There are plenty of menswear rules you can and sometimes should break. But some rules exist for a reason.
From getting your suit jacket to fit and drape properly to mastering the small details that separate a well-dressed man from everyone else, these are 8 classic menswear rules every man should know and follow.
In this video, I'll break down the reasoning behind each rule, why it matters, and how these small details can make a big difference in how you look and present yourself.
---
CHAPTERS: 0:00 — 8 Menswear Rules You Should Follow 0:28 — #1: Unbutton Jacket When Sitting 1:54 — #2: Never Button the Bottom Button 3:01 — #3: Always Show Shirt Cuff 4:12 — #4: Your Jacket Should Cover Your Butt 5:14 — #5: Tie Darker Than Shirt 6:13 — #6: Never Wear Suspenders & Belt Together 7:14 — #7: Match Black Tie Facings 8:41 — #8: Never Button Bottom Waistcoat Button 10:04 — Rules You Can Actually Break
The video discusses eight essential menswear rules that are rooted in proportion, function, and tradition rather than arbitrary convention. The speaker emphasizes that following these specific guidelines demonstrates an understanding of tailored clothing and attention to detail, which ultimately elevates a man's overall presentation and silhouette.
There are a lot of menswear rules that you can
and sometimes should break, but there are also
some that I think you should follow.
Not because they're traditional, not because some menswear
expert says you have to,
but because there's actually a good reason behind them. Some have
to do with proportion, some have to do with how
a garment is designed to fit and function, and some
just prevent you from doing something
that doesn't make much sense in the first place. So here are
eight menswear rules that I actually follow
and why I think you should too. Let's start with a
rule that I apparently need to prove that I know.
When you're wearing a single-breasted jacket,
you should unbutton it when you sit down.
I know this. I follow this rule all the time,
and yet whenever you see me sitting down on camera,
there's a pretty good chance my jacket
is buttoned. And inevitably,
someone in the comments feels compelled to point out that
I'm doing it wrong. You suck! So let's clear this up.
Now, there's a practical reason for this rule.
Single-breasted jacket is designed to hang properly
when it's buttoned while you're
standing. When you sit down with it buttoned,
the front of the jacket gets pushed up and the fabric
can start pulling around the button.
It bunches, it creases, it puts unnecessary stress on the
fabric and the button, and it's usually less comfortable.
So yes, when you sit down, unbutton
your jacket. Unless, apparently,
you are me sitting in front of a camera. Because there is a reason
broadcasters will sometimes leave their jackets buttoned
when they're seated. On camera, especially
in a relatively tight shot like we've got here,
a buttoned jacket keeps everything symmetrical
and composed the jacket stays where you want it instead
of falling open on either side of your
body and potentially being distracting
so am i breaking the very first rule in a video about
rules you should follow yes but i'm doing it deliberately
because i understand what the rule
is for and in this particular situation i have reason
not to follow it and one important
distinction this applies to single breasted jackets traditionally
a double breasted jacket
stays buttoned when you sit now i'm willing
to make an exception for that first rule when i'm
on camera. But this next one, absolutely not.
Never button the bottom button of your suit jacket or
sport coat. For me, this one is non-negotiable, no exceptions.
And honestly, it's one of those
things I noticed immediately
because it's such an obvious tell that someone doesn't really
understand how tailored clothing is supposed to work.
You'll see a guy thinking he looks amazing,
you know, like really full of himself just
because he's wearing a suit and then the bottom button is
fastened and I'm like, sorry, dude,
you do not look as good as you think. But there's also a
practical reason for this.
Jackets today are cut with the expectation that the bottom button stays
open. Button it and you start pulling the front
of the jacket in a way that it wasn't designed to
sit. The skirt doesn't fall properly, the quarters close up,
and the silhouette gets distorted. The
old shorthand is sometimes, always, never.
On a three-button jacket, the top button is sometimes,
the middle is always, and the bottom is never.
Now, you don't see many true three-button jackets
these days, but you do see plenty of three roll two jackets
and the same basic guidance applies.
But the bottom button? Never.
And once you know what you're looking for with tailored clothing,
these little details become very easy to spot.
Which brings me to your shirt cuff. When you're
wearing a suit or sport coat,
you should always show a little bit of shirt cuff beyond the jacket
sleeve. The generally accepted range is somewhere between
a quarter of an inch and a half an inch.
Personally, I prefer closer to a half an inch or just slightly less.
Now, we're talking about a very small amount of fabric here,
but visually, it makes a huge difference.
That little bit of shirt cuff looks polished.
It looks intentional, and it tells me that someone has actually
paid attention to how his clothes fit and how he presents himself.
When I see no cuff at all, one of three things is usually happening.
Either the sleeve jacket is too long, the shirt sleeve is too short,
or the person just doesn't know,
or worse, doesn't care about that detail.
And you can definitely go too far in the other direction.
Once you start showing an inch or more of cuff,
now it looks sloppy and unconsidered,
like your jacket sleeves are simply too short.
So somewhere between a quarter
and a half an inch is where you want to be.
I like mine toward the upper end of that range.
It's a tiny detail, but once you know what right looks like,
it becomes very easy to see what's wrong
and who gets it and who doesn't.
Now, sleeve length is only one part
of getting the proportions of a jacket right.
The other big one is the overall length of the jacket itself.
And when we're talking about classic tailoring,
your jacket should cover your butt.
One easy way to check this is the old curl your fingers test.
Stand naturally with your arms hanging at your sides, make a fist,
curl your fingers underneath the bottom of the jacket,
and they should just kiss it.
