Movie Karate: The Fiction of Fighting | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
Oct 26, 2024
one of our most popular videos is one of
our earliest ones and that was
what kind of karates and cobra kai and
to this day i still get the same
answer it's movie karate it's not real
well they're not wrong and in fact it's
probably the most honest and realistic
answer that one can give
even as much fun as we want to dive into
any history and analytical and what it
might represent
bottom line yes it's movie karate so
today we're going to talk about some
simple tricks that movies use
to make martial art scenes better than
they should be
so almost all movie karate is a lie yes
i'm sorry
i said it even your most favorite
martial arts films chances are they are
lying to you
only because when it comes to making a
movie realism
and an actual realistic fight it's
pretty low on the priority list when it
comes to structuring a scene
you know there's a specific hierarchy
they achieve and that they strive for
and the first thing on that list is
drama
you're watching the story to get some
sort of narrative across
and the drama and storytelling event
takes
precedence so whatever happens in that
scene has to advance the movie forward
second priority is choreography and
that's how it's presented to us
that's how the moves that they choose to
show us because and it's actually
interesting because when you look back
at
previous films you know in the 40s and
the 50s and 60s it was all a lot of like
boxing and fist fighting look at john
wayne he was the on-screen tough guy and
it was
pretty much all punches with him then
you know around the 70s 80s we had
people like chuck norris and van damme
show up on the scene and
now we're seeing these fancy kicks now
as an american
viewing audience that was kind of new
kicks were fancy to us so
back then movies got away with simpler
choreography it was turn kick this guy
turn kick that guy turn kick that guy
now
you know fast forward a couple of
decades we need something a little bit
more than that which you see them up the
ante all the time so you know we got
jackie chan films now which are just
incredible to watch
films like john wick where they get
they're getting really fancy with the
choreography so
you're going to see an evolution over
time how films are choreographed and the
moves
and techniques that they choose third on
the list is presentation
there's a narrative to the scene and
there's a choreography to the scene but
there's also a
way to present it you know in terms of
tonality and stylistic choices and how
they want you to feel
so it doesn't just advance the story
forward but it should invoke some sort
of a
some sort of a dramatic response for you
whether it be to laugh to cry to get
angry
be happy you know you know cheer on your
favorite actor
so you know that's all part of engaging
the viewer into the film
then after all that is taken care of
then they try to make it as real as
possible once the other objectives are
fulfilled
so realism honestly like realistic
fighting
if you go watch home movies or realistic
fights and you try to compare them to a
movie
they usually don't look the same because
movies have that drama structure built
in
that's the whole point of their
existence is to tell a
story so what we're going to go over are
just a couple of lies that they sell you
and a couple of deceptive techniques
that movies use
to kind of make the action look better
than what it actually is
so the first and foremost one we should
probably talk about is perspective
the perspective that we are presented as
an audience camera placement can
sometimes
be everything all it takes is for the
camera to be set up at just the right
angle
to appear as if a person is striking
somebody else because when you talk
about a 2d image on a screen you know
all the fist has to do is kind of
overlap
the image of someone's face and with the
right sound effect and right reaction
that could totally sell the effect
and in fact when that technique is used
most of the time those actors are
usually you know those swings are
usually a foot or two away from the
intended target but you can't always
tell on screen
so one example is the crane kick and
this shouldn't be any surprise anybody
who knows me that i'm going to use this
example is one of the first examples
but in the first karate kid film the
crane kick that daniel does at the end
to johnny
if you really watch it looks like he's
making contact i mean there's no space
in between i mean
it's a clear-cut connection unless you
look
very carefully and realize that you know
there's daniel and johnny on the plane
and they're slightly offset and what
that means is they're facing each other
but they're on a slightly different line
of attack but where the camera is
positioned
it kind of compresses the space you
can't really tell so
in actuality daniel's foot is going in
front of johnny's face
but on screen with the reaction and the
motion blur it looks like johnny is
actually
struck by the kick now playing off of
the spatial compression i want to talk
about
really quick the camera techniques of
dollies and zooms
both have the same kind of objective to
get closer to the action
but they're done two different ways a
dolly when you dolly a camera you are
physically taking the camera and moving
it forward
moving it towards your subject so if
you've got a person standing in the
field
and you move the camera towards them
they're going to get larger because
they're getting closer to the camera but
the background stays the same because
it's way in the back so you actually
retain the distance you can kind of see
the depth of the shot
