Bernard Arnault | Full Q&A | Oxford Union

Bernard Arnault
8 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 19, 2025
Bernard Arnault is the Chairman and CEO of the world’s largest and most successful luxury goods conglomerate, LVMH, which controls brands such as Louis Vuitton, Fendi, TAG Heuer, Bulgari and Marc Jacobs. While growing LVMH’s portfolio of prestigious brands at a staggering pace, Arnault made notable investments in companies such as Netflix over ten years ago. In March 2015, Forbes estimated him to be the world’s thirteenth richest person.
ABOUT THE OXFORD UNION SOCIETY: The Oxford Union is the world's most prestigious debating society, with an unparalleled reputation for bringing international guests and speakers to Oxford. Since 1823, the Union has been promoting debate and discussion not just in Oxford University, but across the globe.
Thank you so much for joining us here this afternoon.
I'll start off by just asking questions myself and then
after I've done that we'll open up to audience questions
which I'm sure there are plenty. So starting off with just a question
about your background, I was wondering is it true that your first career choice
was to be a professional pianist? It's not exactly true.
No, I'm a good amateur pianist. I like very much music but I realized
quite early, in spite of playing quite well, I had not
the level of becoming a real professional,
especially I have a lot of friends who are very
good pianists. I know that some weeks ago you received
my friend Lang Lang. He came, I see him each time he's in
Paris because you know we have a foundation,
Louis Vuitton foundation, and he gave the first concert there
and last week he gave a master class which was fantastic. He came with young
kids of between 10 and 15 that were playing wonderfully and the
way he's explaining the interpretation is
incredible.
No, I could not be a real professional.
So then how was it that you arrived in the luxury sector?
I arrived in the luxury sector for
I would say family reason because when I was managing family
business, which was in a different sector, I
happened to enter in contact with a group in France
that was having problems, business problems,
and in this group there was Christian Dior
and I was interested by business and I wanted to turn around this group
and build on which I think was at the time
the best asset and the best asset was Christian Dior
and I was interested in Christian Dior for a long time because the first time,
you know you are very young, but the first time I was in
New York it's in 71 and I remember the first time I
arrived at Kennedy airport I took a cab
and at the time the president of the U.S. was
Richard Nixon. By the way they were devaluating
the dollar during the summer where I was there.
I bought dollars and my dollars went down but
I arrived at the airport and I started to talk to the cab driver
and he loved France and he was interested in politics
so I asked him and he did not like Nixon
so he was talking about that. He said you love France so what do you
know in France? Do you know the French president?
It was Mr. Pompidou at the time. Nobody here remembers but he said no I
don't know the French president but I know Christian Dior
and immediately he stuck me and showed that the name
of Christian Dior is one of the if not the most
known all over the world in many countries.
When I go to China, when I go everywhere it's
the name which is the most well known so
as far back as 71 I understood the power of a name.
It's not enough but I think it's one reason also
when by chance I was in contact with the real
company I think it's when I had the idea of doing this.
And of course the luxury sector spans over so many different
products but what do you think the definition of luxury
is?
First of all I don't like very much the word luxury because you have
something attached to it which means show off
which means something of non-significance, something
futile, something that is useless. And I think a better definition
is combination of quality and creativity.
It's how I define what we do.
Obviously these products because of the very high quality they have
because of the high level of innovation they are expensive
but the reality is really behind
the appearance behind the price it's the quality and
the innovation that people are looking for.
