The Secret to Soft Cream-Filled Donuts

Health Food
429 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Why do some donuts turn out incredibly light, airy and not greasy at all,
while others become heavy and absorb too much oil after frying?
The result is not only about the recipe, it depends on every stage of working with the dough,
from mixing to proper proofing.
Today I'll walk you through the entire process
and share the key details that truly make a difference.
Let's start with 180 grams of warm milk,
about 86 to 95 degrees Fahrenheit to ideal temperature for healthy yeast activity.
Next, I'm sifting 560 grams of bread flour.
Bread flour has a higher protein content,
which helps develop a stronger gluten network and gives the dough a better structure.
I weigh out 8 grams of instant yeast and 100 grams of sugar.
Then I add 1 teaspoon of salt to the flour and mix everything well.
This helps distribute the salt evenly throughout the flour
and prevents a high concentration of salt from coming into direct contact with the yeast.
Now I'm adding the yeast, sugar, 4 room temperature eggs, about 216 grams and the warm milk.
I'll mix everything using the dough hook on the lowest speed.
At first, it may not look like much is happening.
The flour is gradually absorbing the liquid and the ingredients are just beginning to come together.
Once all the flour is fully hydrated,
the dough will become even softer and may start spreading across the bowl.
That's completely normal, so don't rush to add more flour.
As the mixing continues, the gluten begins to develop.
The dough becomes smoother, starts wrapping around the dough hook,
develops thin gluten starts and gradually pulls away from the sides of the bowl.
Now the dough has come together and completely cleared the sides of the bowl.
This is the point where I stop the mixer and check the gluten development.
At this stage, it's important to pay attention not just to the mixing time,
but to the dough itself.
This is called the gluten window test.
When the dough stretches into a thin, almost translucent membrane without tearing,
it's a sign that the gluten has developed properly and the dough is ready for the next step.
Our goal is to develop a strong gluten network without overmixing the dough.
That way, the dough stays soft and elastic before we start adding the butter.
For this recipe, I'm using 90 grams of butter.
I add it gradually, a little at a time.
Letting each addition fully incorporate before adding the next.
In enriched doughs, butter can interfere with gluten development.
So it's best to add it only after the gluten has already started to develop.
Once all the butter has been incorporated, I continue mixing for another 5 to 7 minutes.
During this time, the dough becomes smooth again,
more elastic and develops a beautiful glossy appearance.
Now the dough is ready for the first fermentation.
I lightly grease the container with vegetable oil to prevent the dough from sticking.
Look at this texture.
The dough is very soft and elastic, but it barely sticks to my hands.
I transfer the dough into the container,
cover it with plastic wrap and let it ferment in a warm place
until it increases in size by about double, instead of relying only on time.
It's important to watch the dough itself.
Overproofed dough becomes weaker and doesn't hold its shape as well.
While the dough is going through its first fermentation,
I prepare the parchment paper for the doughnuts pieces.
I cut it into small squares, about 4 by 4 inches.
This is a very convenient way to work with soft enriched dough.
After proofing, I don't need to lift the doughnuts by hand,
which helps preserve more air inside and prevents the delicate pieces from losing their shape.
While the dough continues fermenting, I'll prepare two fillings for the doughnuts.
A delicate vanilla custard and a rich chocolate.
For the base of both creams, I'm using equal parts milk and heavy cream.
500 grams each.
I separate 6 egg yolks from the whites.
I weigh 350 grams of sugar separately, but I don't add it to the yolks yet.
If sugar sits with the egg yolks for too long, it starts drawing moisture out of them,
which can make the mixture thick and uneven.
That's why I add the sugar and cornstarch only when the milk
and heavy cream are already almost at a simmer.
While the milk and heavy cream are heating,
I add 2 teaspoons of vanilla paste to create a deeper vanilla flavor.
I prepare the remaining ingredients in advance.
