Most Influential Karate Style : History of Shotokan Part 3 | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
Oct 25, 2024
combined from early forms of Okinawan
karate and adapted to planned into the
Japanese culture Shotokan has flourished
across the world
spawning several derivative arts and
even working its way up into the UFC so
how did Shotokan become the most popular
and the most influential style karate in
the world well we're going to answer
that in today's conclusion of the
history of Shotokan
[Music]
[Music]
I would like to thank some of our
viewers for their help with this video a
special thanks to William marmiteiros
Keith Westmoreland and sensei Santino
Ramos for helping connect us with
footage and a special thanks to Ryan
Mooney from combat karate for filming
original footage for this series now
this is part three of the history of
Shotokan and if you haven't seen parts 1
& 2 yet I highly encourage you check
them out
part 1 shows us the origin of the art
that founder gichin funakoshi put
together and part 2 takes a closer look
at the art and its standards that are
still present today even in the MMA and
you can find a link to both of those
into the video description below ok so
what makes Shotokan the most influential
style of karate in the world in order to
begin to answer that we need to define
its place in the history of karate
traditional karate originated in Okinawa
with local fighting systems combined
with Chinese influences this led to the
rise of three primary classifications of
Okinawan karate or ten as it was called
at the time so we had sure reach a new
height a and tomorrow a each named after
the village it was primarily present in
now gichin funakoshi had an extensive
training in Sherita and na hoti in the
form of shorn ruined shoryu respectively
he combined a lot of the elements
between the two systems infused a strong
sense of his philosophy and he took it
to Japan calling it simply karate or
empty hands and again we went into much
more detail on part one but this is just
to get us started
so Shotokan became very popular in Japan
and it spread very quickly but before we
could talk about how it grew and
branched in the future arts let's take a
moment and acknowledge the history and
contribution of the Okinawan arts
because to be quite honest without them
showed Akkad would not exist and would
not have proliferated into the several
arts that we have today so many
traditionalists will consider the
Okinawan karate to be the true official
type of karate and they wouldn't be
wrong however I think it's very
important to both respect its origin
while also appreciate it and exploring
the ways that Karate has grown in the
fall from there and I believe that
Shotokan has been a very powerful
vehicle in that respect so before we
talk about where Shotokan is taking
karate let's observe how it
differentiated from its source material
so how do you Okinawan karate and
Japanese karate compare well I've talked
to enough people who have trained to
both know that it would have to be a
video in and of itself to cover this
adequately there are some big
differences between them both in
philosophy and in technique now this is
by no means a comprehensive comparison
but rather just a few ways in which they
differ in Japan formality and honor are
extremely important and they often take
a regimented approach to cultural
activities extending to the martial arts
now there is a strict sense of etiquette
in Japanese dojos for example the
requirement of bowing before and after
class and in response to instruction
from the sensei
also in Japanese karate a priority is
often placed on forum timing and
perfection of technique uniformity plays
a big role and in an art such as
Shotokan it is extremely efficient to
teach a large academy of students at one
time if everything is well regimented it
preserves the details of technique and
also facilitates a transmission of the
knowledge in contrast Okinawan karate
tends to be a little less formal less
emphasis on bow and formality and dojos
in general tend to have smaller rosters
as a result of this a lot of Okinawan
sensei's will often tailor techniques
based on the individual's learning it
focusing more on the efficiency of what
works to that person as opposed to a
uniform solution intended for a large
class now this uniformity has probably
contributed to how fast Shotokan spread
around the world becoming one of the
most common styles of karate taught it
is streamlined efficient and even
Funakoshi himself is said to have wanted
to implement it into elementary schools
as a core subject traditional Okinawan
schools tend to be smaller often hidden
within the town with a tendency towards
individualized teachings over mass
instruction also generally speaking you
can see a lot of differences in stances
Japanese karate tends to focus on
developing the lower body and
implementing some deep stances now this
is often attributed to Funakoshi son
GIGO who love deep stances diverse kicks
and love to compete this in contrast to
his father who had preferred the higher
stances he had learned in the
traditional Okinawan Sherita in the
Hotei now it's pretty interesting to
watch a performance of a content that
exists in both Japanese and Okinawan
styles of karate again generally
speaking you'll often see a greater
emphasis on lower stances in Japanese
kata and higher more upper
focus movements in Okinawan kata when it
comes to martial arts weapons you're
more likely to see them in Okinawan
karate now this is not to say that
Japanese systems don't use them but
typically they focus more on open hand
techniques and honestly most of the
traditional weapons you see associated
with karate you know the bo staff
nunchucks aside the tonfa all originated
in okinawa and Kabuto the martial way is
a big part of Okinawan arts so while you
may see weapons in both Styles you're
more likely to encounter them in the
Okinawan teachings at least historically
another stark difference is competition
Japanese karate has far more emphasis on
competition in sport than the Okinawan
karate does in okinawa karate is
embedded into a part of their lifestyle
a person doesn't really do karate it is
part of their heritage and their family
life now while some Okinawan schools do
