Taiwan’s “Porcupine Strategy”: Defying China’s Invasion with Smart Power

Just Strange
239 followers
102 Video Views·May 15, 2025
China’s shadow looms large, but Taiwan stands fearless! With its cunning 'Porcupine Strategy,' the island wields drones, missiles, and ingenuity to outsmart a giant. From supersonic strikes to unbreakable resolve, Taiwan’s smart power makes invasion a nightmare for Beijing. Dive into the battle of wits shaking the Taiwan Strait!
China's shadow looms large, but Taiwan
stands fearless. With its cunning
porcupine strategy, the island wields
drones, missiles, and ingenuity to
outsmart a giant. From supersonic
strikes to unbreakable resolve, Taiwan's
smart power makes invasion a nightmare
for Beijing. Dive into the battle of
wits, shaking the Taiwan
straight. For years, communist China has
been preparing for a potential military
invasion of Taiwan. In the worst case
scenario, if US China relations
completely break down, leading to a full
economic decoupling and political
confrontation, Xiinping might see an
invasion of Taiwan as the Chinese
Communist Party's CCP last desperate
move to divert attention from a severe
economic and political crisis and to
alleviate massive domestic social
tensions. For decades, the CCP has
relied on a fixed invasion simulation,
using overwhelming naval power to cross
the 110mi Taiwan Strait, establishing a
beach head under air superiority, and
then advancing on Taipei with an
absolute numerical advantage. The
People's Liberation Army, PLA, boasts
over 2 million active duty personnel,
making it the largest military in the
world, while Taiwan has fewer than
170,000 troops. The PLA Navy has over
350 modern warships, including three
aircraft carriers, compared to Taiwan's
60 plus vessels and no carriers. China
possesses more than 2100 combat
aircraft, while Taiwan has around 350.
China's fighter jets outnumber Taiwan's
by a factor of six, and their models are
more advanced. For decades, Taiwan has
insisted on purchasing advanced fighter
jets, main battle tanks, and large
warships as symbolic weapon systems,
viewing them as a legitimate defensive
force, even though the military balance
has irreversibly tilted toward Beijing.
Following this traditional military
strategy, Taiwan is destined to fail
from the outset because it cannot
compete with China's overwhelming
numerical advantage in a conventional
war. However, the outbreak of the Russia
Ukraine war and the ongoing conflicts
between Iran and Israel in the Middle
East have drawn the attention of
military observers. They noted that
inexpensive Iranian drones can threaten
Israel's billiondoll air defense systems
and lowcost portable missiles allow
Ukrainian soldiers to destroy expensive
Russian armored tanks in an instant.
These lessons on how small-cale, mobile,
and dispersed defenses can thwart and
repel overwhelming offensives have
prompted a fundamental shift in Taiwan's
defense philosophy. During President
Saiing Wen's administration, Taiwan
began implementing a new defense
strategy known as the Porcupine
Strategy. The Porcupine strategy first
emerged in the early 2000s and was
formally proposed by US official William
S. Murray in 2008. It is an asymmetric
warfare strategy, likening Taiwan to a
small porcupine or hedgehog covered in
sharp quills, always ready to prick an
attacking enemy, making the enemy
hesitant to launch an invasion. This
unconventional strategy prioritizes
depleting the enemy's strength rather
than seeking battlefield control,
redefining victory as making the cost of
invasion so high that the enemy is
deterred. At its core is economic cost
asymmetry. For example, China's Type055
destroyer costs approximately $890
million to build, while Taiwan's Xiang
Fung III anti-ship missile costs about
$3.5 million each. Three missiles
totaling 10.5 million could destroy a
destroyer, achieving a cost
effectiveness ratio of 85.1. This highly
cost-effective defense approach allows
Taiwan to effectively resist and
counterattack despite its military
resource disadvantages. Building a
defense system with affordable weapons
and securing its supply chain has become
a key pillar of the porcupine strategy
with drones being a critical component.
10 years ago, the Taiwanese Ministry of
Defense released a military comparison
between the two sides of the Taiwan
Strait, showing that Taiwan had no
military drones at the time. Sutsu Yun
from Taiwan's Institute for National
Defense and Security Research pointed
out that the Ukrainian military's use of
drones to counter Russian forces has
significantly influenced Taiwan's
perspective on drones. Ukraine's
experience offers Taiwan an important
lesson. For a defending side with a
limited military budget, drones can be
built in large quantities at a
relatively low cost, providing a
significant opportunity to offset
China's numerical advantage. If Taiwan's
military deploys drones behind the
beaches, they can autonomously pursue
and destroy landing crafts, preventing
them from reaching shore. He added that
facing China's formidable military
power, Taiwan's strategy is to use
highly mobile weaponry for asymmetric
warfare to effectively counter China.
