Menswear rules can help you dress better but following every rule doesn’t automatically give you great style.
Most menswear rules exist for a reason. But there’s a big difference between knowing the rules and being controlled by them.
After 15 years in menswear, I’ve learned that the guys who dress well aren’t the ones who follow every rule, they’re the ones who understand why the rules exist.
So today, I’m breaking down 8 classic menswear rules.
Understand them. Then decide when to break them and wear the damn clothes.
---
0:00 — 8 Menswear Rules You Should Break 0:26 — Rule #1: No White After Labor Day 1:33 — Rule #2: Your Belt Must Match Your Shoes 2:50 — Rule #3: No Brown in Town 4:10 — Rule #4: You Must Wear a Tie With a Suit 5:35 — Rule #5: Your Socks Should Match Your Pants 6:46 — Rule #6: Never Wear a Watch With a Tuxedo 7:59 — Rule #7: DB Jacket Should Always Be Buttoned 9:20 — Rule #8: Don't Use Your Jacket Pockets 10:56 — The Bottom Line 11:22 — BONUS RULE!
You can follow every menswear rule perfectly and still not have style.
But why?
Because dressing well isn't about following a checklist of what's right and what's wrong.
Now, that doesn't mean the rules are useless.
Most of them exist for a reason.
But there's a big difference between knowing the rules and being controlled by them.
So today we're looking at eight classic menswear rules,
where they came from, why they exist, and why I think you can and sometimes should break them.
So let's start with probably the most famous or infamous one.
No white after Labor Day.
So the exact origin is a little murky,
but the rule dates back to a time when there was a much clearer distinction
between summer resort clothing and what people wore when they returned to the city.
There is also a long-standing theory that these kinds of seasonal dress codes
help the upper class distinguish people who knew the social conventions from those who didn't.
Either way, Labor Day eventually became the unofficial cutoff for wearing white.
And while there's some historical logic there,
I don't know why I'd eliminate an entire color from my wardrobe
because of an arbitrary date on a calendar.
Is white actually a color?
I actually think white, and especially cream and ivory,
can be incredibly elegant in the fall and winter.
Most of what we're wearing then is darker.
Navy, charcoal, brown, olive.
Against those colors, cream feels a little unexpected.
It has presence without being loud.
Sort of a statement without necessarily being a statement.
And to me, it looks like someone who knows what they're doing.
Of course, seasonality matters.
I'm probably not wearing white linen pants in January.
But cream flannel pants?
Absolutely.
So pay attention to the fabric and the context, not the date on the calendar.
Now, this next one is something that I think causes way more anxiety than it should
and is also one that people can take much too seriously.
Your belt has to match your shoes.
This is one that I find that guys who are just getting into menswear
tend to be very susceptible to and kind of overly fascinated with.
And I say this because I'll be wearing a belt and shoe combination like this,
and I'll get a comment along the lines of,
well, wait a second.
I always thought your belt was supposed to match your shoes.
Well, unless we're talking about black,
finding an exact match is nearly impossible.
There are so many shades of brown, different types of leather, different finishes,
and all of that changes as the leather ages anyway.
But even if you could match them perfectly, I'm not sure you'd want to.
Think about a tie and pocket square made from the exact same fabric
or having the exact same pattern.
Technically, yes, it's a perfect match,
but somehow it looks less stylish because it's too perfect.
I think that same principle applies when we're talking about shoes and belts.
A little imperfection makes an outfit feel more natural and less calculated.
Obviously, I'm not saying coordination doesn't matter.
Your belt and shoes should make sense together.
But if they're both brown and one is a little lighter or darker than the other
or maybe a different type of leather, don't overthink it.
Nobody with actual style is judging you for that
unless you're wearing like red shoes and a yellow belt.
Now, if you want to see menswear guys really flex their knowledge in the comments section,
just wear brown in the city because inevitably someone will point out
no brown in town as though they've uncovered
some obscure sartorial statute that nobody else knows about.
And if you've never heard that expression before, consider yourself lucky.
Anyway, no brown in town was an old British convention
and town essentially meant London,
especially the more conservative business environment of the city.
There was a pretty clear distinction at the time
between what you wore in town and what you wore in the country.
