8/25 Dr Siming Hummer: Unveil Bipolar Depression

Northern Medical Center Education Videos
2 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 12, 2026
Slides link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Gr3XBzdSytBbTxVnslOGr9HMVnlmwrJv/view?usp=sharing
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation emphasizes the critical need for accurate diagnosis of bipolar depression, which is frequently misdiagnosed as unipolar depression. The speaker advocates for longitudinal history taking and syndrome-based treatment over symptom-based approaches to prevent treatment resistance, substance abuse, and severe physical comorbidities.
I'm going to talk about unveiled bipolar depression.
The reason I say that,
because everybody knows how to treat depression, right?
I mean, you guys haven't rotated to that part yet,
but doing rotation, you will learn a lot about depression.
When you hear depression, you need to pay attention.
There's different kind of depression.
So I'm going to talk about that.
The learning objective is recognize
and accurately diagnose bipolar depression,
because that is the diagnose mostly misdiagnosed.
And learn psychiatric medical comorbidity
of bipolar depression.
Because a mood disorder not adequately treated,
then your body will develop other issues.
Oh, here we go.
We just started.
You didn't miss much at all.
We're just talking about learning objectives, okay?
Recognize accurately diagnose of bipolar depression,
psychiatric medical comorbidities of bipolar depression.
Actually, any kind of mood disorder,
if it's not adequate treated,
the stress will go towards body.
So people have a lot of physical illness.
So when you become an internal medicine family doc,
when you see people have zillion medical issues,
always think psych.
What else is underlying that has not taken care of?
Then your body will keep doing that.
Treatment strategy of bipolar depression.
In fact, bipolar depression is increasingly recognized
as a prevalent disability mental illness.
A lot of people, when they not recognize
or did not realize it's an illness,
they can have all kinds of problem.
Treatment of acute manic mania is very common.
Everybody recognize that,
but very rarely you have people in manic
and able to catch it, okay?
Vast majority of people even have a bipolar disorder.
They actually spend much more time in depression.
Often bipolar depression is mistakenly diagnosed,
treated as unipolar depression,
potentially resulting in increased disability to patients,
treatment resistance and high risk of relapse.
It is imperative that physicians be updated
to the proper recognition treatment of bipolar depression.
Prevalence, that was summarized many, many years ago.
I'm pretty sure it's pretty much higher now.
I don't do research.
I just see everyday life and that's how I feel.
Lifetime prevalence, of course, according to the statistics
is typically reported 0.5 or 1.5, in reality much higher.
Data suggests that lifetime prevalence
of bipolar disorder, one, two, bipolar spectrum,
adding it together, it's much higher
because when you think about bipolar, they have subtypes.
Bipolar one, bipolar two, bipolar spectrum,
cyclosomic, the list goes on.
So they have subtypes.
For example, in the U.S. community,
3.4% positive for bipolar one and two.
And consider those misdiagnosed.
So it's gonna be a heck of a lot higher.
The epidemiology study, the lifetime prevalence
for bipolar disorder range from three to 6.5.
I still think it's underestimated.
Right now, you guys, I don't know if you guys learned
that DSM-4, DSM-5, that was, DSM-5 comes out.
Right now, you guys only learn DSM-5, right?
They have DSM-4.
When I was learning it,
I'm just doing the comparison with bipolar.
I mean, you can look it up and do those kind of things
and compare yourself.
Bipolar, according to DSM-4, is distinct period
of normally persistently elevated expensive irritable mood
last about a week
or any duration of hospitalizations necessary.
These are too rigid.
In reality, you hardly have anybody able
to meet the criteria.
During the period of mood disturbance,
we form more of the following,
like inflated self-esteem, grandiosity,
decreased need for sleeping.
More talkative than usual or pressure talking.
I don't know if you guys went
through a rotation of psychiatry yet.
I mean, these are the things you have to learn,
getting to understand and remember, right?
Memorize flight of ideas,
minds are racing, distractibility,
not able to pay attention,
and increased goal-directed activity.
They usually are very impulsive.
They want to do something and then will go for it, do it.
Sometimes they have painful consequences
like unplanned trips and shopping sprees,
things like that,
and promiscuous, excessive involvement
in pleasurable activity like we just talked about.
And it's severe enough, sometimes needs to be hospitalized.
That's usually for Bipolar 1.
And Bipolar 1, as a matter of fact, very rare,
very rare because Bipolar 1, you don't need a doctor.
People on the street will recognize manic, okay?
Sometimes other things can mimic manic,
such as substance, drug use, some kind of medication,
and some kind of medical condition
can mimic hypomanic,
but you can do medical testing to figure that out, right?
