Melody Wright explains why lower mortgage rates won’t save housing, why inventory is piling up, and why foreclosures could surge into 2026. If you’re buying, waiting, or investing. ------------------- 👨💼 Guest: Melody Wright, Chief Market Strategist 🏢 Company: M3 Melody Substack 🌎 https://m3melody.substack.com/ 𝕏 @m3_melody 📺 @m3_melody 📅 Recording date: January 13rd, 2026
------------------- 📆 Save the Date 📆 DEUTSCHE GOLDMESSE May 15 & 16, 2026 in Frankfurt, Germany www.deutschegoldmesse.com FREE Registration for Investors!
00:00 – Housing inflation & CPI reality 01:14 – How cold the housing market really is 02:46 – Price cuts, weak demand & excess supply 04:00 – Crisis or slowdown? 05:15 – Trump’s $200B MBS plan 06:57 – Why lower rates won’t save housing 08:45 – Who really controls mortgage rates 10:40 – Credit tightening & debt stress 13:27 – Delinquencies, rejections & foreclosures 16:52 – Why 2026 matters 18:16 – Investors, institutions & policy risk 20:09 – Shadow inventory explained 22:53 – Buying a home in 2026 24:37 – Best & worst housing markets 27:03 – Final thoughts
While the CPI print came in at 2.7% within expectations, shelter has been ticking higher,
and we need to break that down. What is happening in the housing market? President Trump is
proposing some midterm election gifts, $200 billion mortgage-backed security purchases,
credit card interest rate cap. How does it affect the housing market? I think it's a really,
really important discussion to have. I've invited a phenomenal guest to discuss this with us today.
Her name is Melody Wright. She's M3 Melody over on Substack. Phenomenal. I call her the real
estate queen and the housing market queen. I'm really looking forward to getting her insights
because I think it's quite important. The housing market is one of the biggest,
maybe the most important economic pillar in the US, and we'll break it down for you.
Before I switch over to my guest, help us achieve our goal of reaching 100,000 subscribers here by
the end of this quarter. We tremendously appreciate your support and thank you for it.
Thank you so much for hitting that button. Now, Melody, it is great to welcome you back on the
program. It's good to see you again. Happy New Year. Good to see you. Happy New Year,
and thanks for having me. Absolutely. Yeah, you're the queen of real estate and housing,
Melody. We have to catch up. I love our biannual check-ins here. Really get a temperature check
what is happening in the housing market. Maybe let's start at a very high level. What is the
temperature in the housing market right now? It's chilly. It's chilly, Kai. We just got new
home sales that have been delayed by two months. They significantly revised down the prior months,
but the October month looked a lot stronger, but the previous months were heavily revised
downward. You look at the existing home sales, they're just abysmal. They're the lowest we've
seen since 1995. We may get a little bit stronger December sales. We'll know tomorrow. NARs are
going to report. However, that's still not. It's abysmal. It's basically tracking along 2008 at
this point. It's very frigid in the housing market. Redfin has come out saying that there's a whole
bunch more sellers than there are buyers. You've got Zillow coming out and saying,
on over 50% of the homes, you've seen a 9.6 price cut reduction. Those estimates are going down.
You've mentioned CPI. ApartmentList came out last month and said they were seeing year-over-year
rent declines as well as the highest vacancy they'd seen since they started tracking in 2017,
which was somewhat expected because of all of that multifamily that was in progress without
the demographics to support it. Right now, the housing market is pretty frigid. We'll be talking
about, I'm sure, some of these announcements that folks are hoping to pry it loose in that spring
selling season. To be honest, I would like to see it pried loose because then we'll get actual
price discovery, which is not what a lot of people are saying, but you can see it.
You can see anytime that we get a little bit lower rates and we get a higher number of transactions,
we tend to see lower prices. You can see it on the builder side. They just came in
for their October reported median home price is below $400,000. That's also backed up by what the
announced during their earnings. Things are pretty frigid, but I'm hoping to see something
shake loose by the spring. Would you call it a full-blown crisis yet or is it just a cold market?
Crisis. People are delusional. The sellers are delusional. It's a crisis because our young
Americans can't afford homes, but I'm of the opinion that government needs to stay out of it.
If they did, we would clear the market of this speculation and those young Americans would be
able to afford homes. Realtor.com came out and said there's three ways that we could see
affordability improve in the housing market. One is rates go to 2.65%, which I'll talk about.
