Lecture 46 - Short Story and Novel III

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jan 10, 2025
[Music]
[Music]
good morning and welcome back to the
lecture series we are discussing short
story and novel so uh as a continuation
from our earlier discussion uh we see
that with a subjective understanding of
reality uh themes that become Central to
the modern story are alienation and
quest for identity this is actually uh a
symptom uh of the modern period and we
see the same reflection a similar
reflection in the jar of novel to right
uh at the heart of all artistic works
all writings there is the question of
existence finding one's own existence
and the core question remains who am I
so the main formal features of the
modern novel novela and the modern short
story are quite the same uh they uh
Center on different points of view so
the uh the polyglossia the the layer
texture of the artwork uh is rendered
through these multiple perspectives
multiple points of view then we have uh
emphas an emphasis uh on the inner
experience the Journey of the um the
journey on the inner the psychic Journey
uh which which uh remains uh more
complex than the outer world then uh we
have uh the quest for a transpersonal
knowledge of the world a knowledge that
transcends our personal bound something
that unifies a given Humanity a given
Society so transpersonal knowledge that
uh once again uh brings to the four the
transpersonal self and then uh both the
novel and the short story uh seek uh the
process of transformation transform
of several elements from uh the
traditional plot so we see how the
modern period uh embarks on revisiting
the the realist point of view the
naturalist representation for example um
and then uh using of uh too many
metaphors and metonymy uh in the place
of very similitude right and uh the
metaphors and metonymy go on to Define
and describe the events and characters
in the presentation of events and
characters uh metaphor allegory uh
symbols are sought rather than a uh
literal uh representation then we are
talking about a certain economy in form
and style uh in other words uh a
tightness uh is an apodictic uh message
uh a brevity a tightness in the entire
uh uh narration is is symptomatic of the
uh modern period modern and postmodern
writing and uh definitely there are
frequent uh artworks that experiment
with uh the movement of events in time
so there is an outright rejection and
undermining of the chronology iCal
sequencing of events uh so the
phenomenological focus on impressionism
draws on subjectivism there is no
absolute point of view earlier there
used to be one author and a single point
of view being imposed by the author or
directly by The narratorial Voice the
directly by The Narrative voice here we
uh with subjectivism with relativism
values become relative uh absolute order
is dismantled so the world is mediated
by our own experience of it and this
hearkens back what uh I have discussed a
few lectures back uh regarding uh Herman
Brock Herman Brock uh talking about uh
knowledge being mediated right uh so the
very nature of received knowledge a
direct received knowledge uh that is
uniform uh for for all people uh
regardless of their own specificities
own cultural uh own uh social
specificities is uh Vanishing it's uh
being flouted uh time and again so uh
knowledge of any truth I mean a received
knowledge which is definitive and final
uh becomes more and more problematic and
devious and so uh there is a absence of
knowledge of any form of truth
especially a truth with a capital t uh
this leads to the exploration of
multiple truths multiple points of view
so the lonely individuals are typical
subjects and they symptomatic of the
modern fiction both the short story and
the novel um the other uh quality of
feature that defines uh the modern short
story and novel is ellipses ellipses in
in modern short stories is very common
uh by Ellipsis we are referring to
passing over uh the dramatized Middle
episodes that would be uh earlier you
know uh reported extensively in
conventional uh plots uh and uh here in
uh lies the plot conflict right uh so
from that description where we have a
lot of uh strous elements uh we are
moving with modernism we are moving uh
to uh we are moving towards deployment
of minimalism uh so a lot of modern
Works begin in media race without uh any
introduction they begin in the middle
and then they uh never go back to fill
in the beginning and so the narration be
begins in the middle it moves towards
the later part and and and uh it ends
without leaving out um without
suggesting any kind of closure or or uh
uh giving any uh sense of resolution uh
so the plot remains open-ended this is
very much symptomatic of modern uh
writing so in the post second world war
America uh the development of the short
stories genre was uh coal with uh the
the uh fostering of little magazines
little magazines that were sponsored uh
by colleges and universities um some of
these uh little magazines are the
Virginia quarterly uh started first in
1925 we have the southern review in
1935 uh the Kenyan review in 1939 and so
forth all of these little magazines were
responsible for the growth of uh the new
critic school new criticism uh a
formalist movement in literary theory
