Every Matty Healy Song On folklore/evermore

The Song Decoder
12 followers
8 Video Views·Apr 15, 2025
Hi! There are a lot of parallels in this to songs on Midnights and well as The Tortured Poets Department, so I hope this isn't too confusing if you're not caught up on the lore :-). Taylor Swift remains an easter egg nuisance... thanks for watching!
0:00 - 0:24 Intro
0:25 - 3:41 folklore: track 1
3:42 - 5:35 folklore: track 2
5:36 - 5:59 folklore: track 3
6:00 - 6:31 folklore: track 4
6:35 - 8:23 evermore: track 1
8:24 - 10:07 evermore: track 2
10:08 - 3:12 evermore: track 3
13:13 - 14:10 evermore: track 4
14:11 - 16:34 evermore: track 5
16:35 - 17:25 evermore: track 6
17:26 - 18:44 evermore: track 7
Today, we're discussing all of the songs on Folklore and Evermore that are about Maddie Healy.
Following the release of the Torture Poets Department, we definitely need to revisit some of these,
especially after The Line.
Not as long as you're gone,
In love, just as I'm gone.
On Guilty As Sin, which has many people believing that there are some vault songs about Maddie on Folklore and Evermore,
which are her lowercase albums, that were never released, and by that logic, there were definitely some that were.
Number one is Cardigan. Taylor said on stage while Maddie was at her show that this one is about you.
Furthermore, we have The Line.
This album was written before she and Maddie got back together in 2023, and after they got together in 2014,
so in this album, she's just started to wonder what if he was the one for her.
There's also a ton of Maddie-specific lyrics in this one.
These are all just saying that this person has haunted her from her past,
and this person smokes and has tattoos.
This is one, again, very reminiscent of all the songs she has written about him,
where she references meeting him when they were very young,
and these songs are very easy to spot because she doesn't write about anyone else like this.
We also have this parallel.
I discussed this in another video on all the Maddie Healy songs on Midnights,
but this is basically related to the 2014 drama around Taylor and Maddie.
He essentially kept saying that he didn't want to date her because the fame around her was too much,
her reputation was too much, and he said at one point that it would be emasculating to date her,
hence politics and gender roles, hence sensual politics.
This one's pretty self-explanatory.
In Cardigan, she's waiting for this person to show up and stand in her front porch light,
and in Fresh Out the Slammer, which is clearly about her leaving Joe and moving on to Maddie,
we have a role reversal where he's the one that's waiting for her underneath the porch light,
and she's coming to him.
There's a line that's also very much giving
I'm stuck in an unsatisfying relationship vibes.
I wonder where we've heard that before.
Also, I just have to say that some of the lyrics in the song are clearly not about Joe.
Like, this doesn't give Joe vibes.
The final parallel.
There's an entire song about Peter Pan on the Tortured Poets department, okay?
If we take a look at the song, we can see very clear themes of just childhood references
and waiting for someone that you met when you were young, but them never showing up.
Guess how old Maddie was when he and Taylor dated.
He was 25.
Case closed, okay?
Done.
He's Peter, she's Wendy.
As a side note, I think this song was originally supposed to be on folklore
but ended up being one of the vault songs mentioned on Guilty as Sin because it was too specific.
The whole song sounds very folklore-esque in my opinion, especially this line.
Moving on to track number two, The One.
To start off this discussion, a little fun fact is that Taylor switched out Invisible String,
which has been declared by fans to be about Joe, from her heiress tour setlist for this song when
she and Joe broke up around the time also that she and Maddie started dating in 2023.
What a funny coincidence.
Let's get into the lyrics.
As we've discussed, they met when they were young in their roaring 20s, so to speak.
The entire premise of the song is just wondering if someone could have been The One.
The same thing as Cardigan, the same thing as a lot of these songs.
She even says...
This line is just the song question summarized.
It's an exact copy.
But let's get into some of the more niche parallels in the song.
She uses a lot of graveyard imagery in her songs about Maddie and,
of course, this song also features that.
She also says...
I think we can all agree that this isn't giving Joe vibes.
