Why the 18 Year Housing Cycle Doesn’t Add Up - Steven Thomas
This housing market update from Steven Thomas of Reports On Housing examines the increasingly popular 18-year real estate cycle and whether it really signals another housing crash. Steven breaks down the historical timeline, explains why housing cycles do not follow a precise clock, and shows how inflation changes the way long-term home price performance should be viewed. The analysis also looks at today’s recession in closed sales, inflation-adjusted home values, and why different markets can move in very different directions.
Time Stamps: 00:00 Introduction 00:16 What Is the 18 Year Housing Cycle? 01:34 Why the Timeline Does Not Fit 03:02 Not Every Housing Cycle Ends in a Crash 05:53 Housing Cycles Are Real but Not Precisely Timed 06:01 The Difference Between Nominal and Real Home Prices 08:22 Housing’s Inflation-Adjusted Purgatory 09:55 Where Home Prices Go From Here 11:18 Conclusion
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Stephen Thomas analyzes the \"18-year housing cycle\" theory, arguing that rigid time-based predictions are often inaccurate. He distinguishes between nominal and real home values, noting that inflation-adjusted prices are currently eroding. While national trends show stagnation, local market variance remains high, influenced by regional economic drivers like the AI boom.
Hello there, Stephen Thomas, chief economist at reports on housing,
bringing to you another housing debrief.
Thank you so much for joining us this week.
We're going to dive into the 18 year cycle has housing on alert, and you're
probably wondering what is this 18 year cycle?
You'll hear it.
It's making its rounds.
I've actually heard it's getting louder right now.
And that's because it's the right at the precipice of that 18 years cycle.
I saw this recently on Yahoo, and that was basically the 18 year housing cycle
says the next market crash is close.
It's like eminent.
And, and you can, uh, there are a lot of YouTube videos that are done on the 18
year property cycle, explaining exactly what it is.
And it's all the same.
It's basically years one through seven is the recovery phase.
And then you get this mild mid cycle dip and then explosive growth phase.
And then you get this recessionary phase years, 14 through 18.
So, um, if you do the math, that's, I think 2013 to 2020 and 2020 was the
little dip because we went into COVID like everybody could have predicted that.
And then we had this explosive phase and the recession phase.
And it's nice and perfect that we're right at the part right now where we
should have a downturn now, a recessionary phase.
So, uh, this was made very, very popular by a gentleman by the name of Fred
Harrell's Fred Harrison, and he's out of the UK and he's the one that's written.
A lot of different books talks about this.
Uh, I even seen some recent YouTube videos with him on it.
And, uh, basically it talks about eight, every 18 years.
And we're going to get into what that is.
1973 and then 1990 and then 2008.
And this looks very uniform when they put together something like this almost
looks like AI drew it because it's so uniform.
This is exactly how it happens over and over again.
We hit this big dip and then we go up and then we get this big dip.
And, but that's not quite the way it works.
There's a lot of people that are trying to make it work for all the different
times it, when I look at the dates that they put on all these different charts
that are all over the place, they're really wonky because it doesn't really
quite fit that 18 year cycle.
A lot of the different, uh, 18 year gaps that they're talking about.
And, um, and this was somebody that put this together, did a YouTube article,
but he used this piece of paper, talked about 18.6 years because really
it's a little bit past 18 years.
So he's calling it the 18.6 year real estate cycle.
And so are we near the end of the 18 year real estate cycle where values
are going to come back down again?
And, uh, so you can actually see if I zoom in and show you this, this shows
you, it goes back to the 18 hundreds from 18, 18, 18, 36, 18 years.
And then to 18, 54, 18 years, 18, 72, 18 years.
And it looked pretty uniform, but the problem is, and then there's this big
gap from 1925, all the way to 1973, that's 48 years.
And then you have these, they had 1973 to 79 at six, then it's 10 and it's 17.
And it looked very uniform back in the day, but part of that, it was completely
a different United States back in the 1800s, things were done a little
bit differently, the lifespan was a lot less, we were behaving differently.
We don't have all the tools and everything else that we have today.
It's very different today than it was back then.
And, uh, so we're going to get into really all housing cycles.
Don't end in a crash.
That's really what, what this is, what this is about.
Does that mean that we can't go down in values?
