Milton Friedman, August 16, 2002
The home of Rose and Milton Friedman here in San Francisco, and it is August 16th, Friday in the morning.
Do I have that right?
Yes.
And Milton's going to begin by telling us about how he got to the Bureau and how he got to the Bureau from going to Columbia.
And so why don't you begin wherever in the 30s you want to begin.
No, I really got to the Bureau, I'm sure, by virtue of the undergraduate, my undergraduate in Rutgers, because Arthur Burns was one of my teachers at Rutgers.
Right.
And so it was through Arthur Burns that my connection with the Bureau developed.
And then I went to Columbia, but that really had, the only thing that happened at Columbia was that, of course, I took a course from Wesley Mitchell.
And so I got to know Wesley Mitchell, and Wesley Mitchell got to know me a little.
But beyond that, the, but then I went to Washington.
I worked in Washington in the New Deal at the National Resources Committee.
And at about this time, Simon Cousins had gotten involved with, had been involved in estimating the national income.
And as part of his work on national income, he had collected a bunch of data, a bunch of questionnaires from independent professionals as part of his work of getting the data for national income.
But he thought those data required an additional analysis.
He started on that analysis, but he got tied up and got too busy.
And he wanted to hire somebody to help him.
And I think Arthur Burns suggested me to him.
And that's how, and so Simon, I don't remember the details anymore.
Right.
But he offered me a job as an assistant to him at the Bureau.
And so that's how I got to the Bureau.
You mentioned something in Two Lucky People about the Conference on Research and Income and Wealth.
That was one of my assignments at the time.
The main purpose for which Simon hired me was to work on professional income.
And we did complete, ultimately, the book on income from independent professional income.
Now, as you know, that book was the source of a great deal of controversy.
But going back to what you're saying,
a secondary duty was that at the time Simon was organizing the Conference on Research and Wealth and Income,
which was bringing together the various people who were getting involved in this very rapidly growing field of estimates of wealth and national income.
And so I served as secretary or something of the...
Right.
My main function was to edit the proceedings of the successive meetings.
Your role on it began when you were on the NRC.
Yes, I was on the National Research...
Well, my role on it in that sense, if I remember rightly, I attended one meeting.
I attended a meeting as a representative from the NRC because the NRC also was producing material that was relevant to the national income estimate.
Was that the first time you met Simon?
I believe so.
I don't guarantee that, but I think it was the first time I met him.
Okay. And then Arthur comes to you and suggests that you work...
Well, Arthur, I think, suggested to Simon.
Right.
And Simon got in touch with me and offered me the job.
Right. And then that was September of 37, when you went to the Bureau to work with Simon or something like that?
You're better off than I am.
The data's in the book.
Right.
And I'm sure that's about right.
Right. And...
And then, as I say, we started analyzing the data that he had gotten from the professional incomes.
In the course of a year or so, I wrote a bulletin about it.
And ultimately, I used this as my dissertation, my PhD dissertation.
Now, so far as the Conference on Income and Wealth was concerned, I think it played a very important role at that time,
and has ever since, in the business of the various estimates of national income.
I was involved with it for the first... I think I edited the first three volumes of the...
And they say later on that they're the only ones that came out in the same year in which the conference was held.
Well, that certainly would be... It sounds reasonable.
A lot longer now.
Yeah.
And that was an education for me, I must say, because it exposed me to a range of issues and problems
that I would not otherwise have had any connection with.
Right.
But it was not a field that appealed to me, particularly, as anything of any interest for my own work.
And then in between doing that, of course, your main job was working on these data with Simon.
Right.
Yeah, it was a full-time job. This was a very large collection of data.
There were a lot of data, and there were many interesting problems, both statistical and economic.
Right.
And it was a field in which very little had ever been done.
Right.
Essentially, the whole problem was one of human capital, as you realize.
Simon had written a kind of a draft, an initial draft, before I got on it,
which consisted mostly simply of, as I remember it, and very little analysis.
Mostly it was a statistical summary of the relevant material.
And that was mainly to fit it into national income accounting, to fill in for this big hole in income from independent professional practices.
The data were collected for that reason.
