The Arnolfini Portrait, Jan van Eyck, 1434. The National Gallery, London.
Look at their hands. He's holding hers, in what might be the most famous handhold in art. Now look at the mirror behind them. It shows the whole room from behind: the window, the oranges, the chandelier, the two of them. Two things from the room are missing.
Jan van Eyck painted this in Bruges in 1434, and wrote on the wall: "Jan van Eyck was here." For a long time everyone called it a wedding. The man they thought was the groom got married in 1447, six years after the painter died. His cousin is the better answer, and the only wife of his anyone has found a record of was engaged at thirteen and dead before February 1433. Her mother mentions it in half a sentence.
We put as much work into the sound as into the pictures: music made for this painting, a soundscape underneath, and small sounds for the objects as you zoom in. Best with headphones.
Chapters 0:00 Two things are missing 0:36 Who's in this room 1:08 A strange-looking man 1:50 Money on display 2:49 Jan van Eyck was here 3:28 The mirror 4:34 The wedding certificate 5:16 The wrong groom 6:00 Is she pregnant? 6:51 The other Giovanni 7:27 Costanza 8:11 Half a sentence 9:05 One candle 9:56 The saint on the chair 10:34 Zoom in. It gets worse. 10:59 Life and death on the frame 11:30 The dog 12:13 What the mirror doesn't show 13:05 The first drawing 13:35 My theory 14:20 Him 14:50 A lock on the painting 15:41 How it got to London 16:26 The one he signed
Images The Arnolfini Portrait, Jan van Eyck, 1434. The National Gallery, London (NG186). Image and infrared reflectogram: The National Gallery, London, via Closer to Van Eyck (closertovaneyck.kikirpa.be). Public domain. Jan van Eyck, Portrait of a Man (Giovanni Arnolfini?), Gemäldegalerie, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin. Jan van Eyck, Dresden Triptych, right wing, Saint Catherine, 1437, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Dresden. Both via Closer to Van Eyck. Public domain. Jacopo della Quercia, Trenta Altar and tomb slabs, San Frediano, Lucca. Photos: Palickap, CC BY-SA 4.0; Sailko, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Tomb of Margaret of Bourbon, Royal Monastery of Brou. Photo: Christophe Finot, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Inventory of Margaret of Austria, 1516, printed in A. Le Glay, Correspondance de l'empereur Maximilien Ier et de Marguerite d'Autriche, vol. 2, 1839, via Internet Archive. Public domain. Henry Bone after Thomas Lawrence, George IV as Prince Regent. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. CC0.
Look at their hands. He's holding hers.
It's probably the most famous pair of hands in all of art.
And behind them, on the wall, there's a mirror.
It shows this whole room from behind.
The window, the oranges, the chandelier, the two of them.
Two things in this room are missing from that mirror.
To find what's missing,
first, look at what's here.
Jan van Eyck painted this in Bruges,
a rich trading city in what's now Belgium, in 1434.
It's oil paint on oak and it's smaller than most people expect,
about 80 by 60 centimeters.
Today it hangs in the National Gallery in London.
The man is a merchant from Italy and the woman is
his wife. That's about all the museum is sure of.
Even its official title has a question mark in it.
Let's start with him. The National Gallery's own website says
Arnolfini must have been a strange looking man.
That's the museum talking about its own painting.
Van Eyck shows his nose almost straight on.
The museum's researchers think that was to
make the nose, and especially the nostrils, look less grotesque.
And in Van Eyck's first
drawing under the paint, he looked even stranger.
Van Eyck made him better looking as he painted.
His big hat is made of straw, dyed black,
and this raised hand is most likely a greeting
to someone who has just come in. Keep that in mind.
Everything in this room costs a lot, and it's meant to look that way.
Her dress is trimmed with white fur.
How white it is.
No animal back then had fur that pure.
Farmers only bred white mink in the last century.
Van Eyck made up a better fur than existed.
On the windowsill, an orange.
Oranges came all the way from Spain and cost a fortune,
so you put them where guests could see them.
Van Eyck even painted the orange's reflection
in the polished wood of the window.
Outside, the cherry tree has fruit on it,
so it's summer, and they're both wearing fur.
The bed isn't in a bedroom. This is the room where you received guests,
and the bed was the most expensive thing you owned,
so it stood where everyone could see it.
And on the floor, his wooden overshoes,
the ones for the muddy street. Still dirty.
Now look at the wall, above the mirror. There's writing.
Johannes de Eyck, fuit hic. Jan van Eyck was here. 1434.
Van Eyck usually signed his paintings on the frame.
Here he wrote his name on the wall, inside the room.