So for me it's a definition and in the group we are really concentrated
on this. How can we create
the most innovative products and the creators
or the scientists that work with us in the many laboratories we have
they have complete freedom to express new ideas
and after that we have to transform them in reality
all over the world. But this is a really luxury
and when you do that they often ask a question
how do you market the product? I don't know if in this room
you have students in marketing but I often meet students in marketing
and in spite of the group being number one
with the students in France in desirability to work in the group
I always tell them we don't do marketing
because marketing is against what a company like us should do
because marketing what is marketing? Marketing
is to analyze what the customer wants
and then try to follow what the customer is looking for
and test what you create following these trends
and try to do it. We do completely differently. We create
new products and sometimes it fails but when it's
successful the customers follow. So the marketing is not for us
part of the product creation. The marketing
is after. The marketing is when we have these products
how with these products which people want maximize the desire
because our business you ask a question about luxury
luxury for me is how can you create desire? The most important word
in our business is desire. How to create desire
and when you have the product then you have to create
good environments in the shops and you have to
present it well. You have to do well good films if it's a perfume
good advertisement either in the magazine or in the internet if it's a
if it's a product. That's the way I see and we see in my group
the way to the way to put product in contact with
the consumers. So following on from what you're saying about how you
how you create that desire for a product undoubtedly the
the internet and those sorts of media streams have
affected so many industries. I was wondering is
technology and the use of internet universally a good thing
in your business sector or are there brands that you purposely try to keep
offline? Internet is more and more important and
if I judge by the budget that we spend in the media
we are reducing gradually the amount spent in magazine to increase
the spending in the internet or the internet media. So it's more and
more important and what is key also
is the fact that now more and more the customer they want to first
when they want a product they go immediately on their computer
on their
telephone and they check the product. So the way
a brand is presented to the world is extremely
influenced by the internet which explains why when you are on the
site of a brand not only you see the product but you
see the history of the brand you see the
craftsmanship which is behind and more and more
customers are looking at that and they want to understand what is
really behind the brand and they like the product but they want to
see more and with the internet it's extremely easy
and also they want to be able to buy the product easily
we have now in many countries including the UK you can buy a product and
get it very fast in a shop or if you go on the internet you see what is
available in the shop in central London if you want
such or such product you can find the availability of the product
which is growing faster and faster and we
more and more invest in the way we work with internet
companies the problem being they are as you see more and more profitable
because now they get more and more
smart to manage their revenues for instance at the
beginning on Facebook when a brand
was sending a message to its followers you could get them
immediately today it's not the case when you send a message
you can get maybe one or two percent of your followers even a brand like
Dior that has millions of followers they don't get the message unless
you pay something to Facebook and then you can go
on many
followers and you can even get on the competitors followers
if you pay so if you are Dior and if you pay Facebook
you can send your products on the followers of Chanel
and for the Facebook it's a goldmine because many brands are doing this
and is one reason why they are so profitable not all of them are doing
that yet but more and more are going to do it
and do you think that the mainstream platforms such as Instagram and Facebook
improve the chances of new brands and young designers to establish themselves
or is it difficult because they're forced out by bigger companies who can
afford much much more expensive marketing
campaigns such as Louis Vuitton and Dior
as I just explained it's more and more important
because more and more people are looking at it so Instagram
for instance Instagram it's not yet you should not
yet pay to get your message spread out but it will come I think
shortly so when you do this it's really
extremely efficient it's becoming extremely costly
and obviously for smaller companies it's more difficult but it's not
something that you can absolutely
live with for instance in the group we have a small company
that is not doing any advertisement that is not doing so far
what I described on Facebook or internet or
Instagram or anything else or Snapchat or something
and this company small but is growing 50% it's doubling every year
because the product is something that we have created and that
encounter big success and we cannot produce enough it's small
but we started this from scratch what three years ago four years ago
