Leonardo da Vinci is an undeniable genius, but many of his paintings remained unfinished, such as "St. Jerome in the Wilderness", "The Adoration of the Magi", or "La Scapigliata". Why did he never complete them?
In this video, we will analyze each of his unfinished works and try to uncover the reasons why Leonardo left these paintings incomplete.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Leonardo da Vinci is, without a doubt, one of the most extraordinary human beings in history.
A man whose mind transcended art and science, revolutionising the way we understand anatomy,
mechanics, engineering, and of course, painting. His works have defined the history of art,
and his name is tied to some of the most iconic paintings of all time,
the Mona Lisa, The Last Supper, The Virgin of the Rocks. However, there is something that
sets da Vinci apart from other great masters. A significant number of his paintings were never
finished. Why? What led Leonardo to leave his works incomplete? Was it a matter of perfectionism,
lack of time, or simply his restless nature? In today's video, we will delve into da Vinci's
mind and explore the reasons behind his habit of abandoning his paintings.
Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo are the two most famous Renaissance artists known for their
numerous unfinished works. However, the contrast in the possible reasons behind their incomplete
pieces is striking. Before we begin, let me first make some general observations about how people
in the Renaissance might have reacted to the unfinished works of Leonardo and Michelangelo.
In their time, it was not acceptable for Renaissance artists to leave a painting,
sculpture, or building incomplete if it was intended for a final location. Patrons expected
to receive completed works and usually rejected unfinished ones, which, in theory, is how it should
be. During the era of Leonardo and Michelangelo, and according to written records of the time,
the quality of an unfinished work was described using the adjectives non finito or non finito.
Additionally, other synonymous terms were used, such as incomplete, imperfect, or simply sketched.
The notions of non finito or incompleteness, in the most canonical sense in which art historians
use the term today, are critical concepts that slowly emerged after the mid-16th century,
several decades after Leonardo's death. As a term of critical and philosophical discourse,
the notion of non finito was applied early on, and with great emphasis in the writings of
Benedetto Varci in 1547 and 1564, and Giorgio Vasari in 1568 as they discussed and rationalised
why many of Michelangelo's marble sculptures remained in an unfinished or a bozzo state.
Continuing with Leonardo, I would like to start with the monumental and incredibly rare unfinished
painting of Saint Jerome in the Wilderness, which is currently housed in the Vatican Museums.
We will examine this work in greater detail shortly, but I would dare to say that it is
the most personal and intensely spiritual devotional painting by Leonardo that has survived.
Leonardo began painting Saint Jerome around 1483, shortly after his arrival in Milan,
but he left it unfinished at the time of his death in 1519. We do not know the patron or
the general circumstances under which Leonardo produced this painting. However, this work is
closely related in style to his two compositions of the Virgin of the Rocks. Just like in the
unfinished Saint Jerome, monumental caves with dramatic rock formations dominate the
compositions of the Virgin of the Rocks. To understand why Leonardo abandoned this painting,
we must first discuss his habit of working with extreme meticulousness, which often led him to
significantly prolong the completion of his works. There is ample evidence confirming his lengthy
working process, but let us focus on a recent discovery that helps us understand why he took
so long to finish his paintings. One of the most fascinating advancements in painting studies
is infrared reflectography, a modern scientific technique that allows certain non-reflective
pigments to become transparent, penetrating beneath the layers of paint down to the gypsum
preparation. Thanks to this technology, it is possible to reveal hidden sketches and the
different design stages an artist experimented with before reaching the final composition.
