We've done a lot of searching for extraterrestrial life over the years. But how good was it? Did we look hard enough or deep enough? Is it too early for conclusions? Could do a better job? If so, how? Figuring out in this interview.
🟣 Guest: Dr. Ben Zuckerman
📜 Broadband Searches for Extraterrestrial Technological Intelligence: a New Strategy To Find Nearby Alien Civilizations https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.07333
00:00 Intro 01:36 SETI 05:07 How deep did we really look? 24:12 What could we have done differently 36:57 Most satisfying answer to the Fermi Paradox 43:25 Current obsessions 47:35 Final thoughts
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Dr. Ben Zuckerman discusses the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), challenging the idea that we haven't searched enough. He argues that if communicative civilizations existed nearby, we would have detected them. By analyzing the \"phase space\" of local stars and the absence of von Neumann probes, he suggests technological civilizations are extremely rare in the Milky Way.
So here's a topic that I come back to on a regular basis. And that is, are we alone in
the universe? What I love about this question, like it is the most important question humanity
has ever can possibly ask. And yet there is an answer. Yes or no. And both of them in the words
of Arthur C. Clarke are equally terrifying. And now it's a question of of us to try and figure
out which one we live in the universe filled with life or the universe that is devoid of life,
except for us. But it turns out that we have actually done a pretty good job of surveying
the universe within our vicinity. And that that actually can already tell us some slight
information about whether or not we are alone in the universe, or at least how many civilizations
there might be in the Milky Way. My guest today is Dr. Ben Zuckerman. He is an emeritus research
professor at the University of California, Los Angeles. And he has written a recent paper called
broadband searches for extraterrestrial technological intelligence, a new strategy
to find alien civilizations. And in his paper, he has looked at the various searches that humanity
has already done in the optical and the infrared and the radio and actually finds that we have done
a pretty comprehensive job of finding civilizations that want to communicate with us. And the fact
that we haven't found any so far in a fairly large volume of space can tell us something about
how common life itself is in the Milky Way. And so if you want a classic conversation about whether
or not we are alone in the universe, enjoy my interview with Dr. Ben Zuckerman. Ben, it's been
about five years since we talked about your ideas on SETI and space exploration and sort of the
Great Filter and the Fermi Paradox and all of that. And this is always a favorite conversation.
It's funny. I'm obsessed with these ideas now as I was back then, even though I've been, you know,
learning about and interviewing people for five years. So it's great to have you back.
It's nice to be here. Fraser, thanks for inviting me again.
And congratulations. You had coverage over on PBS Space Time. Matt O'Dowd did a fantastic video
covering the ideas in your paper. And so we're going to sort of address them as well. But if
you want a counterpiece to that, definitely go and watch Matt's video. So your paper is titled
Broadband Searches for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, a New Strategy to Find Nearby
Alien Civilizations. But the part that I found really interesting is that you had sort of come
to a conclusion on how many civilizations there are likely around us and maybe a possible reason
why we don't feel like we're seeing anyone out there. Yeah, when I was putting this paper
together, I realized that we've actually done a lot more searching for signals for the
extraterrestrials, the little green men, than we realized we have done. People in the past have
talked about the SETI-specific searches where various astronomers are going out and trying to
detect the extraterrestrials. But it turned out when I looked into the literature and also
developed a model, which I present in my paper, when you put those two things together, it turns
out that there's been a lot of work done that's not SETI-specific and is relevant.
I mean, I think that the classic quote is that, of course, we haven't found aliens. It's like
saying searching the oceans with a tea cup and not seeing any whales.
Jill Tartar likes that. Yeah, Jill Tartar said it.
If you imagine the total amount of water in the Earth's oceans, the amount of phase space that
we've covered in these SETI searches is equivalent to at most a bathtub or something like that.
Right, yes.
It's expanded the size of the bathtub in the last half dozen years or so, or a dozen years,
but it's still tiny compared to the oceans of possible phase space.
Well, a main point, if not the main point of my paper, was if you believe there are technological
civilizations in the solar vicinity who want to communicate with other technological civilizations,
then they will make themselves known in such a way that, at least for the solar neighborhood,
the oceans have shrunk down to something not much bigger than this bathtub, and we can cover the
entire set of phase spaces, if we haven't already covered them, which we haven't,
without all that much trouble in the coming, say, decade or two. We can cover them all.
So it's a fish in a bathtub, not a bathtub scoop of the ocean.