We're going to talk about that because if you look at the, uh, just nominal
with the Schiller home values, uh, since 1942, and he did an extensive study.
The, uh, so, uh, uh, Schiller went all the way back to 1942.
So since the, uh, since the, uh, world war two, we've actually not really gone down.
We've had some flat years.
You can see that in the gray in 1949, 55, 59, and 62, but it wasn't until
1990 that we had values go down, but they didn't go down that much.
They only went down 0.7% and 0.2%.
Now, if you're in California or the West coast and you're one
of the West coast regions, that was the savings and loan scandal where
there was price values that really went down, but it was very, it was a,
a smaller region that brought down the rest of the country because
the rest of the country was fine.
But markets are always local, but this was a little bit bigger, uh, of a, of
a local area that brought down the entire United States so that it was
barely negative for the year down 0.7% for 1990 and down 0.2% and, uh, for
the year in 1991, so, uh, negative years built it.
If you were in California or some of the surrounding states, but for the
rest of the country, it was fine.
And, uh, then it continued to be positive.
And, uh, you can see the run up, uh, in the two thousands all the way
until we got to the great recession.
And that's what everybody remembers.
Everybody remembers the down 5%, the down 12%, down four, down four, down four.
And these are just, uh, these are just, uh, the, what, what the values were.
It's what we refer to as nominal values, but we also have inflation
during the same time period.
So these are actually even more negative.
If you, if you include inflation, there are definitely housing market cycles.
There is the recovery stage first, uh, that's the recovery stage.
And that's where you, you can feel that that would happen from 2013 on.
And then you have the expansion, uh, stage that's where significant
growth and demand increases.
And the markets were kind of manipulated in, in, in the course of that happening.
And that's where there are other parts of the marketplace, like the government,
government policies, federal, uh, reserve policies.
There's different things that can manipulate the real estate market.
So to say that the cycle is going to fit in any different way is not actually that
accurate, but you have the expansion stage.
You have a hyper supply stage where all of a sudden you have the
saturation and, uh, declining values.
And that's now what we're having.
Then you have a recession stage that's declining values and demand.
So, uh, that's the, there are some normal, uh, housing market
cycles that do take place.
It's just putting a time on them is what the problem is.
Now, if you look at where we're at today and you factor in inflation, kind of
like what I said before, there's something called the nominal price difference.
There's also something called the real price difference.
And that's when you factor in inflation and when you factor in inflation, that's
where things are a little bit different.
So.
Uh, already you can see there's been a big change in the number of closed sales.
So this is recessionary there and it's a recession in the number of units.
You could see that, uh, what I'm pointing to is this
waterfall dive in closed sales.
Well, that was 2012.
It came all the way down and pretty much has been stuck at 4 million homes per
year, and this is seasonally adjusted.
When they look at that, it goes up and down by the differences in the months,
but it's pretty much stuck right there at 4 million and that's where it has
been since like November of 2012.
And it's been there continuously.
So we're about to hit our four year mark of being at 4 million, uh, sales, which
is recessionary in the number of units.
That doesn't mean that we're peeling off prices, but it's now at the point
where there's enough inventory where.
Uh, there's this gap and that's where you start to look at how much
values are going up on an, on an, on an annual basis.
And when you adjust for inflation, it's actually negative for the year
because there's such a little appreciation for the year that inflation
is outpacing, uh, how much values are going up for the year.
So values have been going up in the United States over the last several
years, and we're talking about the United States as a whole.
So I know that some people get upset because they say, well, look, what's
happening in this section of Florida or in Austin, Texas, or over here.
The real estate's always local and there's always markets
that are going up or down.
But we're talking about.
United States as a whole.
And, uh, you can, and when I zoom this in, you can actually see that when
you just for inflation, there are different gaps and you could see that
there was a gap, even though we had positive values and from 1979, we had
a gap and that gap was six and a half years when you adjusted for inflation
before it came back to the last peak.
And that also happened, uh, in the 1990s.
So you have, uh, this peak that they say it's like at 1989 is
really where the peak was.
And then it was 11 years until it returned when you adjust for inflation.
And then we had the great recession, which peaked in 2006 and it took 14
and a half years before it returned to the same value, that last peak that
we're at and prices go up over time because of inflation, but after you
adjust for inflation after a while, it takes a long time for it to come
back as you can see right here.