DSM-5 is a little bit different.
The reason I put these two together
because I want you guys also see the difference.
Distinguished period of normal, persistent elevation,
expensive, irritable mood.
These are pretty much the same at least a week,
most of the day, nearly every day.
Hospitalization needed during the period of mood disturbance
they have three, four symptoms of elevation,
such as inflated self-esteem,
decreased need sleeping, more talkative.
These are pretty much the same, okay?
And they usually do things,
have high potential for painful consequence.
Here is the difference between Bipolar, even Bipolar 1.
Bipolar 1, I call it manic depression.
The rest of the Bipolar, I don't call them manic depression.
Bipolar 1 is because they're upper much higher,
but their low can be just as low.
Even with Bipolar 1 itself,
they only spent 20% of the time in manic and hypomanic,
13% mixed stage.
They spent 2 3rds of the time is in a depression.
See the difference?
People think, oh, manic depression,
they have to be high, high.
You're not gonna catch them when they're high.
You only see them when they're depressed.
Particularly when they're in high stage,
they enjoy the life very much.
They don't need much sleep.
They get things done.
They can do a lot of things.
They feel life is superb.
Here comes Bipolar 2.
Bipolar 2 is what I see the most in clinic.
See the pie shape?
Bipolar 2, they spent a whopping 94% time in depression,
2% hypomanic, 4% in mixed stage.
How many people actually even aware of that?
Not many, not in reality, actually.
So when people coming in with depression,
you always have to evaluate thoroughly
to make sure what you are treating,
which tree you are treating, actually.
Most of the time, Bipolar 2 is asymptomatic.
They don't have symptoms.
Only half of the time, they have symptoms.
Even the symptoms they have, 94% time in depression.
Now you see how confusing it is,
even though it's manic depression,
but they spend more time in depression.
Bipolar 1 and 2, the difference between them
is like day and night.
I will talk about that later too.
Misdiagnosed, how do they misdiagnose?
Okay, 26% diagnosed with anxiety.
You will see a lot of people coming in for anxiety,
and 60% misdiagnosed unipolar.
This is not forgiving
because it can be very easily distinguished.
During the first evaluation,
we need to ask enough question to figure it out.
So people, when you hear, oh, you're depressed,
okay, depression, that is wrong
because you need to ask when everything happened,
when you were young, everything.
So I don't take snapshot.
When you take snapshot, it's only now.
When you take a longitudinal picture,
so you know from early on all the way till now,
you need to know all that.
That depend on you, what kind of question you ask
to figure that out, right?
Many people were misdiagnosed with borderline personality.
Personality, for crying out loud,
is a personality disorder, not a disease.
It's not able to treat unless you give therapy.
It's just a personality.
I'm not quite sure why.
Personality disorder, DSM-5, in the past,
only is excess too.
There's nothing much you can do.
And also misdiagnosed schizophrenia.
That is easy to explain.
I will explain later too.
And when people have alcohol dependence, drug abuse,
sometimes misdiagnosed as bipolar.
Schizoaffective disorder is pretty much,
they have a thought disorder mixed with mood disorder,
mood and thought disorder.
35% is usually not adequate diagnosis
until 10 years later.
In reality, sometimes 15, 20 years later,
and the misdiagnosed rate is a lot higher than 35.
Cost of misdiagnosis, lapse in history taking.
So if you take just current, you are prone to misdiagnose.
Presence of the psychiatric and medical commodity.
They coming in with something else,
not necessarily related to mood.
Lack of collateral history, family history.
So usually people come to my clinic outpatient,
usually there was together enough to able to tell you a lot.
Inpatient is a bit different.
They might not all together able to give you information.
So it's up to you to dig information from families,
from other sources of information.
Their previous doctors, their notes on previous,
anything that can relate it, family member of course.
Or lack of screening instruments.
I always use this one to make sure
get the mood disorder out.
It's called the mood questionnaire.
I will talk about that.
Lack of information or respond to previous treatment,
each and every medication.
That is something I added to every of my history taking.
I need to know what kind of medication
they were treated in the past.
Not just that, what's their reaction to the meds.
To me, the biggest clue.
Unipolar, they have different subtypes.
I'm talking about major depression, minor depression,
seasonal, dysthymic.
So if you draw a curve,
major depression may be dipping much deeper.
Minor is dipping a little bit.
Seasonal, you understand winter time.
Dysthymic is even less.
So when you draw the curve,
you can see the difference between the subtypes.
Bipolar, same thing.
