I put the entirety of TTPD in chronological order

The Song Decoder
12 followers
12 Video Views·Apr 15, 2025
Here's all of the songs on Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology based on when I think she wrote all 31 tracks! These are just theories :)
Welcome! Today we're going to be putting the entirety of the Torture Poets Department album
in chronological order based on when I think Taylor wrote these songs. I'm doing this for
this album in particular because every one of these songs is just so, well almost every one
of them, is so incredibly specific that it is actually possible to do this. Without further
ado, let's get started. So first over here I have the entirety of the 31 tracks from the Torture
Poets Department and Torture Poets Department the Anthology, and over to the right I've just built
a little timeline. So first we have her relationship with Joe Alwyn, of course,
then that ends and almost immediately she moves on to Maddie Healy. Then the public finds out
about Maddie Healy, which causes a bunch of public outlash. Then very quickly, actually,
they break up and then the public finds out about that again. And then here in kind of the post
Maddie era I've also put a little dash for the Maddie heartbreak gets somewhat better,
but Taylor's just still really mad at the press because they've just took this narrative and kept
on going with. And then after all this happens, of course, we have her relationship with Travis
Kelsey, who she's with now. And of course, since this is a Taylor Swift album, I felt obliged to
put a this could have been written in 2014 and I wouldn't know box because there's some songs that
are still just so unspecific or aren't even about like a real event. Also, for anybody that doesn't
know the whole thing with Maddie Healy is that she was with him back in 2014 and she kept apparently
fantasizing about him as we see in many of these songs throughout the years until she finally broke
up with Joe and got back together with him. Continuing that train of thought for our first
song fortnight. Now, this is a difficult one because I feel like at first everybody was like,
oh, a fortnight. She was with Maddie Healy in 2023 for like barely any time. She must be talking
about their relationship. And I agree, but I think she here she's actually talking about their
relationship back all the way back in 2014. Now, when could this have been written? I'm going to
put it I'm going to put it right over like right in here. So during the time that she was with
Why do I think that is? Well, a lot of people have pointed out that the styles of the music video,
just the style of the song in general, point to the fact that this might have actually been
written with Maddie Healy. And Post Malone is literally just like a stand in for him. That's
a very popular theory. And honestly, I kind of believe it. So I'm gonna put this here.
But if we look at the lyrics, this is definitely about them kind of running into each other over
the years after they're fling in 2014, because she says she runs into him sometimes asks about
the weather, you know, and they share a lot of common friends. They were at award shows,
etc. This is not I'm not I'm not determining the meaning of all these songs. Well, I'm
I kind of am but it's okay. Let's move on. Let's move on to the tortured poets department.
Also, definitely about Maddie the whole like typewriter aesthetic vibe, but here she's kind
of like making fun of him for liking typewriters. You know, the whole song is giving like you are
trying to get out of this relationship a little bit, or you're like putting spikes down on the
road, but I still want to stay with you. So this has to be somewhere around, I'd say like here,
because this has to be the point where things like towards the end of their relationship where
things start going a little bit south. And Taylor's like, I like I see that and I'm still
gonna stick with it. Like that's the feel like that's the vibe of the song. Moving on to my
boy only breaks his favorite toys. In this song, she's still with Maddie, but I feel like this is
like tortured poets department part two, where she's like, dang, things are going like really,
really not well. So I think I'm gonna put that like after the tortured poets department. Like
the tortured poets department, she says, but you awaken with dread pounding nails in your head.
But she's like, you know what, it's okay, I'll calm you down. And then in my boy only breaks
his favorite toys. She's like, oh, here we go again, the voices in his head. So she's kind of
like, she's over it. And she says there was a litany of reasons why we could have played for
keeps this time, which both confirms that this is alluding to Maddie, because she says this time,
there was a time before this in 2014. But also, this is like the verge of the breakup or like,
during the breakup, or I think in the period where she's like, we're definitely gonna break
up. Anyway, this is after tortured poets department, like right, right there. The next track
is down bad. And the whole concept of this is like aliens pick this girl up from the sky,
and then show her a whole new world and then leave. And that's what Taylor said this concept
was kind of about. And who does that sound like it's about? It sounds like it's about Maddie.
So this is just going to be after the breakup. And I think this was like, almost the first or
one of the first songs she must have written about it. Because she was like, what the hell
just happened? Did you really pick me up in a cloud of sparkling dust? You know what I mean?