Right.
That is, you had figures for almost everything else, but there was no real source of figures for independent professionals.
And so, as part of his project at the Department of Commerce, Simon had arranged for a survey,
to collect a sample survey of the independent professionals.
Right.
And he had used it to make the estimate in what was involved.
And that was what, essentially, I started with, if I remember rightly.
Do you remember how it transformed from measuring the incomes of independent professional practitioners
to fill a national income account to a sort of modern human capital analysis of,
you know, are these equalizing differences, why professionals earn more than other workers,
as opposed to sort of rents and the role of the AMA, which clearly is what it's remembered for now.
Well, I think, I remember my background was largely economic theory.
It was statistics as well.
But the main reason I had really gotten involved in statistics was because that's where jobs were.
But my basic interest was in economic theory.
And I had studied at Chicago before I had gone to Columbia,
and before I had gone to the National Resources Committee, and before I had gone to the Bureau.
And so, it seems to me it was very natural, as a student in Marshall,
as someone who was interested in theoretical issues, to raise the human capital question.
That was a question that was obvious.
And I have no, I have no idea, I have no recollection of anything other than that kind of a,
because I don't believe, yeah, I think that seems, I think it just came out of the prior interest in theory.
But it was a very, it did, I realized at the time that it was,
both Simon and I realized at the time that it was not exactly a widely used approach at the time.
And of course, Simon's interest, it was clear that Simon had an interest in distribution, and this would fit in.
Yeah, the other thing, that's what, see, one of the other things I was involved in at the Bureau
was the study in Delaware, the state of Delaware.
This is using the tax records from Delaware to look at distribution.
Pierre DuDupont was tax commissioner for the state of Delaware,
and he had money of his own that he was willing to spend over and above what the state provided.
And he decided that the only way he could get a satisfactory income tax
was by requiring everyone to file, whether they were subject to tax or not.
And he paid the extra costs of that out of his own pocket, as I remember it.
And so that was a body of data which had no counterpart in the rest of the country.
And I've forgotten who was, there was some, somehow there was a group in Delaware.
I used to go down about once a month or something.
That was very important because it was during the war, and I was able to bring back,
or it was before the war, but just before the war,
and I was able to bring back for Rose nylon stockings, which were available only in Delaware.
DuPont.
They were very precious at that time, though today, as she would tell you,
they were very thick compared to the stockings you get today.
And yeah, Simon was very much interested in the subject of income distribution,
and the Delaware project was one project directed at that.
There was also a project in Wisconsin using the Wisconsin tax returns,
and again, that was part of the attempt to get data on the distribution of income.
All right.
Do we have any other questions on Simon?
I guess, you know, the issue is clearly there was controversy developed in this book
over the conclusions concerning physicians, medical practitioners versus dentists,
and I understand there were many years it took for the publication to come out because of disinformation.
Oh, yes. It was delayed about what?
I think it was completed.
Let me see if I've got this right.
I think it was completed. The book was essentially completed, I think, by 1940, early 40.
It comes out in 45.
And that delay was entirely due to this problem.
Now, I no longer remember exactly the same, but it's described in detail in our book,
so I don't really think that.
Right.
And, you know, Simon, I don't want to let this go without expressing my admiration for Simon.
He was, you know, it would have been very easy for him to have taken the position that,
well, we don't want any trouble with this, let's get rid of this gentleman, but he didn't.
He was completely supportive.
You see, I was responsible for this junk, of course.
Right.
But Simon's position was always one of being supportive and of going as far as he possibly could
to make sure that we weren't prevented from saying what we thought was right.
And Mitchell also was very supportive.
Right.
I mean, this was just...
I think it's a very unusual episode in a way, because under those circumstances,
you know, I was very naive at the time, but after a long experience since then,
the temptation is always to compromise, to give in.
Right.
I mean, it's a wide group of directors.
In part, this policy is a good policy in saying that books will be reviewed by everybody
and anybody has the right to dissent.
Right.
But because the people on the board are representing different groups, they're advocates,
then it's not all scholarly, and then there could be a problem, as in this case.
As in this case.
Right.
Well, you've been going over this, I'm curious.
