Red Wine Downturn Hits Burgundy | The Week in Wine Podcast

Wine Regions Revealed
5 followers
Oct 7, 2026
Don enjoys an attractively priced and very drinkable Vin de France Gamay while Olly enthuses about a similarly-priced Frusinate IGT (Lazio) biodynamic red called Volumnia.
…
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe hosts discuss affordable wine recommendations from France and Italy before analyzing critical industry news. Key topics include the economic struggles and administrative controversies in Napa Valley, market volatility in California and Burgundy, irrigation disputes in Bordeaux, and the controversial use of AI in Champagne marketing, alongside scientific breakthroughs in treating smoke taint.
Welcome to the WineSearcher Week in Wine news podcast, where we look at the latest headlines
and top stories in the world of wine. For more on all of our stories, go to wine-searcher.com.
Good morning, Don. Good morning, Olly. How are you? I'm good. The sun is shining. How
are you? Oh, great. Full of the joys of spring. Excellent. Yep. Had a nice weekend, so relaxed
and ready to hit the ground running on Monday morning. Get back into it. That's the one.
With renewed vigour and fresh. Oh, absolute tons of vigour. So much vigour. I've got buckets
of the stuff here. You're way down by your own vigour. Did you have anything nice to
drink at the weekend? I did, actually. Go on. It was slightly different for me, I suppose,
but I don't know if you remember, but I'm sure our listener will, because our listener
has a mind like a steel trap. Yes, go on. Admittedly, one that's been left out in the
rain and has rusted a little, but still a steel trap. Well, I was talking a while back
about the general disappointments occasionally occasioned by penile war sometimes. Yes. And
how they can be utterly underwhelming and overly mannered in action and all the rest
of it. Well, I kind of had the antithesis to that this weekend, which is, that's not
an easy word to say for a man with as few teeth as I have left. And that was gamay.
Oh. Sort of, sort of, kind of vaguely. I've always kind of lumped it in with penile war
somehow as a kind of a, you know, a lighter grape variety, but also, and also because
of the geographical nature of Beaujolais and Burgundy and so forth. But yes, it was a brilliant
wine. It was really nice. Simple. What was it? It was La Belle Angele. Right. A company
called La Belle Angele, I believe. It's a vin de France. I couldn't even tell you where it's
from, to be perfectly honest with you. It's from France, Don. Fair enough. I think you got me there.
Dear Lord. I'm talking within France. Actually, hang on a minute. It's actually based in New
East St. George. There you go. I've just looked it up. It's a vin de France from New East St.
George. God, I bet they wish they could put New East St. George on the label.
Well, they'd get hounded out of Burgundy, wouldn't they, if they put a gamay out from
New East St. George. Well, just think of the amount of money they'd make in the meantime
before that happened. I'm all about the quick profit and get out sort of attitude. It was
really, really nice. I mean, it's cheap. I mean, I don't mean that in a bad way. I mean,
hey, everybody, this is great. It was cheap.
Well, yeah, it's got a global average retail price of $13,
and an aggregated critic score of 89. I'm delighted to see. It was lovely. It was,
you know, it was in, I don't know what to, I don't want to use any word that starts with
on about it because that sounds like I'm damning it with faint praise, but it was really enjoyable.
It was nice. It was kind of medium bodied. It wasn't too light. It wasn't heavy at all.
You didn't have to think too much about it. It wasn't an overthinking wine.
It was just a really nice little wine to have with some pasta, you know, and it was
boom. It was brilliant. I really enjoyed it. It's probably the most memorable thing I had
this weekend. So what about you? Did you have anything strange or startling over the weekend?
I did. I had something strange and startling. I had something strange and delicious.
Oh, fantastic. Well, don't keep me in suspenders.
It was the wine is called volumnia, volumnia, volumnia. And it is a blend of apologies,
Italian listener, lecce nero, Sangiovese and uva Giulia, Giulia. It's Fruzzinante IGT Rosso.
So red from Fruzzinante IGT, which is Lazio. For those of you who don't know, I didn't know until
Saturday. Oh, I would have struggled with that one myself.
Yeah. So that was it was a lovely, delicious, biodynamic or organic red wine produced by
Asienda Agricola DSBO di Daniello Senna. Yes, that's easy for you to say.
It wasn't. It wasn't done. A lot of this has been a major struggle because I can never remember
which one is the hard C and which one is the soft one, if you know what I mean.
Indeed.
But yeah, apparently he grows his lovely blend of red grape varieties from Lazio, as I said,
and he grows his vines up through trees. Oh, okay. Apparently that's a bit different.
I know. That's fantastic. It was absolutely delicious. It was so so good. So good. Fresh,
lovely, enough character, color, everything. It was all it was all there. I mean, it wasn't too
heavy. It was just delicious, delicious. It was lovely, lovely wine.
Oh, it sounds tremendous. Where did you get hold of this?
