Carbon is misunderstood. It is useful to remove chemicals or nutrients from the water. It removes them by storing them in its cells. When the cells are full it stops absorbing. Then it is useful as a substrate.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
as well as microfauna are able to get in there. Bacteria are able to get in there and break in
breaking that down to make it sensible to plant roots. Welcome to father fish and the natural
aquarium. I support the use of charcoal or carbon but most people don't understand what it is
and how it works. It is wood that has been heated, burned and then heated to a high enough degree
that the moisture has been driven out of it and it retains the cellular structure. Now it's
charcoal. It's used as a as a fire source in many third world countries and the way they
make it is they build a big pile of brush including limbs and branch and cover it with
mud with a little opening in the bottom and that they start a fire in that and then it
it burns but it burns without flame. So it drives all the moisture out, drives all the organic stuff
and leaves charcoal like chunks of charcoal and that charcoal is then they use that
for cooking as a stove fire but it burns very readily and lasts for a few hours. But that same
material put in a fish tank will absorb and it absorbs not only water but when it does it retains
what's in the water. It has very tiny cellular structure and that cellular structure is now in
place like a skeleton. It is a skeletonized cellular structure that is able to create a
filtration that captures microscopic particulate matter in the water column down to the micron
level which means it's capturing medications that you may put in the water. It'll capture
the medication and actually separate it from the water. Now it has limited capacity and that
limited capacity is a function of how hot the carbon has been heated before you get it in order
to make it. There are Japanese blends that heat up in excess of a thousand degrees,
fourteen, fifteen hundred degrees, maybe higher by now I don't know. But the hotter it is the more
it's able to retain. The hotter it is baked the more it's able to retain so it lasts longer. The
shaper carbons of charcoal last between a few hours to a few days and unless your water is
extremely pure it doesn't last beyond that. So after that charcoal or carbon has been in there
I use the words interchangeably because frankly in my mind they mean the same thing to me.
Charcoal is carbon and carbon is mercury. It's the use that distinguishes the difference I think
and not the item itself. In any case when you put that in your tank if you're buying a $20
container of charcoal that's one pound it's not going to be high quality. That is to say
it's not going to be heated at this at a very high temperature. It'll be heated
at the temperature of fire which may be whatever it is 750 800 times whatever it is. When you put
that in if you're trying to get something out of the water like methylene blue you may have put in
or any of the other kinds of NH you put in it's going to it's the water as the water gently
flows through it. Those particulates which are microscopic particles are captured by the cell
wall structure. It's a filter you see. They capture them but once it once it captures them
they can't capture them again in that spot and so it'll capture them in another spot and the
water will keep moving through it creating channels around the spots that are already
until it's until it it can't until water cannot flow through it anymore. It's hard to know when
that actually occurs. You would actually have to take it out and test it and that would be
difficult to do. I usually take the position that that the carbon or the charcoal if it's
the cheaper stuff is used up in a matter of two or three days. I typically leave it in for a week.
Now we talked about this the other day and came to the conclusion in fact it was a
it was a moment of inspiration when we realized that use of carbon or charcoal
makes an absolutely perfect top on topping on a dirty substrate or any other substrate for that
matter. I mean it creates a really excellent substrate. For one thing it is absorbed nutrients
as well as whatever else is absorbed and the the roots of plants are tiny enough to be able to get
down in there and and feed all those nutrients that are in that charcoal as well as microflora
are able to get in there. Bacteria are able to get in there and break in breaking that down to make
it extensible to plant roots. So it's a the old used charcoal shouldn't be thrown out. It should
be left at the bottom of your tank because it's perfectly perfectly useful. Now if I guess if
you've used it to take some toxic chemical out that you've had to use you might not want to do
that. But if you've been using any kind of charcoal or carbon like the filter pad anything like that
routinely you can leave it in there where it is longer and it serves an additional function
of providing nutrients. You putting it in your substrate however would make it even more
healthy.