In the case of the Virgin of the Rocks at the National Gallery in London,
infrared reflectography has uncovered a creative process characteristic of Leonardo. Multiple
revisions and modifications. Evidence shows that he tested several ideas for the arrangement of
figures, painting and repainting over the same panel, layering one solution over another until
he arrived at the definitive version we know today. Here, you can see a diagram showing one
of the discarded ideas discovered through this analysis. According to historians, this version
of the Virgin of the Rocks is linked to a contract signed in 1483 for an altarpiece intended for the
However, the painting was not installed until 1506, suggesting that it remained in progress for
approximately 25 years. In fact, some of the preliminary designs that Leonardo experimented
with in this painting also appear independently on a sheet of sketches preserved at the Metropolitan
Museum of Art in New York. This reinforces the idea that Leonardo not only took a long time to
complete his works but also continuously explored and refined his compositions, leaving behind a
visible trail of his relentless pursuit of perfection. Now, I would like us to examine
some Renaissance representations of Saint Jerome to emphasize the fact that Leonardo's unfinished
Saint Jerome is a revolutionary depiction of the subject. As you may know, Saint Jerome lived
between the late 4th and early 5th centuries AD. He was a highly influential Christian theologian,
famous for his encyclopedic knowledge of the classics. He is considered one of the four
Latin Fathers of the Church and was the translator of the Bible from Hebrew into Latin, the Vulgate.
Medieval and Renaissance artists depicted Saint Jerome in a variety of settings,
often with anachronistic attributes. He is frequently shown wearing a cardinal's robes,
even though cardinals did not yet exist in his time, as seen in the two paintings illustrated
here. The 1451 painting by Antonio de Fabriano II portrays Saint Jerome as a scholar with a halo
over his cardinal's hat, accompanied by his lion, writing and translating texts in his study.
Meanwhile, in this beautiful painting by Antonello da Messina, created between 1460 and 1475,
we see a vast Gothic-style room framed by a masonry arch. Saint Jerome works at his desk,
but his figure appears small in comparison to his surroundings. Although the scene conveys
a serene atmosphere, it is filled with fascinating symbols and attributes while the small lion walks
away in the distance. Depictions of Saint Jerome as a penitent, praying in the wilderness or in
solitude are also abundant. We can see, for example, Andrea Mantegna's painting from 1449,
which portrays Saint Jerome both as a scholar and as an ascetic hermit,
surrounded by symbols, sitting before a monumental cave. In contrast, Giovanni Bellini's 1460 painting
presents Saint Jerome at the entrance of a cave in a vividly narrative composition.
The saint gestures and appears to be speaking directly to his seated lion, as if they were
engaged in conversation. In this other example, the marble narrative relief by Antonio Rossellino,
created between 1465 and 1475, depicts a gaunt Saint Jerome pointing to the crucifix while
holding the stone with which he strikes his chest. Or the painting by Bernardino Pinturicchio
from 1475-1480, which shows Saint Jerome kneeling before a cave, timidly pointing to his prayer book
while holding the stone for self-mortification. These Italian representations of Saint Jerome
as a penitent in the wilderness come closest to Leonardo's unfinished Saint Jerome, as they
emphasize his anatomy and ascetic body. However, these scenes appear relatively passive. By
contrast, Leonardo's unfinished Saint Jerome conveys a dramatic vision of the crucifix.
The saint kneels in an extremely compressed pose, yet his arm extends with immense energy.
Leonardo draws our attention to the dramatic tension created by the figure's arrested movement,
with the trained gaze of a scientist who understood the laws of motion.
Throughout his career, Leonardo studied the physical mechanics of the human body,
breaking down posture sequences into frozen movements. His small theoretical sketches,
like the ones you see here, explore the sequences of a man striking with a rock. In the painting,
Saint Jerome's outstretched arm, holding the stone, appears to have just struck his chest
in mortification, though it is also possible that he is about to do so. I'll leave it to you to
share your thoughts in the comments. Leonardo also chose to emphasize the intensely intimate
spirituality of the scene by omitting all attributes that might seem incongruous in a
natural setting. For instance, in this case, there is no cardinal's hat. Instead, Leonardo highlighted
a deeply private, mystical moment in Saint Jerome's life, in which he is seized by a vision
of Christ on the cross, rather than portraying him in his more public role in the history of
the Catholic Church. Leonardo depicted Saint Jerome as a hermit in the wilderness, drawing
partial inspiration from the golden legend of the 13th century. Reclining before the saint is his
tamed lion, his faithful companion in the desert and a central figure in his legend. According to
the golden legend, Saint Jerome removed a thorn from the paw of the wounded lion and healed it,
which led the beast to become his devoted companion for life, just as we see in these
two renaissance prints. Leonardo's magnificent design of the lion, seen from behind and forming
elegant S-curves with its body and tail, serves as a compositional device that guides us, as viewers,
into the painting. The design of the lion not only connects us to the sacred subject of the
composition, the mystical Saint Jerome, but also helps suggest the depth of pictorial space.