Incomes rise over 50%. Our home prices go down by 35%. This isn't Melody Wright. This is an
industry magazine saying this. I think that rates number actually, I don't think that's
accurate because you've got so many rejections. Mortgage credit is not really available right now
and you've got over 20% rejections on purchases. You've got over 42% rejections on mortgage refi,
both the highest in the series since the Fed has been tracking.
Lower rates, I don't think it's going to do a lot. If you want to pivot to right now,
we can talk about that MBS buying because that has effectively lowered rates since May.
Let's go there because President Trump said we're going to repurchase or purchase $200
billion worth of mortgage-backed securities. Maybe break that down for us. What does that
mean? You already hinted at the ripple effects there.
Yeah. I find it interesting because they've been doing it since May.
There was a Bloomberg article in early December and just doing the math. After the great financial
crisis, there was a cap put on how much they could buy of those mortgage-backed securities
because they became like a self-eating snake when they were buying those things. That was really
looked on as a big no-no after the GOC, but here we all realize they've been doing it since May.
No one would comment from Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. When Trump came out and said,
this is what we're going to do, he didn't really say this is what we've been doing because
they did about $50 billion in purchases. We have seen rates come down, but importantly,
we have not seen sales increase. Everybody needs to remember that the builders have
been doing these permanent buy-downs that effectively have lowered rates for the past
two years. Yet, they've got a lot of inventory and their sales are not good. As much as people
are going to celebrate today, they have to look at those downer divisions and look at
what the whole year would look like. It's not good. They can buy this $200 billion.
What I did in my latest stuff stack is I showed two periods in history. You go back,
the Fed started buying MBS mortgage-backed securities in 2009. It didn't do anything
to really help the housing market. It might have slowed things down a little bit, but not really.
You can see home prices continue to come down even as those rates were coming down.
They also, if you think about $200 billion, and there's a possibility they raised that cap.
They're getting desperate. The Fed bought over $700 billion in MBS from 2021, January 21,
to when they started raising rates in March. Before that time period, they'd bought a whole
bunch. I'm talking about that time period specifically. You had mortgage rates rise.
Everybody jumping on this bandwagon like this is going to be some kind of panacea for the
housing market. That's just not accurate. I'm a little excited. I'm one of the only
bears that gets excited about this, Kai, to be honest. They all think I'm a little crazy.
I mean, what's new? I'm excited to see mortgage rates down because I want transactions. I think
what we've seen over the past year, because we know the boomers own the majority of the homes,
we've seen a lot of what my colleague John Brooks calls rage delisting, where
they can't get the price they want. Instead of just letting it sit there
and age on market, because everybody can see that, and they can say,
oh, you're desperate, aren't you? This house has been on the market for 100 days.
They've been delisting that. We had some of the highest numbers of delisting last year.
The spring is going to be very interesting. I think it will bring more inventory back to the
market because mainstream media will tout this as, if things are more affordable,
you're going to be able to sell this. I think we're going to see a lot of inventory show up
in the spring. I do think that with those lower rates, that's going to
shake things loose, and we're going to see those home price declines.
Talking about lower rates, I just looked up the 30-year mortgage rate,
and it hasn't really moved since September. It's fairly flat, like 6.3% or so,
but we've had three rate cuts since. It hasn't really kept up. Where's the discrepancy?
What am I missing here, Melody? The Fed doesn't control mortgage rates,
and it just cracks me up. For an extended period of time, mortgage rates would track
their action, but they're independent. The bond market controls the 10-year treasury,
and that is how mortgage rates are identified. Right now, I use a mortgage-backed security live
tool. Right now, we're at 6.01%, and that's real time. We got down as low as 5.99% on Friday.
We shot back up to 6.06%. Just for perspective, the lowest point we got last year in 24
was 6.08% right before the Fed did that massive cut, and rates went up.
People that look to the Fed in terms of controlling mortgage rates, that's not how it works.
