Responsibility to the Poor
In reference to talking about government's role in a free society, you mentioned some of the
market failures, and I think that you may have just passed over one that is of utmost importance,
and that is of poverty. And in prefacing my question, I'd like to refer to what President
Kennedy said, that if a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few
who are rich. And to say that, well, we are a government of the people, and when there is a
large sector of the people who are hurting, perhaps it is the responsibility of this government, of
the people to help out. My question is regarding how free are the poor, how free are the unemployed,
and how free are those people who are disadvantaged? And so in reference to that,
what is government's role? I'm glad to see one vote for the poor.
First of all, the government doesn't have any responsibility. People have responsibility.
This building doesn't have responsibility. You and I have responsibility. People have responsibility.
Secondly, the question is how can we as people exercise our responsibility toward our fellow
man most effectively? That's the problem. So far as poverty is concerned, there has never in history
been a more effective machine for eliminating poverty than the free enterprise system and the
free market. The period in which you had the greatest improvement in a lot of the
ordinary man was a period of the 19th and early 20th century. Those of us in this room
are the heirs of that. We benefited from the way in which our parents and our grandparents were
able to come here, and by virtue of the freedom that was offered to them, were able to make a
better life for themselves and them and us. But next, if you look at the real problems of
poverty and denial of freedom to people in this country, almost every single one of them is a
result of government action and would be eliminated if you eliminated the bad government failures.
Let me be precise and specific. Why do we have so high an unemployment rate among black teenagers?
It's a disgrace and a scandal. Why do we have so high an unemployment rate? First of all,
because we give them lousy schooling through governmental schools which make them unqualified
to hold decent jobs. And second of all, we require employers to discriminate against them
by not hiring them unless their productivity is enough to justify a minimum wage.
The minimum wage rate is the most anti-Negro law on the books, and it's an anti-Negro law
because it precisely, having first not enabled the young blacks to have a decent schooling so
that they can have productivity, we next deny them the honor to job training that they
might get if you can induce employers by being able to hire them for relatively low wages
to give them on-the-job training that would make them qualify for higher payment and higher
productivity. In the third place, we have constructed a governmental welfare scheme
which has been a machine for producing poor people. We have induced people to come under
control of welfare. I'm not blaming the people. Don't misunderstand me. It's our fault
for constructing so perverse and so ill-shaped a monster as the whole set of welfare programs
we have under which we encourage families to break up, we encourage people to move from one
part of the country and come to another, under which we have in effect made many people poor.
And yet when all this is said and done, have I ever been weird?
I have sir, of course, of course, more so than most of the people in this room.
How many of you have worked a 12-hour day and gotten paid 78 cents?
But let me go back to the, because, but you know that's all irrelevant. Is there one of you who
is going to say that you don't want a doctor to treat you for cancer unless he himself has had
cancer? I could go down the line. But when all is said and done, while there are people in this
country who are worse off than other people, by and large, even the poorest people in this
country are relatively well off compared to the conditions in many other countries in the world.
What we take as our standard of poverty is above the average income of all of the people in the
Soviet Union, let alone of the people in India or China or in other countries. Now that doesn't mean
we should be satisfied with it. We are a wealthier country and we've been more productive, and we
should set higher standards by ourselves. But by the same token we ought to have a sense of
proportion, and we ought to recognize both the source and the problem.