that uh dominated the American literary
uh tradition in the mid 20th century new
criticism emphasizes close reading of a
text particularly of uh poetry in order
to discover how a work of literature
functions as a
self-contained self-referential athetic
object and the organization of a
literary work is on the inner the the
organization the meaning uh comes from
within and not from without not from uh
social cultural economic historical
categories not from the biography of the
author but uh you know meaning as new
critics would go on to see um meaning uh
emerges from the form itself uh the form
the stylistic devices um exude uh
meanings themselves they are meanings in
themselves um they can uh give us the
central uh message or or the central
essence of uh an artwork uh
so we see uh there are theorists such as
Robert pen Warren cleint Brooks
Katherine anip Porter uh who are
products of the new criticism School uh
we have examples such as Melville's uh
short story bleby uh which first
appeared in a magazine called Putnams
which uh appealed to a small readership
that was intellectual and that was
politically uh liberal and uh we see
that little magazine plays um a a very
important vital role in uh shaping the
taste of the intelligencia so for
example with Melville's ble there is a
moving away from the sentimental
rhetoric now the nature of the
relationship between uh novel and short
story has changed over the time whereas
the 18th century short story uh would
consistently treat the same subject as
uh that of the novel uh the modern short
story uh TR you know has a trend to
divert from the novels uh 1960s onward
and uh we see that novel is adopting
elements of travelog for example
reporting whereas the short story
remains a pure fictional tale now having
said that uh uh this this is an
understanding I I must uh put in
parenthesis uh as an afterthought or as
an addition that this is however the
view of a few critics uh we do see
experimentations in short story form as
well so just like a novel is bringing in
elements of essay of film of uh of of
painting uh we see similar influences of
uh other artworks in short story as well
so it is or other forms of writing other
uh you know uh creative works also speak
to short story so it's not uh uh always
true that short story uh remains a pure
fictional tale only drawing on myths and
fables um now in Europe the rise of the
short story is intertwined with the
emergence of the figure of the modern
artist uh and uh it is coal with a anti
victorianism in its widest sense so
while America has historically
championed the short story story and
Branda Matthews uh claims that the
Native American novel has come into
being uh through uh its uh you know
through drawing inspiration from short
story uh in the late 19 century Britain
the lack of short story writers was uh
chiefly because of this looming
supremacy of the Victorian novel so
Thomas Le uh says that ch story is a
form had an impact on American Authors
uh uh to an extent that many American
novels uh assume the form of story
novels novels went on to become went on
to metamor force into a new form uh
drawing largely on short stories and and
becoming uh thereby story novels so the
story novels we see the short story
culture uh the short story culture
caught on England as a result of um the
the three deer or the multivolume
serialized fiction uh being compressed
uh
into and sometimes displaced by the one
volume novel so uh the treatment of time
the concept of time changes people uh
are uh leading a more hectic life they
uh find it fre quently difficult to read
a longer artwork so keeping in mind the
Horizon of expectations also the the
form of the artwork is compressed right
uh through this process of compression
uh there is a demand for there is a
looking for brav the Aesthetics of short
stories a genre attracts the interests
of critics and narrative theorists from
the from the 20th C Century uh so we
have formalists such as Boris Akin bom
we have Victor schlowsky we have
structuralists such as Vladimir prop and
uh structural uh anthropologists such as
Claud listos right um Frank okon States
the short story never had a hero as such
uh short story rather deals with and uh
centers on pivots on the lonely voice of
the outlawed figures and hence the
protagonists are uh frequently parts of
a submerged or a marginalized population
in the line of uh okon uh Mary leis
Pratt would also say that a short story
can be best linked with regional gender
and political marginalization with
people that are plagued with a sense of
Exile and existential isolation
and the form Finds Its voice in emerging
National literatures and in the process
of uh
decolonization uh clar Hansen uh says
Clare Hansen says that the form
expresses the repressed knowledge of a
dominant culture so knowledge that is
not part of the mainstream a knowledge
that is uh not uh uh talked about too
much in the society
uh that does not belong to the opulent
to uh the the uh the powerful uh
comprises the body the the the content
of the short story to a great extent so
generic considerations generic
considerations of the short story focus
on its uh split allegiances to the
narrative and the L uh the the lyric so