In this painting, Saint Jerome appears extremely gaunt and almost toothless. He is caught in a
trance-like state as he prays, and this close-up of Saint Jerome's face shows how Leonardo first
created shadows and contours using a pale bluish-grey colour, and then reinforced them with
firmer brown lines. The unfinished state of Leonardo's Saint Jerome offers an invaluable insight
into his creative process. We can observe the artist's ideas at the precise moment of their
evolution. Before we continue with the video, I'd like to take a few seconds to invite you to check
out the link in the description once you finish watching. There, you'll find a catalogue of
carefully selected artworks that you can collect for your home. You can purchase your favourite
piece to keep for a lifetime, and the best part is that shipping is free worldwide. I've personally
selected over 500 artworks, and there's even a special collection dedicated exclusively to Da Vinci,
featuring his greatest masterpieces. If you've already placed an order in the store, thank you.
It's because of you that I can continue making these videos, so if you'd like to support the
channel, I invite you to place your order once you finish watching. Now, let's continue. As I
mentioned earlier, Leonardo was famous in his time for working slowly and for failing to complete
his projects, especially his paintings. Contemporary records show that this habit often frustrated his
patrons. The incomplete nature of the painting confirms that Leonardo did not work in a disciplined
manner. Rather, he selected and prioritized the aspects that interested him the most. As a result,
the execution of the painting is quite uneven. In large areas of the composition, we see only
the gesso background preparation on the wooden panel, or merely the earliest design layers,
quickly outlined with a brush in bluish grey and brown tones. However, in other parts of the
painting, Leonardo worked with remarkable attention to detail, particularly in the saint's head, neck
and shoulders. Leonardo was particularly interested in creating an anatomically
precise design for Saint Jerome's ascetic body. His right arm is essentially just sketched with
lines over the background preparation, whereas the saint's lower right leg is modelled with
striking three-dimensionality. Yet, some sections of the torso remain in deep shadow and are
relatively undefined. Leonardo applied colour primarily in the upper left section of the
composition, where traces of greenish-blue pigments can be seen. A detailed examination
of the painting's surface reveals not only Leonardo's brushstrokes but also the presence
of his fingerprints in the upper left sections of the composition. Leonardo used his brush,
his fingers and occasionally the palm of his hand to distribute pigments and create a soft
focus effect in the sky and landscape in the upper left portion of the painting.
Saint Jerome, immersed in a state of ecstasy, directs his gaze toward the crucifix, which is
only faintly outlined inside the cave on the right side of the painting, near the edge of
the composition. Leonardo also sketched the crucifix in a side view, making it particularly
difficult to interpret. Within the monumental cave, to the left of the crucifix, Leonardo
outlined the contours of a religious building. The architectural style of this church resembles
the façade of Santa Maria Novella in Florence, designed by Leon Battista Alberti.
As Leonardo continued developing Saint Jerome in the late 1480s and early 1490s, he was also
deepening his anatomical studies. Here we can see a schematic drawing of the human circulatory
system created by Leonardo. Alongside his anatomical research, the artist explored the
challenges of human proportion. On the right, you can see his famous drawing of the Vitruvian
Man, created around 1492, which represents the harmony of human proportions. For Leonardo,
knowledge, geometry, proportion and anatomy were deeply interconnected. As a theorist of painting,
Leonardo repeatedly emphasised that the two greatest challenges for a skilled painter
were the representation of the human figure and the expression of emotions
and thoughts which manifested through the body's capacity for gesture.
Leonardo worked on the unfinished Saint Jerome during the years when he was most passionately
investigating the location of the soul within the human body. Saint Jerome's face and gestures
convey Leonardo's revolutionary theories on human physiognomy and the psychology of expression.