In the city, you had your navy and gray suits, white shirts, dark ties, black shoes.
Brown was more associated with the country.
Tweed, heavier and more textured fabrics, earthy colors, and of course, brown shoes.
So it wasn't that brown was considered bad taste.
It was really about brown belonging to a different environment
and a different level of formality.
Obviously, we don't live in that world anymore.
I wear tweed in the city sometimes.
I wear suede with tailoring.
I wear brown shoes with navy.
And honestly, I can't imagine a wardrobe without brown
because it's one of the richest and most versatile colors in menswear.
And I really do consider it a neutral on par with navy and gray.
This is one of those rules where knowing the history
actually makes it easier to understand why I don't follow it.
It made sense within a very particular time and place,
but that time and place just doesn't exist anymore.
Okay, let's leave the obscure sartorial statutes behind
and get to know one that I know plenty of people still have strong opinions about.
If you're wearing a suit, you should be wearing a tie.
Historically, there's really nothing surprising about this.
The modern suit developed at a time when neckwear was simply part of being properly dressed.
So wearing a suit without a tie wouldn't have looked intentionally casual.
It would have looked like something was missing.
Today, of course, we've got a lot more flexibility,
but I do think there's a right way and a wrong way to go tieless with a suit.
So if I'm wearing a conservative navy suit, white shirt, black oxford,
it can still look like something's missing
because everything else about the outfit is telling you that a tie should be there.
Where I find this works much better is with suits that are already a little less formal.
I'm talking linen, cotton, tropical wool, even something like hopsack or tweed.
I probably do this more often in the summer exactly for that reason.
Those fabrics naturally give you a little more room to wear an open collar shirt,
a polo or a knit, maybe with loafers or suede shoes.
And I think this has become more relevant as the culture around
getting dressed has gotten increasingly casual.
People love to say that the suit is there,
but I think part of the problem is that we've gotten used to thinking
that there's only one way to wear one.
You don't always need the shirt and tie and traditional dress shoes.
If you understand how to adjust the formality of everything around the suit,
it becomes a much more versatile piece of clothing.
All right, here's a rule that I actually follow most of the time.
Your socks should match your pants.
And there's a good reason for it.
You know, keeping your socks in the same general color family as your pants
creates a sense of cohesion and a continuous line down to your shoes.
It's clean, it's easy, and it doesn't draw unnecessary attention to your ankles.
I usually don't match them exactly.
If I'm wearing navy pants, I might wear a slightly darker or lighter shade of blue.
Same thing with gray or brown.
And most of the time, that's exactly what I want.
But there are certain outfits where I will deliberately do something different.
For example, if I'm going for a more preppy look,
I'm much more likely to introduce some color with my socks
because, you know, it makes sense with the personality of everything else I'm wearing.
And then there is one exception that, for me, is absolutely non-negotiable.
If I am going to a black tie formal event around the holidays,
I'm wearing bright red socks.
I've been doing that for years.
Now, is that technically correct?
No. Do I care?
Also no.
And I think that's an important distinction with all of these rules.
Breaking one doesn't automatically make something more stylish.
You know, sometimes the rule is actually the better choice.
But once you understand what it's doing for the outfit,
you can decide when you want to do something different.
And since I've already shown up to this black tie event wearing red socks,
I might as well break another rule while I'm there.
You should never wear a watch with a tuxedo.
There are actually two reasons behind this one,
and I think they're both pretty interesting.
The first is aesthetic.
Black tie is supposed to be very clean and minimal,
and the argument is that having a watch peeking out from under your cuff interrupts that.
And I can appreciate that.
But the second reason is really about etiquette.
Traditionally, if you're at a formal event,
you're supposed to be enjoying the evening and the company of the people you're with.
Looking at your watch suggests that you're concerned about the time
or maybe wondering when you can leave,
which could be seen as insulting to your host.
So unlike some of the rules we've talked about,
I actually think there's a fair amount of logic behind this one.
I just don't agree with the absolute prohibition.
I've worn a watch with black tie for years.
I even wore one with my tuxedo at my wedding.
But it has to be the right watch.
Simple, thin, understated, ideally on a black leather strap.
