CO2 EXPERIMENT WHAT IS THE BEST WAY TO ADD CO2 IN OUR AQUARIUM

Fish for Talks
2 followers
Welcome to a new video everybody, hope you're doing well. Today we're doing another CO2 experiment
but this time not with the twin scapes but actually with the big shallow. So I would love to know what
is the best way of injecting CO2 into the aquarium. But I also know that I'm probably not going to get
a clear answer to that just because there are so many different variables. But it does mean that
we can do some fun tests, some fun experiments just to get a bit of a better understanding of
which methods work really well and which methods maybe don't work so well.
So today's experiment is basically just a comparison between the three in my opinion
most common methods of CO2 injection or better say diffusing. So I guess the most common method
is the intake diffuser like we have on this aquarium right here, also on this one over here
and same thing on this side as well. And I guess this is the most common CO2 diffusion method just
because it's so simple and unlike these diffusers, very cheap, it's very easy to install and it
basically works on any size aquarium. So it doesn't matter if you have a small tank like this or you
have a 500 liter tank. And I guess it's also very popular because there aren't really that many
downsides to it. I mean one downside is the fact that it's visible. So you have to have this diffuser
in your aquarium and this CO2 tubing. These diffusers are actually quite good but you have
these cheap CO2 diffusers that produce these really large bubbles that go straight to the
water surface and then it's not very efficient. But these CO2 diffusers, these are from Twinstar
also I have them from Aquario. Those are two really good brands CO2 diffusers that I recommend.
Now another very popular method of injecting CO2 is with an inline CO2 diffuser. That's what we have
right here. So this works with your external canister filter. Here's the outflow, then comes the
CO2 diffuser. CO2 is being injected here and then it goes all the way up to the outflow
filter. So the good thing about the inline diffuser is the fact that it's invisible. You don't have any
extra equipment inside the aquarium. Also the CO2 bubbles are usually a little bit smaller than with
a regular in-tank diffuser. You can sort of see the the mist coming out of the outflow lily
pipe here. And because it's attached to the outflow you get a very good CO2 distribution
throughout the entire aquarium. Of course the inline diffuser has some downsides as well.
One downside being the fact that you need to have an external filter. So if you have an internal filter
or you have a hang on the back filter like you can't use an inline CO2 diffuser. Another downside
is the fact that you need to make a cut into your filter hose. So there's another potential
chance of any leaking. And also the fact that it's attached to the outflow like the CO2 mist is coming
out already quite close to the water surface. So there's still a lot of micro bubbles going
straight to the surface and just being lost there. So it's not 100% efficient. And then the least
common method is what I have on the big shallow is the CO2 reactor. So that's what I have here
attached to the Oase Biomaster. So you can just barely see it over there. So the CO2 reactor is
just a chamber that's filled with with some media. CO2 is being injected on the top. Also water is
being injected on the top goes out down at the bottom. So the CO2 is mixed with the water before
it enters the aquarium. So the CO2 reactor has by far the most downsides. So it's quite big. So you
need to have a lot of space in your cabinet to be able to position it somewhere. It's also quite
expensive. So if you cannot make it yourself like you have to buy it it's quite expensive.
If it's not working properly it's noisy as well. So it can make some noise if there's
air trapped in it. You'll hear this water trickling. What else? It's again suitable
only for aquariums with an external filter. And that also makes it not very suitable for
small tanks. Because you need to have a strong filter to be able to push the water through the
chamber. So yeah it's only suitable for bigger aquariums basically. But it does have two very
strong benefits. First benefit is that it has a 100% dissolve rate. Because the CO2 is being
injected on the top of this chamber. And the water is coming going out on the bottom of the
chamber. The CO2 is completely dissolved before it enters the aquarium. So it's very efficient.
So that's a good thing. And another benefit of that is that it has yeah the CO2 is completely
invisible. So you don't have any microbubbles like you have with the in-tank diffuser or the
inline diffuser. With those two methods you always have the CO2 mist inside the aquarium.
And that just spoils the view in my opinion. Like it just doesn't really look nice.
So with the CO2 reactor like it's crazy. But your water is like crystal crystal clear.
So the idea that I have for this experiment is to basically compare those three types of
CO2 diffusion, injection, whatever you want to call it in the big shallow. So tomorrow I'll run
a full day with the CO2 reactor. And then analyze the results. The day after that I'm going to add
this inline CO2 diffuser from CO2 Art. And then see what happens with that. And then the third day
I'll add this CO2 diffuser from Twinstar, the in-tank diffuser. And see what are the results
with that. And then just compare those three results. And just see which one is better.