However, Maddie did release an album titled A Brief Inquiry Into Online Relationships.
It was after this, but still, one might assume that he's the type to meet a woman on the internet
and take her home.
Taylor also kind of refers to this concept in Chloe or Sam or Sofia or Marcus.
There's also a fun lyrical parallel to the 1975 songs in this one.
Finally, she also references Rosé in this song, which she also does on Maroon,
which I think is about Maddie.
Moving on!
Illicit Affairs is literally about illicit affairs.
It's about being in a committed relationship and having these little
meetings with somebody else.
Sounds a little bit familiar.
There's also another parallel to Question in this one.
Finally, to finish off the folklore album, we have This Is Me Trying.
This one isn't really Maddie-specific, so all we have to go off of is the old Flame vibes.
There's also a lyric that's very similar to the concept of standing in someone's front porch light.
To add on to all of this, she also played the song as a mashup with Labyrinth,
which I think is very telling, since Labyrinth is also widely agreed to be about Maddie.
Moving on to Evermore!
There are a lot more songs about him on this one.
It was wild when I looked back on it.
Starting off, we have Gold Rush.
Once again, this lyric does not seem like it's about Joe, and it confused me when I first heard it,
but it mostly just sounds like it's about Joe.
He often says things that are very much against public opinion,
which is the definition of contrarian.
He's essentially got this kind of unhinged bad boy vibe about him,
which she also talks about in her lyrics on the Torture Post department.
From this lyric, we can conclude that this wasn't someone she was dating at the time,
this was someone she was thinking about.
This is consistent with all the other songs in which she's dreaming about him,
namely Guilty as Sin.
She also says...
This gives off the impression of somebody very high-profile, high-status,
maybe in the celebrity world, and this most definitely matches Maddie.
I didn't notice this lyric at first,
but it ties perfectly with her narrative of Maddie in a lot of other songs.
She keeps referring to the time between 2014 and 2023
as a time where she was kind of seeing Maddie out and about and passing by him.
Also, I know blushing is a fairly common phenomenon, but she says...
which ties back to Maroon.
Next up, we have Ivy, which is just about general themes of infidelity.
The whole song is about being with your current partner,
but having somebody else that you're interested in
and wanting to walk away and being afraid that your partner will find out.
It is very much giving I'm-in-a-long-term-relationship-and-I'm-unhappy vibes.
House of Stone being her current relationship with Joe,
and this isn't reached because she literally called her relationship with him jail.
I don't want to hear it.
We also have hints that she's talking about this person that she met when she was younger.
There's also parallels to Snow on the Beach and Loss of My Life in this song,
which are both about Maddie.
This is just one of those instances where Taylor keeps using kind of the same metaphors
and the same imagery for the same person, and in this case, it's glowing with Maddie.
There's also a grave reference that matches those from earlier,
where Taylor keeps describing her relationship with Maddie as buried.
Moving on to Cowboy Like Me, this one's kind of crazy.
And cowboys like to kind of go out and find new passengers.
My only advice would be like, just be a cowboy.
So be a cowboy.
Coincidentally, Taylor happened to reunite with Maddie at this award show in 2020
after not talking to him for like five years.
Some people also say that she looked a little bit disheveled
and she was most certainly drunk when she accepted her award.
But I have this award and I put it in my kitchen.
I wake up and I've just got this just right in my face.
Point being, it's not that far of a reach to conclude
Taylor might have actually remembered this speech,
since it's the first time she saw him in ages and he was there and she was there in person.
But with that aside, this song is about two con men falling in love.
In The Loss of My Life, Taylor literally calls Maddie a con man.
This song also gives major Twin Flame vibes that we see in the Tortured Poets department.
These are two people that are very alike
and are able to immediately understand each other on a deeper level than everybody else.
This song, once again, is about an old flame.
There also seems to be a very interesting lyrical parallel to Glitch in this song.
In Glitch, it seems that she's finally telling Maddie that she's ready to dance with him,
and I also did an analysis of why Glitch is about Maddie in my recent video.
On Cowboy Like Me, she also gives hints that this relationship will have ramifications for her.