There was a friend brought that over, actually, a really good friend of mine, Greg, he came over
and we cracked open a bottle together and had some cheese and some things and we got a bottle
and it was it's imported by a sort of Italian specialist, as you can well imagine, in New
Zealand. But generally, I mean, what I've seen is you're looking at about $20.
You know, if you can get hold of it, roughly $20, depending on, you know, where you are,
obviously. So, yeah, it's just so good. Look, we're saving. We're both saving our
listener money this week. I know. There's our recommendations. Italy and France,
less than less than $20, $20 or less. I know. Amazing. That's a target price.
And they're fantastic. And $20 and it's, you know, it's biodynamic. It's grown in trees.
It's a blend. It's from a relatively unknown, unusual region in Italy. And for that money,
it's amazing. That sounds brilliant. But tell me about the growing through trees.
Well, that's that's from what I'm saying. I don't know too, too much about it, to be honest. But
from what I'm saying, it's quite an old Italian thing, especially towards the south. Rather than
having to set up a whole training system, wires and VSP and, you know, hammer stakes into the
ground, all you do is just grow a vine up along a tree. And then as it kind of follows the branches
and you can sort of, sometimes you've got a ladder and the very willing volunteers, you can pick it.
Oh, that's it. You know, you can also do it while you're picking the apples at the same time or
whatever. It also makes sense in the south of Italy, doesn't it? Because it also would provide
shade for the yeah, for the for the grapes themselves. Well, you need you need a bit of
shade down there, don't you? Yeah. And you get sort of off the ground and away from any sort
of diseases and stuff on the ground. So yeah, that's an airy, airy, shaded. Oh,
they sort of grow them between trees and things. I think yes.
Sounds sounds sounds rather idyllic, really, doesn't it?
Doesn't it? It's a very, yeah.
Very Arcadian.
Yeah. Arcadian. That's the word. Arcadian. Right. Talking of Arcadia,
the dreams, the delights, the beauties. Our month. How was our month, Don? What
were the headlines in wine this month? Well, the month of September was,
I have to tell you now, pretty much all about California.
Yeah, right. I mean, it's been heading that way, hasn't it?
Our big story, of course, was Napa Tasting struggling to hit the spot,
which was all about, well, as you can tell from the headline, it was about
tasting numbers being down in Napa. I mean, it's, yeah, it's horrifically expensive now.
And it's, it's just getting all around more difficult. So, you know, you've got,
you've got the authorities, they're now looking at limiting car numbers.
Oh, wow.
Which is, you know,
But this will be local, this will be local authorities, though, right? This is the
people within Napa themselves.
Yeah, this will be Napa County.
Isn't that just gentrification? Is that sort of just a symptom of gentrification?
I don't know that it is. It's not necessarily gentrification. I mean,
obviously, it's been suggested under an environmental banner, as it were.
Right.
But, you know, it's, oh, you know, we've got too much traffic. It's
clogging everything up. It's not good for the environment. It's not good for people's
blood pressure, really, sitting in traffic. It's not because, you know, they're not,
we're not talking about major highways out there in wine country. It's, they're often not
big roads. And yeah, it's just getting generally clogged up. Yeah, I don't know. I can't help but
feeling sometimes that Napa County just is not trying to kill the goose that laid the golden egg
as such, but certainly being, certainly adversarial towards, or more adversarial towards
the wine industry. I mean, fair enough, the wine industry pretty much called the shots in
Napa for a long time, but now there seems to be something of a backlash against that.
And of course, Napa figured heavily in our next big story of the month, which was
all about Napa Valley Vintners facing questions over their pay.
Over the revelation, the exclusive revelation, I should point out from a news point of view,
that the CEO of Napa Valley Vintners had a remuneration package in excess of $700,000 at a
time when wineries are grumbling a bit about what value they're getting from being part of Napa
Valley Vintners. And I understand some of them weren't too pleased about Napa Valley Vintners
actually emailing them and going, oh, what are we going to do for marketing ideas?
You get paid the big bucks. Why don't you tell us?
Well, I think that would appear to be the general gist of the responses. Anyway, so yes,
that was obviously a big story and you can understand why people would be reading it.
I mean, it's a pretty compelling topic really, isn't it?
We do have quite a sizable American readership though, would that be correct to say?
We do, we do. More than half our readers are based in the United States and they do very
much want to know about California wine, as this month's readership shows.
Yeah, I mean, I was going to say there's a number of things there because if it's sort of
only just over half, you could easily tip the scales either way. But it does help that we have
in someone who is probably one of the more preeminent writers on the American and California
wine industry in particular. I think globally, it would be fair to say, given the volume of
his production, if you know what I mean. You've got big names like Eric Asimov in New York Times
and stuff, but Eric Asimov will only publish once a week if that, whereas Blake is pretty
consistent in his output. Yeah, he is. He's a diehard
journalist as well. He likes going after his story. You know, he's never kind of fallen into
the trap that some wine writers have once they move away from, like if they've started out as
journalists and move into writing about wine, a lot of them just kind of lose a bit of the old
journalistic nose and sort of settle in for a long, almost semi-retirement of drinking vast
quantities of Cabernet. This is the thing, I don't think it does you any favours to do that.