That's almost unheard of.
And was here is not how you sign a contract.
It's what people scratched onto walls.
It's graffiti.
So the most expensive room in Bruges,
and somebody has written on the wall.
But if Van Eyck was here, where is he?
Right underneath.
The mirror.
On the painting, it's about as wide as your hand.
If it were a real mirror, in a real room,
the glass would be at least 28cm across.
Nobody could make a mirror that big back then.
The museum calls it impossibly large.
Around the mirror there are ten tiny round pictures,
each about the size of a fingernail.
They show the last days of Jesus.
Up here, at the top, he's on the cross.
And in the mirror, in the open door, two men are coming in.
One in blue, one in red.
That's who he's waving at.
The museum thinks the man in blue is van Eyck himself.
He was here. He's standing in the door.
And while he was painting this mirror,
van Eyck seems to have dropped a small brush
with blue paint on it right onto the frame.
I think it's this little blue smudge.
He just kept going.
I'll come back to this mirror,
there's more in it.
If you've heard of this painting,
you've probably heard it called the Arnolfini Wedding.
That comes from one man.
In 1934, a famous art historian, Erwin Panofsky,
said this painting was a wedding certificate.
A marriage you could hang on the wall.
The raised hand was an oath. The candle was a wedding candle.
The shoes were off because the
ground was holy. And Jan van Eyck was here,
was the painter signing as a witness. For the oath,
Panofsky gave a Latin legal term. It didn't exist.
He made it up. The painting has been
called a wedding ever since.
For more than a hundred years, everyone agreed on who the groom
was. A very rich merchant from Italy,
living in Bruges, called Giovanni Arnolfini.
Then, in the 1990s, a historian went through
the accounts of the duke who ruled Bruges,
and he found two silver jugs,
a gift from the duke to Giovanni Arnolfini,
au jour de ses noces, on the day of his wedding.
The year was 1447, the date on the wall is 1434,
and Van Eyck died in 1441.
So this man got married six years after the painter was dead.
Whatever this painting is, it is not his wedding.
Then there's the question everyone asks the moment they see her.
Is she pregnant?
The museum says no.
She's lifting the front of a very heavy dress, the way women did.
Van Eyck painted a saint, Saint Catherine, three years later.
She's a virgin.
Same dress, same pose, same shape.
But almost nobody before us believed that.
In 1700, a list of everything the King
of Spain owned describes her like this.
Una alemana preñada.
A pregnant German woman who seems to be getting married at night.
She wasn't German. She was Italian.
And in 1843, a critic in London decided the man was a fortune teller,
reading the lines on her hand to tell her if it's a boy or a girl.
So if it's not the rich Giovanni, who is it?
The best answer is his cousin, also called Giovanni Arnolfini,
also a merchant from Italy, living in Bruges since at least 1419.
In the year of the painting he's in his late 30s
and he sells silk and tapestries to the duke.
And the woman? The museum says she's probably his second wife,
whose identity is unknown.
That's the strange part.
No one has ever found a single document about a second wife.
There is one about his first. Her name was Costanza Trenta.
She was the only daughter of a very rich merchant family
in Lucca, a city in Italy.
Her grandfather paid for an altar in his church,
and for stone slabs over his own grave and his wife's.
They're still there.
In January 1426, Costanza is engaged to Giovanni.
He's around 30.
She is 13.
There's a contract.
If he dies, she won't ask for his money.
And his family promises that, as a widow,
she'll be taken home to Italy with an escort.
Then she leaves for Bruges to marry him.
Seven years later, in February 1433,
Costanza's mother writes a letter to her brother-in-law in
Florence, Lorenzo de' Medici.
She's congratulating him on the birth of a son. In the middle of it,
she says how her own children are doing.
Solamente ne viveno due. Morio la Costanza e Leonardo.
Only two are still alive. Costanza has died, and Leonardo.
That's all. Half a sentence.
She doesn't say when, and she doesn't say how.
Costanza was 20 at most.
Now remember the date on the wall, 1434, a year after that letter.
So who is standing in this room?
A second wife that not one document mentions.
Or Costanza, painted after her own mother wrote that she was dead.
In 2003, an art historian, Margaret Costa, said,
This is a painting to remember someone who has died.
The man is alive, the woman is not.
And the first sign hangs right above them.
It's broad daylight, and one candle is burning.
Over his side.
Over her side, the holder is empty.
Just a bit of wax that ran down.
Costa reads it the way you probably just did.
A candle that's burning for the one who's alive.
A candle that's gone out for the one who isn't.
The museum has a kinder explanation.
A candle lit because guests have come in.
I'd like to believe the museum.
