We return to the City of Claremont for another hidden gem, a modernist home originally designed by Jo Paul Rognstad in 1952. Tucked quietly within the neighborhood, the residence stands as a thoughtful example of postwar Southern California modernism with blending simplicity, warmth, and a deep connection to its surrounding landscape.
We sat down with Mark and Laurel, both accomplished architects, as they shared the story of how they came to acquire the home and the responsibility they felt in preserving its architectural integrity while adapting it for modern living. Throughout the conversation, they reflect on the challenges of restoration, the careful decisions behind each update, and the balance between honoring the original design while thoughtfully evolving the space over time.
They also opened up about one of the home’s most difficult chapters: losing the original studio after fallen trees caused significant damage. Rather than walk away from its history, they chose to rebuild the studio to its former glory while introducing modern improvements that allow the space to continue serving future generations. Their story is one of stewardship, resilience, and a deep respect for architecture and place.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Mark and Laurel Schumann share the story of their home in Claremont, California, a mid-century modernist gem designed by Joe Paul Rongenstead in 1952. They discuss the architectural significance of the residence, their journey in acquiring it, the emotional connection they have with the space, and their commitment to preserving its history while sharing it with others.
The house is very private and is very off-putting from the street and very small from the street.
When you're walking up, there's only one set of windows you see. The porch is really low.
It's compressive. And when you step in, it gives you the impression of stepping into another world.
To walk into the house is to walk into the whole home. It's to step in and see the living room
and the kitchen and past the foyer into the backyard, both levels of the backyard and the
back house. It's almost like that door becomes not an entrance to a building but a gateway
to another place or Eden, shall we say. It's our Eden, definitely. I'm Mark Schumann. We're here
in Claremont, California at our home, my wife and mine's home, originally the Grant residence.
The house was built in 1952 for Mr. and Mrs. Grant. The architect was Joe Paul Rongenstead.
He came out of USC and we believe he was a student of Jim Grant. Sometime in the late 50s,
early 60s, he relocated to practice in Hawaii, where he actually is a relatively prominent
architect, especially in the modernist movement. I had the good fortune to actually talk to Joe
sometime in the late 90s, maybe early aughts, not too long after we had moved into the house
because I was looking for the plans. I wanted to see if he still had the original plans. And what
he had mentioned, it was kind of fun because I told him the house, I told him who it was for,
and he had to search his memory and he even said something like, oh my gosh, that's like one of my
first homes and they were the best clients. They basically let me do whatever I want.
And trust me, as an architect, they are the best clients. We moved into the house
summer of 98. It was never on the market. Our realtor had heard that the city attorney,
Wynn Firth, was moving to Palo Alto. And so she just called, hey, would you be selling your house?
They had not even thought about it. My pushy or our pushy realtor kind of said, well, I've got
this person who would be perfect. And got me in the door that day. And I'll be honest, I walked
in the door and I couldn't believe it. And, you know, you kind of asked, well, what would make
why did we think this was special or what would make it seem like it was the house?
I mean, you step in the door and it just is beautiful. I mean, it's a piece of architecture.
It's more than just a house. Laurel and I had just designed a house for us to build here in
Claremont and it wasn't working out because of some costs and a few other issues from where we
were living. And we decided, well, let's just, let's just find it. Let's see what is available.
To walk into this house was like, okay, I'll be honest. I said, the worst thing you can say to my
realtor, I don't care what it costs or how long it takes. I got to own this house. And it turns
out the only caveat we had, you know, restriction to the purchase is that my wife had to see the
house and agree to it. So I actually offered money on a house without my wife seeing it,
which is a funny story because we're honoring the same thing. I'm happy to say my wife was
very happy with the choices that, no, she, she loves this place. One of the things that
Wynn told me, and I think maybe told us was one of the reasons she was selling it to us
was because she knew we would take care of it, that she, and I mean, that just showed that they
had that same appreciation and love for the architecture, for the space. I had gone before
the city council a number of times to fight developers, and that's how she knew me. I
walked in the door and she goes, you're that impassioned architect. You know, keep up the
good fight. You know, she, she was interested in the things that we're interested in, you know,
living spaces, homes, not houses. You know, it's not an investment. It's where you raise
your children. They don't have to be mutually exclusive, but I think when you approach
a structure as being an investment, as just a house, then it doesn't matter what it looks like.
It doesn't matter its history. One of the things we learned about was the importance of history
in place. One of the things that I've always enjoyed or liked about what I, is creating
memories, creating history, and this place has it. Now, is it ancient? Is it Baroque? Is it craftsman?
No, it, but it is very specific to mid-century California living, and, and I don't even mean
a time capsule. I mean, everything that that brought forth still exists in this structure,
and I don't see why we would want to change it, or what would be better, frankly.
I'm Laurel Tucker, and I have lived in this house with my husband, Mark Schuman, and family
for 27 and a half years. I know that the Grants worked closely with Mr. Roggenstead in the design.
The studio in back was built for Mr. Grants, and there used to be hooks in the beams out there,
and we imagine that he hung large canvases from them. It was fun to find that. Mr. Grant did a lot
of the stonework in the yard around the house, the retaining walls. I know that they came from
Pasadena, and they didn't live in this house very long, and then they moved up north.
This was not a family home for them. It was just the two of them, but they had children later,
and Mark was actually in contact with the son at some point since we've been living here.
We had looked at a lot of houses, and Mark came and saw the house before I did. I was at work.
