Is a $1100 EXT Storia V3 coil shock that much better than an air shock? The first 1,000 people to use the link or my code evansmtbsaga will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: https://skl.sh/evansmtbsaga04221
Credit to Donut Media & Pinkbike for the inspiration behind this mega series.
Buy me a coffee support has ended, thank you for everyone for the support! If you'd like to support the channel, consider becoming a channel member for sneak previews and exclusive access.
If you'd like to send me something for a future video idea: Evan's MTB Saga PO Box 6498 Goodyear, AZ 85338
$300 air shock versus an $1,100 coil shock.
Does expensive equal better?
First up is ripping off the stock SR Suntour air shock
from our two identical Polygon Cisco D5s.
This shock does not have a rebound adjustment
and is very, very bouncy.
And now that we have a blank slate,
on my low bike, I'm installing a new RockShox
Monarch Plus RC3, my favorite shock that I've ever used.
The DebonAir can and extra oil reservoir
made for a really plush ride,
and it always kept the wheel firmly planted on the ground.
But these do have a big history of failing
and needing to be completely rebuilt.
I hope this one works out.
For my high bike, since I have an unlimited budget,
I'm installing an EXD Storia V3 coil shock,
another premium Italian part.
And unfortunately, Evan made me buy this used,
so it's not even custom tuned for this Polygon.
The excuses are starting already,
but that coil shock is way heavier, almost a full pound.
I don't care about weight, I only time the downhills.
First up is installing do bushings
with my eyelet bushing tool.
We're also gonna be reusing the stock hardware.
Next, the shocks are installed to the right torque,
making this a very easy job.
So now the shocks are installed,
but now I wonder, how do I even set up the coil shock?
With an air shock, all I need is a shock pump,
and I can set the sag to whatever I want
in just a few minutes.
The EXD coil shock leaves all sorts of questions,
like what spring rate do I use?
How much preload?
How do I measure sag?
Should I change out the spring?
And where do I even begin
with high and low speed compression?
But now, I think I have it tuned right
after using the spring rate calculator,
and I used the bump stop as a sag indicator,
so it should be at a pretty good base setting,
but that was way more complicated,
and for all that work, the extra cost,
and the extra weight,
is it really gonna be that much better on the trail?
The bikes are ready to go,
and the high bike now weighs 33.8 pounds,
and the total project cost so far is a whopping $5,500.
The low bike now weighs 33.6 pounds,
and so far has cost 2,360 bucks.
I can't wait to see how they stack up against each other,
but it's time for another clean for green,
and this is my subscriber, Alec,
and if he can do this climb in one minute,
I'll give him $10.
All right, go for it.
While he's doing that,
I'm gonna tell you about this video's sponsor, Skillshare.
Skillshare is an online learning community
with thousands of inspiring classes.
It's a perfect place to start learning a new skill,
like productivity, cooking, and making YouTube videos.
Skillshare has a massive library of online learning,
so pretty much anyone can find classes
that will match their goals and interests.
Right now, I'm learning Spanish
to help me at my day job as a nurse.
It's something that I've been putting off for way too long.
There's so many different topics on Skillshare.
There's definitely a class that you'd be interested in,
and if you're curious and love learning like I do,
you should definitely check it out.
Oh, he's almost there,
and the first thousand people
to use my link in the description
or my code EVANSMTBSAGA
will get a one-month free trial of Skillshare.
Let's see, how's Alec doing?
Oh, he made it.
I owe him $10, and you owe me a like.
Chad and I are taking both bikes on the Saga test loop
to see if the shocks give us any time improvements.
On the first short descent,
it was actually the low bike's Monarch shock
that felt way better and more playful.
It felt snappy and light,
which led to getting a PR on the segment,
beating the high bike by an entire second.
Oh, come on, that was basically a fire road.
On the more gnarly downhill,
the EXD shock kept being firmly planted on the ground
and choosing lines and weaving between rocks
became effortless.
But those tests were not enough.
I just hiked up 25,000 feet to the top of South Mountain.
But what I'm gonna do is take both shocks
and put them on the high bike
to get some better baseline tests.
Let's get started.
On the climb up, surprisingly,
the EXD shock felt like it had less pedal bob
because it felt stiffer
and had great traction up the technical climb.
The RockShox Monarch Plus had a normal amount of pedal bob
and lacked behind the coil shock
when it came to rear wheel traction on the tech climbs,
but still had predictable plushness.
Despite the shock upgrades,
hitting this drop to flat still didn't feel great.
And the biggest difference I could feel
is just doing it with better form.
But then on the rough, rocky downhill section,
I finally felt a huge difference.
I got through the rock garden just fine with the RockShox
and had no issues.
But on the coil shock,
the faster I went, the better it handled.
I felt like I was plowing downhill
and I could hold a straight line for much longer.
So after the testing, the coil shock is definitely better.
On that last long downhill,
the air shock was experiencing fade
and that's when the oil in the shock heats up,
making the shock not work as well.
Coil shocks don't really get that,
which is a huge benefit of using a coil.
But bro, I have some bad news.
This coil shock is leaking oil.
Are you kidding?
This is all your fault for making me buy used to save money.
Man, that's a bummer.
If the coil shock is leaking oil,
that means it has air inside of it.
So it may not have been in peak condition for testing,
but we're gonna send it off to be rebuilt.
But what do you expect me to use?
Here, you can use this Fox shock.
Ooh, Kashima.
So what can we learn from all this?
Well, coil shocks are super hard to set up
and there's not a lot of information on how to do it.
Even though the coil shock was better,
I don't think it's worth the hassle
and $800 more.
Air shocks are way more DIY mechanic friendly.
You just pump up more air.
Another takeaway is buying used parts
doesn't always work out.
It can be risky and you might run into a dishonest person
and end up getting a leaking shock
or ripped off altogether.
But now that both bikes have upgraded suspension,
I expected them to feel way more plush than they are.
And I think that's because of the super heavy stock wheelset
and we now have channel membership
so you can get sneak previews on future builds.
What is that?
How much did you spend?