Since the release of The Tortured Poets Department, people have been speculating about which songs on Taylor Swift's prior albums are about The 1975's Matty Healy...This video summarizes all of the fan theories about which songs on the Midnights album are about Matty based on the lyrics, things they've said onstage, and even their history from way back in 2014.
For this video, I've assumed that Fresh Out The Slammer, Guilty as Sin? My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, But Daddy I Love Him, and other such obvious tracks are about Matty because otherwise this video would be an hour long.
THEORIES. THESE ARE ALL THEORIES. Thanks so much for watching.
Music: –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Upbeat Corporate by JP Bianchini https://jpbianchini.com Creative Commons — Attribution 3.0 Unported — CC BY 3.0 Free Download / Stream: https://bit.ly/upbeat-corporate Music promoted by Audio Library • Upbeat Corporate – JP Bianchini (No C... –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– 🎵 Track Info:
Title: Upbeat Corporate by JP Bianchini Genre and Mood: Cinematic + Inspirational ———––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
Today we're talking about all of the songs on the Midnight's album that definitely are,
or maybe about Maddie Healy, because after the release of the Torch Poets Department,
we definitely need to reanalyze some of these. Midnight's is by far the most unspecific album
Taylor has ever released, and that is definitely for a reason. Before we get into this, let me just
say that I'm going off of the fact that Maddie and Taylor definitely did have something going
on back in 2014, and there's a lot of sources to prove that. Now let's dive right into it,
and let's start off with Snow on the Beach. First off, all of the space references on the song
directly parallel a very specific song from the Torch Poets Department, but we'll get into that
a bit later. Based on all of the other space references in the song, we can assume that
Taylor is essentially saying that she saw flashing lights in the sky, or in other words, a UFO.
Here, she's likening the person that she's singing the song about to the UFO that she
saw in the sky. This is very reminiscent of her relationship with Maddie before 2023,
they just kept hearing about and seeing each other randomly throughout the years.
Now if we briefly divert our attention to a song on the Torch Poets Department,
the whole premise of Down Bad is an alien essentially coming down from the sky,
showing Taylor a whole new world, and then leaving.
Not only does this reflect what happened with her and Maddie in 2023, this feels like a direct sequel
and to further corroborate the UFO theory, she literally says,
But let's assume this isn't enough of a hint and analyze the lyrics. Throughout the song,
she keeps repeating,
This very much gives the vibes of what she would have been feeling towards Maddie
during the recording of the Midnight's album. She's daydreaming about an old fling,
which is weird, but in a sense it's also kind of romantic.
How do we know that she's daydreaming about this person?
Well, the entire lyrics of the song.
She's faking this relationship until she makes it, or pretending that it's happening until it
actually happens. She also doesn't even dare to wish it, probably because it's forbidden,
and she might be in another relationship.
Finally, there's also a kind of weird lyric in this, which says,
This is a very random thing to put in a song, but I feel like this may have been left
as a clue for Maddie of an interaction that they had like over text while she was still dating Joe.
Moving on to Question. Now, I'm going to start off this discussion by simply playing you a clip
of Taylor introducing Question in May of 2023, which was two weeks after it was announced that
she and Maddie were dating, and he also flew like 20 hours to see a bunch of her shows.
It's not just the tour, it's like, I don't know, I just sort of feel like
my life finally feels like it makes sense. And um, so I thought I'd play this song,
uh, which brings me really a lot of happy memories.
Another bit of lore here is that this song was also added to the 1975's pre-show playlist in
beginning of 2023, which is an interesting thing to note. Finally, we're going to go on just a
little bit of a reach here, but it's okay. In the song About You by the 1975, which Maddie
has confirmed on stage is about Taylor, just as she has done with Cardigan.
He asks continually,
And she starts off Question by saying,
But let's dive into the lyrics.
This implies that the song is about an old flame that she had something going on with,
but then it ended, and now she keeps searching for what they had. Furthermore, the theme of the song
is just wanting to ask this old flame a question, and the question is, were you slash are you still
interested?
The entire chorus of the song just seems like a bunch of very specific situations that happened
with exactly one person, but they're so specific that only that one person would know. This is a
very common theme on Midnight's. But to analyze the verses of the song, we're gonna have to get
kind of deep into the 2014 Maddie and Taylor lore. To briefly summarize, Taylor was going out to a
bunch of 1975 shows, they were wearing each other's t-shirts, and they were also rumored to hang out
afterwards a lot after these shows. Of course, the press caught on to this and immediately published
a bunch of articles about them dating. Then Maddie essentially got scared that they got his name
wrong and posted this tweet, and then the day after this, he was rumored to be just absolutely losing
it crying on stage. After this, their contact with each other kind of stopped, and the next time that
they saw each other was a few months later at the Brit Awards after party, where Taylor also
happened to meet Calvin Harris, and Taylor and Calvin started dating. Throughout the years, Maddie
kept getting asked about Taylor, but the narrative shifted from they didn't date to they kind of had
a thing, but they couldn't date because Maddie was scared of the whole new level of stardom that
surrounded her. All the press attention, all the bodyguards. At one point, he said dating her would
be emasculating, and it was taken out of context, and it was a whole big thing that he had to
apologize for. Now, if we go back to the lyrics of Question, the line,
begins to make a whole lot more sense. Additionally, the lines right before this say,
Could this be talking about the Brit Awards after party,
where Maddie literally had to watch Taylor go out with some dickhead guy?
