Some Chinese oil paintings look like ordinary old artworks, but their true value can be astonishing! On Antiques Roadshow, experts uncover the fascinating history, artistic techniques, and hidden significance behind remarkable Chinese paintings. From a $20 flea market find to rare historical masterpieces, discover the stories behind these valuable artworks and the surprising appraisals that left their owners amazed!
Chapter: 00:00 1856 Chinese Export Fire Oil Painting 03:43 Chinese Ink & Silk Paintings 07:19 Chinese-export Gouache, ca. 1910 10:37 18th-Century Japanese Painting
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video features the appraisal of several East Asian artworks, including a dramatic scene of the 1856 fire in Canton, traditional bird-and-flower silk paintings, a 20th-century portrait of a woman, and a Japanese Buddhist scroll depicting the Parinirvana. The experts analyze the historical context, materials, and condition of each piece to determine their market value.
What attracted me to this picture was the scene itself, just the fire.
Where did you come by it?
Well, it actually is one of a set of three that belonged to my parents,
and they got them in the Philadelphia area over the past 30 years.
This oil painting recreates a fierce and dramatic scene,
a riverbank engulfed in flames.
According to the expert, this is Canton, known today as Guangzhou,
one of China's largest trading ports at the time.
Along the riverbank stand rows of western trading posts,
where goods were bought, sold, and loaded onto ships.
In the foreground, various types
of vessels crowd tightly together across the water.
This is a piece of Chinese export art, meaning paintings created
by local workshops specifically for foreign buyers.
At first glance, the surface of the painting looks bright and sharp.
However, upon closer inspection,
the expert reveals noticeable signs of intervention.
Several dark areas turn out to be patched punctures,
including one prominent spot right in the sky.
Some regions have also been repainted,
likely because the original paint layer was too thin,
prompting a restorer to apply a fresh coat over it.
The catch is that new oil paint
and old oil paint age at different rates, so over the years,
these repainted sections have begun to mismatch
in color with the rest of the canvas. Under ultraviolet
light, these areas glow much brighter,
helping to clearly distinguish what has been altered.
The frame is equally remarkable, appearing to be the original pine wood
coated in a deep wine red lacquer. Because pine is a porous wood,
the lacquer adheres tightly, though it is also prone to chipping.
To understand why this particular scene was captured,
we must look back at the Canton trade system.
From the year 1757 until the Treaty of Nanjing in the year 1842,
the Qing Dynasty channeled
the vast majority of maritime trade
with the West through this single port.
Foreign merchants were restricted to a designated district
of factories right along the Pearl River,
where flags of various nations flew proudly
in front of each row of buildings.
This very environment gave birth to the export painting market,
as foreign visitors
frequently bought depictions of harbors, ships,
and portraits to take home as souvenirs.
Then came December of the year 1856,
amidst the Second Opium War, when a massive fire
completely destroyed the foreign factory district,
though historical accounts vary regarding
the exact cause.
This painting appears to capture that very historic disaster.
Yet, many unanswered questions remain.
Who actually painted it?
When it comes to export art, this question is often difficult to answer
because many works are unsigned
and were sometimes copied from existing templates.
What do the other two paintings in the set depict,
and where are they located today?
The appraisal makes no mention of them,
leaving those mysteries unsolved.
Here we have a historical moment preserved on canvas,
yet tangled with the scars of time.
So, between its documentary value and the wounds inflicted by age,
where will the market ultimately place this painting?
Because it's a very specific point in time,
it's a rare view of the fire at Canton,
and a very important historical view,
the value of the painting is going to be
in the neighborhood of $15,000 to $25,000.
That's great. Thank you very much. Appreciate it.
I got them at a thrift store,
and I bought them together for $12.99 a piece, roughly five years ago.
Do they hang in your home? Do you have them in a closet?
They're in a closet. They've been sitting
in my husband's closet for about five years.
There is a sticker on the back that mentions an age.
Over a hundred years old.
