Largest Sandpaper Test EVER Done - Top 19 brands Tested using Robots for Unbiased Data.

House Love
61 followers
1 Video View·Nov 15, 2022
Largest Sandpaper Test EVER Done - Top 19 brands Tested using Robots for Unbiased Data.
All right, it is time for a sandpaper showdown
to end all showdowns.
We tested 19 brands.
We've got nine brands of mesh.
We've got 10 brands of film-backed paper.
There was a standout.
It was incredible.
We tested on an industrial robot
at our friend's ATI Industrial Automation
who make the tooling for these robots,
and they have an amazing random orbital sander
that is capable of putting the exact same amount
of pressure over and over and over again
so we're able to run the exact same test on each sandpaper.
We did five-minute intervals for 25 minutes,
and we came out with some real winners
and some real losers.
So we're gonna get into the test here,
but I wanna thank ATI for hosting us this week.
They have no financial affiliation with this video,
but they were very nice in having us
and letting us use and abuse their research
and development department.
Thanks, guys.
So let's get into the test
and let's talk about sandpaper in general.
All right, so let's talk a little bit more about the test.
And again, all this data will be published on my website
as well as a link down to the winners in the pinned comment.
So if you wanna read the data yourself,
you can go ahead and do that.
So the test was set up.
We used Red Oak, which is about a 1300 on the Jenka scale.
I believe it's 1290.
Every sandpaper we tested was a five-inch disc
and it was 120 grit.
This test took us four full days to complete.
So we didn't shoot footage of the entire four days,
but we have shots of all these
just sort of show we did the test.
We used exactly 10.78 pounds and that was the beauty.
And this is why we flew out to North Carolina to ATI
was because they invented this sander
that is capable of putting the exact same amount of pressure.
Last time I did this test, I learned a couple of things.
People will find ways to pick holes
in any scientific test you do.
And one of the big ones was companies saying it wasn't fair
because we could have altered the pressure, you know,
whatever.
So this is a way that there is no question
that this is a fair test.
The other thing I learned is that if you don't say
all the ones you did, but you write them down,
people aren't going to read it.
So we're going to go through every single one.
We're going to do it quickly so as not to waste your time.
We're going to start at the bottom.
We're going to end at the top.
And then we're going to talk about the data
and why I think it came out the way it did.
Like I said, in the intro,
there is a newcomer that whooped everybody.
I mean, reinventing the sandpaper game
kind of whooped everybody.
It's unreal.
So one of the things that has happened
in the last couple of years in the sandpaper industry
is there's been some massive changes.
Company called Mirka, I'm sure you've heard of them.
They held the patent on the mesh disc for quite some time,
but that expired a couple of years ago.
That's allowed companies to experiment.
Some of them have changed their formulas
since our last test,
because ceramic has started to become
a big part of the sandpaper industry.
It's a new thing that 3M just released in their Cubitron
for woodworking.
They've been having it in their metalworking sandpaper
for a long time,
but people have learned that it is better for wood.
So there's some changes in this test from our last one.
Some people reformulated,
but I think you'll be really blown away
by the winner and the results.
So what do we test for?
We are testing for friability.
Friability is what happens to sandpaper
as it deteriorates so that it continues to cut.
There were a couple in this test that had no friability.
Like they got through one of the five minute intervals
and then died and would not cut any more at all.
Some that were pretty close to that.
But the reason we test for friability
is because in consumables,
there's only one way to value consumables.
It is not the price you buy it for.
You can't compare one disc of one company
to another company and see which one costs less
and say that's the one I want to go with
because it doesn't matter.
How long can you use it for?
How much cutting will it do?
It is the only way to measure consumables,
whether it's a router bit or a saw bit,
like how many board feet will it cut?
If I've got a $50 router bit
that will cut a thousand board feet
and I have a $20 router bit that goes dull
after 30 board feet,
it's no question which one I buy.
You buy the $50 one.
The way that we measure the sandpaper
was cost of grams removed.