Blake can talk about it more, I think, because there's obviously a kernel of truth in what you
say. But if you're going to be combative or dare I say journalistic in the wine world, you're
generally not doing yourself a great deal of favours. You've decided to plough yourself a
lonely furrow. Well, you're certainly not going to be invited to the cool kids press trips. No.
You know, the ones where now half the seats have been reserved for influencers.
You know, sort of Instagram people who put a pretty picture up and then
add words that have basically been often scraped off our website. But to my point,
that only happens and it's easy to complain about that. But effectively,
if you're relentlessly friendly to the wine industry or wherever you go,
then you've effectively done exactly the same.
Yeah, you're effectively a PR person for that region. It would be nice to think at least that
people are prepared to write about the negative aspects of a region as well.
I mean, you know, not everywhere is perfect. No, absolutely not. But that's what makes it
interesting. That's the stuff for me that makes it interesting is I don't expect places to be
perfect. I don't want them to be perfect. I want to see how they're overcoming their innate challenges.
Yeah. Anyway, but I think so to that point, I think that things will turn around eventually,
because there's only so much marketing you can read before you just turn off.
The same is true as writers, as it is of influencers, as it is of everyone else.
You know, if I keep hearing good news stories, then frankly, I'm just going to get bored.
Well, that's the whole thing, isn't it? I mean, I think a lot of what we're seeing with the
disappearance of places to publish about wine, except Substack, obviously. So there's plenty
of people writing about wine on Substack. How many of them are being read? I don't know.
But, you know, for general audiences, writing about wine has become a hard sell because in
many cases it's because everybody's writing about the same thing because they're all going on the
same press trips. Yes. So everybody's writing about the latest press trip they've been on
and writing generally uncritically about it. Yeah. You know, OK, fair enough. Some of them
might be very tough in their scoring on their tasting notes, but that's not that doesn't make
any difference. And as a result, I think in a lot of cases, wine writing has almost eaten itself.
Yeah, to a degree. Yeah, it's it's, you know, it's like the snake that eats its own tail.
It's getting gradually smaller and smaller and more, you know, tightly wound.
It's a really sad thing. But anyway, that's a that's a discussion for another day. Let's
carry on. We could be here all night. Yeah, right. So the next story, the next story is
the wine country walls, crisis or opportunity. Again, this is California. This is more of the
same, right? Well, this is this is about, you know, the sale and the closure of wineries.
Quite big ones. I mean, this is this story was sparked by the by Gun Black Bunshu,
one of Napa's oldest wineries. Well, certainly all the family owned wineries still going and
filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. It was big news. And so, I mean, this is
Blake Chapman's people about whether or not this is a correction or whether it's the
the inevitable pebbles of the ensuing avalanche of collapses. And that's what everybody in the
wider media seems to think it is. And that's what they I think they want to see it happen.
But anyway, but in amongst all this California doom and gloom stories,
stick out the great Chenin Blanc Renaissance. Oh, Chenin Blanc. Yeah, we keep talking about this.
And I'm sure if we keep if we keep on talking about maybe another three weeks,
it will become a real thing. Someone will listen. We shall talk it. We shall talk it into existence.
Chenin can finally jump around going, I'm a real boy.
The Pinocchio of wine. Anyway, yes. But that was that it touched a lot of hearts, obviously,
or at least eyeballs, at least. That was followed, of course, by yet another California
one. This was a story about is a story actually from August. Oh, I'm still one of our top 10
stories of September, which is the one about the California governor being the only one to get
from a relief fund set up after a fire last year. But anyway, we've we've thrashed that one out,
we keep mentioning it. And honestly, Mr. Newsome, I'm just we're not having a go at you.
Clarification would be nice. Well, I just, well, I just like to know from anybody else that anybody
else apply for it. Yes. For this relief payout. Maybe he's the only one who's clever. Hang on a
minute. It could be entirely above board. Yeah, it could be entirely above board. Well, I imagine it
is. Right. I mean, I'm one of those Pollyannaish people. You know me. I always see the good in
people. Yeah. I'm not an old cynic yet like you. But yeah. And after that, then hang on,
wait a minute. We've got most expensive champagnes of 2026. Nice. Yeah. So people
like to know about expensive champagne, which is interesting because they didn't
feel quite so excited about the most expensive wines, for example, or
no. Well, I think that's that's relatively well known. Most expensive champagnes.
You know, maybe I know a couple of those. But what what was in the list? You know,
what what else is there? Yeah, I'd have been. That's true. I'd have been curious. And then
then we're then we're back to Napa again with the Gallo. Well, not to Napa. I do apologise.