Have there been many more cases of that kind?
I think the monetary history and...
But the monetary history had an odd one, and I reread that dissent,
and it's almost a real chuckle, because the person has great admiration
and respect for what you and Anna wrote, and somehow he wanted to dissent
and it wasn't clear exactly what the dissent was.
I don't remember any other.
There are some other dissents.
Yeah, but certainly not in the past 20-something years,
while there still are board members representing different constituencies,
they aren't very active.
Technically, still any bureau book has to be approved by the board of directors
by no memory of anything being held up at that level.
Why?
I mean, why should there be a difference?
You would think the AFL-CIO has a representative,
they would have an interest in potentially things that come out on trade positions,
for example, very different than that.
I think it's possibly the professionalization of the field
that then separated it from people who are advocates and representing various groups.
But the members of the board are still advocates.
That's right, but I think that they give in, in some sense,
to the scholars and the academics and the professionals,
and they'll distance themselves and say,
well, I don't really know that much about this.
But why didn't they do that earlier?
That's right.
The question is what outlets, because now those same groups,
when they're not on the board of directors,
have their organizations in Washington that go to the press
and release reports on all these different issues,
but they don't seem to view this as the arena for playing out that,
in a way they apparently did at the time.
Of course, the bureau has become so much larger.
There are many more publications per year.
I think it may also be that this was still in the period
when the bureau served an extremely important role
that was in between the world of academics and the world of government,
which it does not play now.
And so therefore this became a huge contested area.
And what the bureau said, what the bureau did,
was far more important.
That may be why.
Maybe.
And so therefore what you were saying,
the bureau put its imprimatur on this,
and therefore the people on the board of directors said,
do we want this to be viewed as the opinion of the bureau?
And now all of our books say that, they have a disclaimer,
that in fact the bureau has nothing to do with this.
And I don't know when that was added, but maybe that's part of it.
I think it's an important part of the history, though.
Right.
Do you have anything that you want to say,
apart from what you've said elsewhere,
about the relationship between independent professional practice
and the theory of the consumption function
that you view your work with Simon as being quite pivotal
in your work that came after on the consumption function?
Oh, yes, I think so, sure.
I think the income from professional practice was very important in the future.
Certainly the consumption function is derived almost entirely from it.
The whole notion of permanent income versus transitory income
comes from the professional income study.
Now, but I think that's inevitable.
You take any scholar, and his work is going to be cumulative.
What you did in your first study undoubtedly influenced what you did in your next,
and it's been influencing what you're doing now, one way or another.
Now, what's interesting about this, perhaps,
the role of the Bureau in my own case is much more important in a different way.
It's a main reason why I ended up spending most of my time and money.
See, if you go back, professional income wasn't about money.
I started out as a pure price theorist in Jacob Mintzer's terms,
and then I went on to consumption function.
It had nothing to do with money.
Now, I'm not sure.
The Bureau was not solely responsible for my interest in money, of course,
because I wrote about it when I got interested in that largely
as a result of being at the Treasury during the war and being concerned with inflation.
And so I wrote my first pieces in the field of money
during that period before I got involved in the Bureau.
But then it was the request by Arthur that I undertake the money project for the Bureau
that was responsible for my devoting so much attention over the next 30 years or so to the field of money.
And so that's certainly the main way in which the Bureau influenced me.
All right. Let's get into that.
So Arthur came to you, and it must have been around 1949, do you remember?
A little bit earlier than that, I would say.
And said to you that the Bureau wanted to do, in its usual way,
including money in the grand scheme of business cycles.
That's right.
But was it also that Arthur and Mitchell, in their own work,
had realized in their empirical work that every single major downturn
was accompanied by banking distress, enormous banking distress?
Was part of it that?
Well, if you go back to Mitchell's initial business cycle volume, the 1913 volume,
that, of course, stressed the role of banks in money.
After all, business cycle theory, going back to Hume,
was really very heavily centered on banks and money.
So all along, the plan, Mitchell's plan, starting from his 1913 volume,
and essentially then his 1926 business cycle, his second book,
which was not much of a book.
The first book was a real book.