60 grams of cornstarch, 40 grams of butter,
and 80 grams of dark chocolate for the chocolate version.
Once the milk and cream are almost simmering, I remove them from the heat.
Now, I combine the egg yolks with the sugar and cornstarch.
Because this recipe contains a fairly large amount of sugar,
compared to the amount of yolks, the mixture becomes quite thick
and the whisk becomes difficult to use.
So, I switch to a spatula, it makes it easier to combine everything evenly.
Next, I slowly add the hot milk and cream mixture to the yolks while constantly whisking.
This step is called tempering.
We gradually raise the temperature of the yolks
so they don't curdle when they come into contact with the hot liquid.
After that, I strain the mixture back into the saucepan.
This removes any possible bits of cooked egg
or undissolved starch and helps create a smoother, more delicate cream.
Then, I return the saucepan to the stove and continue cooking until the cream thickens.
I cook the cream over medium heat, stirring constantly.
Once the cream starts to thicken and the first bubble appear,
I continue cooking for about 30 more seconds.
This step is important because the starch needs to cook completely.
If the cream is removed from the heat too early,
it can have a starchy taste and the texture may not be stable.
After cooking, I turn off the heat, add the butter and mix until completely smooth.
For an extra silky and perfectly smooth texture,
you can also blend the cream with an immersion blender.
I divide the cream into two portions.
I leave one as a classic vanilla pastry cream and to the second one I add dark chocolate.
While the cream is still hot, the chocolate melts easily and combines with the pastry cream,
creating a smooth and rich chocolate texture.
After that, I cover both creams with plastic wrap directly on the surface
and place them in the refrigerator to cool completely.
Here I have two versions of the same dough.
One went through cold fermentation in the refrigerator
and the other was fermented at room temperature.
The room temperature dough feels softer and more relaxed,
while the cold fermented dough is firmer and more structured.
But when we look inside, both doughs show a delicate web of gluten
with fine strands stretching between the air pockets.
That's a sign of proper mixing and good gluten development.
Cold fermentation isn't essential for great donuts.
It mainly enhances flavor and aroma while making the dough easier to handle.
With proper mixing and fermentation, both methods can produce excellent results.
Here you can see the cold fermented dough.
It feels firmer and more controlled, making it easier to shape.
And here is the dough after room temperature fermentation.
It feels softer, more relaxed and more responsive.
Now I start dividing the dough into portions for the donuts.
I weigh each piece at about 60 grams
so that all the donuts are the same size and fry evenly.
This recipe makes about 19 donuts.
Today I have a little helper.
My daughter is helping me shape the donut pieces.
Now I begin shaping each piece into a smooth ball.
It's important to create a smooth and even surface when shaping.
I lightly grease my hands with a little vegetable oil,
just enough to prevent the dough from sticking.
Pay attention to the bottom of the dough ball.
It also needs to be completely sealed.
If there is a weak spot or an opening underneath,
it can expand during proofing and frying.
Causing the donut to lose its beautiful shape.
That's why I always check that each piece is smooth and closed all around.
After shaping, the donuts go through their second fermentation.
It's very important not to rely only on time
because proofing can vary depending on the room temperature and yeast activity.
After the second fermentation, the donuts are ready to fry.
I carefully transfer each piece onto a slotted spoon,
remove the parchment paper and place the donut into the hot oil.
This method is more convenient for me
because I don't have to remove piece of parchment from the oil afterwards.
I keep the oil temperature around 330 to 340 degrees Fahrenheit
and constantly monitor it with a thermometer
because maintaining a stable temperature is essential for even frying.
I fry each donut for about 2 minutes on one side,
then carefully flip it and fry for another 2 minutes on the other side.
After frying, I remove the donuts,
let the excess oil drain off and place them on a paper towel.
The light colored ring around the donut is one of the signs of a properly made yeast donut.
It develops when the dough has the right level of proofing,
a strong structure and is fried at the correct temperature.