They have bipolar one, bipolar two,
bipolar spectrum, cyclosomic.
So if you draw a sine wave,
manic depression is much deeper curve.
Bipolar two, upper can be very shallow,
but depression can be very deep.
And bipolar spectrum, cyclosomic, same thing.
Note 69% of bipolar patient has been misdiagnosed.
This is actually more accurate.
This is number more accurate.
That's what I see.
In clinic, only 20% bipolar disorder
has been accurately diagnosed.
This is my question for everyone.
Why that's the case?
Most of the bipolar disorder initial symptoms
were depression.
And usually onset is either teens, late teens.
So when they depressed,
and then if they go see,
usually the doctor they first see
is always primary doc, internal medicine.
That's why I call them the front liners.
They need to learn this.
They need to understand this
so they don't get people on the wrong track immediately.
And also you guys are learning in school.
Right now, everything is symptoms based
rather than syndrome based.
What's that mean?
People ask, what do you mean by that?
Symptom based, they're very thorough.
Okay, coming in, check you from head to toe,
headaches, insomnia, this, that, the other,
lung, heart, kidney, right?
That's what Western medicine is all about.
But once you gather all the information,
you don't start to treat.
Here in Western trained medical doc,
we were very thorough and we treat everything, anything,
treat their symptoms, right?
Eastern medicine, I trained there as well.
We are more focused on treat the root.
You need to figure out where those symptoms come from.
Then you will understand what kind of syndrome,
what kind of illness it is causing these kinds of symptoms.
Big difference.
Most of the patients who present initially with depression
may receive antidepressant, very common.
It's almost too common
because I don't usually see patients
for their first episode of depression.
People come to me, they already went through many doctors
and they come to me because they don't get well
and then they come to me.
Later, the patient has insomnia
because usually as teenagers,
they don't really, trouble sleeping starts with that
but it doesn't show clinically, why?
Kids, they can get by with little sleep.
It doesn't phase them.
Okay, so what?
If I go to bed at two, I get up at six, go to school,
they are able still to go to school
but when people age, they might not be able to do that.
So those kinds of symptoms,
usually you don't know until later.
And once they aged, then they start to complain insomnia
and then they will receive sleeping pill.
Then they start to have anxiety
and then get medication for their anxiety.
And eventually, they take several medications
for different symptoms, very common.
But their mood may not be stabilized
because at no time was the entire syndrome evaluated
or only the present symptoms.
So when they go see primary care, that's what they do.
Oh, you can't sleep, here's the pill for that.
You have anxiety, here's the pill for that.
Oh, you can't concentrate, here's the pill for that.
There's so many people misdiagnosed with ADD.
How many cases individual syndromes will resolve
without independent treatment if the syndrome is treated?
In many cases, individual symptoms will resolve
without independently treatment if the syndrome is treated.
So what's that mean is,
if you really treat the root of a problem,
most of the symptoms disappear.
But if you treat it just symptoms,
the syndrome is still there.
This is what I summarized over the years.
Usually when people come,
first they have what, insomnia, right?
I can't sleep.
And they don't usually come to you until in their 30s,
at least, or in the late 20s.
Insomnia is the first thing they will notice.
This is how smart your body is.
As a matter of fact, when people have an illness,
your body is the one bring up symptom
to get your attention, your doctor's attention.
Very first symptom, sleep.
But it changes over time.
So when kids coming in,
oh yeah, I can get by with my sleep.
But it doesn't phase them.
And then sometime they can stay up
two, three days in a row.
For average people, they can't do that.
Two, three days in a row.
Just one night not sleep.
I'll be like drunk the next day.
I can't function.
Do you understand?
So this is a very important,
very first branch, insomnia.
The next one we're talking about mood disorder,
basically it's chemical imbalance in the root.
So your body will bring your attention.
First branch, insomnia.
Second branch, anxiety.
A lot of people, they can talk through anxiety.
Then your body will kick up a notch
to have panic attack.
What's panic attack?
It's escalated anxiety attack with vital sign change.
So your heart racing fast.
You can't breathe.
You have chest pain.
So it's anxiety attack with vital sign change.
Those are the people you might see in ER.
Oh, I'm having a heart attack.
I have chest pain.
So after work, I'd say,
well, you don't have a heart attack.
You have panic attack.
Go see Dr. Hammer.
So I got a lot of patients from ER
because that's how your body trying to get your attention
because when you have chest pain,
obviously it's going to grab your attention, right?
If still not adequately treated,
that's psychosis kicking in.
They start hearing things.
They start seeing things.
They start to get paranoia,
but this is something you need to really pay attention
if you are a psychiatrist.