compete such as school giru and shiteru
which are represented in the world
karate federation it is far more common
see Japanese karate take part in sport
fighting now with all that being said
both Okinawan and Japanese karts they
have a lot to offer and it would be a
very interesting topic to go down that
rabbit hole in the future episode as
there are a lot more different system
what we can cover today Sensei Jesse and
camp from the karate nerd youtube
channel has an absolutely fantastic
mini-series on his trip to okinawa and
experience with Okinawan karate and I
have included those links in the
description below if you are interested
in checking those out
[Music]
in 1934 Nikko she officially established
his organization diny hone karate dough
ken Kukai which was later known as the
shuttle Kai which basically refers to
Shoto society now Shoto was funakoshi
she's pen name that he used when he
wrote poetry and Shoto means pine waves
referring to the sound that wind makes
as it ripples through pine trees
so with Shotokan taking root in Japan
and flourishing among a wide range of
students it was only a matter of time
for the art itself became a starting
point for future systems prior to World
War two during the Japanese occupation
of Korea the Koreans had limited options
regarding the martial arts a lot of
their own local ways were forbidden and
many were forced to learn in Japanese
arts Shotokan was one of those primary
arts being taught so naturally became
implemented into the training of any
Koreans that wanted to train in the
martial arts at that time and one of
these men was the man who would go on to
later found tongue sudo now another
Korean national who was in Japan
immediately after the end of world war
ii was mas oyama he grew a love for the
martial arts and he sought out the
training of Shotokan and he was actually
a direct student under GIGO Funakoshi
the son of founder teaching funakoshi
now this was also the time that American
soldiers were based in Japan and Okinawa
and they began introduction to karate in
the 40s karate was a very unfamiliar art
in America so many soldiers wanted to
learn this new combat style so right
away I think we can start to see how
some of the early seeds were planted
Shotokan was growing in scale and
popularity and it was in 1949 the some
of Funakoshi senior students decided to
establish an association to help govern
promote educate and spread the teachings
of Shotokan so led by master Toshi
Nakayama the japan karate association or
jka
was formally established as a central
authority in Shotokan an elderly
Funakoshi aged 80 at the sign was named
an honorary head of the organization and
we have already established that the
basis of Tong's Udo was Shotokan you see
he mixed in some other influences from
Chinese and other martial arts to direct
the path Atomics who though now this
includes
Taekwondo which is the derivative of
Tonks though and still has a lot of
Shotokan in its lineage so mas oyama had
trained directly under funakoshi son
gingko in Shotokan and then later he
took up the Okinawan art of go Giroux
training under senior student of founder
chosen Miyagi now mas oyama took this
mature
and it went two years of seclusion into
the mountains for vigorous training and
he came back introduced his own art of
kyokushin karate an amalgam of Shotokan
and Okinawan systems actually in fact
kyo-chan retains two sets of kata both
from Shotokan and go Giroux kyo kitchen
has then since also branched off and
spawned further derivatives such as kudo
tension karate Oishi ha ricotta and
others wada ruined Kajukenbo have also
been influenced by Shotokan in their
early development wada Roux was founded
by Hiro norio otsuka in 1939
Otsuka was one of the first students to
receive a black belt in Shotokan Karate
directly from gichin funakoshi
and then he went to blend in Shotokan
with Okinawan karate and jujitsu and
came up with what is now known as Waldo
roux
there are trace elements of Shotokan in
Kajukenbo a greater mixed pot of arts
founded by the efforts of many martial
artists including the notable Adriana
and / Otto so Shotokan has definitely
cemented its place as one of the pillars
of the martial arts and it's hard to
ignore the influence and reach it has
and it continues to have
unfortunately Shotokan was not immune to
the affliction that most major martial
arts are stricken with politics now when
we announced the series I received many
messages asking me to highlight the
differences between all the different
Shotokan associations I'm going to go
over a very brief summary of some of the
couple top prominent ones but a full
deeper look will have to be in a future
video the topic of that scale alone is
an episode in and of itself but like
most arts that have toxic politics we
start at the same trigger the death of
the founder gichin funakoshi passed away
in 1957 at 88 years old he had left his
mark on the history of the martial arts
but he did not leave was a successor it
did not take long for risk to begin
starting with his own funeral Funakoshi
the original organization the show Tokai
formed in 1930 and focused on the spread
and education of Shotokan they
represented students from many
universities to help spread the art and
this was the first and oldest Shotokan
organization the japan karate
association or JK a registered with the
japanese government in 1957 just prior
to Funakoshi death they wish to
represent Shotokan in a larger
professional scale the jka was the only
legally recognized karate association at
the time now there are said to have been
disputes over the arrangements of
Funakoshi funeral supposedly both the
show Tokai and JK asserted the right to
arrange it and the rift between
organisations only continued from there
now as with happens with any
organization with new leadership changes
began to occur the show Tokai was
largely influenced by one of Funakoshi
senior students shakira agami Yagami had
originally began training in the
Funakoshi sun GIGO but then he began to
stray away from show de casas
competitive nature he did not believe
that karate should be a sport and he
withdrew the organization from
tournaments and other competitive events
egami continued to alter the teaching of