when you zoom zooming a camera the
camera doesn't move it's really just
magnifying the image and when you
magnify the image the background
the sub foreground your character your
your subject they all enlarge at the
same time
when that happens it actually compresses
space it looks you lose that spatial
difference and it makes the image look
flatter
so knowing that there's a very simple
technique if you're going to do the
technique of where you're going to
overlap and make it look like an actress
in another actor
you just add a little bit of that
magnification that spatial compression
and you can sell it even further so a
lot of movies such as karate kid2 you
know when miyagi is striking
you know the bad guys he's not really
hitting them i'm willing to bet he was
probably even two to three feet away
from them but the way the image is
compressed
looks like or convincingly enough that
it connects
now a really interesting filmmaking tool
is called the dolly zoom
and i love this effect and there's two
ways you can do it you can
physically move the camera forward while
zooming out or
move the camera out while zooming in and
what that does is that keeps your
subject
your person in the foreground roughly
about the same size
but that makes the background either
stretch out and elongate or stretch and
complex
it's a really bizarre effect and as an
example we see it in mortal kombat
when johnny cage realizes you know he's
among a whole bunch of dead warriors so
it's usually used for more of a vertigo
effect or a psychological
enhancement it it's it's usually a dire
situation for your character it's not
your typical
focus point but it gives something
ethereal give a little bit of an
unsettling move and it's used very very
effectively
now a lot of martial arts films have
martial artists as their protagonists
and it's a lot easier to work with their
choreography because they are
experienced
but many times you'll have actors that
either have very little martial arts
experience
or none at all and when that's the case
unless you do
a super serious training regimen over
and over and over the course of months
to get into the point of looking
convincing
there's some liberties you have to take
and there's a few camera tricks that are
involved
that can help fudge that a little bit
one common technique of doing this
is the shaky cam and i am personally not
a fan of this
but you know you want to seem to feel
frantic a little bit more
raw and especially the cover-up actors
that might not have the fighting
experiences
really close-up shots that are really
shaky now you see your blurs back and
forth and grunting and some people
falling and maybe the occasional wide
shot
i'm not a fan of this because that pulls
me out of the action if i'm watching the
film that's got a martial arts
fight scene in it i want to see what's
happening it's okay to show a blur shot
once in a while but
every now and then there's a movie which
does it excessively and the two biggest
corporates i can think of off the top of
my head are
lethal weapon one you know between mel
gibson and gary bc that
drove me nuts as a kid that i really
couldn't see too much of what they were
doing
and even batman begins there's a lot of
that the later batman films we saw
better choreography but that close-up
the close-up frantic raw
action where it just blurs everything to
me ruins the scene
and that's my personal opinion some of
you might like it but the shaky cam is
definitely one way to add
a raw frantic-ness to the to the battle
as well as
cover-up actors who might not have prime
fighting experience
so those are some of your basic camera
tricks the editor on the other hand
has a few tools in his toolbox to take
things even further
so one is um the way he cuts choice of
cuts
you know he can take you know on set
they film a whole bunch of different
angles typically of different fight
scenes
the editor now has to assemble it one
trick is to
cut angles especially cutting on action
sometimes when you cut on a movement cut
on the action you can abbreviate it
slightly
makes it look a little bit faster it
actually ties in the shots makes the
edits look a little bit smoother
especially when you overlay sound it can
be it can feel a lot more natural and
not such a jerky cut
angle cut ankle cut so one of the tips
is
cutting on the action so when that punch
is connecting
immediately cut to the next person
reacting so to help smooth out the
action sequence a little bit more
now another subtle technique it's called
speed ramping on the average most films
are filmed at 24 frames per second
and they play back at 24 frames per
second every once in a while if they
want to enhance a quick effect or make a
strike look
more snappy or all of a sudden a little
bit faster than it would have been in
real life
is during editing they could ramp up the
frames for just a little tiny second to
make it look like a faster strike
one example is in cobra kai in a
tournament scene ironically enough it's
when
miguel does the crank kick and you can
see it's a normal shot they sit up
but that second his foot connects
there's like that quick little almost a
hyper speed whip to it and the reaction
is real quick
and it goes back to normal speed i'm
pretty sure that's a speed ramp effect
just to enhance the shot and since we
talked about before the alignment
if you look at the shadows on the floor
they're using the same trick they use in
the karate kid but they're just slightly
off plane from each other to give the
illusion they actually made contact
and this was also kind of related to a
trick that they used to do and they
still you
will use once in a while um like i said