Thought disorder is like schizophrenia, right?
They hearing things, seeing things, paranoia
from the get-go, from beginning.
Mood disorder with psychotic feature.
You can see clearly start have mood disorder.
Not adequate treated.
That's when they develop psychosis.
So it's important to distinguish
is mood disorder with psychotic feature
or schizoaffective disorder.
That means they have a thought disorder
adding on a mood disorder.
Doesn't matter.
The diagnosis treatment is pretty much the same thing.
When it's still not adequately treated,
some people they will start to use substances.
I treat a lot of vets and sometimes policemen.
They take things to their own hand.
I'm going to do something about it.
The more they do it, the worse it becomes
because your chemical imbalance is already there.
When you use substance,
you demolish the leftover balance.
And if mood disorder not adequately treated,
the stress will attack people physically.
So if you're young, pretty healthy.
So those symptoms are vague.
Headaches, neck pain, back pain,
irritable bowel, fibromyalgia.
But if you're aged, have something medically,
can be out of proportion.
Out of proportion, what's that mean?
I do many years of consults.
Like somebody can't breathe, right?
They're on 10 liters oxygen.
They still can't breathe.
That's when they call me.
It's like, what is going on?
Why is this patient not getting well?
They missed the big boat
because this patient has not been sleeping for two months.
Everything will be screaming, so to speak.
So just pay attention.
When you do inpatient, you know,
people coming in because of physical illness,
after they tried everything, anything,
patient don't get well,
always think something underlying, a psych.
And then started to affect them,
every level of life, relationship problem,
function problem, they can't hold a job
and start to have legal issues
and they get in and out of jail.
I worked seven years in a prison system.
I see this so clearly play out in their real life.
But the thing is, if somebody catches that early on,
they might not even have that kind of outcome.
How to narrow down accurate diagnosis?
Thoroughly, thoroughly evaluate symptom.
Not only the presenting ones,
but also symptoms in the past,
particularly the past hypomanic symptom.
If you don't ask, they may not bring it up, okay?
And some patient, even when you ask the symptom,
they will deny it for whatever reason.
But reality pretty much tells me,
wait a minute, I will talk some of it if we have time.
Patient respond to medications,
particularly antidepressants
sometimes give you the most clue.
Okay, people are very good at giving people Prozac,
Zoloft, Lexapro, Cymbalta, this and that,
all kinds of antidepressants.
How they're responding to it,
to me, gives me the biggest clue.
It's not just asking, oh, what do you have?
What are you taking?
How are you responding to it?
Because if you not belong to major depression,
your body will kick it.
Your body will give you the clue
and then you just need to listen to that.
Family history mental illness, very, very important.
When we talk about the root, right?
Chemical imbalance, where that come from?
Genetic, vast majority genetic.
Come from father, mother,
sometimes skip generation from grandparent,
but from the family history,
you can get something from that.
And ask aunts, uncle, cousin from both side of family,
anybody have any kind of mood disorder.
Keep one thing in mind in America,
particularly in the past generations,
you might not see most of mood disorder,
but you will see a lot of alcoholic, workaholic
that also should give you some clue.
And now newer generation,
they will just take things of their own hand.
They will use substance to self-medicate.
So those things also very important to ask.
What do you use?
What kind of substance?
When did you start to use?
From what age to what age?
Everything you need to ask.
Alcohol, okay, from when to when?
And what's the most amount?
Did you ever have alcoholic induced shakes, blackouts,
DT, DT means severe withdrawal from alcohol.
There's two withdrawals dangerous.
One is alcohol, the other is benzo.
You guys know benzo, benzodiazepine, right?
These two withdrawals can be lethal.
Have to be careful.
So you always ask those questions.
And everything they use,
you need to lay it down.
Opiates, meth, cocaine, whatever.
So as long they use, you need to jogging down.
When did you use?
When did you stop?
Did you ever stop?
Are you able to stop?
What's the longest time is your sobriety.
Mood disorder questionnaire is validated screen tool
for bipolar disorder.
I use that since graduation actually.
Nobody pay attention to that.
It is the most useful tool
to distinguish manic versus unipolar,
bipolar versus unipolar.
So mood disorder questionnaire, look it up.
You guys should be able to.
I have some slides here too.
Mood disorder questionnaire.
It's very easy.
Just ask those questions.
You feel so good, hyper,
that other people thought you were not your normal self
or you were so hyper, you got into trouble.
These kinds of questions still kind of lame,
but you still need to ask those.
You were so irritable that you start to fight arguments,
self-confident, more self-confident, this, that, the other.