and this year it will do 50 million and next year last year it
was 25 next year it will be 100 small
profitable so you you should not generalize
yes it's very important but you can succeed at least
at a reasonable size at the beginning without it
if really the product is not just marketing
if you do if you do marketing like a real consumer group
I think that is not possible but if you produce something that is really unique
it's possible and would you say that Apple
is now a luxury or your definition your improved definition of luxury
a company that well Apple is a fantastic company
and I happen to know Steve Jobs and when he started
the shops he came to us to ask advice
and you can see is many of these shops are not far from
Louis Vuitton because he told me I would like advice
and I would like to see if we can put Apple shops in the same area of Louis
Vuitton and at that time he was criticized
enormously everybody thought it's completely crazy
to sell Apple products in a shop because at that time he
was selling the Apple products only
through a wholesaler like for instance Dell and I remember at the time
Michael Dell saying it's completely crazy it will never work
so that's an example of
contrarian thinking that is working so I was
not helping but advising a little bit
and I must say I was myself a little doubtful
of selling at that time it was
not iPhone it was the iPod product in the shops
but it was working and we discussed the future and
I asked him do you think Steve that your telephone is to answer
a question about luxury your telephone is going to work
as successfully in 20 years and he said I don't know because
there are some evolution and some newness and so on
and just to laugh with him he told him you know that's the difference
between us because my Dom Pérignon I can guarantee
you it will be sold and successful in 20 years and that's
also a luxury specificity
luxury one part of the products should be timeless that's a
paradox to be successful you have to have the combination between
modernity and timelessness that's a combination that we try to
keep and to have a product from Louis
Vuitton which is was
started in the middle of the 19th century
some products are the same for many years but also
they should represent the utmost modernity
that's the combination and that is what is fun and a key to
success thank you and so Apple
I don't think you can put it in the same category
in spite of it being fantastic absolutely a fantastic company
thank you very much with a world that is constantly
globalizing how do you adapt products and luxury products to
different communities around the world for example how Dolce & Gabbana recently
released a collection of hijabs is this something that you think your
own brands will do in the near future we tend to keep the same products
everywhere we don't think people are looking
at our products to be done differently in a country from
another country I think they want to to buy part of the
European Art de Vive and we try to keep that we try to
show what we do in the creativity of our atelier
in France and we don't think we should modify
and obviously some products are more successful
in Europe in the US or in the Far East but we try to keep the same
products thank you and on a different topic
somewhat related a lot of attention is of course given to
China as an emerging emerging market and very much established market and I was
wondering how do you approach China as a market
well China is one of the most important markets now
and it has evolved very fast I remember the first time I was in
China it was in 91 it's not that far
and the first time in 91 I arrived in Beijing
there was no car and only bicycles and we were opening the
first Louis Vuitton shop and I remember I called my team said
are you sure we are going to be successful
and they said two things one Louis Vuitton and the group we are a
group of pioneers so it's good to start in a country where
we have no competitor we were the first one
and two strangely enough since a few weeks the shop was open
we sell the most expensive products in a country where everybody was going
by bicycles so we started there from there
and then happened what everybody knows and today China is very very big
very developed economically and we have around 30
Louis Vuitton shops one such and many others
and the market is good there are some
questions about China now because of the growth and because of the
problem that you have seen on the stock market there
and in the currency but I think the analysts observers
are under evaluating the real fundamentals of the Chinese
economy I think it's still growing six seven
percent which is quite high the consumption is
going well it's growing and the state
is really in charge for a lot of reasons that
you may not like but is in charge of making the economy following a path
which is oriented towards growth and they have a lot of
reserves so I am quite confident that China will stay as a
number two global economy and for us it will continue to be
really powerful
you have a lot of here in the UK for instance a lot of travelers
coming from from China so I'm not very concerned
but there are changes a few years ago when you go to
Japan for instance you have no Chinese you are no Chinese
today when you go to Japan because of the
low Japan currency and because of the strong yuan
you have a lot of Chinese and you have more and more
Chinese traveling all over the world and the economy is I think
aimed to continued growth maybe not 10 percent as it was