we have uh in parts and El of Novel as
well as uh elements of uh of of poetry
um being wedded uh into the short story
right uh the short story shares with the
novel uh the medium of pros and yet it
also makes use of uh poetry's
metaphorical language uh and it's the
poetry's strategies of
indirect uh uh references indirect
Direction and
suggestion so allthough the novel and
the short story resort to the same Pros
medium their artistic methods are very
different uh more stylized than the
novel the short story tends to distort
everyday reality or uh at least break
away from everyday reality more than the
long form narratives too and so the
short story uh essentially operates
through uh intuition and it has an
inherent uh lyrical effect uh in fact
lyricism is an inherent uh you know like
I said an intrinsic feature that derives
from the tension and intensity of the
short story form I have spoken about the
effect of jolt uh or shock and the role
of the bazire in the short story form
and this is present even in the most uh
realistic uh short stories so uh short
story cannot be only about the praic the
hrum the mandin it has a very uh limited
condensed scope within which it can play
so it has to make use of that jolt that
uh shakes Rader of her feet or that uh
is able to grasp or to Revit the reader
attention uh in a in a very quick period
and very quickly and very rapidly very
promptly g lukach notes that unlike the
novel which basically has a more uh
public vocation uh the short story
remains comparatively more romantic
individualistic and uh intransigent most
of the times it does not give in uh two
the uh public vocation it it is uh
mostly you know the affair of lonely
voice the marginalized the the Exile I
can Mom notes that the novel and the
short story are not only different in
kind but also inherently at odds now
different critics have their own take
own understanding of these two forms
some would say that the two are at odds
we have already discussed a few of such
critics uh who uh say that the short
story uh you know the novel happens uh
to the disadvantage of the short story
the novel is only elaborating too many
uh extraneous too many too too many uh
unnecessary uh details that can be done
away with and so uh they are in favor of
the short story form uh and uh then the
critics that are more comfortable with
the genre of Novel would go go on to say
that the novel uh is not only about the
bear skeleton the story the story line
but uh it has the highest scope to uh uh
play with characters to play with uh
perspectives due to the greater time
space that it can assume and hence the
same question the story is also dealing
with the question of existence can be
can be in in fact dealt uh better in the
novel right so while the short story is
frequently seen as a fundamental
elementary form the novel uh Remains the
syncretic form a form that is bringing
in uh you know uh the the
Opposites uh so uh it it is bringing in
uh uh views that are traditionally seen
as polarized characters that contrast
each other that are that can be seen as
uh you know just opposed to one another
this scope of uh playing with themes
playing with the story and making
thereby a more layered a more nuanced
plot is not available uh to the short
story The discrepancy between the short
story and the novel is marked by the
essential disparity between uh short and
uh long form home so the short story is
a problem in posing uh a single equation
with one unknown on the other hand the
novel is a problem involving various
rules and uh soluble with a whole system
of equations with various unknowns in
which the intermediary steps are more
important than the final answer right uh
so we see within this uh uh within the
matrices of you know characters their uh
inter
illuminations um language uh playing at
uh several levels uh the the complex
treatment of U narrative voice of time
and
temporality uh we have stream of
Consciousness we have flashbacks we have
um you know an entire novel uh happening
in
hindsight uh so this is how the Quest
for self is attend or is attempted in
the novel the short story has to uh you
know take off at once because it's O to
its more compact form obviously and it
cannot har too much on details it uh has
to uh within its Limited uh you know
scope uh talk about uh a theme uh that
surpasses it uh inherent limitations a
theme that is timeless that is spaceless
that remains that lingers with the
reader even after the process of reading
has ended so Edgar aleno would uh state
that the short story forms brav invites
an analogy between the short story and
the special dimension of Visual Arts so
we can see a great uh you know uh
analogy a close a closeness between
painting and
photography uh and short story so we see
some kind of analogy some kind of
similarity between uh how painting and
photography is uh created or produced
and how a short story is written uh and
this differenti is the short story uh
from the temporality of the novel uh
which uh clearly
unfolds travels plays with time it
unfolds in time and plays with travels
in time so while the novel while the
novel operates on the assumption that it
uh presents a full and authentic report
of Human Experience the short story
basically deals with a fragment it could