on average most films were filmed at 24
frames per second and played back at 24
frames per second
one older trick and it's still used once
in a while is
sometimes they would film action
sequences at 22 frames per second
more or less and then when it's played
back at 24 it's sped up slightly
but not sped up so much where it looks
unnatural so that was a very common
trick especially back in the days when
they didn't have digital editing systems
it was more
you know real to real that was a very
simple in-camera trick that they could
do was film at a slightly slower frame
rate
so it captured the action but when it
was projected back it was sped up
just a little bit enough to look a
little more convincing so frame rates
are a tactic as well to make something a
little bit more impressive
shutter speed is another interesting
trick that's used in movie making
and it's a very very subtle unless you
know exactly what to look for
so for those who are not familiar the
camera shutter the shutter speed refers
to how long that shutters open and
closes as it's taking his picture
so a camera shutter that's got a slow
shutter speed the image is open
the longer it's open the more light
comes in and hits the chip
the more motion it picks up the faster
it opens and closes
the less light that hits the chip and
what you get is when you have a longer
exposure when you're when your shutters
open longer
your move anything that's moving will
trail that's where motion blurs come
from because
as long as that shutter is open and that
person's moving they're basically
streaking
versus a higher shutter speed will snap
open and close real quick
it's going to capture more of a sharper
image for example the kingsman had a
fight scene in the church
if you look at it you notice there's
really no motion blurs it's
almost choppy and jerky and almost a
little bit surreal but that matches the
tone of the scene
they're also playing with the dolly and
zooms a little bit so they're giving it
more of a comical a little bit more of a
fantasy
feel to it and that grittiness just
makes it that much more
hard-hitting and you see a little more
detail but let's look at lethal weapon 4
for example
when they were filming with jet li they
did say that jet li moved really fast on
set
and it was almost hard to that sometimes
they had to ask him to slow down because
he was moving a little bit too fast for
the camera to capture him so in a lot of
his shots you see
the motion blur especially when he's
fighting rigs in mertog you know he
moves
you're not seeing very crisp frames
you're seeing blurs and that sells the
illusion of him moving extremely fast
very effective both of them are very
effective filmmaking techniques
it really depends on the mood and what
the intent of the scene you're trying to
get across
and then of course we have stun actors
we can't forget them
many times you might have a high profile
actor that you know might not be able to
do some certain stunts or even fight so
they'll bring in some
actors one and then this happens a lot a
lot of movies especially with dangerous
stunts
but there's certain ways to hide him in
there it kind of stands out as a stunned
actor if you never see that person's
face during the fight
and many times they're their
bodybuilders will be slightly different
to the main actor
so what they'll typically do is they'll
cut it in a way where
it'll go back and forth between stun
actor shots and main actor shots and
i find that as long as you kind of
constantly go back to a face or close-up
of the main actor show them
as a quick glimpse you get away with a
lot more sun after shots especially in
the sequence of cuts
now environments environments are one of
my favorite ways that movies can get
creative with their fight scenes because
it's not just about one guy versus one
guy fighting i find it much more
interesting
if their environment is an obstacle
everything can be a weapon
are there are they are they going is it
unlevel ground are they fighting on
stairs inside of the building on the
mountain
are they in the restaurant they're
grabbing tables are you know they're
grabbing silverware
how creatively are they using the scene
around them
to add to the effect in my personal
opinion i really enjoy
seeing a character utilize their whole
space because that adds a lot more value
to me in the fight because i'm very big
on environmental awareness when it comes
to self defense
it's a big part of the discipline so
when i see movies really creatively use
the set pieces
in the combat that just heightens the
excitement for me and i think it's
that's
i think that's just great filmmaking and
then we have wire effects
now wire effects are very commonplace in
kung fu films but they've you know over
the past several years they've been
working their way into more mainstream
movies here in america
and i really think their usage depends
on what you're trying to get across
wire work is often very obvious but it
works very well in movies that have like
a fantasy element to it or a little bit
of a supernatural element to it
superhero fighting anything with magic
it definitely falls into place with that
if it's a more grounded story you want
to use it sparingly
for example jet li had a little bit of
some wire moments in
lethal weapon four but it was subtle it
was quick and it was just enough to give
him a little bit more of a
a threat level increase to rig zimmer
talk it showed his skill above there
so while it was a wire effect it was
subtle and it sold
that sold the moment of okay he's better
than they are
and it heightens the danger and
heightens the excitement so wire work
when used properly
can also be very effective okay so when