But California, the Gallo vineyard, the California time machine. This is the Monte Rosso vineyard in
Sonoma. Oh, lovely. Because that was just a nice story that it was. It's a lovely story,
isn't it? An old vineyard with really old vines. Yeah. Some of them. Some of them.
Chenin Blanc, let me tell you. Oh, actually. But some but some of them really old, like semi on
some of the probably the oldest semi on vines in the northern hemisphere are there and really old
Zinfandel vines. Yeah. Amazing. And it's yeah. And Gallo are gone. You know what? We're going
to put a bit of money into this and we're going to invest in it and we're going to make
really good wine out of it. And so they are. And it's beautiful to see. Lovely. And then the other
big thing is, is the early grape harvest, fermenting chaos and chaos and uncertainty.
You know, love those words in a headline. Chaos. Uncertainty. Yeah. So that's the end.
As we all know, that's all about the this year's harvests have been earlier and much more compressed
than usual. And it's yeah, it's it's that story is all about the problems that can cause traffic
jams at the crush areas and so forth. It's all a bit it all gets a bit mad. Yeah. Yeah. So that's
that's the big ones from last month. And then I mean, let's let's just go mad and have a quick
Yeah. Because it's quite quite a quite a change of attitude here. We've got the world's best bourbons
which only come out Saturday. So I'm pretty pleased that that's good. Yeah. And world's
most expensive wines. There we go. And we're back in the wine country was obviously. But
another one I really enjoyed this week is testing the value of Pomerol name.
Oh, yeah. How did that go? That went really well. It was it's from a new writer. Yep. And
he did a good job on it. I really I enjoyed it. It was a it was a story that I think people have
kind of overlooked a little bit. It's about basically it's a it's a close look at the floor
which from twenty twenty five stopping Pomerol and came out as a van de France, mostly because
there's issues around irrigation. But also, I think there was a very strong element in
the minds of the family that own it that, you know, we're on the floor.
Are people buying us because we're on the floor or people buying us because we're Pomerol?
And that's what the story is about. And to be honest, there was no appreciable
drop. In fact, if anything, it went up. Yeah. Well, I mean, we we added a piece. We just look
at it from our point of view, like from wine searcher data, the retail prices are bigger,
like they're higher now for the twenty twenty five than they were for the twenty twenty three,
which is a similar vintage. Yes. You know, it's not a hot vintage. It's same scores from the
critics. It was, you know, but it was released on the Pomerol appellation that was released
that hit the shelves in retail at nine hundred and forty four dollars,
a global average retail price of that. And it's risen to nine hundred and ninety nine.
Yeah. The twenty twenty five hit at eight hundred and thirty two dollars. Yeah. And
it's current was currently at the time of writing nine hundred and nine dollars. But so that was
an actual a higher increase in three months than the twenty twenty three had in two years.
Yeah, I think there's there's there's going to be an issue there. I think. Well,
what I see on on that front is that a number of people will look at that and go, huh,
Lafleur is being released as a van de France. There's two possibilities. One is they'll continue
to do so, in which case no problem at all. The other is that Lafleur might go back to
the Pomerol appellation. Try saying that early in the morning. The the reason I'm saying that
is that I suspect because appellations are run by the wineries within them and some of the
arguments that Pomerol are making, of which we'll talk about a little bit in the the Sunday story
in a minute, may well get adopted by the other by the neighboring states. You know, Pomerol won't
be alone in having issues around irrigation and water in these hot vintages. Absolutely.
It's possible they will go back to being Pomerol appellation wines like the next year if it's
relatively benign. They might well release as Pomerol. There's no reason why they shouldn't.
They'll keep everything within the within order and will go under the Pomerol appellation.
Well, in that case, you've got a couple of vintages. If you've bought Pomerol van de France,
you're sitting on a case or two of very expensive wine. Let's not beat around the bush. But it's
very expensive wine that for two years was released as a van de France, which makes its
collectability even greater. So I suspect that there's a bunch of people who are with a mind to
the secondary market, maybe thinking Pomerol might, Lafleur might get back to being Pomerol.
Let's have a flutter on some van de France Lafleur. And if they, you know, if it goes back
to being Pomerol, I've got a bunch of cases which are pretty unique in the history of the appellation
and that the value of those wines will only go up. True, pretty true. But in fairness,
you could also add the point that the value of Lafleur tends to go in one direction only.
Yes. And this is and this is also where Lafleur themselves may go, well, you know what? I think
we're probably big enough. I mean, Petrus could just put itself as Petrus van de France if it
were. And I don't think it would have any impact on the price. No, I don't think it would have any
impact on demand either. No, I'd still I'd still like being one of those negative journalists.
I'd still have a few words to say about that, as I do about as I did about Lafleur.
I still think there's legitimate reasons to question that. And do I say, hang on,
we're back up there. But that again, we can talk about that when we get to Bordeaux and irrigation.
