How to Improve a Gas Mask

Military Head & Gear
1 follower
Oct 5, 2026 #MilitaryEquipment
Taking a look at two similar gas masks, the French M-51 and the Swiss SM-67, if I had the Swiss SM-74 I would have compared that instead. Both masks are similar but the Swiss mask is superior for several small reasons, many masks can be of similar design but fail or succeed due to small changes/features in the mask.
#MilitaryEquipment
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video compares two conceptually similar gas masks—the French M51 and the Swiss SM67—to demonstrate how minor design improvements and engineering choices can significantly impact the quality, comfort, and functionality of a piece of equipment.
Hello everybody, so around my neck I have two different gas masks but both are quite similar
and I wanted to do a video where I looked at masks that are very similar to each other but
one is clearly better than the other through sort of clever design choices and just minor details.
So I have the French M51 in this bag, I think I might have the Belgian export version but
regardless it's the same mask, and in this one I have the Swiss SM67. Now if this was a Swiss SM74
it would look a lot more like the M51 but it's fundamentally a very similar mask. So
first let's look at the French one and a lot of you have heard me complain about this mask before,
this mask is a bit of a shame because there's lots of great things about it but there's a
couple of major drawbacks that mean you know a lot of the masks that should be good is ruined.
Okay so here's the mask, it's made out of quite a soft comfortable rubber but the headstrap system
is really weird, you can tighten the straps at the top and the sides of it but not at the bottom
and on the bottom it hooks on with these little hooks so it's a mask that sort of, I mean it looks
like you can sort of tighten it there, you can because there's a buckle but you can't tighten
it in a way that I think would you know serve the mask very well, so it's a weird strap system is
what I'm really trying to say. It does have one of these though so you can pop that around your
neck as well. Now this mask is fundamentally incredibly simple, you have an inhale valve
coming through there, it does have tissot tubes on both sides so that's a plus so it doesn't
really fog up or you can at least defog it when you breathe, but the weak point as I've said in
all my videos regarding this mask is under this cover is the exhale valve, that is a very flimsy
rubber that can break very easily. I mean in theory you could repair it, people have said like you know
if you've taken gp5 rubber and done it with that you could just get a bit of rubber cut to shape
and repair it but it's kind of a shame that they went to a lot of effort with some parts of the
mask like the rubber on here and then they cut the rubber so thin there that it was you know a weak
point of the mask. Obviously these weren't intended for use in service as long as they were in service
but that was more of a problem with French military funding than anything else. So I'll
pop the mask on, make sure I get the hooks out and under my head okay and then I get these hooks
over to each of the hooks and this is a really stupid strap system in my opinion,
points them to trying to come up with something original but they didn't really succeed.
There we go, so it's on tight enough it's got an airtight seal, I can see fairly well about
out of it, not much downwards but upwards and sideways I can see fairly well.
So the mask is cheap, it does its job you know and it's I guess fairly effective for what it is,
it's just a shame that the exhale valve is just pure crap but it does defog when I inhale,
no inner mask so it fogs up, I don't know what nasal cup I mean but if you put some anti-dim
paste on the inside you'd probably find it wouldn't fog up very much and it would completely
clear every time you inhale. At the moment it completely clears every time I inhale but it
does fog up quite a lot on exhaling. So anyway that was the French M51, so what I'm going to
show you now is the Swiss SM67 and I will demonstrate to you how that other mask despite
looking very similar works a lot better. So here is the Swiss SM67 and let me just do a
side-by-side comparison with the other mask. So this one takes the filter there so it's still
kind of downwards but with this one it's more up the front than actually completely at the bottom
but you see both masks have a very similar profile. The exhale valve on this one goes
straight down as said with the Swiss SM74 it's actually on the nose area more similar to the
M51 but both masks fundamentally have quite a similar design. Now let's look at what makes
this mask better. Firstly it's got proper fabric straps you know the stretchy sort of elastic ones
that are both comfortable and work. You've got an actual chin rest in there so your chin doesn't go
too far into the mask and one of the things I really like this mask is how it's shaped.
The eyes sit very close to your eyes so you get the best field of view possible
but that also prevents some fogging because this doesn't have any sort of Tissot system or anything
like that. I've got some anti-dim paste on the inside but you probably think how does this mask
work well? Well it's simply because the mask sits so well to your face it doesn't need any of those
things. So I'll put it on and do the straps up. Okay so what you'll see now is I've just done a
strap while I was adjusting the straps but this mask is very interesting. I'll just pop the filter
on it for sake of um you know the video. My vision's a bit steamed up but that's not actually
where it's steamed up it's the sort of whatever type of fat or synthetic chemical they use for
the anti-dim stuff. There we go very easy filter to put on as well even though this isn't the Swiss
filter it's a British one but where the actual port is. So the mask sits so well to your face
that my nose is like under the eye section. I'm sure if I got the straps even tighter you know
the eyes again would be even closer to my head um so I'll just try and do that but yeah. So what I
like with this mask is that the eyes like that you can do that one tighter as well sit very close to
my eyes because the shape of the mask you know fits the human face very well. I mean obviously
it will depend a bit on how your face is shaped but what this means is how the mask is shaped
it sits very well in comparison to your face. This one doesn't as much but like I said the main fault
of that is the exhale valve but what I'm saying is you can take a mask like this you can make the
shape sit slightly better to your face and then you almost don't need a defogging system because
it won't fog up because the hot air is trapped in the lower section of the mask the inhaling
and exhaling is purely down this end not the top end. So I said this is a very clever design
for a mask and I really like it it's one of those masks that seems primitive but it's been
cleverly thought out I guess that's very Swiss you know they've gone to extreme lengths to
engineer something very well. So hopefully this video was sort of can I get that off without
undoing the straps? Just about. So hopefully this video has pointed out how you can have two masks
that are conceptually very similar but due to clever design choices you can have something
that's much better you know with one than the other. As said if I had the SM74 it would look
closer to this M51. Again I don't mean to keep shitting on this mask because it is I kind of
like it it's just it's a real shame that they couldn't have done a better exhale valve
um you know and maybe put a very primitive oral nasal cup in but as it stands yeah it was adequate
when it was made it's just the French kept them in service for far too long and didn't make new
ones or replace them. But you know there you go so the point of the video was that you can have
two very similar design masks but somebody if they're you know competent enough can improve
upon the design and make something far better. Like I was saying in the other video with the
American M9 and the Finnish M61s how the Finnish M61s had the sort of things that made them both
more comfortable and made a better airtight seal just from you know very small changes made to the
masks. But there you go that's how you can have two masks but one can be far better with very
little changes.
