Delicious homemade marshmallows in three delightful flavors

Bigger Bolder Baking with Gemma Stafford
1 follower
Oct 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi Bold Bakers, marshmallows are not only easy
to make at home but they're really
satisfying.
Now we all know and love a traditional vanilla marshmallow
but why stop there, I'm gonna
show you how you can make
so many different flavors including a birthday cake marshmallow.
Now as always the recipe can be found on BiggerBolderBaking.com
and make sure you check out my website because
I've got hundreds of other recipes there.
Okay let's get started.
So into the bowl of your stand mixer add in some hot water
and then powdered gelatin.
And then straight away go in with the whisk and mix it all together.
Now if you're vegetarian, vegan,
you don't like gelatin, you can always replace this
with a vegan gel and I'm going to put that information on my website.
Agar agar can give you different results
so I don't recommend using that.
Okie dokie, we're going to let this sit here for a few minutes
and we're going to get started
in our saucepan.
So add in your water, sugar, a pinch of salt,
and then a very important ingredient is corn
syrup.
Now we're gonna turn the heat to a low heat
and just let the sugar and the mix dissolve
without letting it simmer yet.
So now if you don't have corn syrup
in your country, don't worry, you can use brown
rice syrup, cane syrup or even golden syrup
and that will work really well.
So our next step is to clip on my candy thermometer,
now this is really important when making marshmallows
and you do need one of these guys.
Mine is GoodCook, really inexpensive, definitely get yourself one.
Now all we're going to do is just let
this mix come to a simmer over a medium-low heat
and let it very gently bubble away,
you don't want rapid boiling, you just want a very gentle
simmer away.
So what you have to do now is hold your nerve
and wait for this to reach soft-ball stage
on your thermometer, which is 240 degrees.
So here's the deal, this step takes around 15-20 minutes.
Now what you're not to do here is number one,
stir it, number two, crank up that heat.
you crank up the heat, you're going to end up
with caramel and you're gonna have to start
all over again. So just hold your nerve.
Okay, so take some time we finally reached softball
stage on the thermometer.
So here's what we're going to do turn off the heat. Very carefully
remove your thermometer and then be very careful.
Move it over to your mixer and then pour it
into your mixer fitted with a whisk.
If you need help for this step then ask for it. Once
all your mixes in there, turn on your machine
to a medium high speed and let it whip for
around 12 to 15 minutes.
So our marshmallows have doubled in size, they look really good.
They're almost done.
So at this point, I'm going to add in a little bit of vanilla extract,
a little bit of almond extract, some red food coloring,
some pink food coloring, and of
course, sprinkles
because you can't have birthday cake without sprinkles.
So while that's mixing,
we're going to prepare our tin.
So here I have an eight by eight tin seven by 11 also
works really well, you want to grease
this with some flavorless oil like a vegetable
oil and then you're going to dust it with a bit of cornstarch
and sugar mixed together.
Now this is really important because it helps
your marshmallows to release out of the tin
really easily.
So once it's all mixed through turn off your machine
and then straight away get it
into your tin.
So you do want to work fast because the sugar starts to set.
You can see this is a very messy job
but the thing about it is if you grease your spatula
with a little bit of vegetable oil,
it will actually help a lot to get the marshmallow
out of there.
Perfect, get as much out as you can.
And then what you want to do is with a little bit
of flavorless oil again on your fingertips,
just go ahead and flatten down the top
of the marshmallow to get it nice and even.
The oil will stop it from sticking to your fingers.
Then of course I'm gonna add on a few more sprinkles on top,
and then we're gonna sift
over a little bit of that sugar
and cornstarch mix that we did the tray with.
So the cornstarch in your sugar actually stops
your marshmallows from getting wet, it keeps
them nice and dry.
If you're allergic to cornstarch you can feel free
to leave it out but just note they might
be a little bit stickier.
So now at this point we set this over
to the side for a minimum of 4 hours but usually
I actually leave it overnight,
and all this will do is get a nice little bit of a skin
on top of the marshmallows and make them ready for us to cut.
So now what you want to do is just turn it out onto
a surface and now we're gonna let
this side get a little bit of a skin on it too for another 3-4 hours.
So our marshmallows are no longer sticky to the touch
so now it is time to cut them, it's
my favorite part.
So now to make your life really easy
when cutting these guys, dust your knife with a
little bit of your cornstarch sugar mix.
And then just go ahead and cut them as big or as small as you'd like.
Once they're all cut up you'll notice that they
are still a little bit sticky, so what
you want to do is toss them in a little bit more
of the cornstarch sugar mix and this
This just coats them and stops them from sticking together,
and keeps them nice and dry.
Beautiful.
Now come here to me, I know it seemed like a lot of work,
but just check out this.
How amazing is that?
Look at all those sprinkles, it's super squishy,
exactly what you want from a marshmallow.
So these marshmallows are so awesome,
I couldn't just share one flavor with you.
So if you go over to my website,
I've got bonus recipes over there, showing you how
you can make an amazing chocolate marshmallow,
and even mint chocolate chip.
I mean seriously, they're squishy, soft, bubbly,
and best of all, it tastes just like birthday
cake.
What more do you want from a marshmallow?
I really hope you enjoyed this episode,
head over to my website to get those bonus recipes,
and I'll see you back here really soon for more Bigger Bolder Baking.
