be gojiru because it wasn't
around yet
which is where jesse's theory makes
complete and perfect sense
however i believe it's very very
possible especially in okinawa when a
lot of styles in the local villages and
they share and they they're training
influences each other
that when goju was established i think
it's very possible that miyagi's father
may have incorporated it especially
since that they make a point in karate
kid part two to mention that miyagi's
village is next to the village of naha
which is where jojo miyagi lived and
then his name miyagi so we can even
maybe stretch so far as to infer
that perhaps it's a fictional relative
but that being said though is
it's not uncommon for people to adapt
style so perhaps miyagi's father
adapted this new style of karate and
blend into the training which
you know which would explain the goju
patch and hanging up trojan miyagi
but would also explain the contests that
are present that
aren't normally in gojiru but they are
in the other styles of okinawan karate
so i do believe that there's room there
for both theories to exist and i think
that jesse's kind of cracked open this
to
look at it further it's not just
miyagido karate but there's different
generations of it and there's a little
bit more layers that we can look into
with that
now another contradiction jesse brought
up was the fact that in
okinawa most fathers didn't teach their
own sons
but in the movie it is very clearly
stated by miyagi that he was taught
karate by his father that he and his
best friend sato were taught by his
father so that is established in the
movie lore however in the teaser for
season three of corporate kai they
indicate that mr miyagi has been keeping
some sort of family history or family
secret from daniel and we don't know
what that is so that might perfectly
line up with what jesse's saying i'm
really intrigued to find out but i do
have a question for all of you and
for uh jesse sensei if you're watching
as well is since this kind of spurred on
the topic of the photo being hung up
in the karate kid part 2 we see the
miyagi family dojo and there are
pictures hanging up on the wall
jojo miyagi is not shown to be one of
them but there are other faces so i'm
kind of curious if these since um
you know i'm not as well versus okinawan
knowledge as jesse is or a lot of you
out there
i'm just kind of curious are these real
figures are these real historical
martial artists or are these photos and
drawings that they made just for the
film
that's a question i have for you guys
out there i'm really curious to know and
then there are those out there who say
it's just a movie it doesn't matter it's
fake karate
of course it is just a movie it's
fantasy it's fiction but when you have
fiction that's based on reality at least
to some degree
i find it to be a fun exercise to kind
of pick apart references and just see
what influences are so that's the
question here is are the screenwriters
doing a really deep dive and trying to
be historically accurate
or are we just seeing a blend of
different choreographers putting their
own mix into the system
honestly it's probably that so i just
wanted to touch on that since i was
doing an update anyway on
on our previous episode so wanted to
throw my hat into the ring on this issue
so once again if you're not familiar
with jesse go check out his channel i
have a link in the description below
you're not going to find anyone on
youtube with a better wealth of
knowledge of okinawan across the history
than him
top-notch authority however when it
comes to cinema production and the
karate kid movie trilogy
i'm the ultimate nerd
we recently did an episode on the
different katas of the karate kid
trilogy and the cobra kai tv show
and through a fun analysis and exercise
we were able to find
four katas that we found present in the
movies and the show
now some of you out there have some very
keen eyes and we received several
comments to point out
two of them that we missed so this
episode serves a bit of an update to
that
episode if you haven't seen it yet go
ahead hit pause and i've put the link in
the description below just open a new
tab and give it a quick watch through
otherwise we're going to talk about uh
the other two content that you guys have
found and we're going to
add them to the mix so just to recap the
four contests that we identified are
the main kata of the series that the
only one in the movies or show that's
actually referred to as kata
and that is and that is a traditional
okinawan kata that we see miyagi
teaching daniel and daniel teaching his
students throughout the
process of the show so the second kind
of we identified was
choreo or a version of it thomas ian
griffith who plays terry silver in
karate kid part three
was performing a version of a very
standard form in or poomsae in taekwondo
but it's not the traditional version or
one that you normally see but a version
taught by joon chong
which was his teacher so that is present
in karate kid part three
also we mentioned how the chores that mr
miyagi has daniel do the wax on wax off
sand the floor paint the house paint the
fence
those all stem from tensho you know the
hand motions taught in the okinawan kata
of tensho
and then finally the most elusive one
was the one that we only caught a
glimpse of in karate kid part two
when daniel and miyagi go to okinawa
daniel wakes up and sees miyagi
finishing the kata
in the family dojo so through a little
bit of analysis and investigation we
determined that that was
shisho chin agoji rukata so those are
the four kata that we identified in the
movies and tv shows and for the most
part you all agreed which was
yay great but as awesome as you all are
you pointed out two more that we missed
so let's talk about those now
so the first one is kanku and although
seyunchen is the primary kata of the
karate kids series all together
in cobra kai we do catch glimpses of
kanku when daniel's teaching his
students
in sioux which is kind of weird because
it kind of just pops in there as a
glimpse this is a very old kata believed
to have been brought to okinawa by a
chinese diplomat
during the course of karate spread kanku
has found itself a part of several
karate systems including
shuritei shotokan kyokushin and the
korean arts of
tonksudo and taekwondo so we don't
really see very much of it in the show
just a few of the signature opening
moves in which the hand motions
distinctively represent
gazing up into the sky so while it is
brief
it is present so we are going to
acknowledge it now the second kata is
present in the movie the next karate kid
and i feel like we're going to have to
cover this soon in the future cine dojo
episode because there's a little bit to
talk about here
because the movie itself kind of fits
into a weird place
now it is a spin-off film and
technically it is part of the universe
but
i don't really consider it as part of
the original trilogy
mostly because of several
inconsistencies where this movie breaks
canon with the main series
but we're going to get to that into
another time to give it a fair look
viewers have pointed out yet another
kata present in that film
and that is the kata of nyanji samdan
and sometimes it's pronounced different
ways
and it may also be referred to as techie
and some other japanese systems
now we mainly see it in the part where
julie's in the monastery performing
nikata when the monks walk in
and they seem to have felt the creative
liberty to throw in the crane kick
randomly in the beginning because
reasons and she's performing it to the
song dreams by the cranberries because
who doesn't love performing kata through
the cranberries
and i i don't know
nyachi samdan is also an old okinawan
form that too has found its way into
multiple arts including tonksudo as well
now as far as how both of these kata fit
into the universe of the karate kid
well technically speaking we determined
that miyagi del crate is go guru
but gojiru was founded when miyagi was
really young you know back in the 30s
so it would stand to reason that karate
being miyagi's family art
that his father and family would have
known some other local fighting systems
and have other
okinawan influences so technically
speaking
kusanku could have been somewhere in
that mix
but it's more likely that choreographers
pat johnson and hirokota
put them into the next karate kid and
the cobra kai show respectively
so all in all this was just a fun
exercise yes it's just moving tv shows
but sometimes it's something to break it
down and see what we can dig up
and with all of you guys participating
and pointing out new stuff i didn't know
made it that much better so now we can
confirm that there are six kata present
in the mainline karate kid franchise now
this does not include the 2010 remake
the karate kid only because
that's a completely different
consistency it's in a different universe
it's not canon whatsoever
and that's a whole eye roll all in
itself thank you so much for watching if
there's anything else we missed any
other techniques or contests please be
sure to put them in the comments below
and we'll be happy to take a look
until next time
[Music]
you