His idea was to develop each chapter of it, each section of it.
So he had, as you know, more volume estimates on inventories
and thread mills on prices and so on.
And one of the missing elements was money,
and in view of my own interest in money.
See, as I say, I developed an interest in money
as a result of my work at the Treasury.
Arthur asked me if I would be willing to take over the money chapter
of the contemplated book.
You said take over because Angel had been working on it?
I really don't remember.
Anna said that she had begun it.
She had.
She had begun this work in 1941 with Jim Angel.
She had done...
You had taken a course from her at Columbia in trade.
And she and Angel worked on it, and of course she was the person
who was collecting the data, collecting it in the, as she said,
in the bureau tradition that monthly was what you had to do.
Everything had to be monthly.
And she had a set of series that she was supposed to collect,
and she would work in her little cubbyhole up at Columbia on this work,
and she was a paid employee of the bureau, not a research fellow,
not a research assistant as you had become.
And she labored at this, and then Angel wasn't that interested in it
and left the project.
She never, she didn't say exactly how much she had done,
but she had worked for a very long time.
But in addition, she had worked with Gayer and...
Of course, on the other project.
That's right.
Right, and that's what gave her a sense of what you had to do
to do it in the bureau business cycle fashion.
And then you're right to bring that up, of course.
When Arthur came to me, he told me that Anna had been doing work
and essentially offered me to have the services of Anna
and to start from her work.
So she was an essential element in the,
she was, in a way, the bureau's contribution to me.
Absolutely.
And in many ways, vice versa, because, as you must know from Anna,
her view of economics was never the same after the two of you met.
Well, I suppose that's so.
In many ways, this was...
No, it was a very good collaboration, there's no question.
We complemented one another.
I really never would have had the patience to go through
the accumulation of all the data, which Anna has.
She's a real economic historian, which I am not.
And on the other hand, I think I complemented her
in terms of the theoretical aspects of the subject.
So it was a very good collaboration, and we worked together for, what,
25 years or so, or 40, well, from 1948 or so to 1985, about.
That's pretty good.
As I say, it was a very good collaboration.
We never had any fights, never had any argument.
Right.
I don't mean to say we didn't have any differences of opinion,
but we never had any personal arguments.
But as Anna said, if you had any differences of opinion,
they would have been expressed in writing.
That's right.
Because you did...
We were in two different places.
You were in two different places, and telephone calls were somewhat expensive.
That's right.
No, but you know, it's interesting.
One thing that interests me, currently,
is the extent to which there is multiple authorship.
Apparently, nobody ever publishes anything on his own.
Few people, yes.
Very few, very few.
Why?
Why is that now?
Now, I mention that because I think collaboration can be very useful at a distance.
But also, it seems to me as being much overdone.
I can't believe that these three-, four-, five-person papers make any sense.
How do you explain that?
Is that simply because more people want to have longer...?
Well, I think that one has to ask
whether the quality of the papers is very good
and whether people are putting out papers
because they feel that this is part of the sort of grand game and grand scheme,
and therefore, they're sort of going down the marginal benefit curve,
and so they're hitting it much too low now.
And people are getting more than one-fifth the credit
if they're writing with five people.
It's one possibility.
Gee, I would think that when I look at somebody's vita,
I look for the papers they've written by themselves.
Right.
They're the only ones you can really judge by.
Right, and we spend a lot of time in meetings
trying to figure out what this person's contribution was,
and by golly, if you want to support the person,
you take all the four authored papers and you give them full credit for it.
And in another meeting in another city,
author number two is being given 100% of the credit,
so if you add it up, there's 400%.
Well, I think two authored papers are still more.
Sort of the norm has gone from one to two.
There are a lot of four and three.
We do a fair amount together,
and our meeting, somewhat like your meeting with Anna,
was a sense of an Edgeworth box and gains from trade appearing,
and that's the way I view my work with Larry.
I don't view these four authored, three authored, five authored papers
often as having very much additional benefit.
It's often that author one published a piece on X
and author two on Y, and now we have X plus Y,
and we've gained nothing.
Let's talk about when you first met Anna
and what you talked about.
