Milk Alternatives for Coffee (Tested & Compared)

Seven Miles Coffee Roasters
12 followers
14 Video Views·Mar 1, 2023
With so many alternative milks available in the market right now, it really begs the question,
which one tastes best with coffee? We tested 14 different brands, almond milks, oat milks,
soy milks and coconut milks to find an answer. Stick around to find out the results. Hi there,
it's Adam Carr here from the Coffee Science and Education Centre at Seven Miles Coffee Roasters
here in Sydney, Australia. So today we're here to talk about alternative milks or non-dairy milks
or plant-based milks or milks with a Y, you know, whatever you want to call them,
they're non-dairy milks. Well, the reason we did this, part of the reason that we did this is
because we've just released a study called CAFE 2025. It's looking at market trends into the
future. And one of the trends we found is that alternative milks are predicted to fill a void
where dairy milk consumption is dropping off across the next five years. So about a 15% drop
in dairy milk consumption is what is expected in Australia in the next five years. The other thing
that's filling that void is black coffee, which may be the subject of another video. But right
now we're here to talk about alternative milks. We wanted to find which one was the best. Now,
obviously, the best is a relatively subjective thing when it comes to taste, especially.
We certainly tried to put objective criteria on testing these milks. So how much foam does
the milk produce? Does it curdle in contact with coffee? How high a temperature can you reach before
the milk curdles? In some way, you're going to test these yourself into the day to determine
which one you like best. And we do have some general recommendations on what to look for.
So you can find out a bit more about that in this video. So first up, we want to talk about almond
milk. And the reason we're talking about almond milk is because it is now the most popular alternative
milk out there in the market, and it's still going to be growing in its popularity. Almond milk
generally has only about 3% almonds, although that varies based on brand. It's a nut extract
mixed through water and stabilized. So that again, once you foam it up, once you pour it inside your
coffee, hopefully that emulsion doesn't break. Breaking that stable milk is what we call curdling.
So it forms clumps. The proteins degrade for various reasons, maybe temperature, maybe the
acidity of the material that's being poured into it. Whatever it happens to be, it can denature
proteins and that forms clumps. We call that curdling. And it's generally fairly undesirable.
So we tested five different brands of almond milk. And generally what we found is that you're
playing Russian roulette if you're going for an unsweetened variety. The unsweetened almond
milks that we tested did two extremes. One of them curdled just by heating it to 65 degrees
Celsius, the regular temperature you'd be trying to pour this into a coffee at. On the other hand,
the other milk that was unsweetened didn't form much foam at all. Moreover, one thing I'll also
say on unsweetened milk before I get to the sweetened stuff is it didn't taste very good.
Watery, relatively insipid, it was chalky in the mouth and generally felt quite clumpy.
Now the sweetened stuff was a lot better. It held its stability at high temperature,
it poured very well, didn't tend to curdle, which was great, had a great nutty flavor running
throughout. So that sugar inside the almond milk actually has a significant impact on both the
taste and stability of it. Of the brands we tested, there was one winner that sort of just
munched it out across the other ones. We found Australia's own almond milk blend works better
than the rest. But again, I mean, your taste, let your taste decide. So now let's talk about
soy milk. Soy milk is the second most popular alternative milk used behind almond milk.
And whilst popular is sort of waning, it's still a lot of people really, really like it.
And it's interesting when we did our testing, particularly when we did some consumer testing
here as well, is that while we ourselves at Seven Miles prefer generally the slightly less beany
taste, a lot of consumers out there actually like the beany taste of soy milk. Maybe it's just been
built into their psyche, that's something they really like. They love that flavor in there. So
taste preference is kind of an interesting one inside this category. In terms of stability and
pouring soy milk in coffee, I'm sure many of you will be aware it tends to curdle, it tends to
split quite easily. And we actually found that there was not any soy milk that we tested in our
list at least that didn't curdle. The one that tended to curdle the slowest or the one that
didn't curdle as much when we poured it in fresh was Happy Happy Soy Boy. And it was interesting
that that milk had a particularly high pH. In other words, it was a more alkaline milk. All
the other ones were generally a little bit less than neutral, slightly acidic. So when you pour
these milks into an acidic coffee, obviously whatever the pH is at the end of the day will
have an impact on how fast that thing curdles. We actually did a second experiment with this
with soy milk because we looked at how it poured into hot chocolate. Hot chocolate itself is a
neutral pH and actually we found that none of them curdled when put into a hot chocolate. So it's
heat stable, but it is not so much pH stable. So yeah, the next product I'm going to talk about
is oat milk. And we're quite excited about this one as a category. For us, I guess as baristas,
as a coffee company, we think it best approximates a dairy milk in terms of a latte.