So we did five five-minute interval tests.
We weighed them before and after each test,
and then we took the cost of that disc
divided by the total grams removed,
and we came up with a winner that way.
So let's get into the test.
We're gonna get through every single one
starting from bottom to top,
and then we're gonna talk about the results,
talk about some outliers,
and talk about why we would throw
a couple of these results out
just because it was so cheap
but it still didn't remove a lot of material,
that kind of stuff.
So we're gonna talk about that
after we get through the results.
So let's get started with number 19,
the worst of the bunch, Makita.
Makita, which is common in big box stores,
did the worst by removing four grams the whole test.
It's cheap at 50 cents a disc,
but it cost 12.54 cents to remove a gram of material,
which is so much more than anything else in this test.
And again, we spot-checked the best, the worst,
and a few other random ones
to make sure we're getting accurate results,
and we double-checked this
because we didn't believe it.
Really, Makita, absolute garbage, never buy this.
Let's go on to number 18.
Number 18 was Wonderweave,
or I think it's sometimes called Pronet.
This is not one we tested last time,
but it was highly requested in the comments.
I think it's really popular with turners,
so woodworkers think that maybe it's a good one,
but it did terribly.
It's cheap, it's 50 cents a disc,
and it cost 4.17 cents per gram removed.
Number 17 is Norton Pro Sand Air.
This is one of the attempts at a mesh disc
before Mirka had lost their patent.
I did pretty good middle of the road
for grams removed at 45 grams.
It's the first ceramic-based sandpaper in our test,
but the problem with this is it's so expensive
at $1.80 per disc,
so it came in at 4 cents per gram removed.
Number 16 is Festool Rubin 2.
We did not test all the Festool papers in our last test,
and we got a lot of heat in the comments,
so I tested everything Festool makes during this test.
Festool Rubin 2 is an expensive paper at $1.40 per disc.
Did, again, middle of the road for grams removed
at 45 grams at a cost of 3.1 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number 15,
another big box super hitter, Gator Resin.
I believe it's Walmart's brand.
Only removed 13 grams during the entire test.
Very cheap at 40 cents per disc,
and cost about 3.07 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number 14, Klingspor PS-29.
Another middle of the road performer for grams removed,
but at a cost of $1.29,
it costs 3 cents per gram removed
at 43 grams for the whole test.
Unlucky number 13, Festool Granite Net.
Festool has two lines of granite.
We tested both.
One is a net, and one is a disc.
This one costs $1.14 per disc.
It removed 38 grams during the whole test,
so kind of lower middle of the pack
at a cost of 3 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number 12, Festool Granite, the disc version.
At $1.60 per disc, and this is interesting.
In this test, you'll find a lot of times
the mesh is always cheaper than the discs,
which is also the case.
Removed 56 grams in the test,
so kind of middle higher end of the pack
at 2.86 cents per disc.
Coming in at number 11, Diablo Sand Net.
Now this is one of the ones
that was definitely reformulated since our last test.
They added ceramic to it.
Diablo Sand Net removed 64 grams of material
during the whole test at a cost of 2.36 cents per gram.
Coming in at number 10,
one of the top performers in grams removed.
Just about tied with the original Cubitron
at 76 grams during the test.
Only problem is these are very expensive
at $1.70 per disc, and cost 2.24 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number nine, another big box store brand.
Not the worst performer, but very cheap at 65 cents.
30 total grams removed during the competition
at 1.96 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number eight, Shopsmith G2 Tech.
Middle of the road with 39 total grams removed
at a cost of 78 cents per disc
at a total cost of 2 cents per grams removed.
Coming in at number seven at 46 cents per disc.
Third worst performer in grams removed at 23 grams,
but because it was so cheap,
it was able to eke out a number seven spot
at 1.99 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number six,
one that has definitely been reformatted
since our last test, Bosch.
Bosch barely cut in the last test at all.