These lines also start to make a lot more sense and are also very telling. She's referring to
them as children, essentially, that were naive and made the wrong choices. This is the theme
that's also present in some songs on the Tortured Poets department. Moving on to Maroon.
Does Joe seem like the type to have incense on his vinyl shelf? Do any of these people really
seem like the type? I don't think so. I think that's more of a Maddie thing, but once again,
that's just me. This song is also about an old flame, and she also says,
This line mirrors a lot of the songs on the Tortured Poets department that portray her and
Maddie as sort of having this twin best friend connection where they both write songs and are
very similar as people. Now, where on the Tortured Poets department did we get a Maroon reference?
That's right, in Chloe or Sam or Sofia or Marcus.
If it weren't for this reference, I wouldn't be sure that the song is about Maddie, but if we
look at the lyrics of this as well, this is just a dead giveaway. The entire song is essentially
just a clone of Question.
This song has the same exact themes of meeting someone when she was younger,
when she was naive, and things not working out. She even says decade, and she and Maddie met in
2014 and she released this album in 2024. She also keeps saying,
This is the same premise as in Question where she keeps asking this person if they're still
interested. Moving on to Glitch, this song doesn't reek of Maddie quite as much as the other ones,
but I want to bring your attention to a very specific line.
How long is 2190 days? It is exactly six years. Now, a lot of people seem to think that this
lyric references Taylor and Joe because they dated for six years. People seem to forget that
Midnight's was released back in October of 2022, and Taylor and Joe started dating in September of
2016. This means that out of the two years that she was writing Midnight's, the song would have
had to be written like a month before its official release date. If you look at Maddie and Taylor's
timeline, they had their fling around the end of 2014 plus six years, that's the end of 2020,
when Evermore was released, which is, I think, much more realistic since the recording process
and all the promo takes months to plan. But stepping away from the math a little bit,
she says it's been this many days of their love blackout. Now, this could be interpreted in
multiple different ways, but mainly just their love failing. A blackout is a failure of something.
And this makes sense with Maddie and Taylor's relationship because they weren't dating,
their love wasn't being actualized in this period of six years. But with Joe and Taylor,
it seems like she had this honeymoon phase when she first started dating him, and then over the
years their love just sort of went downhill. It would be brutal and also inaccurate to describe
these six years as a total blackout of love. Additionally, it looks like the song is about
an old flame as well. I was supposed to sweat you out. This doesn't give the vibes of her and
Joe's relationship. I don't think she was trying to sweat him out, whereas with an old flame,
you definitely would want to get rid of those old feelings. Furthermore, she says we were supposed
to be just friends. Maybe this means London because she moved to London to be with Joe
and coincidentally Maddie is also from the UK and lived in London for a time,
so that could be referencing that. This also very much mirrors the theme of Snow on the Beach where
she says she's kind of seeing this person out and about once in a while, and here she says
maybe I'll see you out some weekend. Moving on to Hits Different, this song once again is just
about an old flame. She says
we also have Taylor fantasizing a bunch in this.
She also ends up asking
you which I think very much mirrors her emotional state at the start of the Tortured Poets
Department and I think it's very reminiscent of just like going insane when you're daydreaming
about someone while in a relationship with someone else. She also mentions Ken's which
I just think is a very fun parallel to My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys on Tortured Poets
Department. I'll admit this song doesn't really have any very Maddie specific lyrics except maybe
I don't really imagine her getting drunk in a bar over Maddie while she was with Joe.
So this must have happened earlier in time and she did say that
But there is enough non-specificity for this to be about someone else.
Moving on to Paris, we have one lyric that really sums up the message of the song really well.
The entire song is about a romance that Taylor has kept private and hid from the
public and the media and at the same time she used this romance as an escape.
Let the only flashing lights be the tower at midnight references the paparazzi and she also
says that they're levitating above all the messes they made which means essentially that they're
While this song may be about another fling that Taylor sort of hid from the public,
I'm sure there's been some of those that we don't know about, I think this is about Maddie.
In songs that are very clearly about him on Tortured Poets Department and even on this
album she keeps highlighting kind of their reputations and the media so it makes sense
for her to write the song about them. Maddie is also like one of the few people that she keeps
writing these fantasizing songs about both on Midnight and Tortured Poets Department so I
really think he was the only one that she was obsessed enough with to write this.
Moving on to our last case study, Bejeweled. Now this song is interesting.
It's about being in a relationship that you're not satisfied with and wanting to go out.
Who was she kept in lockdown with? It was Jo.
This whole song is just very reminiscent of what she was saying about her relationship
with Jo in the songs on the Tortured Poets Department.
She made Jo her whole world when she moved to London for him.
Now where am I going with this? The song is about Jo, what are you talking about?
Well, when she says
I think it would be really funny if this was referring to the 1975. That's all I wanted to
say about the song. Thanks for watching, that's all I have for you today and let me know if you
want me to do Folklore and Evermore as well or release a video that I have that literally goes
through every single song about Maddie on every single one of her albums. Please subscribe if you
made it this far and also follow my Twitter because I post a lot of fun little lyric things on there.