But Mark how do you decide which one is better? Well I think for that we have to look at the pH
level of the water inside the aquarium. Because if you're injecting CO2 your pH level will start
to drop. So in a nutshell the lower your pH level the higher the CO2 content. So if we can look at
the pH level throughout the entire day of the photo period. Then we should get a better understanding
of which CO2 infusion, infusion? Which CO2 diffusion method works best. So the main reason I
want to do the experiment on the shallow is because here we already have the CO2 reactor in the
cabinet. I don't think I can fit the CO2 reactor anywhere else. But also because the shallow has
the Intaco controller. The what is? So this little device right here. So this is the Intaco
controller. So this is like a mini computer that controls my light, my CO2 system and also fertilizers
if I were to attach some bottles here. I'm going to try to keep this as simple as possible. But to the
controller I've added a pH sensor. The pH sensor sits in the CO2 reactor and it measures the pH
of the water inside the shallow. Right now it's probably around pH 8. But ideally I would like to
have it pH 6.7, 6.8. So normally at nine o'clock the CO2 turns on here. The computer tells the
CO2 to turn on. If I would have a CO2 bottle attached here, CO2 would turn on. CO2 would be
injected into the CO2 reactor and then the pH level starts to drop. As soon as it reaches pH 6.8
the computer will say okay that's enough. It will stop the CO2 system and that's it. The good thing
about this Intaco controller is that it gives us accurate data and that's exactly what we need
for this experiment. So I have this little graph that I'll pull up on the screen right now. And
here you see a couple of lines. You see a yellow line, a green line and a blue line. The green line
is this CO2 valve. So right now it's just on and off. So it's on at nine o'clock and it's off at
6.8. And the blue line that's the pH level. So right now it's a straight line and that's
because I haven't really been dosing CO2 for the past, actually it's been almost a month.
That's another story. So once we start adding CO2 again the blue line should look completely
different and also the green line should look completely different. So that's what we're going
to see starting from tomorrow. The next day. Okay it's now the next day. I'm just waiting for the
CO2 to start. I've hooked up the bottle. It's now almost 11 a.m. CO2 should start at 11 a.m.
and switch off at 9 p.m. See the lights turn on at 1 p.m. and switch off at 10 p.m.
So we're going to run a full cycle today then see the results on the graph basically. Tomorrow
we'll do the same but then with the inline CO2 and the day after we'll do the same with the
in-tank diffuser. So today's the first day. Let's see what happens. Here we go. So let's open the
neurovalve. I think this is a good amount. It's quite a lot but it's a big tank. It's a shallow
tank so we have a lot of surface area so we need quite a lot of CO2 in here. Okay so another day
has passed. Today we're going to remove the CO2 reactor and replace it with this inline diffuser.
But first let's take a look at the data from yesterday. So this blue line that you see right
here that's the pH from yesterday. So that's what we're going to be checking out. So yesterday around
11 o'clock we started. So 11 o'clock pH was 8.33. That's when the CO2 kicked in.
And then it went all the way down, all the way down, all the way down. And I think at about
yeah between 2 and 3 it was finally at its lowest point which was just around pH 7. So
it just dropped a little bit below 7 like 6.9. Yeah 6.9 basically 6.95. So in order for this
aquarium to have enough CO2 I need a pH of 6.8. So with the amount of CO2 that we were injecting
yesterday which was quite a lot already we actually did not reach that level. So we were
not injecting enough CO2. But as you saw like the bubble the bubbles per second were kind of going
crazy already. So the reason I need to inject this much CO2 in this aquarium is for a number
of reasons. Reason number one is I'm using tap water in this aquarium. My tap water is quite
hard and in hard water it's just more difficult to dissolve enough CO2 to make the pH drop enough.
Another reason is it's a shallow tank so we have a small water volume but we still have a lot of
surface area. It's still a big water surface. We have a lot of evaporation as well so a lot of CO2
just gets released into the air again. And also with the way that the filter outflows right now
we have quite a lot of surface movement. So we just we're also losing quite a bit of CO2.
There's not really ideal conditions but I'm not going to change the amount of bubbles per second.
I'm going to keep it exactly the same for every three days of this experiment. So right now let's
the CO2 reactor and see how well the inline CO2 will perform today. So the CO2 reactor is now
disconnected. I've removed the pH sensor as well. It's now sitting in the aquarium over there.