If the dough is under-proofed, the donut doesn't have enough time to fill with air
and may turn out denser.
If the dough is over-proofed, the structure becomes weaker.
The donut may lose its shape,
absorb more oil and sometimes collapse or wrinkle after cooling.
I want to show you a situation that is a very common reason for unsuccessful results.
This dough went through too long of a proof.
At first glance, it may look very airy,
but the internal structure has already become weaker.
During frying, donuts made from over-proofed dough can expand evenly with large air bubbles,
become misshapen, absorb more oil and lose their structure after frying.
That's why with yeast dough, more time doesn't always mean a better result.
The most important thing is learning to recognize the right stage of the dough.
After the donuts have a cooling slightly, I coat them in sugar.
Traditionally, Berliner-style donuts and Italian bomboloni are often served this way,
with a light coating of sugar on the outside and a delicate filling inside.
Now comes the most enjoyable part, filling the donuts.
Today I'm using two types of filling,
a delicate vanilla pastry cream and a rich chocolate pastry cream.
Before filling, both creams need to be completely chilled.
I transfer them into piping bags.
This makes the filling process much easier and more precise.
Now take a look at this texture inside.
The donut has a light and tender crumb with a beautiful airy structure.
The soft, delicate dough creates the perfect balance with the creamy filling.
Before adding the cream, I make a small opening in each donut
and gently create some space inside, so the filling can spread evenly.
I love when filled donuts have a generous amount of cream, so I don't hold back on the filling.
This amount of cream is exactly enough to generously fill the entire
batch of donuts from this recipe.
You can see how the donuts become even fuller and more plump after being filled.
For me, the perfect donut is all about balance.
A light, airy dough paired with a smooth and velvety cream filling.
That balances what I look for in every dessert I create.
In this small experiment, I wanted to compare
how dough proofing and oil temperature affect the final result.
All dough pieces were prepared at the same size, exactly 60 grams each.
Let's start with the properly proofed donut.
Before frying, I weighed it one more time.
The weight remains the same, 60 grams.
The oil has already been heated to 328 degrees Fahrenheit.
The parchment paper releases easily from the dough without damaging the surface
or changing the shape of the dough piece.
I fried the donut for 2 minutes on each side.
Now, let's look at the overproofed dough piece.
After a longer proofing time, its weight has already decreased to 58 grams.
During this time, the dough gradually lost some moisture and overall mass.
Notice that the parchment paper is no longer coming off as easily.
As I remove it from the surface, the dough starts to slightly deform.
I fried this donut at the same temperature,
328 degrees Fahrenheit, also for 2 minutes on each side.
Now, let's move on to the next variation.
This dough piece also went through an extended proofing time and its weight is now 58 grams.
The parchment paper is much harder to remove and noticeably affect the shape of the dough.
Some of the air escapes and the dough starts losing volume even before it reaches the oil.
This time, the oil is heated to 300 degrees Fahrenheit.
To make sure the donut cooks all the way through,
I need to increase the frying time to 4 minutes on each side.
In my experience, this temperature is too low for yeast-raised donuts.
Even with a longer frying time, they tend to absorb more oil
and don't achieve the same light and airy texture.
And now, the final variation.
This dough piece also weighed 58 grams after the extended proofing time.
Once again, the parchment paper is difficult to remove
and the dough easily loses its shape before frying even begins.
This time, the oil is heated to 360 degrees Fahrenheit.
At this temperature, the donut develops color very quickly,
so I fry it for only 40 seconds on each side.
And finally, I want to share a small technique that can be helpful in this situation.
If the dough is very delicate and sticks strongly to the parchment,
for example, because of overproofing,
or simply because of the type of parchment you are using,
don't try to force it off beforehand.
Instead, carefully place the dough piece into the oil with the parchment still attached.
After a few seconds, once the surface of the dough has started to set,
the parchment can be removed easily without deforming the donut.