But what happens when Fannie and Freddie barf the Fed by those mortgage-backed securities,
what you do is you tighten the spread between the 10-year and those mortgage rates. That's
what's been happening. But I agree. They've cut, I think, four times since September of last year,
and it did nothing for mortgage rates. But we've come down a little bit since the beginning of
2024. I'm sorry, 2025. I'm excited to see us at this low level. Again, I'll be the only housing
bear that's going to say that. No, that's good, though. There's got to be a little positivity,
so there's always opportunity as well. Since we started down the path of potential midterm
election gifts, let's stay on that. It's the credit card interest rate, what do you call it,
cap that has been proposed, 10%. It sounds great because people are drowning in debt,
credit card debt. But the question is, what are the ripple effects? You talked about credit markets
and credit tightening. What are the effects of that? Because the 30% interest rate that you get
on your credit card is pretty much unchecked and unsecured. What is going to change there
if that really comes? This is wild to me. It's hard to even process. I feel like we're not even
pretending anymore. We live in a capitalist society. I just can't even imagine the conversation
with Diamond unless there was some sort of backroom deal on this, because what's going to
happen is lending will tighten. I haven't had time to do the math, but you cut interest income,
which is the bread and butter of the banks or these credit card holders. They're going to take
a massive hit. You can see today, and again, I haven't had time to dive in, but I can see that
took a big provision for loan loss. That means that they are already in a distressed situation
having to wipe some off of their net income and put it in a reserve because of loan losses.
This is going to tighten lending, which is not going to be good for the housing market.
I find it wild, but also in a weird way, it's kind of an interesting move.
I was like, is this Elizabeth Warren that we're seeing here? Is this Bernie Sanders? No, it's
Trump. Trump kind of stole their platform. I think Bernie had this as proposed legislation.
This is wild, Kai. Telling the banks you can't do X, Y, and Z is kind of crazy.
He's trying to do the same with the defense contractors as well. It's not too far-fetched.
I mean, not with what we've seen, but historically speaking, this is pretty-
It's unprecedented what we're seeing, which makes it fun to talk about, quite honestly,
as an outsider because I sit in Germany. For me, it's always easier to talk about
something that's not happening here. What I was going to come back to,
you talked about rejections have already increased dramatically. I think that ties
in perfectly to what we've just been talking about. Do you see that number of rejections
increased even further? It's not positive, obviously. It could increase further or you
just see fewer applications. I mean, that's the thing. It's like when you know you're going to
get rejected, you don't apply. I have family members that were one of those rejections for
their refinance and they're not going to apply for some time. We might see it, but really what's
going to increase those rejections is we still don't have all the delinquent student loans
reporting to credit. Once we get all of those, then yeah, you're going to see more rejections,
but that's really what's happening right now is that you had a whole bunch of people that
weren't reported as delinquent that are- I say suddenly, it happened last spring,
but they're now being reported as delinquent, which is a big deal in mortgage. If you have an
FHA loan and you have a student loan delinquency over 270 days, you're not going to be eligible
for any loan modification or workout. And so you're going to be fully responsible for that
mortgage. So this is a big deal. We'd all been waiting, those of us that track the consumer,
we'd all been waiting really to see this ripple and the ripples have started.
It sounds like an unfair- I wouldn't say unfair, it's like a macabre question I was
to ask. How do you profit from that now? Of course, there's investors and others sitting
on the sidelines waiting for this to maybe crash properly. What's the timeline on that?
Should we be sharpening our knives for that to happen?
Well, yeah, I know a lot of people who are already building funds for distressed assets
because there's going to- I know people who are already buying multifamily because
it is so distressed that they're getting it for cheaper than the construction cost.
I'm sorry, I don't mean to laugh. I mean, that's somebody's livelihood,
but that's what's happening. And so I think, Bill, if you're interested in those distressed
properties, then probably be saving for that time period. So what's going to happen is now
that those guardrails are on that FHA program, we're seeing delinquency rise and we're seeing
serious delinquency rise. What had been happening is that anybody that was serious delinquent could
keep going back to the teal for a workout until maybe they ran out. But it was hard to do under
that last program. Now they can't do that. They can get it one every two years. And they also
have to do something called make trial payments, which what was happening is a lot of people would
get that workout and they become performing and they wouldn't pay again for the next three months,
do the same thing, not pay again. Now to be eligible for that workout, you have to pay for
three months in a row. And I've heard from my colleague, John Comiskey, who's talking to some
folks in servicing that think that that fallout rate is going to be about 50%, which is unheard
of, Kai. I managed default back during the crisis. And I mean, nothing like that in terms
of fallout to workout. So this is a really nasty situation, which means we're going to have more
material foreclosures by Q2 of 2026, which is also going to be a drag on home prices.
Why do you say Q2 2026? Is there a certain like, why?
It's the timing. So after the GFC, you have to wait 120 days of delinquency before you can refer
a loan to foreclosure. Well, when they're in these workouts, like let's say you sign up for one of
these partial claim workouts, but you don't make your trial payment for three months, the servicer
has to wait until that time is over before they can refer you to foreclosure. And then each state
has a ton of noticing requirements. Sometimes you have to do a mediation before you refer people to
foreclosure. And so it just takes a ton of time for these things to flow through the system.