Wong Yu Chu, CEO of Future, a startup in
Shinshu, northern Taiwan, stated,
"Currently, Taiwan has deployed two sets
of drone defense systems on the outlying
island of Kinman. This year, our
Ministry of Defense officially announced
plans to scale up to 26 units. The
company has developed radar systems to
detect drone positions. When paired with
signal jammers and other equipment,
these systems can disrupt enemy small
drones within a 5 km radius, rendering
them unable to fly. FUD Tiger Technology
Co. Lady, founded in 1979, was
originally a manufacturer of remotec
controlled toy cars and helicopters.
About 10 years ago, leveraging its
accumulated production expertise, the
company began developing highmobility
drones. Su Shangier, the company's
chairman and general manager, said,
"Based on our 45 years of experience, we
quickly developed small and micro drones
as well as medium and large drones.
While our foundation is primarily
commercial, under these circumstances,
we are developing drones that could
potentially be used for military
purposes at the request of Taiwanese
authorities. Taiwan is currently the
only country besides China with a
complete drone production supply chain.
In his inaugural address last year,
Taiwanese President Lie Ching Tay
expressed his vision to position Taiwan
as the Asia-Pacific hub for a democratic
drone supply chain, designating drones
as a key component of the military
industry within Taiwan's five trusted
industries. In 2021, the Taiwanese
government transformed the former
National Taiwan Sport University Chi
campus into the Asia Drone AI Innovation
and Application RM D Center. In 2022,
former President Saiing Wen officiated
its opening, marking the official
formation of Taiwan's drone national
team. Taiwan also signed a memorandum of
cooperation with the US leading 15
companies to participate in the 2024
AUVSI exponential exhibition in the US
DAO establishing a regional innovation
cluster for drones in Chi. In 2025,
Taiwan's Ministry of Defense has
tentatively allocated 720 million TWWD
approximately 2357 million to procure
850 micro drones. In the future, the
military plans to distribute these to
reserve brigades in various counties and
cities, incorporating them into training
programs, meaning conscripts may soon
have the opportunity to train with
drones. Oh, additionally, the Taiwanese
military has shown strong interest in
developing attack unmanned surface
vessels, USVs. Plans to develop new
remote controlled attack USVS have also
been put on the agenda. Moreover, the
Shiongfang missile family is a crown
jewel of Taiwan's domestically produced
weaponry, critical to its asymmetric
defense. The Xiongfung III HF3
supersonic anti-hship missile can reach
speeds of Mach 3.5 with a range of 120
150 km extendable to 400 km. It employs
high altitude cruise trajectories and
evasive maneuvers such as lowaltitude
sea skimming and high G lateral
movements to evade defenses. Taiwan has
also deployed over 100 secretly
developed Xiongfang 2ie HF Thai land
attack missiles. According to Taiwanese
defense officials, the HFT Thai is an
extended range version with a range of
up to 1200 km capable of striking
targets deep within mainland China,
potentially even reaching Beijing.
Another major pillar of Taiwan's
Porcupine strategy relies heavily on
foreign weapons procurement,
particularly US made systems. The F-16V
Block 70 is the cornerstone of Taiwan's
Air Force modernization. It is the
latest model in the F-16 family.
Originally developed with funding from
Taiwan and tailored specifically for the
Republic of China Air Force. Unlike
older F-16 models, the F-16V is equipped
with the
ANAPG83 active electronically scanned
array AES radar capable of tracking over
20 targets simultaneously with a
detection range exceeding 370 km, 2.2
times that of its predecessors. This
radar was developed by Northrup Grumman.