in the past but between five and seven which is quite substantial so I'm
I'm confident and the Chinese to answer a question about
product in the market is more and more educated
at the beginning a lot of brands were successful relatively easily
because it was new but the Chinese they have learned very fast and now
they are like like the US consumer they are very very informed and very
selective so so it's a challenging market but
for strong brands it's full of potential which
other markets do you see in the next in the next few years
that you think that luxury groups will be fighting over
well for for the economy you have two big engines which is the US
and China but in the developed market the economy is going to continue to be
good as a friend of mine told me
some months ago when I asked him about what do you think of the
the future of the of the economy he is very confident
but he said for the next 20 years I think we'll have 80 percent
of good years we'll have 20 percent of bad years and in the 20
we have 10 very bad and then just bad but I am not able to tell you exactly
when the bad will arrive so
I tend to agree to that because today the world globally is going
relatively well but you have this uncertainty
about the level of money available and the money created
by the banks the European Bank the Federal Reserve they are printing
money tons of money so what what will happen
if this printing of money is not sufficient to really
stimulate the economy and for the time being it's it's what we
see the economy in Europe is so so
in spite of the interest rates being negative and in spite of big influx
of money so what will be the consequence
will it create the next crisis
personally I think it's not unlikely that within the next
few years there is a new
crisis of a different type because of this amount of money which is
unbelievably high and because of the level of debt
of many of many countries so
we have to adapt but also when you have a crisis
we tried as a business manager of the group and very much to take
advantage of it because we have very little debt and
when the market is becoming to be less good we can
in the past we went through many crises we
are able to grow faster than the competition and sometimes also
it's a good period to to find opportunities
but you have to be patient and try to avoid
to invest when everything is too expensive
because you see people in the stock market
when it's going to grow fast they try to buy and on the opposite when
it's going down the people try to sell
faster and faster which is strange but
it's good to be sometime contrarian to that it's not easy it's not easy
thank you so much there's just a couple more questions from me before i'll move
on to questions from the audience you were knighted by prince charles in
2012 for your services to britain and i was wondering on your opinion
on what difference it will make to lvmh if britain decides to stay or leave
the european union i think for the group
economically it will not make a big difference
as an observer of the situation i will not interfere because i am not
a uk citizen with a politic decision of the uk but
from outside i cannot imagine that the uk
take advantage economically of a movement like this
i think a movement like this will not benefit to the uk
economically because it will separate your country from
the rest of europe with all the trade which is involved with all the
exchange that would be more difficult so it will create
i think and again it's seen from outside and i don't want to
take part of the debate but it should be economically negative
for for the uk so it's all i can say but we have the same
people in france that also want france to to quit not only
europe but also the currency it's strange for me to
to see that you know in politics if i take
the the french example
we use as an argument things and
logic that everybody knows is not going to work but
it is good in terms of rhetoric and and power because it's different
when in france politicians say we should stop
the frontiers it's stupid
but it has some power on the on the media and and most of the
time person who says that
know that it's completely irrealistic but it gives her
some audience it's no different with business you know in business you see
the result politics well it can just
be ideas and who knows where this idea will lead
well we shall see the result the last question for me before moving on
is just that the the financial times reported recently that you may be
interested in acquiring burberry and i was just
wondering if you could comment on this
well i will be very open i am not very interested it's a
magnificent company but it's not on our agenda
thank you very much with that i will move to questions from the audience so
please raise your hand if you would like to ask a question
i will go first to the um member on the front row in the glass oh there's
your base and glasses the one nearest to me
hi thanks for your remarks um congratulations on the new fondation
louis vuitton's home in paris i'm wondering if you can speak a bit
about both the foundation and your personal collecting habits
and if you can specifically answer the question what makes a great art
collection as an art collection ah the the
collection yeah well the art collection you know in the
foundation that we have we have
a collection which is part collection of the foundation
part my own collection and we have also temporary exhibition twice a year
with association with museum for instance this year we have announced
