Filippo Brunelleschi The Dome of Florence Cathedral

Renaissance Architecture
15 followers
#Architecture #buildingdesign #FamousDesign #Palladian #Renaissan
Filippo Brunelleschi, The Dome of Santa Maria del Fiore (Florence Cathedral), 1420–36
speakers: Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker
The year was 1417, and the city of Florence
had a huge problem.
A century earlier, Arnolfo de Cambio
had laid the groundwork for an enormous cathedral.
The city of Florence wanted to outshine everybody,
and so it laid out an enormous footprint.
Arnolfo's design called for a giant dome
over the east end of the church,
and they figured by the time they had to build it,
they would figure out how to do it.
The Florentines had really backed themselves into a corner.
They had an enormous cathedral that needed a dome,
and they had no idea how to actually pull that off,
and they laid a set of foundations for the dome,
knowing that whatever solution they would eventually find,
it would require thick walls and piers
to support an unfathomably heavy stone vault.
No one had built anything like this since antiquity,
since the Pantheon in Rome.
The problem was that the conventional method
of building a dome required centering,
wooden frames to support the dome as it was raised.
One of the problems was that there simply
were not enough trees big enough
to create that kind of centering.
The way that centering was traditionally used
is that wooden framework would support the stone vaults
until the keystone was put into place,
which would stabilize the entire structure,
and then the timbers could be removed,
and the dome would be self-supporting.
The city-state of Siena had also tried
to build an enormous dome and failed.
They just could not figure this out
until a middle-aged sculptor, goldsmith, and architect
who had actually not built anything substantial
in his entire life came forward with a solution.
Brunelleschi said to the councils
that were in charge of the building,
we can do this without centering.
We can build a dome without any kind of internal support.
The dome can be self-supporting as it is constructed,
and I know this because I've studied the Pantheon in Rome.
Brunelleschi had actually gone to Rome,
likely with Donatello, and when he was there,
he, of course, visited the Pantheon.
But in some ways, the dome in Florence
was even more ambitious because instead
of being raised on a relatively low barrel,
this dome was to be built atop a towering edifice.
Marvin Trachtenberg puts it this way.
It bordered on a collective insanity,
yielding a tide of desperation
that eventually would allow the approval
of a hair-raising structural solution
proposed by a conspicuously untested architect
as the unimaginable resolution of an unthinkable problem.
So when Brunelleschi said,
I can do all of this without centering,
they thought he was joking.
And in fact, Vasari recounts how when Brunelleschi
walked through the streets of Florence after that,
people said, there goes the madman.
What Brunelleschi must have realized
when he was studying the Pantheon
was that domes were conceived of
as a series of arches in the round,
and therefore, they needed a keystone.
But the Pantheon is a perfectly hemispherical dome
that has no keystone.
In fact, at its top, there's an oculus.
That is, there's a hole.
And yet somehow, that dome stands up.
Now, the Pantheon is made out of concrete,
so it was poured, but it was poured in concentric circles
as it rose up.
And Brunelleschi realized that hemispherical domes
function in a self-supporting manner
if they're constructed out of concentric circles,
that each level up functions in a sense
as a narrowing oculus,
and that the last ring functions
to support the rings below it.
Was it possible to take that conceptual structure
and to apply it to a different type of dome,
a dome that is octagonal?
There are many reasons that the dome stands today.
When we look at the dome from the inside,
we're seeing this enormous open space
that is unsupported in the center.
And when we see the building from the outside,
we're actually seeing a different dome.
Brunelleschi designed this as a double shell.
Most of the structural work
is being done by the interior shell.
That shell is significantly thicker than the outer shell,
which really just needs to support itself.
And there is space between these shells.
In fact, you can still buy a ticket
and walk up to the lantern at the very top,
and the steps that you climb
are in between those two shells.
But there are other things.
There's the herringbone pattern of the bricks, for example,
that allowed the bricks to be more stable as the dome rose.
Those herringbone courses of brick
rise up at a curving diagonal
with bricks that are laid vertically
in contrast to the horizontal courses of brick.