So you can look these up.
To me, what's most important besides this,
specifically ask them sleep.
Were you able to get by with sleep from time to time?
How old were you when that very first time?
That gives me the clue.
Most people start symptoms in the teens, 20s.
I add more questions, stay up.
That gives me the most clue.
A lot of people are not able to stay up.
If some people are able to stay up two, three days
in a row, you pretty much narrow down
what diagnosis he had.
Average person not knowing,
able to stay up two, three days in a row.
What is MDQ?
The question I just, the screen.
This one is very useful
because it can identify 70% of person with bipolar,
will eliminate 90% people without the condition.
So it's very important,
particularly anybody coming in with mood disorder,
you need to distinguish unipolar, bipolar,
totally different tree, totally.
It is for the treatment purpose.
Not a lot of people understand that.
I will talk about that.
Every patient suspect of having unipolar depression
should be evaluated for bipolar disorder.
Use a quick screen tool to make sure
you make sure it's distinguished.
Depression no longer should be thought of as a diagnosis,
but rather as a presentation of several important disorder
that needs to be ruled in or out.
Yeah, people coming in, they're all depressed.
Number one, but really, is that true?
You will be the detective.
You will be the one tell the difference.
Healthcare professions can no longer ignore
the cost of untreated bipolar
and the cost with related with everything.
Every patient diagnosed with depression
who's not responding well to antidepressant
should be re-evaluated for other forms of things.
So primary care physicians see disproportionate number
of patient with bipolar disorder
who may present with symptom depression and primary care.
They might rotate it in psychiatry,
but they are not specifically trained.
So it's very easy for them to forget.
Oh, you have depression.
Here comes the antidepressant.
Failure to diagnose both bipolar when present,
significant departure from optimal treatment pattern,
potential malpractice hazard.
Most of the bipolar initial symptoms, depression.
Keep that in mind.
And primary care and psychiatrists should work together
to recognize, manage patient.
I don't mind if they don't know how to treat.
You need to learn when to refer out.
American patients are very,
actually most of them, they are very obedient.
They just listen.
Okay, you're the doctor.
I'm just taking meds.
It's after years and years as I'm not getting anyways.
Something is wrong.
That's when they started to look for other doctor,
but how many years has been wasted, right?
Every managed care organization, logical practice,
have a disease management program
in major depression place.
Collaborative care offers the best option
for managing bipolar disorder.
Should not be regarded simply as illness
that requires treatment,
but also as a chronic lifelong probe
that needs long-term management.
I usually teach people how to manage.
And yeah, I will make follow-up appointment.
One thing different with my clinic,
I give patient the option.
I know when is the incoming episode.
It always starts with trouble sleeping.
So when that happens,
you don't have to wait for our appointment.
Send me a message.
If I can pull them in sooner, start medication,
I can help them aborted an episode.
Very important.
I'd rather treat them before the manic
than to deal with aftermath of an episode.
So if mood disorder,
particularly bipolar, not adequately treated,
they can have all kinds of issues.
Like we already touched upon,
I said the stress will hit you physically, right?
So neuroendocrinology dysregulation,
they have diabetes,
they have cardiovascular disease.
People actually have heart attacks.
Obesity, that I'm gonna talk about it
because nobody's talking about that.
Why is that?
Why they're overweight?
Okay, think about polar bear.
Winter is a big stressor, right?
Whatever the polar bear intake
stored away as fuels for the polar bear.
So when you look around people
with chronic illness, chronic pain,
they are huge.
I'm not quite sure if it's the same case
in Taiwan, in America.
That's what I see.
Why is that?
They really tell me I don't eat more than other people.
I said, I totally get it.
Whatever you intake your body,
hold on to it,
store away as fuels to do you a favor.
We don't need that favor.
Now you understand.
When you actually taking care of stress,
it's easier to lose weight.
That is something you really need to keep in mind.
In Asia, maybe that's not so obvious,
but in America, very obvious.
Migraine headaches is some, oops.
Migraine headache is something they usually complain
and compromised immune response,
asthma, the whole nine yard illness,
particularly pain, headaches, neck pain,
back pain, irritable bowel.
It can be out of control.
Oops, where we at?
Okay, now we're going to talk about the common pathway,
where the patient come to me actually.
If you can think about a common pathway,
it's almost look like a funnel.
The first line people, they go see family doc,
internal medicine, pediatrician, OB.
So when they depressed,
they will complain to those people, right?
But they're going to be treated antidepressant.
If they truly have major depression,
they move on, they get better.
If they don't get well, where do they go?