the system focusing on looser and less
explosive training methods and placing
greater importance on spirituality
mental balance and sticking closer to
the niju khun or the twenty principals
establishment Funakoshi
and stressing an emphasis on kata i
would like to read an excerpt from the
show Tokai official website show Tokai
follows the words of master funakoshi
who said karate dough is an art for
training our own minds sports that can
be practiced by people with little
physical strength and
art for maintaining health and the art
of self-defense therefore karate doe is
not a martial art only for people who
have strong muscles and physical
strength but is an art that all people
of all ages all over the world need and
can practice shuttle Kai follows the
last instruction of Master Funakoshi
there are no contests in karate be
devoted to kata shuttle Kai has a lesson
system that focuses on practicing kata
the shoto Chi often refers to itself as
the system closest to the original
teachings of gichin funakoshi now the
jka went a different direction
first they asserted their position of
being the only legally recognised karate
organization led by ma satoshi nakamoto
a to make changes to the material
hardening the art and focusing on
explosive power and rigorous training
now unlike the shuttle Kai they do
engage in competition but they take it
much more seriously than your typical
point-based tournaments
two different excerpts from their
official website highlight this
philosophy unlike many other karate
organizations the jka was not created as
an organization whose major purpose is
holding matches and tournaments though
it does sponsor tournaments its major
focus is the practice of karate its
purpose is the teaching of karate as a
way of life the website also goes to say
karate is not a sport one place for
points in jka kumite there are no weight
classifications and no arbitrary point
system jka tournaments are much stricter
at the jka there is only equal one full
point which means you have down your
opponent in one the basis of jka karate
is the ability to take down your
opponent regardless of size or weight
with one blow there is no room for
incremental points in such a tradition
the difference is obvious we teach our
students how they gain mastery of
themselves and overwhelm the opponents
to pretty diverse philosophies and
unfortunately these were not the only
disagreements other senior students
disagree with the direction the jke was
going with the Shotokan and the jakie a
splintered off into several groups which
we will have to elaborate more on in
another future episode shotokan karate
found a strong foothold in the united
states as well shotokan karate of
america was founded in 1959 by Tsutomu
Oshima who currently at age 89 still
leads the organization and teaches to
this day Oshima was a direct student of
gichin funakoshi himself and in 1955
came to america
each school at the University of
Southern California now at the school he
opened the first American karate club in
1957 and established the Southern
California karate association in 1959
later being renamed to shotokan karate
of america the SKA is a nonprofit
organization with a strong goal to lead
Shotokan and United States and reach a
wide base of students offer traditional
karate under one of the original
students of the system the SKA does
perform a competition and tournaments
although they stress a balance on karate
as a lifestyle they are also known for
holding special training events twice a
year typically in the summer in the
winter the goal of these events is to
engage in the intense training session
for a short duration with large groups
of practitioners it's basically a karate
camp kyokushin karate is also known for
their intense trot the camps held twice
a year so one notable mark on the SKA is
that Oshima received his fifth on black
belt directly from gichin funakoshi
himself now this was the highest rank
ever given out by Funakoshi
and in the spirit of the tradition of
the ska they retained the original
ranking system used by Funakoshi
and does not recognize any ranks above
going on now there are many many many
more Shotokan organizations and notable
practitioners worth getting into but it
would not do them any justice to just
cram them in here and I do apologize to
those of you who were hoping to dig
deeper into that topic however they
would require an entire episode for
themselves and I thought it was worth
doing a quick overview just to kind of
set the first stone of that path I do of
course welcome any contributions to
those of you who can expand or elaborate
or want to add to the different Shotokan
associations of the world and if we get
enough information then we can do a
follow-up episode in a near future so
how is shota calm one of the most
influential science of karate in the
world well it started with one man
learning the roots of Okinawan karate
combining them into his own practice
resorting to the poet that he was and
infusing his own deep philosophy and
crafting a balance between the
importance of physical and mental
training he knew how to adapt a system
to fit different political paradigms he
adopted and established standards and
ranking etiquette practice and teaching
that resonated across generations of
future karate styles his influence
rippled back to Okinawan roots some of
which took on some of his new standards
and the threads of Shotokan can still be
found today in many derivative artists
and even in the UFC so this concludes
our series on the history
now Shotokan may not have been the
original form of crotch a but there is
no doubt that qingcheng funakoshi was a
true pioneer and his legacy will be
embedded in the foundation of martial
arts forever thank you all so much for
watching our history of Shotokan series
now these videos take a tremendous
amount of time and effort so if you do
enjoy them and would like to see more
art history videos then please join us
on patreon it helps keep the channel
going and the more support we get the
more of these we get to do we also have
a ton of exclusive content episodes
available so there's lots of stuff for
you to dig into we appreciate all of you
especially anyone who lies and
subscribes and joins us here on the mat
every week
you