So I'm gonna put this before public finds out again, just because I think she was just like,
dumbfounded here. I'm just gonna put it here. The next song is so long London. This one's
obviously about Joe. We're just gonna we're not gonna discuss this that much. We're gonna put it
like, yeah, she's talking about this could have been written when she was with him. It could be
written like, right around the time of breakup. I'm just gonna put it like, right,
genuinely right here. Next up is, but daddy, I love him. This I think everyone agrees it was
written to the as a response to kind of the public outlash that her relationship with Maddie Healey
received. So we're just gonna put it right here on the public finds out. Okay, she was going crazy.
She was like, literally, I'd tell you something right now. I'd rather burn my whole life down
than listen to one more second of all this bitching and moaning. I think this is also
a commentary on all of her relationships as a whole, and like the public scrutinizing those,
but especially especially Maddie Healey. Here I have the image from yeah, the fans wrote like an
open letter to Taylor Swift in order to get her to stop dating Maddie Healey, which is just
ridiculous. I would write the song to a much trashier version, but still, if people do that
to me. Next up is fresh out of the slammer. The slammer in this case, I think pretty obviously
and widely agreed upon is Joe. And then the person who she's running back home to is Maddie. She says
now pretty baby, I'm running back home to you fresh out the slammer. I know who my first call
will be too. I think it's very hard to interpret the song any other way, especially because she
says, as I said in my letters, now that I know better, I will never lose my baby again. As she
said in her letters, or maybe her songs, she won't lose Maddie again like she did in 2014.
She's coming out of a long relationship that felt like jail to someone that she's been with prior.
That said, we're going to put fresh out the slammer right here in its rightful place right
after so long, London. Now at this point, I want you to know that we've covered the leaving Joe
and getting back together with Maddie territory. We've covered the public scrutiny that Maddie and
Taylor's relationship faced. We've also covered a little bit of kind of their relationship going
wrong. We have a whole two songs about like the progress of that. We also have a song about their
past kind of fortnight. So really what is missing here from the timeline that a regular relationship
takes? We don't have a singular honeymoon song about her and Maddie. And Taylor loves writing
these songs. Like this was legitimately like 80% of lover where all of the songs were just about
this honeymoon phase where she's obsessed with this person that she's with and everything's going
really great. Point being, I just like you to think about this a little bit and keep it in mind as we
move on to discussing future songs. Because once again, isn't it so strange that the person she's
daydreamed about for 10 years doesn't have a honeymoon song dedicated to them? Anyway, moving
on to Florida. Florida's a difficult one because people were like, oh my god, what happened in
Florida, you know? But in an interview, Taylor said it wasn't about anything specific, any specific
event that happened in that state. It was just kind of following the concept of the Florida man,
who we have an image of right here. But anyway, the concept of the Florida man was that people
kind of go to Florida after they commit heinous crimes to kind of start a new life and cover up
their past wrongdoings, which is the emotional state that she was in when she was writing this
song. Now, when would she be in such an emotional state that she would literally want to just like
throw her entire life away and go start a new life in another state? Was it after she broke up with
Joe? I don't think so, because she went straight on to Maddie and seemed really happy about that.
Was it when the public found out about her and Maddie and everyone was like, Taylor, what are
you doing in a really not polite way? I don't think so, because she was in her but daddy I love
him mood. She was like, I don't care about any of these people, I just want you. That was the
vibe that we were getting. Now, after her breakup with Maddie, she was dealing with this person that
she has been romanticizing for about a decade, just up and leave. He essentially ghosted her
based on her lyrics. So she was dealing with that. And then on top of all of that, the public found
out again and started kind of scrutinizing these two breakups that she'd had in a really short
period of time. And she was kind of forced to deal with the fact that this person that she went so
quickly public with just kind of embarrassed her in front of everybody by leaving. And honestly, at
that point, I'd want to move to Florida. Okay, I think the song was inspired by kind of this moment
of just the public finding out. It doesn't really make sense to put it really anywhere else on the
timeline. For the record, she like literally says in the song, I need to forget so take me to Florida.