It still did very terribly in total grams removed
at 30 grams, not the worst, but I think fourth worst.
But because it's so cheap at 59 cents per disc,
it came in at 1.96 cents per gram removed.
And again, we're gonna talk about
why we would throw some of these out
after we talk about the next, the top five.
We're getting into the top five here, the winners.
Number five, Mirka Abranet,
the original patent holder for the NetMesh disc
at 80 cents a disc, 44 grams removed
at 1.82 cents per grams removed.
Coming in at number four, Mirka Autonet,
a very inexpensive disc at 53 cents per disc,
removing 37 grams during the test
at a total cost of 1.42 cents per disc.
Coming in at number three, Klingspor PS77,
again, a very expensive disc at 53 cents,
removing 40 grams during the test
at 1.33 cents per gram removed.
Coming in at number two, the winner from our last test
at one of my favorite sandpapers for the last year
since we did that test, 3M Cubitron,
removing 74 grams, 34 more than the number three spot
at a cost of 1.14 cents per gram removed.
Now let's get into number one.
These numbers are gonna blow you away.
Coming in at number one is this.
Would you believe if you saw this
that this could put up the numbers that it did?
During the test, in its 25th interval,
so after five five-minute intervals,
this still removed more material
than almost every other paper in the test
did in its first round.
During the whole test, it removed 114 grams.
That's 40 grams more than the number two
and number three spot.
That is unreal.
I mean, it has like half the grit of anything else,
so I'm not sure why it did so well,
but this is the new 3M X-Trak.
It's their Cubitron blend,
their proprietary ceramic blend
that's in the original Cubitron
that got the number two spot,
and they designed this insane
like herringbone pattern sandpaper.
It's unbelievable.
And the craziest part about it,
it only cost 41 cents per disc.
It's like half the price of the Cubitron,
whereas the number two spot was 1.14 cents
to per gram removed.
This was a third of a cent.
Like this is gonna revolutionize the sandpaper again.
And let me stress that these are not sponsored videos.
We paid for this test.
We paid for all 19 of these different sandpaper brands.
I can't believe this.
This is like unreal how good this sandpaper is.
So let's talk a little bit more about the data.
Let's talk about why we would throw out
some of those in the upper mid-level,
and let's talk about why it's important
to look at data like this.
So every time we do a test like this,
I feel like I learn so much.
And I went through the comments of the last test,
and we bought every single one
that somebody requested us test.
And the thing that I have learned in this test
is that mesh is the wave of the future.
I mean, obviously 3M has come up with something so special.
My theory is that because it's so open
and there's these massive spaces without grit,
it really reduces clogging,
and it allows it to stay much, much cooler when it's sanded.
That's my personal theory.
I don't know if that's true,
but I think that that's part of why it cuts so well,
because heat is the enemy of sharpness.
So if this stays cooler, it's gonna retain its grain
and continue to cut really well.
But to do 40 grams more than the number two
and number three is just insane.
If you look at the number two, Cubitron,
partly because it's inexpensive at like 81 cents a disc,
but it also has a ton of holes in it.
So it mimics mesh.
This would fit on any sander.
Phenomenal value in sandpaper.
I've been using this.
And when I started using it,
I was blown away by how it cuts.
So now that this is available,
this is what I'm gonna probably switch to.
Pretty incredible.
Cubitron and Norton Mesh were so close.
Cubitron was 74 grams.
This was 76 grams.
So these were basically tied as far as grams removed,
but this Norton Mesh is very expensive.
I think at a buck 71 per disc.
So that's why we look at things like this.
So let's look at a chart here.
This is cost per grams and total grams removed.
Now this chart is ordered in cost per grams removed.
So from left to right, that's the order of the test.
And you can see that you'd probably wanna toss out
like the number three, four, five, six, seven, eight,
nine spot if you're a person who likes getting stuff done.
The only reason they were able to sort of be good
on this metric is because we're comparing the cost
towards the amount removed,
but they removed so little compared
to some of the other ones.
