The #1 reason your Flat White doesn't taste right

Seven Miles Coffee Roasters
12 followers
14 Video Views·Mar 2, 2023
Fun fact, here in Australia, over 90% of coffee is served with milk.
We drink so much milk that you could say that we've got a milk culture rather than a coffee
culture.
Anyway, rather than getting on our high horse about how everyone should be drinking black
coffee, we decided it was time to dig deeper into how to make the best damn milk coffee
possible.
Now, we've known for a long time that the ratio of coffee to milk makes a big difference
in customer preference.
Some people choose stronger coffees like the piccolo latte, double shot flat white, or
a cortado.
These are often in the range of 1 parts coffee to 1 to 2 parts milk.
While on the other end of the scale, some people choose half or even quarter strength.
But honestly, if we look at the numbers, both of these groups are in the minority.
The vast majority of people go for something in between like a cappuccino, flat white or
a latte.
So for these popular styles of coffee, we wanted to find out what the ideal coffee to
milk ratio is and if it changes depending on the blend of coffee that you use.
So naturally, we did a few tests.
We picked a range of espresso blends, a classic medium roast crowd pleaser, a heavier Italian
style blend, lighter roast specialty blend, and a fruity natural process specialty blend.
For each blend, we made a series of milk coffees with a coffee to milk ratio ranging from 1
to 4.5 and 1 to 6.5.
We mixed up the samples and got a group of people to taste and rank them based on their
own personal preference.
We then crunched the numbers and found a couple of things that we weren't actually expecting.
But before I dive into that, just bear in mind, these numbers are naturally biased by
our location and the types of coffees that our tasters are used to drinking, so your
own results may vary.
We're just sharing what we found in our own tests in case that is useful for you.
With that out of the way, this is the very first thing that we found.
People chose the same ratio regardless of the blend that we used.
We expected that people would prefer more milk in the traditional punchier blends.
We often talk about certain blends cutting through the milk, so this was pretty surprising.
Particularly for the Italian style blend that contains a mix of Arabica and Robusta, Robusta
adds a strong distinctive note to the blend, often used to bump up the perception of strength,
so we expected people would prefer more milk with this particular blend, but no.
Most people picked the same ratio as they did for the other three blends.
This isn't to say that people didn't notice a difference in strength between these coffees.
It's simply what they preferred when it came to the same ratio of coffee to milk for whatever
reason.
Of course, like all roasters, we have a certain style of roasting, so these results may be
different if you use a very dark or a very light style of roast, but it is interesting
nonetheless.
Our group of tasters overwhelmingly preferred coffees when the coffee to milk ratio was
between 1 to 5 and 1 to 6.
Samples that were stronger or weaker than this range ranked lower across every blend
that we did test.
With all this talk of ratios, it's pretty easy to overlook the actual quantity of milk
that we're talking about.
In terms of volume, the sweet spot range adds up to a difference of just about 20ml of milk
for a typical small single shot coffee.
20ml is basically a dash of milk, so it's really easy to overshoot this amount if you
have too much or not enough foam, or if you're using a cup that's too big.
Okay, I realise that this is probably all too much nerdy hipster nonsense for some people.
Analysing small amounts of milk in a flat white is pretty over the top, but for those
of us who are willing, here are a couple of practical ways that we can use this information.
And the first is pretty basic.
It's really important to find the right size cups.
If you've ever watched our previous videos, then you'll know that I'm always banging
on about cup size.
It's trickier than it seems to work this out, and mainly because we have to allow for some
headspace for milk foam at the top.
Based on testing this with some cups in our espresso bar, we found that the cups with
a capacity of 170ml for a single shot or 340ml for a double shot hit this ratio, based
on the way that we make coffee.
The 340ml cup was almost exactly the same capacity as a 12oz paper cup that we use.
Paper cups are a whole other problem, which I won't get into now, but I will link to another
video down below if you're interested.
The other thing we control when it comes to the ratio of coffee to milk is the amount
of foam.
The foamier the milk, then the less liquid is going to get into the cup, so you'll end
up with a stronger coffee to milk ratio, and vice versa.
Naturally, if you inject too much air, or not enough air into the milk when steaming,
then this will be your primary cause.
But there are also a few other ways that this can be affected.
Like if you pour two coffees from the same jug, then the first will have more foam than
the second.
Or if you pour very slowly, then more foam will be held back in the jug.
Either way, the quickest way to work out if you've hit the mark is to use a set of scales.
And yes, this is probably overkill if you're making coffee at home, but in a cafe, it can
be a pretty useful quality control and training method, and will allow you the ability to
make multiple drinks of the same type really quickly, really accurately.
So once you've worked out the ideal quantity of milk that you're aiming for, pop the cup
with the espresso shot on the scales, and zero it.
Then pour the coffee in, put the finished product back on the scales, and you can see
if you need to adjust your technique for the next time.
Okay, it is time for my coffee, I am thirsty, so until next time, stay stoked.