A classic dress watch that almost disappears into the outfit.
What I'm not wearing is a giant dive watch on a steel bracelet.
To me, that just completely misses the point.
So I think the spirit of the rule is still worth respecting.
Black tie is about restraint.
You can wear a watch without disrupting that,
but the watch itself needs to understand the assignment.
This next one is probably going to get me in trouble with the traditionalists.
A double-breasted jacket should always be buttoned.
And from a purely technical standpoint, they're right.
A double-breasted jacket is designed to be worn closed.
The overlapping fronts are anchored by the buttons.
The waist suppression is more apparent.
The lapels sit the way they were intended to.
And you get that strong, clean, and powerful double-breasted silhouette.
Open it up and there's simply more fabric hanging there
than you have with a single-breasted jacket.
So I completely understand why the conventional advice is to keep it buttoned.
But I also wear double-breasted jackets open sometimes.
And I do it because I like what happens to the attitude of the jacket when you do.
Double-breasted tailoring can feel very formal, very serious,
and even a little imposing.
But wearing it open takes some of that away.
It feels more relaxed and nonchalant, which I think makes it easier to wear
in our current culture where tailoring in general has become much less formal.
And I don't think that's because the double-breasted jacket itself
has fundamentally changed.
Obviously it hasn't.
I think we've changed the way we wear tailoring.
Guys who legitimately love this stuff have figured out ways to make it work
in a world where people simply don't dress the way they used to.
So yes, I know the jacket was designed to be worn buttoned.
I know it probably looks better buttoned from a traditional tailoring perspective.
But sometimes I prefer the way it feels open.
And for me, that's reason enough.
And finally, now this last one is probably more myth than actual rule,
but I've heard it repeated enough over the years that I think it belongs here.
Don't use the outside pockets on your suit jackets and sport coats.
The idea is that putting things in your pockets will stretch the fabric,
distort the shape of the jacket, the pocket, and eventually ruin the silhouette.
And sure, if you're stuffing your phone, keys, wallet,
half the contents of your desk in there,
and keeping your hands glued in there like the coolest menswear dude in the world,
well, it's probably going to happen.
But they're pockets. They're meant to be used.
And I think part of the confusion comes from the fact that
pockets on a new jacket are often sewn shut.
Now, some people take that to mean that you're supposed to leave them that way,
but they're sewn shut to help the jacket maintain its shape during manufacturing,
shipping, and while it's hanging in the store.
It's the same thing with the vents.
Once the jacket is yours, you can remove the stitching and use them.
And with the vents, it's non-negotiable.
You will remove the stitching.
I use my suit jacket and sport coat pockets all the time, especially when I'm traveling.
Boarding pass, hotel key, card case, small light things that I want to be able to get to easily.
And I'm obviously not trying to see how much stuff I can stuff in my pockets.
And this gets at something about menswear that has always bothered me a little bit.
Sometimes we become so concerned with preserving our clothes
that we forget to actually wear them.
We don't want them to wrinkle. We don't want them to crease.
We don't want to use the pockets because, God forbid,
the jacket eventually looks like somebody actually wore it and lived in it.
These are clothes. Take care of them. Absolutely.
Learn the rules, understand why they exist, and use them when they're useful.
But at some point, you have to stop worrying about doing everything perfectly
and just wear the dang clothes.
And that's really where things start to get interesting
because you can know all the rules, follow every one of them,
and still put on an outfit that just doesn't look right.
Sometimes it's fit. Sometimes it's proportion.
Sometimes every individual piece is perfectly fine.
And somehow the whole thing just isn't working.
Figuring out why that happens is something I've been digging into quite a bit lately.
And if you've ever put something on, looked in the mirror, and thought,
why does this look bad on me? Start with that playlist right up there.
And if you've been sitting through this whole video thinking,
wait a second, he's breaking a rule this entire time.
And that rule being, I'm sitting with my jacket buttoned.
I really should start charging you guys every time you leave this comment
because, yes, technically you are supposed to unbutton your jacket when you sit down.
I do it. Don't worry about it.
But on camera, it's common practice for broadcasters to button the jacket
because it just looks better.
And don't think I forgot. Thanks for watching and stay tailored.