By the late 1480s, Leonardo had begun to develop his anatomical research,
partly based on dissection, alongside his theories on gesture. According to Leonardo,
the external gestures of the face and body communicated what he called the movements
of the mind and passions of the soul, terms he described at various times as passione dell'anima,
moti mentale and affetti mentale. In his unfinished writings, executed between 1493 and 1498,
his mural of the Last Supper represents his theories on expression and passione dell'anima
with profound meaning and a great variety of gestures. Leonardo continued working on Saint
Jerome throughout the late 1480s and 1490s, while his experimental anatomical research also led him
to reflect on the human soul. Leonardo's 1489 anatomical studies of the human skull reflect
his exploration of the theory of sensus communis, or common sense, which, according to beliefs of
his time, was the seat of the soul. Leonardo considered the sensus communis to be the
convergence of human mental and imaginative faculties physically located in the internal
According to the Aristotelian and Galenic traditions of his era, the geometric centre
of the head was believed to be where the soul resided. In this drawing, Leonardo represented
an architectural cross-section of the human skull, illustrating the location of the sensus communis
at its perfect geometric centre. This reflects Leonardo's complex understanding of anatomy,
geometry, and their relationship to spiritual and intellectual concepts.
We know a great deal about Leonardo's library thanks to an inventory of his books titled
Reminder of Books Left Locked in the Large Chests, recorded between 1503 and 1505
in the Madrid Codex II. This list includes about 116 books, many of which can still be
identified today. Most of these books were printed editions in Italian rather than the
original Latin texts. For example, one of the books Leonardo owned was an Aristotelian manual
on the immortality of the soul by Fra Jacopo Canfora da Genova, titled Della Immortalità dell'Anima.
This text mentions the Passioni dell'Anima, the emotions and movements of the mind,
terms that Leonardo adopted and expanded within his own theoretical framework.
Leonardo radically transformed popular Aristotelian notions by attempting to
visualise the human mind in terms of physical anatomy. On the left, you can see a diagram
from a compendium of Aristotelian texts by Johann Lindner of Munchberg, now housed in the
Wellcome Institute Library in London. This diagram presents a rudimentary representation of the brain,
with red ink indicating the location of the five mental faculties.
Although Leonardo did not directly study this manuscript, its ideas circulated widely among
15th century scholars. By comparison, Leonardo's anatomical representations, seen on the right,
are remarkably superior in accuracy, depicting the brain, cerebral ventricles and cranial nerves
with a high level of realism. The expressive power of Saint Jerome's gestures lies in the
high degree of anatomical naturalism with which Leonardo modelled the saint's head, neck and chest.
Leonardo's theoretical writings emphasise that painting should move the viewer with an emotional
intensity equal to that of the scene's protagonists. This awareness of the viewer's active
participation in the interpretation of a painting functions as a fundamental device in most of
Leonardo's pictorial compositions, especially in the Mona Lisa. Now, I would like us to shift our
perspective and reflect on the broader issue of the unfinished state in Leonardo's work,
beyond his Saint Jerome in the wilderness. As you may recall, there is extensive evidence
that Leonardo's patrons expected completed works from him. The notion of non finito as a positive
quality did not emerge until the mid-16th century, several decades after Leonardo's death,
when critics began associating it with Michelangelo's unfinished sculptures.
Leonardo's greatest strength lay in his process of inventing compositions. He was deeply connected
to the phase of creative exploration where the frenzied flow of ideas remained in constant
evolution. He believed in the total mutability of ideas, both in the artist's mind and on the
working surface, without the need to commit to a final version. For this reason, Leonardo produced
countless preparatory sketches on paper, many of which emphasised the spontaneity and dynamism of
A key example of this approach is his large unfinished painting,
The Adoration of the Magi, now housed in the Uffizi Gallery. This altarpiece was commissioned
by the Augustinian monks of San Donato in Scopeto in 1481, but was never completed.
We can compare Leonardo's unfinished Adoration of the Magi with an early unfinished painting
by Michelangelo, the Manchester Madonna, located in the National Gallery in London.
In stark contrast to Michelangelo's work, Leonardo's Adoration of the Magi conveys the
fluidity of emerging ideas. Leonardo conceived the composition in a schematic manner,
with an organic sense of the whole, whereas Michelangelo developed his painting figure
by figure, progressing methodically from right to left. In the Manchester Madonna,
the two young figures to the left of the Virgin remain unfinished,
with large areas of white gesso preparation visible. These unfinished figures were painted
in terraverde, a green pigment traditionally used as an underlayer for flesh tones.