Over a hundred years old. Qing Dynasty, right?
Yes.
Placed side by side, the two paintings look quite similar.
Both depict flowers and insects,
rendered in ink and opaque body color on silk.
Yet, the expert confirms they are not by the same artist.
The older piece bears the signature of Zongyang Quelan.
Zongyang is a county in Anhui province,
the hometown of the artist Quelan, who lived
from 1758 to 1844.
The painting does not record a year of creation,
but the expert estimates it dates back to
around the year 1800.
The other piece is later, dating to around the late 19th century,
painted in the style of Emperor Huizong.
Silk makes a smooth yet fragile canvas,
and these two artworks bear the marks of time in very different ways.
The later painting only shows natural silk yellowing,
which the expert considers entirely normal.
The Chulan piece, however, has suffered heavy damage.
Tears run across the surface.
Some spots filled in with extra paint to conceal them,
and others patched up likely just to stabilize the work
and prevent further tearing.
Despite this, the tears remain clearly visible.
The Huizong style is not a random choice.
Emperor Huizong reigned from around 1100 to 1126
and is famous for his mastery of painting,
particularly bird and flower subjects,
as well as being a great patron of the Imperial Academy.
Painting in his style means following
that refined tradition,
rather than implying the artwork was created by the emperor himself.
On the Chulan piece,
Every motif carries a specific symbolic meaning.
Peonies symbolize wealth and prosperity.
Butterflies, according to the expert,
are auspicious symbols frequently associated with
marriage. Certain references on Chinese symbolism
also note that the Chinese word for butterfly
shares a homophone with longevity,
meaning butterflies can likewise be read as a wish for a
For a long life.
The expert also suggests that this insect
and flower subject may have once belonged to a larger
set celebrating the harmony of nature.
Several mysteries still remain unconfirmed. Because the
Chulan painting lacks a date,
the time frame around 1800 is merely an inference based on the
artist's biography.
If it was once part of a series, where the remaining pieces are today
Today is completely unknown.
Meanwhile, the sticker on the back is just a brief line of text,
which can never replace rigorous stylistic analysis
and signature verification.
Both pieces were purchased for the exact same price,
yet one is heavily torn and over two
centuries old, while the other is much better preserved
but dates nearly a century later.
Which way will the scale of value tip and by how much?
What do you think they're worth?
I hope more than $12.99.
More than $12.99. Well,
I will tell you they are worth more than $12.99.
This painting on its own in today's market
at auction is worth four to six thousand dollars.
That's cool. Yes, I'm excited about that.
I got it a few weeks ago at an outdoor flea market in Ohio for $20.
It's Chinese. It's what we refer to as a Chinese export painting.
It's gouache on paper.
And she's a beautiful woman.
Chinese export painting.
The high points are during the 18th and 19th century.
This is a little bit late. This is into
the first quarter, second quarter
of the 20th century. So there's a real
deco feel to me about the painting.
The phrase export painting sounds rather dry
but it simply refers to a very specific type of artwork.
Pieces created to sell to buyers
from elsewhere rather than for the domestic art market.
Consequently, the subject matter was usually tailored
to the tastes and curiosities of
foreign visitors, featuring harbors, ships, flora, and portraits.
In this case, we have a portrait of a woman,
belonging to a category of paintings that
the expert notes could vary wildly in execution and detail.
Gouache is an opaque, water-based medium,
made of pigments bound in water-soluble glue
like gum arabic, often mixed
with an inert white pigment to make it opaque.
Unlike transparent watercolor,
gouache covers the paper completely, delivering flat, bold
blocks of color that obscure everything underneath.
For a portrait artist, this meant they could build up the face,
clothing, and background
Using distinct shapes of color
and then layer finer details right on top
That capacity for layering is precisely what separates an elaborate,
highly detailed painting from a more simplified one.
Aesthetically speaking, the Art Deco movement took shape following the
International Exhibition of Modern Decorative
and Industrial Arts held in Paris in the year 1925,
characterized by clean lines,
stylized geometric shapes, and a sleek modern vibe.