And so we're already seeing them come over the dam in November and December. We just got December
results. And that's just going to build and build and build. And so we're going to see the increases.
There's always a push and pull to delinquency because of those workouts. But by Q2 2026,
enough are going to be coming through the pipeline that you're going to see it,
and it's going to have a significant impact on the market.
Gotcha. No, I appreciate that. That clarifies timing a little bit as well. Another fun headline
I just read as well, like Trump wants to ban investors from purchasing single family homes.
What do you make of that headline? What are the ramifications possibly here?
Yeah, so I see this differently. I mean, I watch narratives, Kai. It's my background
and probably literature and history. And they floated this before the election. It was popular.
Really, the institutionals own less than 2% of the entire market. Don't get me wrong.
Where they have a significant presence, it's a big deal in those markets like Atlanta,
Tampa, Charlotte, San Antonio. In Atlanta and San Antonio, you're seeing them fire sale and
you're seeing that impact on prices. And so this is, you know, it makes for good politicking.
But in reality, what I think this is, is a setup for an institutional bailout that
they'll, you know, they've got two housing bills and committee, you know, be very easy to add
sort of a out for the institutionals where they could partner with a nonprofit, get some sort of
credit if they sell at a certain price floor to nonprofits who then turn around and make those
homes available and affordable housing. Like, you know, let's say you make 75% of your area's
household median income. These are the types of programs that they're looking at. And so
I see this a bit like further out. And I see this as this, although all they're talking about is
putting a ban on it, I guarantee you there's going to be a phase two and it may be very quiet.
That's what they've been doing with the non-performing loan sales. They used to do big
auctions for some of them and they've actually created this partner program specifically on FHA
where they're selling them more quietly now. And so, you know, it probably won't be splashy
headlines, but they're providing an exit strategy for the institutionals. Interesting. Yeah. I
haven't looked at it from that angle. So we'll see how that develops, of course.
Melody, we talked about it a little bit already, but it's really inventory. Like we've talked about
it before, like inventory used to be tight, but now it sounds like there's a lot of shadow
inventory. Like what do we make of this shadow inventory and how do we gauge that properly?
Like, do we need to build more houses now? Or is there enough? No, I mean, no. There might be
areas, Kai, where you need a little bit of building, but we have so many housing units in
this country. You know, we have 15 million vacant homes. You know, we have a lot of second, third,
fourth home ownership, but we have a lot of investors that participate in the market. I mean,
especially in the Northeast and on the coast, you know, you look at owner occupancy, it's very low
because the boomers, you know, landlording is an American pastime. And so they bought those up.
They did long-term rental. They did short-term rental. You know, you look at somewhere like San
Diego, it's just, it looks like an infestation for short-term rental, like over 12,000 Airbnbs.
I mean, San Diego is not that big, Kai, and they have plenty of hotels. So, you know, people just
went nuts. And we'll start, that inventory already started coming to the market, you know, in 24,
in 25, and it's just going to continue to accumulate. And then, of course, we have the
demographic silver tsunami that's coming our way, you know, where Harvard believes we're going to
lose over 15 million of our boomers between 2025 and 2035. And again, they own the majority of the
homes. And then, you know, Charles Schwab did a survey that said 70% of the time, people who
inherit a home sell it. And so I'm already seeing people that have passed on, you know, their homes
are sitting in probate, because that also takes some time, and it takes some time for the kids to
decide what to do. So, you know, we have plenty of inventory today. Or last night, I tweeted
something, there was an article in the Wall Street Journal about all the rental incentives in
multifamily. And, you know, the Wall Street Journal used the word overbuilt. And I remember when I used
that word, how I was roasted on social media. I mean, people call me absolutely insane. And so,
you know, all this stuff that I've been talking about for years, because I was looking way ahead,
not at what was listed on a multiple listing service or MLS or Zillow, I was looking at what,
you know, what is actually coming. And so, you know, all this is, it's playing out. These are
themes that take a long time to play out. And when the government gets involved and intervenes,
it takes even longer. Yeah, I think we can all agree on that. I think that's, I'm contested.