Perhaps I know that we can't reproduce that moment,
but the vision that the two of you had.
Do you remember anything about the first meeting or the early meetings?
You went to New York, I think, right?
I think so, yes.
I think, again, if anybody is really seriously interested in that,
it's all documented in the letters and papers that I exchanged with one another
because it was mostly done by correspondence rather than in person.
I think I may have made one trip or one or more trips to New York.
I certainly, as of that time, would have been going to New York on and off.
And, of course, whenever I was in New York, I spent some time with Anna.
But my memory isn't good enough to answer your question.
Right, right.
But let's talk about ideas.
The vision that Anna had for the project at first
wasn't necessarily her vision.
It was what the Bureau was going to do,
what Jim Angel, what Arthur had wanted,
what Wesley, Claire Mitchell had wanted years before.
But when you stepped in,
when did you suddenly see what the vision was,
what the project was going to be?
I don't know.
Because it certainly changed in various ways.
Sure, it changed.
But the change had nothing to do with money.
Right.
It had to do with the fact of a theoretical approach
as opposed to an empirical approach.
Right.
And the fact was that Mitchell's approach...
See, Mitchell was not really a theorist.
No.
I listened to...
In the year I spent at Columbia as a student,
when I graduated from Columbia,
I attended Mitchell's course in business cycles.
And I thought it was kind of a dull course
because there was no theory in it.
There was no...
It was really all empirical, pure empiricism.
And so any subject...
My natural tendency was to approach any subject,
whether it was consumption or professional income,
from a point of view of economic theory.
And similarly, if I'm going to deal with money,
I want to look at what is the demand curve,
what's the supply curve,
how do they interact, etc.
That's what naturally occurs to anybody of a theoretical bent.
Now, I always felt then, and I feel now,
that the Bureau's great virtue
is to combine the emphasis on the empirical side
with a theoretical approach.
See, if we go back to the early days when I was involved there,
I didn't have much use for the work that Fred Mills did
because I thought it was almost wholly empirical
and didn't really have any theoretical understanding.
So I don't know that there was any grand plan at all.
We just started out to...
Well, one thing that influenced us very much to begin with,
as I'm sure I've described it in The Two Lucky People,
is going down to Princeton and talking to...
Oh, what's the matter with me?
Was that where Walter Stewart was?
Walter Stewart.
Yes.
Talking to Walter Stewart.
He was a very wise fellow
and had a great deal of experience,
had been, as you know, at the Bank of England
and also at the Federal Reserve Bank.
And the original understanding
was that we were going to do a statistical analysis.
And he really persuaded us
that we needed to precede it by doing a history.
And it was really Walter Stewart
who was responsible for getting us to go on the historical side.
And...
Well, I really don't...
If we were going to do this seriously,
the thing to do would be to go back to the papers
that Anne and I exchanged at that time.
I think they were all down at the Hoover in the archives.
And I hesitate to try to reconstruct now.
That's okay because I think that
my dear friend Hugh Rockoff would love to do that.
And will do that.
Yeah.
Because this is one of the questions...
Hugh Rockoff.
Oh, Hugh Rockoff, sure.
You remember Hugh who was...
Sure, oh yeah, he was at Rutgers.
Exactly.
Is he still at Rutgers?
He still is at Rutgers.
They have a very good group of economic historians
who do financial and banking history.
Three of them.
Well, Rockoff, Mike Bordeaux.
And Gene White.
So it's a very, very good group.
I've kept in touch on and off with Mike Bordeaux.
Much less with the others.
Right.
So Walter Stewart suggests to you that the book half,
what you and he must have called a narrative,
a historical narrative.
And I believe that that date,
from what you've written about it,
was in about 1953 that you spoke to Walter Stewart.
Maybe a little bit earlier.
I don't remember.
Yeah.
I think in the acknowledgments to a monetary history,
you begin the acknowledgments with
a bit more than a decade ago
that Walter Stewart expressed to one of us,
and I didn't know which one.
It was obviously you,
that we add a narrative.
And you said,
we had written several chapters.
I think you had almost completed the entire
core of the volume
without the narrative.
And then he said,
add a narrative.