Do I? Yes, indeed. Because we'll get around to that shortly, because there's just one other
story I want to talk about from this week. And that was Can Science Solve Smoke Tent,
which was a great story. Oh, yeah. From Monday. Yeah. Yeah. This was this was a really good story,
because it turns out that scientists in Australia believe, yes, they can.
Yeah. They can genetically modify. Well, not genetically modify. That's
fairly loaded. Yeah. Look, they're just saying the Tasman Institute of Agriculture, Tasmanian
Institute of Agriculture, sorry, have said that it's possible to make good quality sparkling
wine from grapes that have been affected by bushfire smoke. This is after 10 years of trial.
They've nullified the sensory impact of compounds during the aging process.
So it's a it's around bacteria. Yes. It involves using naturally occurring bacteria. So nothing
genetic at all. But yeah, so they're using a specific bacterium that can break down guaiacol,
one of the main phenols responsible for smoking. And they found two
strains of the same species of bacterium that uses guaiacol as their only food source,
which is very interesting. I mean, that's just it's a brilliant idea.
Oh, well, there's another thing that's that this story doesn't mention, which is quite interesting
in that guaiacol is one of the components of an aspect of Brutanomyces. I don't know whether it
works in the terms of Brut, but you could actually if you if you're taking this bacteria,
you could potentially remove some of the Brut notes in wine.
Yep. I mean, it's this this is seriously groundbreaking stuff. I mean, this is incredibly
nerdy. It literally doesn't get much nerdier than this, but it really is exciting. Yeah. I mean,
it's genuinely exciting news, which is great. But now let's go back to the big story of the week.
Oh, and literally, this was the biggest story of the week was Sunday. It was yesterday's story
about burgundy's big reds fall from favour. Wow. So let's talk. Let's talk about the Sunday roundup.
Let's talk about Sunday roundup. First of all, it was a very like I said in the intro,
it was a very busy week. Well, I did. But especially for the for people we already know.
I mean, this was this was gosh, I mean, as soon as I got to the global superstar Shakira,
that was me I was hoped. Well, I thought I was hoping that there was more to that story so that
we can actually make it the headline story. But there wasn't it was I found Shakira was it was
at a flamenco venue Corral de la Moreira and and had a 200 year old wine was basically it that was
all I could find on all these Spanish news. It's amazing how often I'm sorry, I just need to get
this in while I think of it. It's it's amazing how often or maybe it isn't. Stories about
celebrities turn out to be so utterly, utterly shallow. No depth whatsoever. Shakira went to
an eatery in Madrid and had an old wine was basically the story. There were pictures of
you know, there's you know, there's droppers that you get, you know,
dripping things in your ear and stuff. That's all I remember when I was a kid,
but she had one of those sort of droppers and was dropping a bit of this 200 year old wine onto her
tongue, which, you know, would have made would have made great and it did make for some great
pictures. Celebrity websites. I bet it's Shakira with her tongue sticking out. I imagine there
that there are specialist websites everywhere just paying top dollar for those pictures.
Right. And so this one, yeah, I think they've got a good line in sherry this flamenco venue,
which makes sense, you know, flamenco and Lucia sherry. It's 200 years old. You know,
it's pretty rare to find a standard red wine. Or it was red, by the way, or certainly dark,
a dark hue. So I'm assuming it was sherry. Anyway, more so much more. Peruvian bullfighter
This is brilliant, isn't it? I mean, you know, we're even getting Peruvian bullfighters
making the news. It was great. But this was also another one where you're like,
you look at the substance of it. Yeah, there's not much here to string a whole new story to,
but it turns out he like he plumped for a Vegas Sicilia Valbuena 5 2015 to crack open with his
parents. Yeah, it's all going up. You know, Hereth lost its bid for Ciudad Espanola de Vino,
Spanish city of wine next year, 2027, where it turns out his regional counterpart Montilla
has taken the title. Yes, that wouldn't have been great. There's, you know, I mean,
you'd think, wouldn't you? You'd think, wouldn't you? That if they're looking in the south of
Spain for a city of wine that Hereth, it's a penalty kick. I mean, it's a lay down mosaic.
It's everything easy. It's every easy metaphor you can think of.
So I was just very impressed with your with your run of metaphors there. That was fantastic,
Don. That's why you're an editor. There you go.
There's there was also some interesting stuff. I sort of glossed over this, but there's probably
there was potentially more to it. But there's only so many 2026 is going to be a massive
VF wine. You know, they're gonna be big wines in 2026 that you can do. And there
the 2026 Loire wines were characterised as robust monsters by people talking to
Courier de l'Ouest. And then also Alsace reportedly sidestepped Carnage, according to Vegesphere.
It does look like Alsace has had a tricky vintage. It does, doesn't it? It does. And the depth of
that story was that it doesn't some producers were saying their Rieslings aren't as good as
normal years. And that actually other varieties and also so Riesling and Gewürz have had tough
years. This year, I've had tough a tough year. This year, apparently the kind of have tough
years most years. Normally, you'd hope that Riesling would would sort of stand through it
all. But apparently I don't know, according to some of the people that Vegesphere talk to not
so much, but that might not be generally true for the region. So it'll be interesting to see
what comes out of that one. There's more on the Castel back and forth.