This style quickly spread worldwide, including to Shanghai,
a city that was rapidly internationalizing during the 1920s and 1930s.
There, commercial advertisements
and calendar posters featuring fashionable women,
commonly known as yuefenpai, became a major visual phenomenon.
This background merely helps us understand
the aesthetic atmosphere of the period.
The appraisal does not directly tie
this painting to that specific genre,
and viewers should be careful not to jump to conclusions.
What remains unknown is far greater than what we actually know.
The expert doesn't mention the artist, the exact place of creation,
or whether the painting was originally made
for a foreign traveler or a local buyer.
Regarding its dating,
the expert only narrows it down to the first half of the 20th century,
meaning any tighter time frame would require
independent research and verification.
The transcript also leaves it unstated whether
the artwork bears any signature or workshop seal.
Without a known artist or clear provenance,
we are left with just a single face
and a painting style that evokes a bygone era.
How will a lucky find picked up at an ordinary flea market
ultimately be valued?
In a retail setting, this would be worth $3,000.
My great-great-grandparents were missionaries in Hawaii in 1828
and they had like eight children
and I think seven of them all became missionaries and when Japan opened
to the west in 1868 or whatever then three or four of them went
to Japan as missionaries and I think maybe one of them acquired
this while they were in Japan but they also were going into China.
So I've always wondered, is this Japanese or is it Chinese?
And that's all I know about it.
The scene depicted in the painting
captures the final moment of the Buddha's passing,
a concept known in Buddhism as parinirvana.
The Buddha lies at the very center,
surrounded by grieving disciples, mythological figures,
monks, and various animals.
A white elephant appears near the bottom,
while high up in the clouds is Queen Maya,
the mother of the Buddha.
This hanging scroll was once much larger than it is today,
with the expert noting that it has
been cropped at both the top and bottom edges.
Traditional East Asian hanging scrolls consist
of artwork pasted onto a backing,
bordered with fabric or paper,
and attached to a wooden roller at the base.
Therefore, trimming the top
and bottom margins does more than just make the painting physically
smaller. It likely cuts away peripheral details
and alters the exact proportions
originally intended by the artist.
Even though the core subject remains recognizable,
viewers today can never truly know what has been lost.
This theme boasts a very long historical tradition.
According to Buddhist lore,
the Buddha passed away between two sal trees
lying on his right side as all creatures came to bid him farewell.
In Japan, paintings of the Parinirvana, known as Nehanzu,
are traditionally displayed
in temples during memorial services held in mid-February.
The inclusion of the white elephant and Queen Maya
also carries deep symbolic meaning.
Tradition holds that Maya dreamed of a white elephant entering her side
before conceiving Prince Siddhartha.
She passed away just days after his birth,
and was believed to have been reborn into the heavens,
which is why she is frequently depicted floating
on clouds during farewell scenes.
Another important historical backdrop is worth noting.
During the early years of the Meiji period,
an anti-Buddhist movement and the separation of Shinto from Buddhism
caused many temples to lose their assets, flooding the market with art
and giving foreign residents in Japan an opportunity to buy them.
This remains purely contextual, however,
as there is no direct proof linking this
specific scroll to those events.
The exact origin of the scroll itself remains entirely open.
The family legend of a relative acquiring it
in Japan is merely oral history,
and has not been independently verified. Furthermore,
the expert does not explain why the scroll was cut down
or when that alteration took place.
A sacred Buddhist scroll, a family whose journey spanned two countries,
and a question passed down through generations.
Japanese or Chinese? The expert is about to reveal
the answer, along with the market value of an incomplete scroll.
So 18th century Japanese,
it's a Kakemono ink and color on paper,
and at auction is worth about $12,000 to $18,000.
Okay, it's nice to know if it had been in its full size
It would have been worth as much as thirty
to fifty thousand dollars in the current market. Okay