This simple technique helps preserve the shape of the dough
and prevents losing volume before frying.
Now let's see how these changes affected the finished donuts after frying.
This is the donut with the proper proof.
Before frying, it weighed 60 grams, and after frying, the weight remained the same.
This doesn't mean that the donut absorbed no oil.
During frying, two processes happen at the same time.
The dough loses moisture, while some oil is absorbed into the structure.
In this case, these changes balanced each other out, so the final weight stayed the same.
Now let's look at the donut made from overproofed dough, fried at 328 degrees Fahrenheit.
After frying, its weight increased to 63 grams.
This means the final weight increased after frying,
showing a different balance between moisture loss and oil absorption.
The next donut was also fried from overproofed dough, but at 300 degrees Fahrenheit.
After frying, its weight is also 63 grams.
And the final version was fried at 360 degrees Fahrenheit.
Its weight after frying is also 63 grams.
It's interesting that all three donuts fried at different
temperature ended up with the same final weight.
But as we'll see next, the same weight after frying
doesn't always mean the same structure or the same result.
Now let's look inside.
First, let's compare the donut with the proper proof.
I'm showing two donuts together to demonstrate that
this is not just a single result, but a consistent outcome.
Both donuts have the same structure.
Small, evenly distributed air cells and a soft, light crumb.
This comes from proper mixing, good gluten development, and the right proofing process.
The dough was able to hold air evenly and maintain its shape.
Now let's look at the donut made from overproofed dough, fried at 328 degrees Fahrenheit.
The structure is already different.
The air pockets are larger and less even.
The donut still has volume, but you can see larger spaces inside.
Compared to the properly proofed donut,
the crumb looks heavier and feels more saturated with oil.
The next donut is also from overproofed dough, but it was fried at 300 degrees Fahrenheit.
Here the difference becomes even more noticeable.
The air pockets inside are larger, the structure is less uniform,
and you can clearly see a more noticeable oily area near the crust at the bottom of the donut.
This is the result of two factors combined.
A weaker dough structure after overproofed and a lower frying temperature.
And finally, the last version.
Overproofed dough fried at 360 degrees Fahrenheit.
At first glance, this donut looks good.
It has volume, the inside is fully cooked, and there is no raw dough.
But when we compare it to the properly proofed donut, the difference becomes clear.
The air pockets here are the largest of all the versions.
The structure is less even and the crumb looks more oily.
Large air pockets don't always mean a lighter donut.
Sometimes there is a sign that the dough has lost its ability to hold gas evenly
and create a stable structure.
This experiment clearly shows how important the correct proofing stage is.
With proper proofing, the dough maintains a strong structure.
The gas is distributed evenly, the donut has a light texture with a fine,
uniform crumb, and it's able to hold its shape well.
With overproofing, the dough structure becomes weaker.
The gas is no longer distributed as evenly, larger air pockets develop,
the dough loses some of its strength, and the donut can absorb more oil during frying.
Oil temperature is also an important factor.
If the temperature is too low, the donut stays in the oil longer,
which can result in a heavier and oilier texture.
After this experiment, I also checked the donut the next day.
The properly proofed donuts remained soft and tender.
The donuts made from overproofed dough become noticeably denser in texture
and didn't have the same lightness as when they were freshly fried.
The biggest takeaway is that with this dough,
it's important to learn how to read the dough itself rather than relying only on time.
I also want to mention one more detail that I noticed during this experiment.
While the overproofed dough pieces were waiting to be fried,
they were not completely covered,
so the surface of the dough dried slightly and developed a thin skin.
In a previous batch, where the surface remained soft,
I often noticed large bubbles forming on the side of the overproofed donuts during frying.
This time I didn't see the same strong side bubbles.
The slightly dried surface may have affected the way the dough expanded during frying.
However, it's important to understand
that this didn't improve the structure of the overproofed dough.
It only changed how the problem appeared during frying.