Melody, like we're trying to leave our audience with a bit of advice as well. Like if you were
buying a house in 2026, like what should you be paying attention to? Like if you had like a top
three checklist, what would you do? Yeah. So, you know, what people do today is not what you do,
Kai. You don't go to Zillow and look at what school is in that neighborhood. I mean,
you really need to understand the area that you're buying into. You need to understand
employment. You need to understand your demographics. You need to understand,
so how much are there institutional owners in your market? So that takes a lot of deep
research and time. And, you know, a lot of people don't want to do that amount of work,
but it's really important. I recommend a tool like Property Radar, which you can really get the
behind the scenes of what's going on in a housing market. It's going to be very different than what
you look at on Zillow because it's going to show you tax liens, like the people that aren't paying
their taxes. It's going to show you owner liens. It's going to show you bankruptcy. It's going to
show you divorces, death. And so you'll get a very different view of a market than, say,
what you see on Zillow. So that's what I would recommend for buyers. And honestly, you know,
sign up for the free version of my Substack. I do, I talk, you know, I provide a lot of data
in that free version. You don't even have to pay to understand how I look at the market,
but that's what I would say for people that need to buy. And if you don't have to buy,
be very careful because this is, we are in one of those inflection points in the market where
you could get burned. No, that's very sound advice. And the websites make a lot of sense
checking out. So thanks for that. I'm just curious, like what cities are hot right now
and which ones are cold? Like where do you get the best deal? The best deal? I mean,
you're getting the best deals in the South. I mean, you're getting the best deals in
Texas, Florida. I mean, you're getting, so people in California might think they're deals. I don't
think they're deals, but you're definitely in the West. You're also seeing year over year
price declines. And so, but it's still not enough. I mean, I was talking to someone yesterday who
sells houses in Nashville and he's like, but look how much affordability has improved. And I'm like,
yes, compare that to a household median income, compare that to history, and it's still way too
expensive. And so although we've had sort of this very small improvement in affordability,
it's not enough. And so that's the other thing I would say, look at your household median income
and look at your household and look at your median sale price. And you'll see how out of
whack things are. And for perspective, you really should only be paying about 28%
of your income toward housing. I mean, that's a tried and true kind of metric.
No, that makes absolute sense. 28%. I think when I was a student, I read Donald Trump's books as
well. And I think there was one takeaway I actually had from his books. He said, 25%,
I think max is what you should be investing in. I forgot which book it is. I don't have
them behind me. They're somewhere in the garage. Quickly, what's fascinating is they'll say that
on the FDIC website, they'll say that on the Fannie Mae website, but you can look at the
existing book of business for Fannie Mae right now. And they're at a 38% debt to income, which
is where we were in 2008. And so we're over that. Even though everybody has done all that credit
quality gospel singing, the underwriting standards got tighter. That's just untrue.
People learned how to game the automated underwriting systems. And I've seen things
in this cycle that I didn't even see last time in servicing, which is where you always see the
works. You see what happened in the heyday once it gets into regular old mortgage servicing and
when things go delinquent. Fascinating times. I'm trying to put money aside a little bit for
a distressed asset fund. It'd be fun. I think I told you that before, Melody. I had a friend
reach out to me. I think it was 2008, 2009. And he was looking at a house in Las Vegas.
It was like $150,000 and asked me if I wanted to go in with him. That was way before I'd
accumulated anything. So I was like, yeah, I can't do that. That house probably be worth $500,000,
now. I don't think we'll see $150,000 again. But what's your expectation? What do you think
we'll see again? It won't match median income, but it will be that historical relationship.
I think you're looking at a median around $250,000. Las Vegas, they're about to take a
you never know. I'm sharpening my knives already. I'm getting ready.
Yeah, it's so overbuilt in Las Vegas. Melody, tremendously appreciate your insights. You
already hinted at your sub stack, but just repeat it. Where can people find more of your work?
Sure. So my sub stack, M3 Melody sub stack, you can find me on Twitter
at M3 Melody. And infrequently, I post on my YouTube channel at M3 Melody YouTube.
Melody, thank you so much. Tremendously appreciate your time. It's always great to
catch up. I love having specialists on the show, meaning market sector specialists,
because it gives us a bit of a look underneath the hood here.
Absolutely.
Tremendously appreciate it, Melody. Thank you so much. Can't wait to do this again in about
six months time to get another temperature check from you there. So thank you so much.
And to everybody else, thank you so much for tuning in to Soar Financially. I hope you found
this conversation of interest and useful, of course, as well, especially if you're buying a
in 2026. If you haven't done so, hit that like and subscribe button. It helps us out tremendously.
And we want to reach our goal of 100,000 subscribers, but it's only possible with
your help. And we tremendously appreciate it. Thank you so much for doing that.
And take care out there. Be safe.