In contrast, the neighbouring figures are nearly fully developed in colour and modelling.
If we look more closely at Leonardo's Adoration of the Magi,
we can note that it was meticulously cleaned between 2013 and 2017 at the conservation
laboratories of the Operificio delle Pietre Dure in Florence. Over the centuries, previous
restorers had applied thick layers of varnish over the entire surface of the painting in an attempt
to unify the unfinished areas. These varnish layers were largely removed during the recent
restoration. Although the painting remains in an unfinished state, similar to a sketch on the
wooden panel, it is now evident that Leonardo began adding colour in certain areas while
calibrating the overall tonal balance of the composition. For instance, he developed the
sky using pale blue pigments which had been obscured under layers of opaque brownish tones
before the cleaning process. Both the unfinished Adoration of the Magi and Saint Jerome in the
Wilderness offer similar examples of Leonardo's working method, one that was rather free and
undisciplined. In both paintings, Leonardo began adding colour in different sections while
continuing to adjust and refine the composition in terms of tone and form. In the infrared
reflectography scan of the Adoration of the Magi, numerous details become visible that cannot be
seen with the naked eye, such as labourers who appear to be constructing what seems to be the
Temple of Jerusalem. As you may recall, infrared reflectography allows for deep penetration into
non-reflective pigments, revealing the underlying preparatory drawing. Leonardo's paper sketches
reveal the extent to which he contemplated the animation of figure gestures. He constantly
altered and refined his ideas, rethinking the arrangement and movement of the characters.
The large number of figures and the ever-changing state of the design suggest that one of the main
reasons Leonardo left this altarpiece unfinished was that his design process remained in perpetual
evolution. The painting became uncontrollable, with no definitive idea ever fully established
on the surface. Leonardo's extensive theoretical writings help us understand the role of creative
imagination and the importance of exploratory sketches in his working method. For example,
his sketch sheet of the Virgin Adoring the Child related to the Virgin of the Rocks presents at
least four alternative ideas for an altarpiece. At the bottom centre of the sheet, we can see
Leonardo explored various possibilities for the gestures of the Virgin and Child,
articulating his ideas through a visual language of abbreviated notations.
His monumental written legacy on painting theory and narrative composition was revolutionary.
His writings on quick sketches and the role of creative imagination are arguably the most
innovative from a historical perspective. In these writings, Leonardo recognised and sought
to verbalise the role of the conscious, semi-conscious and unconscious mind in the
creative process. Florentine humanists and educated artists of Leonardo's time were familiar with both
ancient and contemporary literature on the power of sketches, imagination and the creative energy
that could be perceived in an unfinished work. One of the most influential classical
texts was Natural History by Pliny the Elder, a book Leonardo owned around 1493-1495.
We know Leonardo possessed this book because he mentioned the Italianised name of the author,
Plinio, in his book inventory, indicating that his copy was an Italian translation
by Cristoforo Landino, titled Historia naturale di Plinio II, printed in Venice in 1476 and later
editions. Pliny documented key examples of rapid execution and technical virtuosity in ancient
painting. One of the most celebrated cases is that of Apelles and his unfinished Venus,
which, in its sketched state, was more admired than his completed masterpiece of the goddess.
Leonardo was also well-versed in the theories on painting by Leon Battista Alberti,
who advised painters to work with spontaneity, recommending an approach of quick yet skilful
execution, prestezza con diligenza, swiftness with diligence. Leonardo's theoretical descriptions
of drawing and sketching offer an unprecedented level of empirical and reflective detail.
His ideas on compositional sketching matured in the notes of Manuscript A,
a text dedicated to drafting his unfinished treatise on painting. In these notes,
Leonardo reflected on the role of imagination in the creative process.