Next up is guilty as sin where Taylor's in a relationship with somebody, but she's fantasizing
another person and she's asking like, is this okay? Am I guilty as sin? I think we all agree that this
is kind of what she was thinking while she was in her relationship with Joe. So I'm just gonna put
this right around here. I'm gonna leave Who's Afraid of Little Old Me alone for now and we're
gonna plug it into the timeline a bit later because I feel like this one is just like really, really
unspecific. So we're gonna move on to the next one for now. But he's just gonna, the ghostie is
just gonna chill out over here. Now moving on to I Can Fix Him, No Really I Can. This is the denial
stage song of her being with Maddie. Maddie is known for causing controversies and overall not
really thinking before he speaks. And this is exactly the kind of character that this person
details. She says the smoke cloud billows out his mouth like a freight train through a small town,
which is not only a reference to trains, which the band that Maddie is part of, the 1975, really often
uses in their songs, but it's saying that first of all he smokes, which Maddie does smoke, and
second of all can be used as a metaphor for someone that is just a loud mouth. She also says that her
friends are like God help her when she tells him that he's her man, which I think explains the
whole theme of the song essentially. So we're gonna put this one right between Torture Codes Department
and My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys because I think My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys was
like kind of the the pinnacle of realizing that this was going wrong. In I Can Fix Him, for a
like, no no no, trust like I can make this better. But in My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, she's
like it's it's it's dumb. Moving on to Loss Slash Love of My Life. This is an especially difficult
one because I too have a hard time believing that Taylor didn't write a song called Loss of My Life
about Joe Alwyn, who she was with for six years. But if you look at the lyrics of Lommel, this does
not point to Joe at all. She asks, who's gonna stop us from waltzing back into rekindled flames
if we know the steps anyway? This seems like someone that she's broken up with prior that
she wants to get back together with. Now, all signs point to the fact that this was not her state
of mind when she broke up with Joe. It seems that with Joe, she knew the breakup was coming from like
a mile away and she had essentially already said her goodbyes. Like, she tried to save the
relationship but didn't work out. After her breakup with Joe, it doesn't seem like there's
potential for, you know, rekindling flames. But with Maddie, it seems like she was left absolutely
befuddled by him leaving and didn't really get to say any goodbyes. She literally wrote so many songs
that we're going to get into later about not believing that it's really over. So this lyric
definitely seems like it pertains to Maddie. And then the next line after this, we embroider the
memories of the time I was away, stitching we were just kids, babe. This is literally about an old
flame that she had when she was younger. Please, like, correct me if I'm wrong about this, but
explain to me how on earth this lyric is meant to pertain to Joe. Finally, to cement this, she says
at the end of the song, what a valiant roar, what a bland goodbye. And I think this kind of perfectly
encapsulates the ending of her relationship with Maddie because it was such a big deal when they
first got together, but it was a really bland goodbye in the sense that he just left, he ghosted
her based on her lyrics. Maybe she wrote this about both of them, sourcing from both of these
relationships, I don't know. But given these lines that definitely pertain to Maddie, I'm gonna put
this after, like, Public finds out again, like, in the grieving stage of this. Next up is I Can Do It
With a Broken Heart. This is, I think, this was written definitely when Taylor was feeling a lot
better because this is so... she was still sad, but, like, I don't think you could write this song while,
like, in the trenches, while, like, what am I doing with my life? Like, where did this person go? You
know what I mean? So I'm gonna put this right before, like, for now, I'm gonna put this right before
Travis, yeah. And then the next one is The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived, and in it she says,
I don't want you back, I just want to know if ruining my sparkling summer was the goal. And
maybe this isn't true, maybe she still wants him back, but, like, this attitude of, you know what,
it's fine, I don't need him back, I'm just still really mad. Though I think this, we can put this
right before I Can Do It With a Broken Heart when she was, when she was feeling, like, better.
Because if you compare this song to what is being said in Lommel, I think there was, there was
definitely a period of time between these two songs, between going just, I lost the love of my
life to I don't even want you back, you know what I mean? Okay, moving on to The Alchemy. Remember when I
said we didn't really have a honeymoon song about Maddie? Well, I'm gonna come back to that, hear me
out on this one. Because the football references in The Alchemy, everybody knows about those. They're,
they're there, they're bright and clear, and they all point to Travis Kelsey, who Taylor is dating
now, who is a football player. Now a common theory that has risen up and that I believe with all of
my heart is that these football references were thrown in, like, as a last-minute resort to have,
like, some songs on the album be about Travis. Because if you really look at the underlying
lyrics, this entire, the entirety of this song just points to Maddie. She says, what if I told
Now she's coming out of something like the hospital, something like a jail, something like a
long-term relationship, you know, and circling this person on a map. Did she circle Travis on a map?