we have fantastic exhibition with the collection
that was bought at the beginning of the 20th century by this russian
magnate tukin and which is now in russia in the museum
in moscow and in saint petersburg and they have masterpieces from
painters of that time that nobody wanted to buy
they have masterpieces from matisse monet goga we will have
150 paintings coming to paris it will be open in october of this
year it will last three or four months so you should
come and and have a look i think it will last four months and we
wait we we are expecting 1 million visitors
in the in the museum so this is really something that
we try to do twice a year and for the selection of the art that we
own we are doing it for maybe 20
25 years and we try to we have advice we have a very very good
curator who had been managing the artistic director of the
museum the musée de la ville de paris very very
knowledgeable and that help because she knows the
artist and she knows also the good collection
and she she is helping us to to buy but
i cannot describe all the the process it's her that really
knows the artist and the living artists and that put us in
contact with them we we commission also some of the
artists to do things specifically for the foundation
it's very very interesting to to work with them
and that's a long process thank you for your question we'll now
go for the member on the aisle
you mentioned quantitative easing and you mentioned the threat of money
printing and the possibility of another crisis
on the horizon what are the two or three things
you most worry about for the future of your business do you worry
about the cost of the materials that you use to make your goods do you
worry about consumer appetite for luxury spending
if you take a long view if you think about 10 years or 20 years what what are
the things that most concern you for the future of
lvmh first of all i think
in a business which is successful as is this business
i always say to my team you should be thinking that
the worst is coming and you should be never you should never
be satisfied and you should be always
frightened and on the kiviv in a way the state of mind
is to be positive paranoid and
always in a situation think of what can go wrong and
always put you in question is what we do really
enough are we doing the good innovations are we
managing in the right direction what can go
bad and
in our business
what is really important is to keep the level of innovation
so for the long term i think we have the teams that
assure us to create enough new invention new products
to keep on with the growth of the market
but it's a constant
quest we see maybe every year 20
between 20 and 25 percent of new products
and we have to look at them in every detail
to make sure that the level of innovation
is really
sufficient because the tendency in a group that work well is
sometimes and we try to avoid it some form of auto-satisfaction
and when you see the results from the press
i prefer frankly to have some critics than to have as we did during the last
release of the numbers people everywhere saying oh it's
fantastic the numbers are great and blah blah blah which is not good
for the state of mind you know at the beginning when i started
the group we did a turnaround
and i think to be really good long term you should
keep that same state of mind as
the company even if it's successful should be managed in a way as if
it could get under within the next 12 months and so it gives you a different
perspective different perspective in terms of
investment in terms of hiring people
in terms of new acquisition so that's the state of mind
so with this that we try really to keep
and we try to see what the future
big problems can be and i see as i said maybe a big
crisis like the one in 2008 coming within the next five to ten years
but a crisis like this for our type of activities
which is linked to consumption is something we can manage
and not only we can manage but we can also in some cases
take advantage of it you have seen during the last crisis some
investors should take
some us investors like Warren Buffett they did at a time where
everybody thought the world was going to collapse
in fact
they did the best investment possible so at our scale
in the our market we did the same and we bought shares in other companies
when everybody was thinking that the end
at the end of the luxury business at the end of almost everything
stock market went down i remember in 2009
having bought for the group shares of LVMH at 39
today it's what 150 so and people were selling
because of the general mentality when you open the newspaper you you saw
that's really the end everybody was was depressed so on one end
we try to be
thinking of the worse but on the other hand
we are optimistic i try to be optimistic long term
but pessimistic short term and that's a good state of mind i think
thank you for your question um we'll now go to the question at the back
uh which brand of champagne made by your group is the
your favorite
my favorite brand your favorite brand of champagne
my favorite brand is uh don perignon
thank you very much uh we'll now go for a question from a member there
um thank you for coming to oxford uni my name is penny pan
i'm a mb student outside the business school and i'm from china
so you mentioned china is important strategic market
for your brand it has been and it will it will be
but it's quite obvious the brand has been poorly in recent years in the
main market china there are many challenges