Outpatient psych, right?
That's when they see psychiatrist.
And if those doctors not pay attention,
not asking thorough question,
they give you big gunners.
We have now developed so many more potent antidepressants,
different kinds, more meds, higher dose.
If they still don't get well, where do they go?
Emergency room, crisis center.
Now they develop suicidal thoughts.
I'm nervous wreck, I'm hanging on with teeth nails.
When they still don't get well, they go inpatient.
And then by then, some people lose their insurance,
lose their job.
They ended up go to community mental health center.
And then bottom line, they go prison system
if still not adequate treated.
I just want you to see that common pathway.
So people coming layer by layer,
if they're truly adequate treated,
they will not drop down.
If they not, that's the way they go.
I see every patient in every situation like that.
Very sad.
Seven year in the prison system,
I see so many patient misdiagnosed.
Lose job, not able to hold on a job, all because of that.
Weight loss, I mean, job loss and short term disability,
negative impact, and of course, divorce,
marital problem, school, job related.
So there's consequences
if the illness is not adequate treated.
Higher divorce rate, you see that a lot.
Now, treatment.
Mood disorder, I made it very distinguished.
What is unipolar, what is bipolar?
Why do we distinguish these three?
Treatment purpose only.
You might not learn in school.
You might not learn that in the US school.
Sometimes the magazine doesn't tell you that either
in continuing education.
In reality, that's what I see.
Unipolar treated with antidepressant.
That means any antidepressant should work.
Bipolar treated with mood stabilizer.
Totally, totally different category meds.
I actually don't mix them together.
To me, when you mix them together, they butt in heads.
The patient didn't actually get the benefit.
That's what I'm talking about.
How they respond to med makes a difference.
If they truly belong to unipolar,
antidepressant of any kind should work.
If you need to be on two, three, four,
different antidepressant pushed to the top,
not working, that means they don't have unipolar.
So when people with bipolar treated antidepressant,
what you need to look?
Number one, nothing.
I didn't see any help.
Number two, yeah, seems working.
Always stop working.
Number three, if they are potent,
antidepressant make them worse immediately.
In what ways?
More trouble sleeping, more anxious, anxiety, pacing,
waiting for the other shoe to drop,
and you don't even know where's the other shoe yet.
So what is mood stabilizer?
I think this might be too much for you guys.
You haven't go through that yet,
but you can learn something about mood stabilizer.
They have Mobilify.
Back then, Saphiris, it's not actually very potent.
Forayla is a very good meds.
Latuda is mediocre.
I rely a lot on the Zyprexa, Cretiapine.
Tiara is okay, it's a less side effect.
Problemazepine, I almost never use.
Problemazepine is interesting.
This medication enhance other medication metabolize,
kind of take down other people efficacy,
so I don't hardly ever use that one.
Depakote, too many side effect.
Lamotrigine is a wonder drug.
I use that a lot, particularly for bipolar depression.
Works wonders with very little side effect, almost none.
Lithium is a very, very good one
for people with a lot of manic.
Like I said, I see a lot of bipolar depression,
but they have some spend more time in the manic.
Do they have those case?
Yes, they do.
When those case, when you use mood stabilizer,
still not able to balance them at lithium, always works.
It's a very classic meds, very toxic
because they're therapeutic toxic level very close.
So you have to be very careful and monitor closely.
Here's the argument.
Some psychiatrists argue that one third of patient
bipolar respond well to antidepressant.
My take is different.
70% do not respond well to antidepressant.
Why play with the fire?
They don't.
So when people with bipolar antidepressant,
I usually taper them off.
Antidepressant with bipolar patient, be very, very careful.
They will have, it's called the rebound.
So you can't stop cold turkey.
It will make them miserable.
It's not because this meds help you.
Precisely, it's not.
You will see the worst rebound.
That means causing rebound anxiety,
rebound depression, more trouble sleeping.
They're basically a mess.
So whatever antidepressant they are,
if you want to switch them to mood stabilizer,
you need to make very sure, get them stabilized first,
then slowly get rid of the meds,
even though they don't have,
supposedly they shouldn't have withdrawals, but they do.
This is actually already touched upon.
So when people with bipolar treated antidepressant,
first is nothing, I didn't notice any help,
or maybe it works, but always stop working.
Worsening symptom, you have to really, really pay attention.
More anxious, more nervous, more restless,
develop suicidal thoughts.
Only one case I learned when I was in residency,
it actually triggered a euphoria.
They kick them into a manic.
I feel great the next day.
I have one patient when I was a resident,
late nineties coming in.