But it's also an exciting one to watch because it is the fastest growing category of alternative
milk products. So it's a good one to talk about here. And we found actually that all the oat
milks that we tested and at the time of this filming, there were only three that were available
that we could actually get our hands on. We found that all three of them were perfectly acceptable.
They were stable to heat, they were stable to pH, and they all had a fairly acceptable taste
in coffee. If we had to choose one, kind of like my children, if we had to choose one,
Oatly would be the one that we would recommend of all three of them. But again, you know,
there are so many companies that are producing new products as oat milks, new oat milk products.
We recommend you go out and try those ones. I'm sure there's some pretty exciting ones out there.
So in terms of an interesting scientific result from the studies we did on oat milk,
the protein content, the pH, the stabilizer content, and the sugar content all pretty
closely mirrored that in a lot of the alternative milks that tended to curdle.
But these ones didn't. And our reasoning for why that might be the case is because the protein
content inside oat milk will be, the types of proteins inside oat milk will be quite different
to those produced from another milk. I know it's a very different product to a nut. And so I think
these are the reasons why there is stability here, where in other ones with similar, let's call them
scientific values, tend to fail. So the final milk we tested was coconut. And it's a bit of a
strange one. There was no real reason why, why not macadamia or something. It was just something
that was quite different. We wanted to put it in the study because, you know, I like coconut.
So what did we find? Well, interestingly, coconut milks of the three brands that we tested,
all of them were quite stable at temperature and none of them curdled in milk. So that's
quite a positive. However, in terms of taste, there was quite a big variation between the
different coconut milks. So some tasted too watery and relatively insipid. Some were quite
creamy and tasty, but tasted very much like coconut, surprisingly. So I mean, coconut is
kind of one that has a very broad range and won't go so far as to call it a Russian roulette here.
But if you like coconut milk, and if customers are demanding it, you can't go wrong with many of them.
Just be careful that you don't get one that tastes quite watery when it's mixed with coffee.
So overall recommendations, Adam, what would you recommend that I use in my cafe? Well,
overall, I would say oat milk as a broad category, because oat milk is incredibly stable.
It has a great taste in coffee, you get a lot of coffee, actual coffee taste through the milk.
So I think oats a winner. Almond milk is 100% acceptable and lovely. And you can get some
really good, good versions of almond milk and across the whole gamut of brands that are out
there. And it's also generally if you get a sweetened almond milk, it's generally quite
stable as well. So we recommend those. Following that, it's kind of hard to go beyond soy milk,
purely because I think there's a lot of people in a lot of customers who actually want
soy milk. So it's a safe bet to have inside of a cafe. Although I do think that it's starting
to lose a bit of ground, quite a lot of ground to almond and oat milk. One of the things you'll
notice in this video is that we purely talked about the quality of the milk in a coffee,
we didn't talk about sustainability, what's the impact of each thing on the environment,
we didn't talk about how each one's good, or maybe not as good for your health. These
we're studying actually right now. And we're doing a bit of work on this and we are intending
on publishing some stuff a little later on. If you would like more details about the work that
we've presented here, for example, the numbers and some of the specifics in terms of testing
criteria that we did per brand. All those details are going to be available on a blog and on a post
we have on our website. They'll be available very soon. And when it's ready, we'll post a link
down below here. So until next time, I'm Adam Carr from the Coffee Science and Education Centre.
See you around.