And you added a narrative to one chapter.
And then it looked good
and you added a narrative to another chapter
and to another chapter
until it developed into the book that it is.
Well, let me see.
That would have been 63.
So that's right.
The acknowledgment was written in 63,
so this would have put it in about 51, 52.
So it was fairly soon after you stepped into the project.
Yeah, it was very soon after.
So, of course, Anna,
you stepped into the project
and Anna probably...
But Anna already had a lot of data.
Already had all the data.
Oh, yeah.
Well, not all the data,
but she had a lot of data.
Right.
She had done the major data work before that.
Right.
And could show you various aspects of them.
You could make sense out of it.
You could put it into more of a theoretical model.
And the book began to gain shape and take form.
But let's talk a little bit about this narrative
because as an economic historian,
it is a superb and important book in history.
And it must be hard for one to say
at some point you realized
that you were writing a great book of history.
Oh, no.
No.
Oh, no.
Of course not.
You never do that.
No.
You don't ever think of your own work in those terms.
No.
You're just doing your...
Right.
You're doing what seems right.
But you must have switched on in your mind
a different mode of writing.
For example, in the Great Contraction volume,
which became a volume,
part of it is brilliantly written.
It's compellingly written.
Did you have that sense?
It's written in a very different way
than the drier Bureau books
and even your own work
that you've done for the Bureau was written.
Some of it is great writing.
Did you have a sense that you were writing
an important, compelling narrative?
No.
Oh, hold on.
Yes.
There's no doubt I had the feeling
that the narrative was important.
Not that the writing was important.
Yes.
But that the narrative was important.
I had no doubt whatsoever
that the point we were making
was an enormously important point
and that it had major implications
for economic and monetary policy.
It was certainly clear to me at the time
that the bulk of the profession
regarded the Great Depression
as having very little to do
with being a failure of the business system
and that the thesis
that it was a failure of the government
and of the monetary system
was against the grain
of what was taken to be
orthodox standard value.
So that I understood completely.
There's no question.
But it wasn't the narrative.
It was the events.
Right.
The story that was important.
Right.
Well, I suppose sometimes
when the story is important
you write from some other part of your brain
that makes it a very compelling writing as well.
Well, Ann and I, more or less,
we have no record of who wrote which.
That's interesting.
How did going back to your times at Chicago
before you went to Columbia,
can you tell me how your courses
and studies with Mintz and Simons
influenced the monetary history?
I never took any course with Simons.
I knew him.
I got to know him personally
and I read what he wrote
and undoubtedly listened to him in lectures.
But I never formally took any courses with him.
But there's no doubt.
And I would say that Viner as much as Mintz,
even though I took a course from Viner
in international economics
and a course from Mintz in money.
And both of them, of course,
were quantity theorists.
And both of them emphasized the role of money.
And so undoubtedly,
my basic theoretical understanding
owed a great deal to both Viner and Mintz.
And so it influenced monetary history
primarily by providing the theoretical background,
the theoretical framework,
in terms of which we tried to analyze the problem.
That is, after all,
the whole structure of the book
is one of supply versus demand.
Right.
And the statistical core of it
is the data on the supply of money, fundamentally.
Right.
Using that as looking at money demand,
Yeah.
Is there, I know,
you'd worked as a research assistant for Schultz,
Schultz on estimating demand,
sort of functions of that.
Is that part of the intellectual heritage
of thinking of then the sort of empirical work there?
Or was that a sort of,
did you make any connections between?
Well, I suppose it had some connection.
I have to admit that I'm not very much given to introspection.
But I suppose it had some connection.
But it really didn't, in a way,
because it all goes back simply, you know,
what really opened my mind
was the one quarter of pure economic theory
which I took with Jacob Viner.
And that was really the real eye-opener
that gave you a different framework
in which to see things.
It's like what you described of Jacob Mintz.
You suddenly see a light.
And I think Viner's course
opened up that light in my mind.
And that applies to everything, money, anything else.
All really the same principles.
Right.
Anna has told me
that she views a monetary history,
one of the key aspects of it,
is that it pioneered the role of money
in the real economy.