I mean, of course, back then don't know much.
Okay, depressed, give him Prozac the next day.
Actually, he come back and thanked me,
and he feel like on seventh heaven.
He said, I don't know, doc, what you gave me,
but I feel so great.
I'm like, okay, you're not leaving.
So that's the only case actually triggered a manic.
And he is nice enough to come back,
tell me what a learning experience.
I'm like, okay.
But ever since then, I never see euphoria.
I see dysphoria.
That's the one we talked about,
more anxious, nervous, pacing, restless.
That's dysphoria.
When I treat patient,
the first thing I do is stabilize sleep pattern.
I don't give a sleeping pill.
Let me explain that.
Average person, we have go through four or five cycles
to reset our computer.
Our brain is our computer.
What is the sleep pattern?
We go through a shallow sleep,
deep sleep, dream sleep, REM sleep.
We go through a four or five cycle to sleep deeply.
To me, most of the sleeping pill
is give you the shallow sleep.
So some people wake up, say, I don't know, did I sleep?
I don't know, I still feel tired.
Restore sleep pattern is something like mood stabilizer
was restore their sleep pattern.
Basically you treat the root of a problem,
then you will do that.
Not a sleeping pill per se.
So people like to use Trazolone, it's an antidepressant.
You give it for sleep purpose for bipolar people,
they either not working or make them feel miserable.
That's what your body needs
is actually take care of my problem
instead of kill my messenger.
Insomnia is a messenger.
I kill the messenger, you're not gonna solve problem.
And also adjust the dose
according to the phase of the illness.
See, for example, I'd never dictate the patient's dosing.
Each individual is different.
Even when you use one meds,
the criteria I gave for them,
okay, when you take this,
if you're able to fall asleep within 30 minutes,
sleep through the night, all night,
that's your dosing, take it every night.
Each individual is different.
Some people, my starting dose is already achieve that.
Some people maybe need mid dose, higher dose.
So each individual is different.
Educate patient to be on the lookout for symptom changing,
complete abstinence from substance use.
That's very important
because I have a background for addiction treatment.
I'm ASAM certified for American Society of Medicine Addiction.
So it's not a psych addiction program.
It's medicine addiction.
Back then, I did a lot of like detox, inpatient detox.
Those kinds of information,
the education I learned helped me a great deal
as a patient psychiatrist.
And when I treat a lot of vets,
their theory is, okay, don't mix with alcohol.
So they will drink alcohol in the morning
and take meds at nighttime.
I'm just telling them, no, that's not gonna work.
Why?
All the psychotropic meds comes to the brain.
Your brain cell have receptors,
grab the medicine, chemical balance,
message, move on, right?
When you drink, I'm not talking about a bottle.
I'm talking about one sip.
You have millions of molecules and they have high affinity.
So they locked in with the receptor
faster than your medication.
When your seat's taken,
it's like a movie theater seat's taken.
You can't sit on other people.
So your medication have nowhere to connect,
lost the destiny.
And that's the main reason.
If you want to get well, take the meds,
stay away from any substance, same thing.
One puff of marijuana, millions of molecule.
So basically tell them substance is basically hijack.
Hijack your medication.
So it's easier for them to understand that, to stop.
Otherwise you can give them, you know,
anti-abuse, nortraxone, whatever.
They might not able to do that.
So adjust those in coach to each patient.
Educate patient to be on the lookout, symptom changing.
Okay.
This is what I do usually for the evaluation.
You need to do a thorough evaluation.
I just gave you an example of how I do it.
HPI, I will screen everything and anything
from major depression to bipolar to psych.
And you pretty much screen everything.
When it comes to it, we'll talk about it.
Reference is basically, just take a look at what this is.
So that's pretty much the end of our talk.
Now we'll take some questions.
Man, that took a lot of time too already.
Any questions?
This might be too specific because you haven't
specialized what kind of field you're going to practice.
But hopefully no matter what kind of field,
keep one thing in mind.
Psych is the root issue.
In Chinese medicine, you understand root and branch, right?
That's how human body operates.
If you're able to identify what is the root,
it's easier to handle.
But if you start to treat everything,
anything comes your way, it's going to be a bare tree.
Every branch is cut, not be a healthy tree though.
Can I ask a question in Chinese?
When I was reading the book,
I mentioned that the difference between DSM-IV and V
and the definition of bipolar is that
for IV, if it's a mental illness caused by drugs,
then it's not a bipolar mania.
But for V, even if it's caused by drugs,
it's still a mania.
Is that right?
Not in reality.
I don't want to draw like definite.