I quote,
I cannot refrain from mentioning among these precepts a new method for imagination,
which, although it may seem trivial and almost laughable, is extremely useful for
stimulating the mind toward various inventions. This consists of observing stained surfaces,
irregularly patterned stones, or clouds. In them, if one must invent a scene,
they will find similarities to landscapes full of mountains, rivers, rocks, trees,
plains, valleys, and hills arranged in various ways. They may also see battles, figures in motion,
strange faces, and garments, in short, an infinite variety of things that can be refined
into well-defined forms. As an artist, Leonardo felt most comfortable in the continuum of the
creative process, where multiple visual ideas could coexist in a state of perpetual gestation
within the artist's imagination. His artistic method emphasized an intuitive response to
abstract forms and accidental stains, representing a major breakthrough in the history of creativity.
After the initial phase of invention, Leonardo refined the dynamic arrangement of figures
through scientific studies of light and shadow. In his sketches and many of his unfinished paintings,
this exploratory phase seems to have become the final state of the work. The ongoing influence
of Pliny's natural history on Leonardo's theoretical and practical ideas was significant.
It is likely that his conception of the famous fragmentary painting known as
La Scapigliata, the Disheveled One, was inspired by Apelles' Unfinished Venus, mentioned by Pliny.
In its barely-sketched state, this painting became an exercise in technical virtuosity
that highlights Leonardo's spontaneity and fluidity of brushwork. In 2009, a fundamental
discovery was made, a marginal note written by Agostino Vespucci in an early printed book
dated October 1503. This note briefly mentions Leonardo and states,
We shall see what he does with the Great Council, a commission for which he has already signed a
contract with the Gonfaloniere. Vespucci's comment references three works by Leonardo,
Saint Anne, the Mona Lisa, the Battle of Anghiari. All of them were in progress at the time.
The most important aspect of the Vespucci note is that it provides a precise date for the
beginning of the Mona Lisa, definitively resolving the debate over the model's identity.
It confirms that the model was Lisa Gherardini, wife of Francesco del Giocondo.
Although Leonardo began the Mona Lisa in 1503, the painting remained in his studio as a work
in progress for a long time. In fact, Leonardo never delivered the painting to his patron
and kept it with him until at least 1517, likely until his death. Infrared reflectography scans
reveal substantial changes in the underdrawing of the Mona Lisa as Leonardo refined the composition.
For instance, the detail of the Mona Lisa's hands resting on the chair's arm when observed
under infrared reflectography shows that the figure originally had smaller proportions.
The background of the painting still presents many unfinished areas with unresolved details.
16th century authors attempted to explain Leonardo's tendency to leave his paintings unfinished
in various ways, often focusing on material or technical aspects of his work. However,
the issue of the unfinished in Leonardo extends beyond the purely tangible. As a theorist,
Leonardo firmly stated that all disciplines were based on mathematical principles.
His obsession with geometry, particularly transformational geometry, shaped his thinking
from the mid-1490s until his death. His study of algebra and geometry led him to reflect on infinity,
transformation processes, and limitless divisibility. In his notes for a treatise
on transformational geometry, titled De Ludo Geometrico, Leonardo explored the properties
of continuous quantity in geometry. Over the years, Leonardo's theoretical vocabulary on
painting began to incorporate mathematical and geometrical terms. He spoke of the indivisibility
of space, infinite atmospheric effects, the endless nature of perspectival projection,
and the continuous subdivision of lines. The Virgin and Child with Saint Anne housed in the Louvre
represents the culmination of Leonardo's theoretical and pictorial practice. This work
remained in progress for over a decade, even during Leonardo's years in France. In this painting,
Leonardo achieved infinitely subtle effects of colour, light, and sfumato. The sacred figures
sublimely expressed the passions of the soul, passioni dell'anima, through the rhythmic harmony
of their gestures, in accordance with his theory of painting. Few artists have influenced the
history of painting as profoundly as Leonardo da Vinci. His ceaseless pursuit of perfection,
his experimental approach, and his visionary understanding of light, movement, and expression
left a legacy that continues to captivate and inspire. While his unfinished works may have
frustrated his patrons, they offer us an unparalleled glimpse into the mind of one of
the greatest geniuses in history, an artist for whom the creative process itself was more
important than the finished product. Thank you for watching the video until the end,
I hope you enjoyed it, and if you did, don't forget to leave a like and subscribe to the
channel so you don't miss the next video. I also invite you to place your order at
inspiragio.com and follow me on my social media. See you in the next video.