Others, and I believe you're on record for saying this,
say that it expanded that view,
but it didn't pioneer it.
Can you comment a bit on
this slight difference of opinion?
Well, you can go back to David Hume
and his famous essay
in which he clearly indicates
the effect of money on the real economy.
When he talks about the fact that
what's necessary is that
it be a slow and steady increase.
And that at first,
essentially he has a modern analysis of it.
So it's hard to say that anything that was written in 1960
or 1950 would have pioneered the idea
of money having a role in the real economy.
On the other hand, what is true
is that that way of looking at things
had gone out of fashion.
Right.
And so this was a reminder and a repeat of it.
But it surely did not pioneer it.
Right.
But I don't know.
You know, when you're writing something,
you're not thinking in those terms.
When you're writing something,
you're writing something.
And that problem, no.
I just saw your piece in the JPE.
What?
On the telephone.
Yeah.
And now,
before you sat down to write that,
did you think about what anybody else,
what the current state of thinking was about
or whether you were pioneering something or anything?
No.
You just had a problem and you went
and you tried to solve the problem.
So I really don't have anything to say about that.
Right.
One other thing about the use of history.
When you began to restructure the volume with history,
did history, did the,
and someone, you and Anna both,
sat down and read an enormous amount of,
mainly secondary literature.
Some of the greats.
Some material that you later found lacking.
Some material that you had to accept
because you weren't going to go back
to the primary sources.
Did the historical work,
what we'll call the historical narrative,
change what you were doing in any way?
Did it turn on lights?
Did you see something that was different?
Can you remember any of the episodes historically
in which it had any grand effect
or was it to sort of make it more interesting?
I find it very hard to answer that question.
Okay.
Because once we got started on the line
of making it a narrative,
everything developed together
as you came to the episodes
and tried to understand them.
I really don't know how to answer you.
That's too hard a question.
Right.
It must have been enormous fun
reading all these secondary sources.
Yes, sure it was.
Sure.
Anna did most of the historical work.
Uh-huh.
I read what she told me to read.
But she did a much broader reading than I did.
Well, it's always very good
to have an extraordinarily good research assistant
or colleague who will read everything
and then say, this is what's important.
Absolutely.
And then you go out and you look at it
and then it turns lights on for you
and that's extremely good.
Well, she was a collaborator and a colleague,
not a research assistant.
Absolutely.
That's why I was thinking of my own research assistant.
No, no, that's right.
I remember in one state,
Phil Kagan was my research assistant
and he did exactly what you've described.
I had him read a whole lot of stuff
and tell me what I had to read.
Right, right.
Do you have any questions?
Yes, I have one.
If I think of the three major projects
you did with the Bureau,
income from independent professional practice,
theory of the consumption function,
and monetary history,
they all seem to have a style
of a strong analytic theoretical framework
organizing them.
But then rather than going out
and getting one body of data
and doing a specific type test of the theory,
I would say there's a collage of evidence
of a wide range of implications of the theory,
looking at whether it's budget studies
and time series size consumption function,
cutting the data different ways,
income from professional practice,
looking historically as well as
contemporary monetary history.
Do you have, I mean,
much of empirical research recently
has become very narrow on a specific test.
I've always been very skeptical
of narrowly based tests
because of the fact that
statistical tests of significance
are really of limited use
because they're always the best of so many.
And if you massage one body of data,
you can always get some good statistical result.
But it's useless.
And so I've always tried,
I've always had the preference
for trying to see if you can get
a broad range of material,
try to get different countries
or try to get different periods of time
or something else,
but don't depend on any single analysis.
It's good to have the statistical analysis,
but it's a very, very shaky basis
on which to stand.
So I think what you're describing
has always been sort of part of my modus operandi.
A good lesson for economics today.
Many of these four author papers
are on very narrow questions.
I know. I think so much of today's,
I find I can't read most of what comes out today
because it's so narrow
and so much of a detailed,
over analysis, over statistical analysis.
I've always, I've thought that the journals today
are making a great mistake.
They ought to insist on relegating
more of the mathematics to the appendix
and having more of English in the article.
And then they would see that
they didn't have much of an article
and then they would demand more.