And we're so, so cheap that they were able to sort of sneak
into the top of the test.
So if you've got all the time in the world,
nothing wrong with any of those,
like the Mirka, Shopsmith, Clingspore.
You know, they're good sandpapers
and they're gonna be just average.
If you wanna get stuff done though, for a fair price,
you gotta go with the 3M Cubitron.
And if that's not readily available,
certainly the Norton Mesh, Diablo Sandnet,
and the Festool Granite are gonna be good papers.
Now, one of the things that Festool has always done well
is have proprietary consumables.
And that's where that Festool Granite comes in,
but that's why Mesh is such a game changer
because something like the 3M Extract,
that's gonna fit on any sander,
including any Festool sander you have.
So there's no reason to buy
that super expensive Festool paper.
And that's why they have those proprietary hole patterns
is they want you to buy their consumables.
You know, it's part of how they keep the cost
of their power tools down
because they know they're gonna get you in the long run
as you're buying sandpaper.
But again, still removed a decent amount of materials,
in the mid fifties there.
To me, as somebody who really dislikes sanding,
this is the chart I look at, cost per grams removed.
And that is what is important to me
because I wanna find a sandpaper
that removes a ton of material for a cheap price.
And to me, after doing this test,
I'm so blown away by this Festool Extract.
Like I said, I'm gonna link that down in the pin comment,
highly suggest you check it out.
Mike is one of the only guys,
the person who I linked there who will split up packs.
So he'll sell small packs if you just wanna test it.
The crazy thing is if you look
at the five minute interval chart,
this is why friability matters so much.
And this is why a test like this matters so much.
Cause you know, if you look at like a paper,
like the Gator or the Bosch or the DeWalt,
they just completely fail after 10 minutes.
They're just garbage.
They're not working anymore.
And yeah, they removed a little bit of material
in their first round.
So that helped their total go up.
But if you look at like the Extract,
in its fifth five minute interval,
it removed 19 grams of material.
The only ones that even did better than that
in the first five minutes were the Diablo Sand Net
and the Norton Mesh Power.
The 3M Cubitron came close
and the Festool Granite came close
in their first five minutes
to the last five minutes of the Extract.
I mean, that is just absolutely insane.
So I think this chart is very telling
cause this is how you can see friability.
Again, these will be on my website as well.
And then lastly,
if you wanna just see them ranked in total grams removed,
from number one, I'll list quickly the top five.
It was the 3M Cubitron Mesh, Norton Mesh Power,
3M Cubitron, Diablo Sand Net,
and then the Festool Granite.
So if cost is of no object to you,
you can buy based on that.
If you look at the bottom five,
Makita, the Wonder Weave Pro Net,
the Gator Red Resin, Sungold Abrasives.
I think Sungold's like really popular on Amazon.
And then the DeWalt and Bosch
were all at the very bottom for grams removed.
So I think this test is absolutely telling.
Took us four days to do and was eye-opening.
But it was so cool to see that since our last test,
that really, I don't know,
that's probably not the reason the industry's changing.
I think that the technology is getting better.
And I really think that, you know,
if you look at the top four here,
they all have ceramic in them.
Ceramic is the future of sandpaper.
So make sure your sandpaper has ceramic
if you're not gonna go buy the Extract
or the Cubitron or the Norton Meth.
Really, you should value your time
more than the actual retail cost of something
because it really does make a difference
to do something based on cost per grams removed
rather than just retail costs
because it's how much can I get done in what amount of time?
And I think that's really important.
So guys, if you wanna support us
doing more things like this,
I would really appreciate it
if you head over to the Katzmosis store
and check out the tools we have over there.
We actually have a bunch coming out here in a little bit
and some good, exciting announcements,
which I'm really excited about.
So guys, thank you for watching.
The 3M Extract and Cubitron will be linked down below
as well as all the data over on my website,
which will be published in a blog.
Guys, stay safe in the shop.
Have a wonderful day.