Never stops. Yeah. But let's move on. So main headline, red wine downturn hits Burgundy.
This is a story coming out of Commedia Borgogna. I didn't realize the Commedia Borgogna,
the BIVB, which is their wine trade bureau, had changed names. It's now Commedia Borgogna.
When did that happen? Well, for a press and publicity focused organization,
they certainly kept that quiet, didn't they? I didn't hear anything about that. Anyway,
so they're talking about a drop pretty much in five percent of red wine sales across the last
year. Yes. Which is significant and it should sound the alarm, says Commedia Borgogna president
Laurent Delaunay. Yeah. And it says apparently, and this was frustrating, it's been even more
true for Villarge, Premier and Grand Cru wines. They didn't quote any figures on that that I saw.
So there was a bit of a bit frustrating there because it would have been nice to know just
how badly affected were the Premier and Grand Cru sales. It's evident that US market, the Trump
tariffs have had a negative effect on Burgundy. Their exports are now down 10% in volume and 20%
in value to the US. So that's a good indication that it is the more expensive wines that are big.
Yeah, that's pretty tricky and not great. The good news is that standard or decent Burgundy
whites, Chablis, Petit Chablis, Borgogna, Macon wines are showing a steady growth, 0.4%. I mean,
it's better than going in the negative, right? And there's been a strong sales rebound in the UK
market, which is good. There's sounds of worry here. I'm not surprised. Yeah, he said it was
difficult to draw broad conclusions about the market and that we're almost trying to navigate
blindly, which is not what you want to hear from someone who's at the charge of your regional wine
trade bureau. Not true. And there's also the giveaway sign that they're really worried when
they're talking about hope for growth in the emergent ex-market. In this case, they're talking
about India. India market, yeah. Bordeaux reopens irrigation debate. Oh, yeah, no. This was
relatively interesting. It's a tricky one. Depending on your outlook or depending on how
you view this, some growers are saying, look, we need to irrigate. Others are saying, we might need
to irrigate, but only in certain areas. And others are saying, absolutely, this is not the right
call, you know, as you'd expect from a relatively contentious topic.
The issue here, and it's the same with La Fleur, is if your argument is that wine is made in the
vineyard and that terroir, you know, your terroir is the greatest thing in the world. Well, if you're
having to effectively synthesize rain or in bad years, as happens in Bordeaux, synthesize sunshine
by adding sugar. How great is that terroir? That's sacrilege, man. You can't say that.
Well, there's a bunch of things happening. And this is what I think Cornelius Van Leeuwen,
who's a professor of viticulture at Bordeaux, told Vitisfair on this front, or was it AFP,
I can't remember which one. He said it's unnecessary because we still have enormous
room to manoeuvre with other options. Part of La Fleur's problem, from what I understand,
is the vine density issue. They've got very, very dense plantings,
and in dry years, it makes it really, really hard on the plants. So the answer for La Fleur is
probably not irrigation. It's probably reducing vine density. So that's one thing. Others are
saying pretty much against it. Others are saying, what did he say? A portion of the Bordeaux vineyard
is going to need it, said the regional farmers union boss and cloak-to-ball wine grower,
Jean-Samuel Henard. In order to get young wines started and replace old vines, irrigation is
to be indispensable. So there's all this big discussion about, is ideologically irrigation
the right way for Bordeaux to go? The thing then is, you're probably going to do it across Bordeaux
and Bordeaux Superior, which are the lower end appellations, but that's a huge area.
And we get then onto the volumes of water you need to irrigate the Bordeaux vineyard area.
And they reckon that would exceed the annually earmarked water drinking supply for the
inhabitants of the region. So there's then going to be a big fight. And they've already said,
according to the organization overseas, the regional aquifer, the aquifer itself is already
in a state of overexploitation. So just adding vineyards to it would have major ecological
impacts. I'm tempted to say, let them drink claret. I'm sorry, that's possibly a little glib.
But that's a huge question, isn't it? I mean, is this wrong to irrigate? Is it always wrong
to irrigate? Is it sometimes wrong to irrigate? I mean, yes, I see what you mean. The vine density
thing, I think, is probably more of an issue for them than the need for water, surely. I mean,
they could sort the irrigation problem out by simply reducing the vine density, couldn't they?
I mean, it's great for vines to struggle, but Jesus, you don't want them struggling that much,
surely. Yeah, but we live in a New World country, New Zealand, New World, innovative commas,
and irrigation is pretty much ubiquitous in our vineyards, which is something that the French
have always said, hey, look over there, all these California, Australia, New Zealand,
they all need irrigation. Bordeaux, we have the perfect climate, we don't need it.