it comes to multiple attackers
the concept of multiple attackers is
dancing in line of realism
just by default because it's very very
difficult to fight more than one person
at a time
realistically and in movies you know
everyone seems to be a one-man army
and everyone at this point is i think
pretty tired of the trope of
you know a group of guys surround your
back or your main character but they
only attack one at a time and he takes
them out
that's kind of the only way of doing it
so what do they do now like how can you
make it a little bit more convincing
movement keep the scene moving if you've
got multiple attackers don't just have
them standing waiting to turn
have them move maybe have one guy trying
to climb and come forward maybe have
another guy trying to get around another
guy
maybe your character hits one person
turns into another give this guy a
second to recover but keep movement
going
especially if it's a large scene just
keep the motion going
and when you cut with the motion
sometimes it's hard to get your bearing
and as a viewer it's more exciting
because you're wondering like oh okay
well i see this bad guy what about the
one he was just fighting
and you can play around with those
camera angles but i think it's very
important to keep the motion
going but as an example of a movie that
i think does it quite poorly
believe it or not is dark knight rises i
was actually really disappointed with
the choreography in that film
uh the batman vs bane shots aren't so
bad you know they still follow the main
rules
they're well cut the great one-on-one
fighting
choreography but in the scenes that have
a lot of background action
particularly when they're on the rooftop
fighting
and when the big the big finale at the
end if you look at the background action
it is a borderline ridiculous look at
this
scene right here with batman fighting
bane and you see all the cops and the
criminals fighting in the background
most of them are just hugging each other
and doing little patty cake hits and
they're just kind of jumping
there's almost no fight card
choreography going on at all they're
just
moving and jumping with some the
occasional
mimic of a move so i mean when you
really watch that background scene you
kind of go like
well that just looks silly and same
thing again like on the rooftop when cat
one and batman are on the rooftop
fighting it's the same thing there's
just motion in the background
even so far as a guy who seems to be
getting beat up by nobody and getting
knocked down
after fighting nobody so that's as much
as i love those films that's just messy
filmmaking and that kind of drew me out
of the scenes because that's an example
of bad background motion so
you want to you want to make it
convincing you want to have motion going
on you want to have the right angles you
want to be able to cut the scene
together
that sells the intensity it sells the
impacts it sells the dramatic nature
again it all comes to telling that story
and if there's any element
in there that distracts the viewer any
mistake like that or something that
draws their mind well you're drawing
them out of the story and you're kind of
losing them so
your the primary goal is to drive that
narrative forward
and when all else fails if you find
yourself needing to do a stunt that's
too dangerous
or our weapons at play or for whatever
reason the logistics of the scene are
just too difficult
sometimes cgi is the way to go and you'd
be surprised how many times you can
watch a scene in the film
where you're not even looking at real
live actors they're just animated john
wick three is actually a good example of
this where there's some sequences where
it's just animation or
animation enhanced fighting sequences
that you wouldn't have picked out
normally
so that was just kind of maybe a little
fun way to look at martial arts films
and understand that
the movie camera is lying to you you
know we we talk
we have fun breaking down scenes and
what's realistic what's not but again
it's all about selling the drama and
selling the moment you know for better
for worse whether you
feel or hurts the martial arts or not
but i encourage you now to go go watch
some of your favorite martial arts
scenes now
and see if you can pick out any of these
techniques there might be a few things
you never noticed before especially like
watching background action and watch for
cuts and continuity
there's a lot of things that you might
not have picked out the first time
viewing
and also as an experiment i get a lot of
messages from from viewers who are
talking about different martial arts
scenes so we had this discussion quite a
bit
so i thought this would be kind of a fun
look so the kind of play off of this on
thursday
if you're watching this episode today on
tuesday on this release on thursday
we're going to release another episode
taking a look at one scene from the
cobra kai season 1 episode 5
the lunchroom scene the lunchroom fight
scene so we're going to kind of take
that and break that down step by second
kind of analyze what's realistic versus
what's cinematic about it and how it was
framed and shot
a certain way to deliver that narrative
across so go ahead and set your reminder
for that you can click on the bell so
that way when it drops you'll be
notified right away
so that's it for now i hope you guys
enjoyed this um if you want to talk
about future movie scenes if you like
the breakdown and talk about what's
realistic versus cinematic please leave
your feedback in the comments below i
would love to hear what you guys think
and maybe we can do more of these in the
future
uh so thank you so much and we will see
you next time
[Music]
you