So the CO2 reactor is not in line with the filter anymore. Right now we have the CO2 diffuser.
So I've placed it as close to the outflow as possible. We have quite a long way still before
enters the aquarium on the back over there. So let's start the filter and then see if everything
works. Yeah almost almost. All right seems like we're all good. Filter's back in position.
It's still it's only 10 o'clock so let's come back in an hour and see when CO2 turns on. See
if everything is okay. I don't see any leaks on the inline diffuser so that's good. So come back
in an hour. Okay so it's almost 11 o'clock. CO2 is going to turn on in just a few minutes.
One thing that I just realized though is that we might struggle to keep the bubbles per second
the same with all three experiments. Yeah every system works with a different pressure because
the CO2 reactor that we had yesterday doesn't require a lot of pressure at all. The inline
diffuser that we're doing right now requires at least 30 psi of pressure to be able to work.
And I'm guessing that with the regular intake diffuser it's going to be different as well. So
that might be a bit of an issue. I'll try to keep the bubbles per second exactly the same but
it might be a little bit off. Yeah let's just see how it goes. There we go. You can see that it's
already slowing down because the pressure is building up inside the hose. So let's move over
to the diffuser. Yeah can't really see anything there. So we need to increase the pressure to
30 psi. So right now it's 20. So let's increase it to 30. So that's 30. So I just checked the
footage from yesterday and kind of tried to match the bubbles per second with that footage.
So I think right now we're good. So that's it. We'll let this again run for a full day,
check the pH level, see if there's any big differences and I'll come back to you guys
tomorrow. Just came in to check how the inline CO2 diffuser is doing and it seems to be doing
really really well. So if you take a look at the rock right here, you might be able to see
all these micro bubbles. So there's like a slight mist in the water. Yeah seems like it's doing
really good. The next day I removed the inline diffuser and replaced it with the in-tank diffuser
from Twinstar. Placed it on the opposite side of the outflow and again tried to keep the amount
of bubbles per second exactly the same as with the previous two methods. All right ladies and
gentlemen, we have ourselves a winner. So it's been a few days since we started the experiment.
We tried the CO2 reactor, we tried the inline diffuser and we tried the in-tank diffuser.
Three very different methods and also with very different results.
And the winner is currently running on the Oase Biomasa 850. So let's see who it is.
All right so without further ado let's reveal the winner of this CO2 experiment and that is the
inline diffuser from CO2 Art. So I kind of knew that in this setup an in-tank diffuser just
wouldn't perform well because it's such a shallow tank. It's only 30 centimeters high
and the bubbles from an in-tank diffuser they will just go straight to the surface.
But I still had hopes that the CO2 reactor would perform better than the inline diffuser. But
yeah the data is clear that the inline diffuser performed much better. So let's take a look at
the data right now and then I can show you. All right so here we have all three days side by side.
So all the way on the left we have the CO2 reactor which we already saw. In the middle
we have the inline diffuser and all the way on the right we have the in-tank diffuser.
If you look at the blue line you can see that all the way on the right
the pH didn't even manage to fall below 7. So the in-tank diffuser definitely performed the worst.
I think the lowest it managed to get the pH was 7.04 something like that.
And the CO2 reactor we already saw lowest the lowest point there was 6.95.
So yeah the CO2 reactor is second place. And if we look at the winner you can clearly see also
by the green line that there were three points where the CO2 actually managed to switch off
where we had reached the desired pH level of 6.8. So the first time the CO2 turned off was around
quarter to four. Then 15 minutes later or so it turned on again and then it turned off again at
six o'clock. Turned on again at 6.30 and then at eight o'clock it turned off one more time. So
three points in during the day they managed to reach pH 6.8. And yeah in my opinion that's
the perfect line of CO2 that I want to see. So does this mean that everybody should now switch
to an inline CO2 diffuser? I mean no I don't think so of course not. I mean this was just
one experiment it was just for fun. And like I said in the beginning of the video there are so
many different variables when it comes to injecting CO2. So with this experiment we used a shallow
tank with a big water surface, lots of surface movement, very hard tap water. And if you would
a higher tank with soft tap water and less water surface movement then I'm sure the results are
going to be completely different. So this was just one experiment just for fun. I hope you
guys enjoyed this one. Don't forget to smash the like button and I'll see you guys next time.
Take care.