You're like, well, really? So there's ideological arguments, and then now they're starting to say,
actually, there's an ecological argument, which is that we probably don't have the water supplies
available to do this. But that ecological argument is also applicable in places like New Zealand,
like where I live. I know, and I have seen, and you can go and find it, you can look at farms,
and you can look at vineyards, and they take water directly from the rivers to pump out into
the vineyards. And by the time the rivers reach the sea, they're at a trickle in summer, and
volumes should be down, but they shouldn't be that low. And there's big ecological concerns
about irrigation. It's an interesting debate, and it's one that's not going to go away.
No, it's not going to go away, and it's one that we're going to be having in years to come.
I mean, another couple of vintages, like 2025, and 2026, and 2023,
and, you know, there's going to be chains of people out there with buckets of water.
Yeah, it's going to be interesting.
Right, more bad news. Sautern harvest on a knife edge. This was a story from Actu,
which is a regional newspaper, well, actually, it's a national website with regional syndicates.
So La Forie Paraguay, which is a Premier Grand Prix Class A Sautern estate, admitted that so far
it's lost three quarters of its harvest. Everything's just dried out. They haven't
any botrytis, and they're just hoping that come October, there'll be a bit of humidity,
and the botrytis will develop on the grapes, the 25% of grapes they've got left,
which is quite a story. There was a couple of other estates. These are all estates in Bomb,
in the Bomb area of Sautern. So it might be better further on the lower-lying regions.
But it's, I don't know, I reckon Sautern might have a tricky 2026 harvest.
Well, you can see where Sautern producers have been thinking, oh, we need a backup plan
in recent years, when they've been aiming at making dry white wines. But yeah, this could be,
this is potentially disastrous, really, isn't it? I mean, it's-
It's not looking great. I mean, the other guys they talked to, Actu talked to,
I mean, they're smaller estates. It's not like La Forie Paraguay is run by Silvio Dent,
who has Lalique. He's got a whole bunch of luxury things. He could, you know,
he can pretty much afford to sit this one out, potentially. But others can't. And they've said
as much. They've said, look, we just had to start harvesting. If we'd have waited longer,
the berries would have just dried out, and we'd have raisins. And you need a bit of acidity to
make sweet or even light harvest, which is effectively what this will be, white wines.
So we'll bring them in, and we'll do what we can. Some people have said they got a little
bit of botrytis, but not that much. So yeah, it was a fascinating story,
and one that didn't, like, Sauternes doesn't get much press. It generally sort of
trundles along in the background. But I think, fabulous wines, and just a very interesting story.
Yeah, indeed. Three bad news stories in a row. Please tell me there's more,
there's something to smile about.
Well, it depends if you like a good spat. Does Solis carry on?
I love a good spat.
This one's been going on for a while. Felix Solis and Jay Garcia carry on. These are
major Spanish wineries. They're some of the biggest sort of bulk wine, is that fair? I don't
know. They're some of the biggest sort of supermarket label wineries in Spain, with
major operations primarily in Valdepeñas, but effectively La Mancha, central Spain.
And they have been at loggerheads for years. We've covered them a lot. They've been in court
against each other numerous times for all sorts of reasons. The last one, I think, was over an
advertising and pricing campaign over the Christmas period, a couple of years back,
when one of them claimed to... I don't know. The ins and outs of it, after a while, frankly,
become difficult to follow. But this one was another advertising campaign in which... Now,
let me get this right. Felix Solis ran an advertising campaign in which they implied
that their Vina Albali, which will be known to many people, was the region's most drunk
wine. García Carrion took them to court, and using the latest Nielsen IQ data,
it showed that actually García Carrion's Pata Negra Reserva was, in fact, the best-selling
Valdepeñas Reserva, and that Felix Solis' advertising campaign had misled consumers.
Cue a spokesperson for García Carrion saying this was an endorsement,
you know, we've been proved right, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
I love it. I'm sorry, I do love a spaff. I mean, there's nothing... I'm being Irish,
I mean, I treasure a grudge like very little. You know, I mean, I've had grudges so long that
I can't even remember what started them, but I'm still furiously holding on to them.
Cherish them.
Indeed, exactly. You know, forget but never forgive, which is something you'll find in the
DNA. But I just love it. I just love the fact that they just seem to be constantly sniping
at each other. I mean, this is the Hatfields and the McCoys, you know, with pinstriped suits on.
Yeah, it's fascinating. I was surprised to hear that. I was like, oh, here we... I was surprised,
and then also like, here we go again in equal measure, if you know what I mean, when I saw this.
If I may be allowed one terrible pun.
Go on.
What a dreadful carrion.
Oh, Lord, no. I mean, I suppose it is your stocking trade, you know, as an editor.
Finally, last drink, champ.
I'd like to apologize for that pun, by the way. I can't, I can't help myself.
Lastly, Champagne Group spends three million euros on AI ads.
So this is...
Oh, yeah. This is odd.