But I think that even more important than that
is the idea that Brunelleschi created masses of bricks
held at an angle in wedge shapes
that actually scalloped slightly
so that each of these masses of brick masonry
would function as wedges that held each other in place
as the dome rose and began to incline inward
so that each enormous unit of brick
became, in a sense, a kind of stone boussoir
wedged into place.
And once the ring of those masses were completed,
they would be self-sustaining.
In other words, just like the Pantheon,
each horse moving up was self-sustaining.
Brunelleschi used wooden scaffolding
to help stabilize things at each stage,
but there was no internal centering.
The members of this commission
in charge of overseeing the building of the dome
were not entirely secure with Brunelleschi's solution,
and they wanted insurance.
And this involved using iron to help contain the stone
almost like a girdle around the dome.
I think a lot of people think of this iron chain
as continuous, as an actual chain.
It's not that.
It's a stone chain.
That is, blocks of stone are almost stapled together
with staples of iron.
It helps to ensure that the lateral thrust
that the dome produces, which pushes outward
as well as down, is held in place.
It must have provided a degree of reassurance
to the cathedral committees as the dome rose.
Not only did he solve how to support the dome
as it was raised, he designed a machine
that helped to hoist the heavy stones
all the way up to the top of the dome
as it was being built.
One can only imagine the planning
that was required to get the materials in place,
to hoist them up, and to make sure
that the engineering was flawless.
What we're left with is a building
that at its base is a beautiful Gothic cathedral.
But as we rise up, we begin to see Brunelleschi's interest
in the classical tradition.
And we move away from the purely Gothic
into the style that we now recognize as the Renaissance.
Most of the time when we think about Gothic architecture,
what comes to mind is a French cathedral
surrounded by flying buttresses
that allow for enormous amounts of stained glass
and light to come in.
But Gothic architecture in Italy was decidedly different.
What we see in the building today
is very much a kind of Tuscan style of Gothic.
We see a building made of brick
but faced with different colored marble
in these beautiful geometric designs and patterns
that activate the surface of the building.
This polychromy, this use of different colored stone,
recalls ancient Roman architecture.
But we can still see some trademark references
to the Gothic that we recognize
from French and English cathedrals.
If we look at the lancet windows, those slender windows,
we can see small rose windows.
All of this is part of the international Gothic.
And it's probably worth mentioning
that past the west side of the cathedral is the baptistry,
which the Florentines believed was ancient Roman,
even though it wasn't quite that old.
And it uses the same kind of polychromy on its exterior.
And so this building is very much recalling that tradition.
And in this way, the city links itself
to this noble ancient tradition.
Florence was seeing itself at this moment as the new Rome.
And so these references to ancient Rome
were entirely appropriate.
So we have this otherwise Gothic building.
But if we look up at the blind tribunes
at the base of the dome,
we see pairs of attached columns with Corinthian capitals
framing round arches with this lovely shell shape
inside the niche.
We also see a very heavy entablature.
These are forms that Brunelleschi is borrowing
from classical architecture.
He's reinventing architecture using these classical forms
for the new modern Florence.
And those classicizing tribunes alternate
with more traditional semi-domes
that help to stabilize the central dome itself.
In fact, just below those semi-domes,
you can see enormous buttresses.
These are not pierced, so they're not flying buttresses
in the French and English manner.
But they are nevertheless doing important work
supporting not only the weight of the dome,
but also its lateral thrust.
Brunelleschi's blind tribune is such a contrast
to what's around it.
Right below the tribune, in fact,
we see a landing supported by brackets.
And in between the brackets,
we see pointed arches decorated with a trefoil.
This is quintessentially Gothic,
but then right above,
Brunelleschi's recalling classical antiquity.
The building's scale is so great
that even as we sit here in the piazza
just behind the cathedral looking up,
it's almost impossible for me to understand how large it is.
I actually have to look at the scale of the people
that you can see at the bottom of the lantern,
just at the top of the dome.
As they're enjoying incredible views of the city,
only really they give me a sense
of the enormous scale of the structure,
of the enormous ambition of this structure,
of the enormous ambition of Brunelleschi
and of Florence in the 15th century.
♪♪♪