For context, the radar on the US is most
advanced fighter, the F-22
ANAPG77 was co-developed by Northrup
Grumman and Rathon, while the F-35's
ANAPG-81 was also developed by Northrup
Grumman. In designing the downsized
APG-83 for the F-16V, Northrup Grumman
incorporated much of the same software
and hardware technology used in the F-22
and F-35, resulting in a smaller radar
that still delivers exceptional
performance and strong anti-jamming
capabilities. For an aircraft, the radar
is one eye while infrared detection is
the other. In 2023, the US government
approved the sale of infrared search and
track IRST systems to Taiwan. As early
as 2019, Loheed Martin showcased a model
of the F-16V at the bianial Taipei
Aerospace and defense technology
exhibition featuring a podmounted IRST
system beneath the aircraft. Unlike
radar, IRST detects enemy aircraft using
infrared. What we typically call a
stealth fighter refers to an aircraft
that minimizes its radar cross-section
or absorbs radar waves through surface
coatings, reducing the signal detected
by enemy radar. However, these methods
are ineffective against infrared
detection. An advanced IRST system acts
like a powerful telescope capable of
clearly identifying enemies from a
distance. With the addition of IRST, the
F-16V gains another means of detecting
enemy aircraft, including stealth
fighters. China's stealth fighters J20
and J35 rely on engine technology
derived from Russia with the WS10 and
WS-15 engines marking significant
progress through independent development
achieving radar stealth performance
close to that of U S and Russian fifth
generation fighters. However, their
infrared stealth technology remains a
weakness. Limited by engine exhaust
temperatures of
9001400° SGS and aerodynamic heating of
the airframe, the J20 cannot fully
conceal itself from far infrared
detection, making it vulnerable to
advanced IRST systems or missiles beyond
the range of its own radar. Both the
F-16V and the US F-35 are equipped with
such systems. This means that in the
competition for air superiority over the
Taiwan Strait, the Chinese Air Force is
actually at a disadvantage. While
Taiwan's current air defense
capabilities are sufficiently robust. As
for China's third aircraft carrier, the
Fujian, which we mentioned earlier, none
of China's active carriers are
nuclearpowered, requiring frequent
refueling, which limits their ability to
sustain long-term operations in the
Pacific during an invasion. Its
electromagnetic catapult system is also
reportedly plagued by reliability
issues, far less dependable than the
mature technology of the U is 11
nuclearpowered carriers. China's other
two older carriers appear even more
outdated in the face of America's latest
technological upgrades. In essence,
Taiwan's porcupine strategy, whether for
air or naval defense, is continuously
building and refining its asymmetric
warfare systems to create sufficient
deterrence, making the cost of a Chinese
invasion prohibitively high.
Additionally, Taiwanese civil defense
organizations like Forward Alliance play
a crucial role in enhancing societal
resilience against potential foreign
invasions through wartime mobilization
and emergency drills. On September 14th,
2024, over 100 volunteers in New Taipei
City participated in a disaster response
exercise jointly organized by Forward
Alliance and the U SGO Spirit of
America. The drill simulated a
large-scale explosion scenario with
firefighters, emergency personnel, and
volunteers rescuing injured civilians.
Inspired by Ukraine's civil defense
model, these exercises focus on
practical skills like evacuating the
wounded and protecting infrastructure,
preparing for scenarios where Taiwan's
14 undersea cables might be severed by
the enemy. By fostering grassroots
preparedness, these organizations
strengthen Taiwan's porcupine strategy,
enhancing strategic resilience and
ensuring civilians can support military
efforts during a crisis. Furthermore,
some military experts believe that China
would need to attack Japan before
invading Taiwan. This is because Japan
hosts US military forces that could
provide humanitarian and military aid to
Taiwan, as well as strategic rear
support for Taiwan's forces,
particularly its air force. The US has
approximately 54,000 troops stationed in
Japan with major BSE including Yokosuka,
home to the US 7th Fleet, Kadina Air
Force, and Okinawa Marines. The Kadina
Air Force Base in Okinawa Prefecture,
the largest US air base in Asia, is just
640 km from Taipei in a straight line.
If China were to directly attack Japan,
it would trigger the US Japan security
treaty, leading to a full-scale conflict
between the US and China. Whether
Xiinping and the CCP could bear such a
risk and whether they have the courage
to do so is something she and the
various factions within the CCP must
carefully weigh. Seeking peace is the
desire of every rational person, but
peace is not always achieved through
pleading. It often requires strength as
a foundation. The success of Taiwan's
porcupine strategy hinges on the
regional power projection capabilities
of both the US and China. By using
cost-effective asymmetric defense
systems to delay a Chinese invasion,
Taiwan can buy time for Allied
intervention. Even if facing China's
military might alone, Taiwan could make
the cost of invasion so high that it
deters aggression. Welcome your comments
and unique opinions on this topic.
Thanks for you watching. and we'll see
you next time.