He called me while I was sitting at my desk, and he said, this is a great house. It has a shoe closet,
and I said, buy it. But then the first time I came in, when Firth and Don Brenes,
the owners at that time, had a fire going in the fireplace, and I walked in the front door and just
went, this feels like home. It's just so comfortable and welcoming. You open that door, and it just
welcomes you with open arms. We had an amazing realtor who really got to know who we were,
and she found out that this house was going to be coming up for sale, and she got us in the door
before it ever hit the market, and I have thanked her ever since for doing that for us.
I like to call it a case study house. That's not really a case study house, but
it's so beautifully designed already, and when our friend said, oh, what's your first project
going to be? We said, unpack our boxes, because it's a perfect house, and so when we added the
primary suite, we were very careful to try to keep it exactly in character with what we already had.
We had two big, beautiful pine trees. The one close to the house was an Italian stone pine,
and the one closer to the studio was an Aleppo pine, but I used to go out and look up at it
and I would literally hug the tree and say, don't ever fall, because if you do,
it'll break my heart, and it'll destroy a lot of things, and then on January 21st, 2022,
Friday night, the winds were picking up, and it was pretty bad. It got more and more windy.
There was no power, and it was getting late, so we went to bed, and I was watching the branches
on the big tree flailing around, and then a branch dipped down, and I thought, that doesn't look
right, and then saw the trunk just go down, and you know, I said, Mark, oh my god, it's going down,
so we jumped out of bed and ran outside, and there was our tree lying across the garage.
The winds kept blowing, and then I heard this huge crack. I realized it was the other pine tree
had gone down on the other side of the studio, and then I kind of lost my mind. I was like,
okay, one tree, we'll deal with it, but the other one was just really awful, but we begin
rebuilding, you know, one foot in front of the other, and you know, the community was great.
People were around us and supporting us. Further into it, we were thinking, neither one of our kids
lives at home anymore, so do we really even need this for work anymore? So we said, let's just,
you know, maybe set it up as a rental or something. Then the city, in the last year, approved
short-term rentals, Airbnb, Vacaso, that kind of thing. We decided to try it. It's been a real
gift, so we rebuilt it almost exactly as it was, but modernized it, put in a kitchen. It's turned
out to be a wonderful thing. When we bought the house, we just liked the house. We wanted the
house. We didn't realize that it would become kind of, I feel like in some ways, it's our civic duty,
but I feel like it's giving back, and when you are fortunate enough to have something
as wonderful as a house like this, I don't know, I feel it's incumbent on us to share it,
try to help educate, you know, some of the beauties of having a place like this and the
connection to the out-of-doors. I think it's civic duty, but there's also pride.
You know, not everybody gets to have something like this, and I feel like we're sharing it,
and having the Airbnb, that's a big thing. Now we have people coming in every week.
They tell us, oh my gosh, this is such a great place, and the yard is so beautiful. Thank you,
Mark Schuman, for the amazing landscaping and back, but it's wonderful to share it,
because I think it brings joy to other people too.
When we added our primary suite, it felt really open. The bedroom had initially just had one
wall of glass looking in the backyard, but when we pushed it out into the backyard,
it almost felt like we were sleeping outdoors, and it was a little bit uncomfortable at first,
I've gotten used to it now, and there's glass, and you're part of nature, and everything that's
happening outside, you experience when you're inside. It's like living, it's almost like
camping sometimes, and we're both pretty avid campers, so it suits us. So one of the aspects
about this house is how well-ventilated it is, and so during the summer months, if you open these
large doors that are to my right, and in the afternoons, when the sea breezes are coming from
the west, we get great follow-through with these vents. Likewise, there's vents behind the
fireplace, which also let a lot of air in. That, in combination with some clear stories that open,
just allows the air to flow through. In fact, what's nice about it is we can leave the house
locked with these open, so when we get home in the summer months, it's not real stuffy in here.
It's spatially fabulous, right? I mean, it feels good to the human scale. The back wall of the
is really low, but it doesn't feel compressive because it goes up to about 10 feet, and it's
glass. There's glass all over the place, so again, you don't really feel like you're in a house as
much as you are very sheltered by these planes. If you were talking about a style, Laurel's dad
talked about how, when he first walked in, he felt like he was in Japan again. It reminded of
him of Japanese homes, and when we would go to the Japanese pavilion at the Huntington,
we were taken aback by how similar our home was, but even this style of home. You know,
movable walls, whether they're glass or not. We even have shoji screens from that standpoint,
but certain horizontalities, and the house is built on a four foot by four and a half foot grid,
not quite the tatami size, but still, it's regular, and by the way, that might be another
reason why my wife loves this place. She loves a grid. I'm not a grid architect. She's a grid
architect. The colors are all muted, and in some ways, it's front and center, but it really does
take a backdrop to the artwork, the possessions that we have filled, our story, and to the
gardens. The house exists here, and it's beautiful, don't get me wrong. I love it. When it was empty,
it was amazing, but it's not, it's not, it's, there's no grandeur to it, but you're impressed.
It's a human-centric space, which is what we do. That's our careers, is building space for humans,
and we get to live in a space like that every day. I will also say that when we bought the house,
Laura and I felt, oh, we finally got a grown-up's house. Interesting enough, and I think the style
has a lot to do with that. It's, you know, it's a house that you want, it just dies for a martini
in one hand and a cigarette in the other. Great music playing with crowds of people, and maybe
that's one of the reasons why we have parties and invite people in, and the tours, is it just feels
like a place that was meant for that, and 27 years, 27 years later, it still feels that way.
We're still so happy to be here, and that's as much Claremont as well. I mean, it's a quiet place,
it's a neat neighborhood. You know, we travel well and never really lived there in a long time, but,
you know, if I've got to spend time, I'm really fortunate to be able to spend time in a town like
this in Southern California, but specifically a house like this. Not a bad, not a bad place.