be an incident it could be a uh single
small scale event even a fraction of any
of these uh so in contrast to the novel
uh which focuses on the
interconnectedness of various things
various events uh that take place over a
longer period of time the short story is
uh interested and it depicts only a
fragment the short story centers on a
scene or a person that is cut off from
the largest social historical or
existential Continuum because there is
basically uh not much time and space to
talk too much about the backdrop in a
short story and so the short story
concentrates rather on a moment of
awareness Epiphany rather than a
completed action unlike the novel the
short story does not attempt to embrace
the whole of experience with its uh
complex fabric of uh casual processes or
uh elaborate um too much on temporal
durations instead short story presents
uh slices or snapshots or wigets of
reality right so we were talking about
poetry and short story it has the inner
organization
and it has to be pre-planned by the
short story
writer otherwise it will
dilute uh it might vulgarize the effect
might uh you know the effect which is
the soul the spirit of the story might
uh flow out of it and the novel's author
is persistently chasing the question the
core question that's the basic
difference so Raymond cover argues that
the short story offers only a glimpse uh
that uh given life turns into something
that illuminates the moment and so it
acquires further ranging consequences
and meanings so uh the short story might
stop but the imagination persists the
imagination a good short story uh is
marked by the feature of keeping the
leer to Crave for more that is uh one of
the chief features of a good a
successful short story because a form
needs to be imposed on the short story
it ends but uh the the thinking
process the reader thinking uh and
analyzing uh lingers beyond the form of
the short story right it uh leaves the
further ranging the the the meaning of
or or the consequence of that story is
uh far broader it it uh uh encompasses
uh much more than the story in its
physical form uh does right uh so its
effect is uh all Inc compassing the
meaning that it is exuding is uh
something so Timeless that that
something so immediately
identifiable uh and and that is the sign
of a good story basically so the short
story writer's task uh uh precisely
comprises in in investing this Glimpse
with all that is in his power we are
once again going back to uh you know um
words key words that I have used in my
earlier lecture intensification
condensation distillation telescoping
these are some of the words that uh that
Define the quintessential short story
moreover the moment of short story which
is uh plucked out of the flow of time
it's outside of time and it seeks
meaning beyond the Continuum and the
particular this Glimpse Revelation or
Flash to use the uh God's terms uh
strives towards something that is more
General and Universal something that is
left uh unstated by the story itself and
something that appears to be uh
incommunicable
uh so this theme is
atemporal a theme that we have carried
with us uh almost uh always right uh and
so so it's almost it reminds me of uh
the primordial image the concept of
primordial image when we
see an exper when we experience
something on the outside it directly
addresses uh something uh that we have
been carrying along inside of us uh
almost uh since birth it it it has been
there in uh in US it's the effect of the
primordial image almost where the inner
and the outer resonate the ecoo and uh
the effect is uh large that effect is
much larger than the short story in its
physical form right there is kind of
resonance where what is on the inner uh
reflects on and EOS with uh what is on
the outer right uh so this ecoo
transcends time and temporality in the
case of the short story so Julio cazar
uh discusses the difference between the
novel and the short story through the
metaphoric comparison of Photography and
Motion Pictures so when we we are
talking about short studia we are
thinking about a still photograph on the
other hand novel uh is closer to Motion
Pictures so cazar has pointed out that
the novel uh develops on paper in the
course of writing uh in the course of
the time that it takes to read it uh and
so there is no internal limit to the
novel other than the exhaustion of the
artistic material in other words the
novelist's authorial control lies in
imposing a form a physical form and
thereby a limit to his document the
novel through writing a stable
conclusion or ending on the other hand
uh the short story for its part begins
with the notion of limits it is more
limited in the first place it has its
physical limits so that uh in
France
uh in in Traditions I mean such as you
know French short stories when a short
you know when a story uh exceeds uh 20
Pages it is called nille so in France
they're very particular about uh where a
short story stops and anal begins when a
short story exceeds 20 Pages it becomes
it is rather called anal something that
is between a short story and a
fulllength novel with this I'm going to
conclude today's lecture and let's meet
again with another round of discussions
in the following lectures thank you
[Music]
a
[Music]