This references the public scrutiny she knows she will face if she enters into this relationship
with him, and this is also a very common theme in her writing about him.
There's also a fun parallel to Fortnite in this song.
Finally, there are some starry-eyed references.
I also want to mention that there's a song that's very stylistically similar
to Cowboy Like Me on the Tortured Poets department that is also about Maddie,
and that is I Can Fix Him, No Really I Can.
It has really western-style acoustics if you look at the intro,
and the lyrics are also very much western-themed.
Moving on to Tis the Damn Season.
This is self-explanatory. Once again, she's wondering what would have happened
with a prior romance in her life if she had continued it.
She also says,
This is once again a nod back to Gold Rush, where she says,
Walk past, quick brush.
We also get a curious sneak peek of what happened with them back in 2014 when she says,
Remember how you watched me leave.
This is a direct parallel to Chloe or Sam or Sofia or Marcus, where she also says,
Chloe or Sam or Sofia or Marcus is set, I think, in the time between
she and Maddie broke up in 2014 and when they got back together in 2023.
Just if you look at the lyrics, it makes sense, but I'll do another video on that.
Finally, the protagonist of Tis the Damn Season also goes off to LA to become famous.
This might reflect Taylor prioritizing her career over Maddie during that time period
because she didn't want to be associated with someone with his reputation.
We're on to the title track, Evermore.
I'm just gonna play a couple lines for the song because I feel like I'm repeating myself.
Huh, this seems familiar. Have we seen this theme anywhere?
This last one is essentially saying that she's writing letters that she can't send,
probably because she's in a relationship and probably because she doesn't know if
that person actually wants her back.
This is also a direct parallel to Fresh Out the Slammer, where she mentions letters as well.
We can definitely interpret letters in this context to mean songs because
she's written a lot of songs about him.
This is another hint that there's a line drawn in the sand with what she can do with this person,
once again because she's in a relationship.
She's thinking of the ramifications of her being in a relationship with this person as well,
both her reputation and throwing her current relationship away.
There's also just a fun lyrical parallel to Goldrush in the song.
There's also a very, very well executed lyrical parallel in I Look in People's Windows,
which I think is set after her relationship with Maddie ended in 2023.
Finally, if you read the poetry that Taylor released along with the Torture Poets department,
you'll know that she says,
Fresh Out the Slammer and Into the Tidal Wave, referring to being fresh out of her
relationship with Joe and right into her tumultuous relationship with Maddie.
And here in Evermore, she happens to say,
which is a very interesting reference to that.
This song also ties back to This Is Me Trying, which we discussed earlier in the video.
She's essentially likening her memories of this person to a film reel.
Now we're once again getting into the territory of very non-specific songs,
but let's just dissect these for a minute.
This song is very difficult to analyze, even just lyrically.
I think she's talking about essentially getting into relationship with someone,
having a very bad history with relationships prior,
and then she thinks this guy is the one, but then somebody passes by.
Which has been a very popular way to reference Maddie and her
kind of brushing past each other all these years,
and also on Down Bad and Snow on the Beach, where she uses a ton of space references
and calling him a UFO or an alien passing by, essentially.
And then she kind of switches on herself in Long Story Short and is falling for this guy instead.
Finally, we have Right Where You Left Me,
and this entire song is about waiting for a previous love.
She also says,
which makes sense for her and Maddie, but I think the song may have been inspired by him,
but it's not necessarily about him.
I think this song is very much just clever story writing.
Before I end this video, I just really quickly want to discuss all of the songs on this album
that aren't about Maddie, but are about her believing and being dissatisfied in a long-term
relationship, and I think these definitely reflect her mental state with Joe at the time,
because she had to be sourcing these from somewhere.
In It's Time to Go, she's essentially saying
that it's time to leave this person that she's been with for a very long time.
In Champagne Problems, she's essentially saying
that she's declining this person's request for marriage and breaking their heart.
That's all I have to say for today. Thank you so much for watching. Please subscribe if you
made it this far, it really helps me out, and I'll also be releasing a video on all
of the Maddie songs, period, on all of her albums soon, so stay tuned for that.