No, she just met him. But with Maddie, she was like, I know where I'm going right after this
relationship with Joe. So I really think this lyric is referring to him. And if we look at the later
ones, this becomes, like, abundantly clear. Because she says,
which means she had a relationship with this person when she was younger, and now she's coming
back. Like, these lyrics make absolutely no sense if you think about them in, like, from the Travis
perspective. Like, the sign on your heart says it's still reserved for me. Did Travis reserve his
heart for her? No. Did Maddie? Yes. Okay, game over. That was a funny one. Anyway, we're moving
the alchemy to as the designated honeymoon song for Maddie. Please, once again, prove to me that
song is about Travis. I'm open to suggestions, but it just, like, to me, it doesn't seem like it.
We're gonna leave Clara Bao alone for now. We're gonna put her right next to Who's Afraid of Little
Old Me, because she's a little bit unspecific, too. And we're gonna move on to The Black Dog.
In The Black Dog, she's singing about how this person that she's broken up with, or actually
gotten broke up with, which is more the vibe from the lyrics, is walking into this bar called The
Black Dog, but they didn't turn off their location, so she can see it. And then she's like, I just
don't understand how you don't miss me in The Black Dog. This, to me, implies that this was, once
again, a breakup song written about Maddie, because we're really getting the vibe that she really
didn't understand why he broke up with her. And to finish it off, she says, when someone plays
the starting line and you jump up, but she's too young to know this song, the starting line is a
band that Maddie and the 1975 have sampled, and it's one of their favorites, and that just kind
of confirms it for me. So we're gonna put The Black Dog, for now, like, in the in the Lommel
space, you know? Like, right next to it, for now, because that's that's essentially the same vibe.
She's like, damn, I want this person back. Next up, on a slightly different subject, is I'm Gonna Get
You Back, which is essentially a song about not knowing whether you're angry with a person, or not
knowing whether you want to marry them, as she says in the lyrics, but really just being convinced that
you're gonna get them back. She also says that this person drove her into a ditch like an Aston
Martin, so I'm gonna go with the popular theory that the song is, once again, about Maddie, but I
think this was at the very beginning of their breakup, where she was like, you know what, I'm,
I am mad at you, you know, but I still want you back. And that is going right before Down Bad.
As we get into the anthology, we're gonna skip, skip a few more songs. So The Albatross, we're
gonna put right along with the, our little collection of non-specific ones, right on top,
we're gonna place those later, and we're gonna move on to Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus,
which you might think is unspecific, but if you look at the lyrics, it is actually very specific.
She literally says, as the decade would play us for fools, and you saw my bones out with somebody
new, you just watched it happen. The decade is the key here. She and Maddie have been kind of orbiting
around each other for around a decade. There's a bunch of clues in the song to this being about
Maddie. She also, on the theme of kind of this being an old relationship, says, if you want to
break my cold, cold heart, just say I loved you the way that you were, meaning she was different
when she originally met this person, and that's true, she met him when she was way younger.
We also have, I changed it into goddesses, villains, and fools, all to outrun the desertion of you.
I saw a fun theory about this being about her three albums, which were 1989, goddesses,
reputation, villains, and fools, lover, kind of being these eras that she went through while she
wasn't with him. And finally, the first line, which is a bit puzzling, she says, your hologram
stumbled into my apartment, hands in the hair of somebody in darkness, like Chloe or Sam or
Sophie or Marcus, and I just watched it happen. I also am for the theory that this is about
Maddie kind of kissing a bunch of his fans at shows, which he does, but this then
gets spread online, and she was probably essentially seeing these videos throughout
the years of him doing that. And what is meant by a hologram here is just him on her phone screen,
because as he's like a really popular star, she now has to face this phenomenon of him haunting
her online, just like her past lovers are probably haunted by her media presence literally everywhere.
So okay, that being said, I think this was written like while she was with Joe, because in this song
she doesn't say anything about him actually appearing after all that time. She kind of, it
sounds almost like she's giving up on him doing so. So I'm gonna put this before Guilty as Sin.