And if I show you where we're at currently right now, it's been, we hit a
and it's been a 50 months and 50 months, uh, is just a little bit over four years.
So it's four years and two months that we have been, uh, since we last peaked.
So that was a long time since the last time that, that we peaked.
And that's this gap that we have, we kind of call it purgatory.
And really when you adjust for inflation, it's actually down 4.1%.
So it's 4.1% below the 2022 peak.
And where do we think things are going to go?
Probably by the time that we continue down this course, it'll be down
10% when you adjust for inflation.
So it could be going, it's been going up slightly, but it hasn't
really kept up with inflation.
So it hasn't outpaced inflation.
So really in the background, homes are becoming a little bit more
affordable because they're being eroded by inflation and incomes
are going up at the same time.
And they're going up faster than the pace of home values.
So, uh, and you can, you can, I'm just going to show you what's
happened to values over time.
So this is the beginning of this gap that we're having.
And how long is this going to last?
It could be a another.
Five years from now, it could be four years.
We just don't know exactly when this gap will end.
When we say that we're going to go down another 6% and it's
gonna be 10% down, that's kind of just a guess as to where we're
going to go, because nobody quite knows what different policies and,
and where rates are at and, uh, how inventory levels and demand,
uh, unfold over the years.
We'll be watching that.
But as far as the Zillow home price index is concerned, we have a whole
bunch of, I just looked at the Freddie Mac home price index was,
which was just released.
We're very, it's only going up slightly since, since, uh, 2022.
And you can see that on the right-hand side of this.
This is a home prices and then just been going up a little bit, but
they're kind of flat right now.
And for the rest of the year, it's going to be negative.
We're just gonna have to see where things are going to go.
And you can see attached is actually down a little bit over recent
months, and there are many markets where this is negative.
I track a lot of different markets over here in the West and Vegas is
being hit harder than Maricopa Phoenix.
And, uh, then the Bay area is actually resuming because of AI San Francisco.
Nobody's talking about it, but it is up a tremendous amount year over
year, and that's because of AI.
Everybody's talking about it when it was going down, but nobody's paying
attention now that it's going up, but there are areas that are going down.
So it's very, very local.
You need to understand that.
Values are local and they can do different things locally, but, uh,
when you adjust it for inflation, how much are they really going up?
And you can see if it's kind of flat that it's really going down, uh, on an
annual basis, because you're, if you adjust values for inflation, it's
actually eroding the values, uh, over time.
And that's currently where we're at.
And like I said, this is Clark County shows you where attached
is at right now.
And it's down.
If I, if I show you this, this is where it's getting hit a little bit harder
and attached in Merrick and Clark County.
That's Vegas, uh, is, uh, is going down faster than detached.
And that's the way it is across the country.
And that's why I brought that out.
So, Hey, by the way, I'd like you to like this.
If you like what you're watching and subscribe to our YouTube channel and go
to reports and housing.com for more information and, uh, the most recent
report, cause we have reports that all over SoCal, the Bay area, Vegas and
Phoenix, and then, and now 2008 versus two, uh, today, and basically we're
just showing you what it was like prior to the lead up to the great recession
and what it's like now, and, you know, comparing and contrasting, because
there are definitive differences.
One of the only things that really matches up is that we have low demand.
The biggest thing missing is for selling.
And you can watch our video from last week.
If you want to know more about, uh, the potential of a crash.
So, uh, that's the most recent report.
It's come on.
It's come out for all the coast and the other markets.
Get it next week in and now 2008 versus, uh, versus now.
And if you'd like a free month, utilize the coupon code cycle.
And just one more time.
I did this last week.
I just want everybody to know we launched something new for subscribers
and that is nerd lab HQ and nerd lab, hq.com.
That is for all subscribers.
They can actually go in to our, our backside, uh, and, and play
with the data a little bit, come out with some of their own reports
where they can hit a full report.
And then, uh, then they can actually then export it, share it.
And there are a bunch of social media posts and all different shapes and
sizes and reports that you can send clients, and then you can drill
down even further by the city.
So that's what it's about.
It's getting as much information as possible out to everybody.
And that's just one more perk, one more value add that we've
added to for our subscribers.
Anyways, thank you so much for joining us for another, uh, housing debrief.
Really appreciate it.
Hope you have a fantastic finished your week and we will
see you on the other side.