Yeah, if it's substance induced, it's transient.
If they truly don't have mood disorder, fine.
But if they do, even the substance is removed,
the symptom will persist.
So I don't just based on one thing to exclude,
oh, you don't have mood disorder.
Oh, you don't have this.
You don't have that.
I will hold on.
I will take this as part of the history.
Okay, we touched upon that.
But what about vast majority people
use substance for a reason?
If you don't have a mood disorder,
people really don't care to use substance
if they are really stupid.
I mean, it's just different.
But if they don't have anything underlying,
how many people will be crazy
about using substance persistently?
When you see those kind of case,
you always evaluate what is going on underlying.
I'm an addictionologist, so to me,
90% of people, when they have substance use,
they have a mood disorder of some sort underlying.
That's the main reason why they use.
Otherwise, they can care less.
And they're vulnerable.
Some people, they have something underlying,
use substance once, kick them over,
and they start to have symptoms and they don't go away.
That happens in reality.
But if they truly, one time substance
get them really into a scary thing,
they're no longer use anymore and they now have no symptom.
Yeah, I agree.
They don't have anything.
But I will not use that as a standard rule.
Okay, you don't have mood disorder.
I will not dare to draw that kind of conclusion.
That's kind of like taking a snapshot.
I'm like, okay, you have this purpose.
So let's see, hopefully never happen again
and watch out for this, that, the other.
If you have those, let me know.
That's another way to tell people on the watch out.
Instead tell you, oh, you don't have this.
And then he will, I'm okay.
I can still try it.
I can still do this.
So.
Thank you.
Yes, I know.
Yeah, a lot of times you really have to think.
In reality, for me, I'm very conscientious.
If my patient is not doing well, I will go back.
I will dig deeper.
What else I miss?
And yeah, when people get well,
for a long time, suddenly symptom returned.
The first thing you ask, do you take your meds?
Number one.
Number two, do you use substance?
It's the only two reason.
If they don't take meds yet, their symptom return.
And if they use substance, they kick off the meds,
the symptom return also.
Very good question though.
Any other question?
And mood disorder usually is a base.
And if it's not adequately treated,
it will keep branching out to ADD, to OCD,
to this, to that, the other.
But you still need to really, really focus down
to see what kind of mood base it is.
I hardly ever see free diagnosis only anxiety.
So if we encounter anxiety patient,
he often has depression.
You need to screen that at least.
Ask everything related to depression.
Because anxiety partly is a free diagnosis,
just the anxiety disorder, nothing else.
It always correlates related to mood disorder,
either major depression or bipolar depression.
So when you treat major depression,
treat bipolar depression, anxiety goes away.
I see that day in, day out.
So you don't need other meds to treat anxiety alone.
Particularly, I don't use benzos to treat anxiety.
It's very much set people up.
Different topic, different day, anyways.
All right, any other question?
We have two more minutes.
Whether you become a psychiatrist or not,
but keep that in mind.
Always, when patient's medical issues way out of line,
always ask for a psych counsel
to see what else is underlying.
Trauma also play a role.
Substance use play a role.
Family history play a role.
So there's other contributing factor
you need to really screen carefully.
Because some are very serious.
You should know at first glance.
And if it's not that serious,
you probably won't switch to psychiatry.
But there's nothing very dangerous,
that people often forget,
but you should switch to psychiatry.
Case by case, you have to really look
what else is going on.
So your antenna should be high.
What else is, could be, would be.
So it will reveal how you think,
prevalence, I mean,
what kind of differential diagnosis could be.
Why this patient has such a severe physical illness,
per se, right?
Or something else.
That usually will trigger you to think,
okay, what else is going on?
Because human body is intertwined.
Mental, physical is intertwined.
And if their physical disorder is way out of whack,
you always think, oh, what else did we miss?
But if it's not, it's mild.
And they never, I mean,
those questions you can't even ask.
Did you ever treat it for depression, anxiety?
I mean, just one line.
They're, no, never have that.
That's okay.
And if something triggers,
you feel like, maybe I need to ask for psych counsel.
If they ever be abused,
maybe some people are so severely abused,
they don't even have memory of,
and their body physically will display certain symptoms.
Yeah, that's also should be considered,
maybe something underlying.
Thank you.
Very good.
Hopefully this can be some helpful hints.
Other than that, you two are very inquisitive mind.
This is wonderful.
Have a good rotation.
And I will sign out.
Thank you, teacher.
Oh, you're welcome.
We learn much.
Yeah.
Thank you.
All right, have the best of the rest of your rotation, okay?
Yeah, thank you.
Bye-bye.