I'm gonna put this like way back, and you'll see what I mean. Actually, I'm just gonna, like, this
song is like a sister song, I think, to Peter. So I'm just gonna do Peter now. Peter is very much
the same type of vibe, and nobody can convince me that Peter is not about Maddie, because it says
literally everything that is said in Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus, but in a much more specific
manner. She keeps saying, you said you were gonna grow up, and then you were gonna come find me,
which is like, okay, she's talking about someone from her past that she wants to reunite with, and
then she says, you said you were gonna come get me, but you were 25. Maddie was literally 25 during
their brief little fling in 2014, and the song indicates that they kind of made each other this
promise of coming back for each other, but it didn't end up working out. But at the end of the
song, she also says, like, forgive me, Peter, but the woman who sits at the window has turned out the
light, which is a reference to Wendy, of course, sitting out the window, but also indicates that
Taylor is, like, done waiting for him, which is why I think this song was once again written, like,
while she was with Joe. I don't think this was written before she was with Joe, because that
would be both too far back for the, for placing something on this album, and also because this
sounds like, really just sounds like a reject from folklore, that she was like, I can't put this on
the album because this is too specific, but I'm gonna save it for later, because Peter Pan is also
mentioned in folklore, and, like, in closets like Cedar just seems like a folklore lyric. Anyway,
my point being, we're gonna put this, like, yeah, we're gonna put this as the first song. This was
written, like, way back when, I think. Moving on to How Did It End, I think this was definitely
written more so about her, the end of her relationship with Joe, rather than her relationship
with Maddie, because there's a lot of references to this relationship kind of dying slowly over
time. She says, we were blind to unforeseen circumstances, we learned the right steps to
different dances, whereas with her songs about Maddie, she tends to kind of blame Maddie more
for this. And then she also says, my beloved ghost and me, sitting in a tree, d-y-i-n-g,
like, their relationship slowly dying over time, and Joe essentially being a ghost by the end of
it, and not really being into the relationship, as we see in So Long London. There's also a line
that kind of cements this for me in the first couple verses. She says, he was a hothouse flower
to my outdoorsman, which a hothouse flower is basically, like, kind of a cage for plants, and
plants are grown in hothouses. So she's essentially saying that he wanted to stay inside while she
wanted to go out and about, which is very true of her relationship with Joe, who seemed like
he just wanted to stay inside and not go out in the public eye. I think this could have been
written at the same time as So Long London, but based on the lyrics, I'm just gonna put it, like,
right a little bit after it, so between So Long London and Fresh Off The Slammer. Moving on to
So High School, which is really a different theme from the previous tracks. High school vibes, I like
this person, I feel like I'm back in high school, because he makes me nervous and such. And so, I,
because of the lack of Travis songs on this album, really, I'm just gonna designate this as a Travis
song. You know, I have a hard time believing that she didn't write any about him, so I'm just gonna
put it here. Taylor in her Heiress Tour performances, as well, kind of designates this as a Travis song.
So, I'm gonna put it, I'm gonna put it here. I'm gonna put it as the last one. Okay, moving on to I
Hate It Here. This is pretty self-explanatory. This isn't really, this is not specific, this isn't
about a person, this is just about a state of mind, and where, when would Taylor, you know, really hate
it here? I think this was written after Lawmall and The Black Dog and that assortment of songs,
where she was just kind of grieving Maddie in particular, and it probably moved on to just,
damn, this sucks in general. But she kind of probably exhausted her writing about him, so she
just wrote this one. I'm gonna put it after Lawmall for now. This is kind of, I think, a sister to
Florida, but a much more calm one, you know what I mean? So, maybe this was, maybe this was after
Florida? But no, I feel like she would have written all these Maddie songs first, before being like,
I hate it here. I'm gonna put it after Lawmall. I'm gonna, I'm gonna stick with that. Now, the
Kim song. If you didn't know the capitalized letters spelled Kim, this is about Kim. I, I'm
gonna, like, I'm gonna go right ahead and put this in the, this could have been written in 2014,
and I wouldn't know, box. Because it could have, it could have, maybe not, because of the poetic
language, but it sure as hell, I have no idea where to put this. Okay, this is gonna, this is
gonna stay in the box. I Look in People's Windows is the next one. The whole message of the song is,
she wants to see this person one more time. She says, what if your eyes looked up and met mine
one more time? And that's why she's looking through people's windows. Once again, I don't
think this was her attitude towards Joe at the end of their relationship. I think she was done
with it. And also, she says, I'm afflicted by the not knowing so, which means she doesn't really,
she's, this has such an impact on her, because she doesn't know what could have happened. And I think
that makes sense with Maddie, because he ended it suddenly, and she still doesn't know, to this day,
what would have happened with them if it had kept going. So we're gonna, actually, we're gonna slide
I Hate It Here over, because we've stuck with the narrative that this was written after all the
I Miss Maddie songs. So we're gonna, we're gonna stick that in there. Once again, these are, these
are theories, right? But I feel like this is, we have a pretty solid order going on so far.