Yes, it's a Champagne du Vigneron organization, which seems to be like a sort of subset of the
Champagne Growers Union, the SGV, which represents independent wine growers and cooperatives in
Champagne.
They reckon it's going to spend between three and four million euros on a campaign, which
I said was sort of minimal, or they said was minimalist, to be specific, it was minimalist,
generated by AI.
The best way to describe these is, as I wrote, they feature a range of potential food matches
and dining situations in which they're sort of...
Yeah, it's very strange.
Let's take one.
Your sushi turned up on time.
Champagne, is the quote one advert says, with the text in the shape of a Champagne bottle.
So the bottle shape, and then there's sort of the foil on top, so you can't mistake it
for anything other than Champagne.
On a wood veneer table next to a tray, a nice sort of luminous sushi.
It's clearly AI generated sushi.
There's all the kind of sushi that you'd see in a sushi restaurant picture, you know, when
you order it, when you get to order it.
And then there's sort of out-of-focus city lights visible through a window in the background.
And it seems to be more wooden panelling on the walls as well.
It's very, quite sort of, yeah.
And it's all the same thing.
Burger looks like the burger in the picture.
Champagne!
Your guests brought dessert.
Champagne!
Got a tomato from your vegetable garden?
Champagne!
I quite like that one.
Your hard work, your slaving away has produced one tomato.
Champagne, that was quite, to be fair.
You can't even make a bowl of soup out of it.
You can't even make a salad.
Yeah, you can have a sandwich maybe, that's about it.
So yeah, other people have responded to that saying, what?
Three million for that?
And I think, actually, I suspect the money wasn't spent on the advertising.
The money has been spent on placing them.
Yeah, you are off on the way.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So I suspect it'll be, they'll end up in prominent places around, well, primarily Paris,
Doesn't this just go against centuries of champagne marketing?
That champagne is special, that it's different, that it's a class apart,
that you should be delighted to be paying so much money to be able to get hold of champagne.
Good point.
Now they're saying, oh no, honestly, it's just every day, even the little small wins.
Well, I was thinking the other way.
Absolutely, yeah, just open champagne at the drop of a hat.
I mean, I'm not against the ethos, generally, I'm just-
No, not really.
I just see, yeah, you're right, it is a change of tact.
The other thing I was thinking of also was just the use of AI.
It's just like, well, if you make a product, which, I mean, wine is generally a craft, right?
It's people making wine.
They make a product and time and effort goes into it.
Growing grapes.
Yeah, it's champagne.
You have to hand pick grapes.
It's a rule.
Yeah.
You can't use machines to pick champagne.
But then to use, to sort of say then, well, then we don't need that ethos
in the production of marketing champagne.
We could just hand it over to AI, let it be done by large language models and stuff like that.
I don't know, yeah, not a fan.
Let's put centuries of prestige to one side and just bang out something in AI.
Yeah.
And we'll just spend the money on trying to get the ads in a good place or something like that.
Yeah, I don't know.
Oh, well, it'll be interesting to see where they do surface.
Yeah.
What's there to look forward to this week, Don?
Oh, we've got lots to look forward to this weekend.
Oh, sorry, this week.
I'm thinking of the weekend again already.
That's unforgivable, I wonder.
And I'd like to apologise to our reader in case I got you all excited
and you thought it was the weekend again.
All of a sudden, yeah.
Well, we've got, because we're moving into our,
because we're turning to the end of the year now, we're moving into our best wines series.
Right, best, right.
So we've already kicked off earlier this week, obviously, on Saturday,
and we'll be following up with best Sauvignons in the world
and best tequilas coming up this week.
We've also got a really interesting story from Marisa Davari about,
if you're finding Etna's getting a little bit out beyond your price range these days,
there's another volcano or volcanic wine region you should be looking at,
which is Vesuvius.
Ah, yes, yes, yes.
Which is a reasonably famous volcano in its own right, I was going to say.
Although that's gone.
Yeah, so it'll be the Pompeii Cuvée and the Chateau Herculaneum.
And so forth.
It'll be, you know, wines that stand the test of time.
We've had a new contributor, Marisa Davari.
She's gone to visit and have a look around, and she's come back with a story for us.
So that's exciting.
And we have another new competitor coming up this week.
I'm delighted to say we've got a story from Julia Harding, M.W.
from JancisRobinson.com.
And it's a story about Portugal.
So it's all about Portuguese wines.
Sorry, she's a new addition to our Wine Voices section.
So that will be appearing in our Wine Voices section on Wednesday.
So all those of you who are fans of Julia Harding, M.W., you know where to come.
And those of you who are fans of Portuguese wines.
Excellent.
Right, Devin, well, you have a great week.
Well, you too.
Thanks, mate.
And we'll catch up next week.
Look forward to it.
Have a good one.
Bye.
Thank you for listening to the Week in Wine news podcast.
For more than all that we discuss, and for price and retail information on all the wines near you,
including comprehensive coverage from our pro-membership option, go to wine-searcher.com.