among which i would pick up a few the massive problem of counterfeits
the changing governmental policy for corruption
um the rising trend for affordable luxury
where you'll see competing brands where like
uh uh like a coach what we are doing really well
where lv is perceived as a something we don't buy anymore is becoming
we call to how we only buy them people who are rich but
lowly poorly educated so it seems that the desire
in china is gone something you mentioned very important to our product design
your marketing strategy so how in your mind the brand will
face those challenges in coming years in china market
thank you okay chinese is a important market and
there are challenges we try to be following the rules in every country we
operate and in china we are not producing
anything so we avoid in doing that
some problems that can happen in some factories
where independently of the government maybe
they use workers too young and things like that that we have a clear
policy in the group to really
not do anything that is not complying with the best practice
for the counterfeiting it's clear that china
is one of the major sources of the counterfeiting
and we try to fight but it's extremely difficult it's
extremely difficult because it's a huge market
and it's a profitable market which is in the
hands most of the time of organized crime so even if
the chinese government officially want to help even for them it's
difficult even in china where there is
a clear direction it's difficult and
for our teams is difficult also because we don't want to expose our teams
directly to people that can really do can really harm them
so we have the help of the government and sometime we
are successful i have many examples of entire factories producing
counterfeiting that with the help of the chinese government we destroy
but the problem is when we destroy when we destroy one
factory they rebuild it some kilometers
further so it's not very efficient and with the internet it's even more
complicated because you have a lot of sites
you can go with the name of a brand and you think
that you buy the real product but in reality you buy a fake
and there also we fight them but you have a ton of them and
when some we are successful in making disappear
new one appear so it's a permanent a constant
fight we spent in the group around 100 million a year to fight that
worldwide it's really a big big problem
you know for organized crime it's the second
resources after drug trafficking counterfeiting so it's huge and so it's
why it's so difficult to fight and in some countries
the government is more efficient for instance in france it's efficient
years ago if you were going to the because
they find interesting way years ago if you went to the beaches in the south of
france you had people working with
counterfeiting when you were sunbathing and offering
products and for years they were just arresting the guy and
after two days the guy was free so he came back and
they found something much more efficient now
when somebody like that is working because they
they passed a law to do it they seize the products and they destroy it and
now the counterfeiting cell on the beaches
in the south of france are almost disappeared
but if you go next country in italy they did not do it because
there is some old links between counterfeiters in some part of the
authorities i'll give you an example i was in venice
the other day in front of a louis vitton shop you have
counterfeiter installed selling the products
and so what do we do we call the police and the police come
but before coming they make a lot of noise for 15 minutes
so the guys they pack the products they go out and when the police arrive
nobody is left
what can we do and two hours later they are back
and so we call the police and they pack and it's
completely inefficient so it depends of the country
but it's it's a big it's a big a big problem
thank you for your question uh we now go for
the member about three rows back on this side
and given the improved relationship between iran and the west
and the lifting of sanctions especially between banks and financial
intermediaries would you look at tapping into the
iranian market and having formal representatives there
given the huge demand that exists for luxury brands and the need
for the iranians to spend the great amounts on such luxury products
thank you no i know i know that the iranian people
like very much our products yes and i went myself years ago
in iran before the revolution it was another time and today
we have already a lot of contacts and i think we are going to start with
one of our brand which is in fact
a brand which is selling other brand but you see sephora you know sephora
and beauty chain it's very successful and we are just
about to to start with this maybe next year
in iran but i am perfectly aware of the very good taste of iranian people
and and and i know there is a very good market
and we are just we are ready if everything is possible
following the rules of our different countries
but we we would like very much to go and and if if we go
the team of my group will go with me and we would be delighted to go back we
look forward to welcoming you
thank you very much for your question unfortunately that's all we have
time for this afternoon uh thank you so much for
um for joining us it's been an absolute pleasure for us all to welcome you here
if i could ask everyone to remain seated whilst
myself and his guests to leave and please join me
in thanking one final time