Next up is The Prophecy. The Prophecy is a really, it's really interesting, lyrically. But it's
essentially saying, like, in its essence, that Taylor still hasn't found a life partner. And it's kind
of her prophecy. Like, she's like, maybe this isn't meant for me. Maybe because of her reputation and
her status, you know, it's really difficult finding someone. And she's just had these two failed
breakups. And she's like, please don't let this be the prophecy. Like, please let me find someone.
At least that's what I took from the song. And so I think this is, like, this could be before or after
I Hate It Here. Once again, after she's exhausted her song writing about Maddie, she kind of moves
on a little bit to other topics. I think maybe this was written, actually, before I Hate It Here,
because she was, like, sad about not being able to, like, really find a good relationship with
anybody. And then after that came just, like, damn, I hate it here. I'm gonna go with that.
And then the next one, oh man, we have, like, a series of fun ones. Let's just, let's just discuss
all of these, honestly. Because these are, we have the most confusing ones left. Let's go, let's go
back to the albatross. Because it's giving really the same kind of vibes as the prophecy. Because
the albatross is a traditional, like, mythical sign of luck. But then the legend goes that if a
sailor shoots an albatross, now it becomes, like, a bad omen. And in this song, she's comparing
herself to this albatross. In third person, she says she's the albatross. She is here to destroy
you. And then in, I think, the last couple, yeah, in the last couple verses, she says I'm the
albatross. I'm here to destroy you. And to me, I think this is a take on her, like, reputation and
how it impacts her relationship with men that she's with being, having been warned about her
reputation with guys in the press. And also about what it kind of takes to be with a person who's at
that caliber of fame, you know. Because it must also be quite difficult having your name in the
headlines once you're also with Taylor Swift. So just because of this theme that's going on here,
I think this probably was written right after the prophecy. Because it's the same kind of theme,
except now she's, like, essentially blaming herself for this prophecy that she won't find
someone. Which is really sad, actually. That's, that's really unfortunate. Let's move on to
Cassandra. So Cassandra is essentially named after Cassandra of Troy, who could see the future
and was at the same time cursed to never be believed by those around her. So she warned
Troy about the Trojan horse, apparently, but they didn't, like, nobody believed her and the people
in the Trojan horse were killed. And so she's once again kind of comparing herself to Cassandra.
And she says, so they filled my cell with snakes. Which is, like, many people online have discussed
this, and I think the conclusion everyone has come to is that she's referring to her literal
cell phone being filled with snake emojis. Which is what happened back in 2014 with the whole
Kim Kanye drama. And this is, this is essentially about that. This is about nobody believing her
and, yeah, etc, etc. I'm actually gonna make a new category. I'm gonna put Thank You Amy and
Cassandra way before Joe. Because even though they were probably written while she was with him,
she was just taking inspiration from whenever this happened, the Kim drama. Like, was it 2016,
2015, 2014, one of those. Anyway, we're gonna put this all the way back here for clarity's sake.
Now we're gonna, we're gonna look at Who's Afraid of Little Old Me. In an interview,
Taylor, it says that Taylor revealed that she wrote the tune alone sitting at a piano in one
of those moments when I felt bitter about all the things that we do to our artists as a society
and as a culture. Now there's several, like, events that could have inspired this. She could
have taken inspiration from, like, the Kim Kanye drama, but that wasn't really about, like, her as
an artist. She could have taken inspiration from just literally anything. Like, there's a lot of
around her every day. Or she could have written this kind of in response to the drama surrounding
her and Maddie dating and everybody scrutinizing her. I don't, this could have been written while
she's with, she was with Joe. But I'm gonna, like, assume, I'm gonna assume that this was written,
like, in her I'm really sad phase following Maddie. Because we have the prophecy and the
albatross which kind of touch on the concept of her reputation just ruining it for everybody.