I can't quite.
On her side of the room, carved into the back of the chair,
there's a little saint with a dragon.
Saint Margaret, the saint women prayed to when they were giving birth.
Costa thinks Costanza might have died giving birth.
Nobody knows that.
But this is the saint that stands next to her.
And when van Eyck first drew this room, the chair wasn't there.
He added it later.
Costa also points to the bed.
In paintings from this time,
a big curtain bed like this one usually means one of two things.
Someone is being born, or someone is dying.
Back to the hands from the beginning.
Just above them, on the arm of the bench, there's a little carving.
Zoom in, it's worse.
A monster with a grinning human face
and hooves where its hands should be,
and it's sitting right above the spot where their hands touch.
Costa says it's threatening the two of them.
Now the ten little pictures around the mirror again.
Look at his side, on the left.
Jesus is arrested, whipped, carrying his cross.
He's suffering, but he's alive.
Now her side, on the right.
He's taken down from the cross,
laid in his grave, and then rising from the dead.
So on the man's side, Jesus is alive.
On the woman's side, Jesus has died.
And the dog.
He's the only one in the painting looking at us.
A dog is loyal, so people read him as loyalty.
But Costa points to something else.
On graves from this time, the stone figure of the dead person
often has a little dog lying at their feet.
And this dog wasn't in van Eyck's first drawing either.
Like the chair, he came later.
My favorite thing in this painting is right here, in the dog's shadow.
To soften the edge of the shadow, van Eyck smudged it with his finger.
And his thumbprint is still there.
You can see the lines of his skin.
Jan van Eyck was here.
That's the proof.
Remember the mirror on the back wall?
The one that shows this whole room from behind?
I said two things from the room are missing from it.
Here's the window.
The oranges.
The chandelier.
The two visitors in the door.
And the couple from behind.
Now look between them.
In the room, they're holding hands.
In the mirror, they're apart.
The visitors are standing in the gap.
And down here, on the floor between them.
In the room, the dog is standing right there.
In the mirror, the floor is empty.
Maybe their robes hide the dog, maybe it's the angle.
Nothing I've read explains it, and nobody I know of has.
I love that.
There's one more thing.
The museum has photographed this painting with an infrared camera.
It sees through the paint, down to van Eyck's first drawing.
In that first drawing, he was looking at her,
and his fingers went further around her hand.
He was holding her more firmly.
Van Eyck loosened his grip.
Costa's words.
Now it slips through his fingers, as perhaps did Costanza herself.
So here's my theory, and it's only mine.
In the room, Van Eyck could paint whatever
this couple wanted the world to see.
Hand in hand. A loyal dog.
Both of them in their best fur.
A mirror can't do that. A mirror just shows what's there.
And in the mirror, he's let go of her hand.
And the dog isn't there at all.
Maybe the dog was never in the room.
Only in the painting.
And look where van Eyck chose to write his name.
Not under the couple. Right above the mirror.
Jan van Eyck was here. The mirror is what he saw. And Giovanni?
In the years after this painting, his business goes badly wrong.
In 1442, he promises the city of Bruges that he will never trade again.
Van Eyck painted him one more time, a few years later.
Same face, older. And instead of silk and fur, plain wool.
No children of his are known.
This November, for the first time ever,
the two paintings will hang side by side, in London.
For 80 years, no document mentions the painting.
Then, in 1516, it's the first item on the list
of paintings owned by Margaret of Austria,
the Emperor's daughter who ruled the Netherlands.
Arnoul Neufin, avec sa femme.
Arnolfini, with his wife.
Her name is already gone.
And in the margin, a note.
A lock had to be fitted, to keep it shut.
Madame ordered it. Nobody knows why.
Later, in Spain, someone writes two lines on the frame,
from a Roman poet's guide to seducing women.
What harm is there in a promise? With promises, anyone can be rich.
In 1700, the king's list says those lines tell how
the two of them are deceiving each other.
In 1813, after a battle in Spain,
British soldiers loot the luggage of the king who is running away.
Soon after, a Scottish officer, James Hay, has the painting.
How he got it, nobody knows.
He offers it to the prince who will become King George IV.
The prince hangs it in the attic room next
to his bedroom for two years and gives it back.
Then it spends about 13 years in a doctor's bedroom in London.
The doctor wrote that it was seen by many visitors,
none of whom deemed it worthy of their notice.
In 1842, the National Gallery buys it for 600 guineas.
It's the first Dutch or Flemish painting they ever owned.
The room is the portrait they paid for.
The mirror is the one he signed.
Thank you for looking with me.
If you want to see what's hiding in the next one, subscribe.
I'll be here.