Now, about a decade ago, during the height of the slim fit era,
jackets got a lot shorter.
Tom Brown was really at the forefront of that,
re-envisioning the suit with shorter proportions
that felt sportier and much more fashion forward.
And that's fine if that's what you're going for,
but if you're watching this channel,
I'm guessing fashion forward probably isn't your thing.
For classic tailoring, jacket length is incredibly important
to the overall balance and proportion
of the outfit. And when a jacket is too short,
even if it technically fits you correctly through
the shoulders and the body, it's just going
to look like you're wearing a jacket that's too small.
So this is one I really wouldn't mess around with.
Remember, like a good lawyer, your jacket should always cover your ass.
Not every rule worth following is about fit and proportion.
Sometimes, something just looks right,
and you may not even realize there's a rule behind it.
Your tie should generally be darker than your shirt.
And to be honest, you know, this isn't a rule
that I consciously think about when I'm getting dressed.
I just do it because, visually, it makes sense.
The shirt becomes the background, and the darker tie creates contrast,
establishes a clear visual hierarchy,
and helps draw the eye upward toward your face.
Flip that around with a dark shirt and a lighter tie,
and you start getting into mafioso territory.
Which, that's your thing, you know,
in terms of what I've been saying.
Forget about it.
Now there is one exception I actually like,
and that's going completely tonal,
matching the shirt and tie color.
Think Robert De Niro as a Thrastean in Casino.
There's something very deliberate about that.
It has a little flare, it has a little throwback style,
and it works precisely because
you're clearly making a choice.
But for traditional tailoring,
I'd stick with the darker tie.
It creates contrast, it frames the face,
and quite simply, it just looks right.
Now that last rule has a little room for interpretation.
This one has none.
Never wear suspenders and a belt at the same time.
Suspenders, or braces as they're also known,
do exactly the same thing as a belt.
They hold up your pants.
So wearing both is completely redundant.
You don't need a backup system,
frankly, it looks absurd.
It immediately tells me that you might have absolutely no idea what
either one is actually for.
For me, choosing between the two is really a question of formality.
With a suit, I almost always wear suspenders,
and I always wear them with formal wear. As things get
more casual, business casual and below,
that's when I'll wear a belt. And part of the reason
is that suspenders preserve the clean lines of a suit.
There's no belt cutting across the waist,
and ideally your suit pants will have side
adjusters rather than belt loops anyway.
One other thing, if you're wearing suspenders with tailoring,
use button-on suspenders. Flip-on ones just look juvenile.
So there's really nothing complicated about this rule.
Belt or suspenders. Never both.
Now there is one area of menswear where I think the rules matter
more than almost anywhere else. And that's black tie.
Black tie is one of the most prescriptive dress codes
for men. It's pretty cut and dry.
and whether you know it's right
or wrong for me to think i've always considered it to be an
exceptional barometer for who's done their homework
and who's just playing dress up because black tie
is all about the details
and there are four details in particular that need to match your
lapel facing bow tie cummerbund and trouser braid
and just so we're on the same page the
facing is the contrasting material on the lapel of your tuxedo jacket
and the braid is the stripe
running down the outside of your pants
so if you have satin lapel facings you should have a satin
bow tie, satin cummerbund, and satin braid on your pants.
If the lapel facings are grosgrain,
then it's a grosgrain bow tie, grosgrain cummerbund,
and grosgrain braid. I personally
don't have a preference between the two.
I wear both and usually just choose based on how I'm
feeling that night. But mixing them? Absolutely not.
Where I generally see people get this wrong
are with the bow tie and cummerbund.
They're treated like separate accessories instead of
parts of a complete black tie ensemble.
And that's really what I love about black tie.
It's full of these tiny details
that most people won't consciously notice,
but they immediately reveal who knows their stuff and who doesn't.
So for me, again, this one is non-negotiable.
Satin with satin, grosgrain with grosgrain.
And though I do love black tie, that's better.
And we're going to finish almost exactly where we started,
with another bottom button you are not supposed to button.
If you're wearing a waistcoat or a vest,
which is perfectly acceptable to call it,
always leave the bottom button undone.
For me, this one is a must.
Now, I don't wear waistcoats all that often,
but occasionally I will wear a three-piece suit.
And when I do, that bottom button is always left open.
Now, the famous explanation for this goes back to King Edward VII.
The story is that as he gained weight,
he began leaving the bottom button of his waistcoat undone
because it was more comfortable when seated,
either in a chair or on a horse.
And because he was the king, other men followed his lead.
Eventually, it became a convention.
No word on if there was some type of coercion involved.
How much of that story is fact
and how much is menswear folklore is debatable,
but regardless, the convention stuck.
And there is a practical benefit.
Leaving that bottom button open gives
the waistcoat a little more freedom
around the waist and hips, especially when you sit down.
But for me, this one is really more about aesthetics
and understanding the traditions of classic menswear.
It's such a small detail, but it says a lot.
When I see somebody wearing a three-piece suit
with the bottom button of the waistcoat undone, I notice it.
It tells me that he understands what he's wearing,
that he's paid attention to the details,
and that he knows a little something
about the history behind it.
And when it's buttoned, well, I notice that too.
Of course, knowing which rules are worth following
is only half the equation
because there are plenty of menswear rules that you can
and sometimes should break.
And knowing which ones those are and why
is just as important as understanding
the ones we talked about here.
So that's where you should head next,
eight menswear rules you can break.
Go ahead and click right up there to watch that now.
And as always, thanks for watching and stay tailored.