And also I hate it here where she's just straight up I hate it here. So I think it makes sense for
Who's Afraid of Little Old Me to kind of emerge after that where she kind of turns this and kind
of turns it into an anger which can we can also see in The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived. I'm trying
to, like, sort them by mood because that's all we have to go off of. And so we have this sad period
and then we kind of have these kind of angry songs like Who's Afraid of Little Old Me and
The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived. Moving on to, let's see, like, Clara Bao is a really interesting
song because it's about Clara Bao who was an actress that had to make the transition from
silent film to talking films. And she survived but the essence of this is, like, artists have
to keep reinventing themselves and have to keep the public entertained and keep up with all the
trends or they're just gonna be cast away and forgotten. And that's how Taylor feels actually
a lot of the time it seems because she also brought this up in Nothing New which is a song
on the Red album. But anyway, point being the song is about that. It's kind of about her reputation
and so I'm gonna put it right after I hate it here and between Who's Afraid of Little Old Me
because she's still kind of in Who's Afraid of Little Old Me she's kind of she's kind of mad now
but Clara Bao just has this kind of vibe to it that she's kind of just giving in and giving up.
So in terms of, like, matching songs by mood I think it it fits well there. And also I just saw
that I have this marked as Maddie Heartbreak gets somewhat better but she's still mad at the press.
Once again Clara Bao and Who's Afraid of Little Old Me kind of really makes sense in this scenario
because I think The Sun was releasing some wild stuff like oh Maddie and Taylor are back together
a couple months after they broke up and weren't showing literally any signs of getting back
together so that might have inspired one or two of these. Okay moving on to we only have three left
let's put The Manuscript somewhere. The Manuscript is I couldn't figure out what this was about for
the longest time but I think from reading various reddit threads online that this is a song that
essentially just looks back on this chapter or just like on her whole life in general and kind
of closes off this chapter of her life as well. A manuscript is like a handwritten book essentially
and the theme of the Tortured Poets Department is almost like she's writing kind of a post-mortem
analysis of all these things that have happened to her. The last lines of the manuscript are
the only thing that's left is the manuscript one last souvenir from my trip to your shores
now and then I reread the manuscript but the story isn't mine anymore and this was also kind
of the sentiment of the Tortured Poets Department poetry that she released that was saying that this
chapter in the poet's life is now closed and available for all of us to read so I think this was
written after Maddie and all this public scrutiny that happened both with both of her relationships
but I do think this must have been written like before at least so high school yeah we're gonna
put it before so high school but after I can do it with a broken heart just because I can do with a
broken heart I feel like was written as a high like literally as a hype song for Taylor herself
she was like dang I'm really sad I need something to hype me up and I think this was what did it
and actually looking back on that I think I'm gonna switch I can do it with a broken heart and
the smallest man who ever lived because the smallest man who ever lived just like the manuscript
kind of seemed like she's closing this chapter in her life but I can do it with a broken heart
just seems like she was trying to make herself feel better and apparently it worked you know so
good for her um so we have the bolter and robin left the bolt I think this is about a fictional
person and it's about somebody having this trauma from their childhood that they now run from all
their relationships and I don't think Taylor like does that I don't think Taylor's written
about her personally doing that so I'm gonna go and put that in the in this box of shame this
could have been written in 2014 and I wouldn't know actually this probably could have been
written in during the folklore era to be more specific and I wouldn't know and then the last
song we have is robin which is essentially about preserving the innocence of a young child more
specifically Aaron Dessner's son who's really young who we have a picture of Taylor with here
is named Robin so I think everyone agrees that the song was kind of a tribute to him and I'm also
gonna put this in this could have been written in well not in 2014 because I don't think that
his son was born back then but you know what I mean you know I don't know when this was written
and that's that's it for today folks I think we have put this in order some people are definitely
going to disagree with me on this and that's okay that's fine you can I can probably look back on
this in a couple weeks and say damn what was I thinking you know some of these are really out
of order but you know we'll never know so I hope you enjoyed the video if you've made it this far
please consider joining and supporting the channel these videos do take quite a lot of time to make
as a member you'll get access to all sorts of exclusive perks such as priority comment replies
early access to videos the spotify playlist that I make to go along with all of my videos I'm gonna
go make one for this one right now and you'll also just get all the materials I use in my videos such
as the presentation from my Taylor Swift songs about Mattie Healy video and also stuff like this
timeline okay that's it thanks for watching bye