Yes.
Then they would have thinner journals.
Yes.
Right.
But they have actually,
the number of articles has not increased
in a typical journal,
but the number of pages per article has gone up
despite the fact that they seem to be more narrow.
Right.
Just in conclusion,
you said in your book with Rose
that the Bureau opened a new world for me.
And you said some wonderful things about the Bureau,
about the attitude towards research,
about the fact that,
and you said it was a role,
it was one that was to play a large role
in shaping the rest of my academic life.
That's a very strong and very complimentary statement.
Well, but surely the fact that
these monetary studies that I did,
the professional income and consumption functions
were relatively limited in both size and duration.
But after all,
I spent something over two or three decades
on a monetary study.
And had it not been for the Bureau,
I would not have been doing them.
And had it not been for the Bureau,
I would not have had the collaboration of Anna.
So it's clear that it did play a very important role
in my academic life.
Right.
And it all begins with your undergraduate days at Rutgers.
That what?
It all begins with your undergraduate days at Rutgers.
With Arthur Burns.
With Arthur Burns,
whom you greatly admired as a teacher.
He was a splendid teacher.
Arthur, that's a very difficult subject.
Yes.
But Arthur was a great teacher.
And certainly one of the major educational experiences
that I had was the seminar
in which there were two or three people,
two of us, I think only two of us,
going over Arthur's doctor's dissertation.
Yes.
On production trends.
And that was a real education.
But as you know, the problem is
that I got into some difficulty with Arthur
when he was in Washington.
Right.
Over his support of price control.
Right.
One last thing.
But you know, I don't know,
did you know Arthur at all?
I met Arthur on one or two occasions that I remember.
I didn't know Arthur so much as an academic and scholar
as I did as someone who would deliver comments at conferences
when he was, you know,
was probably in the early 1980s.
Because Arthur was really,
he was an excellent teacher.
And he was a first-rate economist in every respect.
His book, Production Trends,
was an important book.
Measuring Business Cycles
was an important book.
Though it was subject to criticism
as not having enough theory in it.
Right.
But Arthur himself, interestingly enough,
was capable of theoretical analysis.
He was very much of an admirer of Marshall.
And I was first introduced to Marshall by Arthur.
But on the other hand,
he was in some ways more interested in the politics of the things
than he was in the economics of it.
That, I think, was...
He was not a good chairman of the Fed, unfortunately.
Right.
When he was appointed,
I wrote a column in Newsweek
saying the right person at the right place at the right time.
And I was just wrong.
Of course, you were close with Simon.
You were close with Arthur.
Do you have anything to say about their differences at the Bureau?
No, I observed their differences.
They really were not compatible personalities.
And they did differ a good deal.
I guess that's why Simon really left the Bureau on that account.
But I never got involved in their personal discussion.
I never...
But how would you summarize briefly
their differences, their very different personalities?
Do you think they were largely personal
or do you think they were also substantive
over what research direction the Bureau should be going?
I really don't know.
I don't think they were personal, though.
I think they were over what the Bureau should be doing.
Because...
Well, I shouldn't say that.
I really don't know.
I'm not very good at that kind of thing.
They didn't...
As you know, at the time I knew them,
Simon was living in Philadelphia
and Arthur, of course, was living in New York.
So there was not a great deal of personal contact.
Their contacts were mostly at the...
What's happening to Rose?
Excuse me.
Let me get that phone.
Very close to Arthur and Helen Burns
in a way that we were not.
We were close.
We were intimate.
We knew very well Simon and Edith.
But we didn't have the kind of contact with them
that we had with the Burns.
The Burns and we spent the summer up
in the same part of Vermont, New Hampshire,
every summer.
So we saw a lot of them.
And so...
I never observed very much
the personal interaction
between Arthur and Simon.
Right.
I think that the major break
came earlier in about 1947
when Simon wanted the Bureau
to go in a more comparative direction
and Arthur stayed more with
the original mission of the Bureau
which was the foundations of the U.S. economy.
But let me just conclude this
by thanking you enormously.
That's all right.
Glad to do it.
Pleasure to see you.
Okay. Thanks.