That's a good way to put it, yeah.
Yeah. So then let's talk about this sort of level of observation that we have already done,
because, again, I think if you talk to most people, probably even most SETI astronomers,
and you say, do you feel like you've done a comprehensive job of scanning the sky?
They'll go, no, of course not. We've just barely scratched the surface. We need more telescopes.
We need more time. There's so many frequencies. There's so many different ways they can
communicate. There's active, there's passive. How can we possibly say we've even scratched
the surface of this? Why do you feel confident that, in fact, astronomers have pretty exhaustively
scanned our near vicinity for civilizations that are attempting to communicate with us?
Well, the people, the astronomers who think that we've just covered a tiny portion of
potential phase spaces, and these phase spaces can encompass a variety of things. They include
distance and direction, sensitivity, wavelength, and time, or epoch. It turns out, if you set
up a model such as I did in my paper, then you can pretty much eliminate all, as unknowns,
all of these areas of phase space with the exception of wavelength or frequency. We do not
know at whether the extraterrestrials, if they're interested in transmission, will transmit at radio,
infrared, or optical wavelengths. So that's a big unknown. But in terms of power, for example,
or direction, whatnot, I talk about all these things in the paper. In terms of power, for
example, the standard assumption with the SETI programs is that the reception of the signal would
be basically what I call power starved. The extraterrestrials don't know we're here, is the
assumption, and therefore they're transmitting in all directions, and so the amount of power
received in any one direction is tiny, and so you need to use big antennas with maximally
designed spectrometers in order to detect these weak signals. But the point of my paper basically
is, if there is any nearby technological civilization, and I just use for as a
fiducial calculation, just so I can put some numbers down on a piece of paper,
out to about 200 parsecs or 650 light years, nothing sacred about that, but out to that
distance, you can show, as I think I did, that an extraterrestrial wants to communicate with
other technological extraterrestrials, will be sending incredibly strong signals in all directions,
so this power starvation is just not relevant. And that's unidirectional. If it's directional,
like if they're actually pointing a signal at us, then it should be quite obvious. I think of the
example of the, like when the Arecibo Ray used to fire its radar pulse to observe the surfaces of
asteroids, from what I understand, that pulse is so bright that if you were on the other side of
it, you could be 10,000 light years away and detect, we could detect that because it's directed.
And so if someone was actually, they wouldn't, you know, like humanity could send a targeted
message to Alpha Centauri, and the Alpha Centaurians could not miss it, if we wanted to.
And vice versa.
The thing with the kind of signal you just mentioned, or a military radar or something
like that, that's not pointed in the appropriate directions, which are the directions of the
nearest, say, few hundred thousand old sun-like stars.
No, but if they did.
Yeah, if they did, absolutely. Yeah. In the example you just mentioned, that such a signal
could be detected accidentally, and maybe only once. But in the situation where the extraterrestrials
actually have a program to communicate with other civilizations, their transmitters are going to be
on all the time, pointing at all the nearby interesting stars.
And I go through planets, all the interesting planets that orbit around nearby stars.
And I go through a progression as to how they can narrow down their local old sun-like stars
into a small, interesting group of potential life-bearing planets that will include the Earth.
Right. So they're an advanced enough civilization that they have good telescopes. They've scanned
all of the stars in their vicinity. They've built their versions of the Habitable Worlds
Observatory. They know which ones have terrestrial worlds inside the habitable zone.
They've got this shortlist. And then they have this really powerful
radar dish, kind of like Garcebo, or who knows what it is. And it is sending a coherent,
targeted beam at each one of these worlds in their vicinity. And that includes us, in theory.
Yes, right. And, yeah, right. But you said.
Okay. Right. Yeah. So, and so, I mean, I think one sort of really interesting idea that stuck
with me for for a long time is is that like, obviously, you go back to go to the Tartar
analogy here. You you take the ocean, you put in a bathtub, look at look at it,
set the bathtub aside, dig up another bathtub, dig up another bathtub. After a while,
you will have dug up a whale's worth of water out of the ocean and you can start to make some kind of
Bayesian predictions about whether or not the rest of that ocean is going to contain any whales.
Does that 600, I didn't get whether, was it was it a 600 light year diameter or radius?
The 650 light year radius. Again, it was just.
Right. Okay.
I mean, there's nothing sacred about that, but I did a calculation assuming that radius.
But if but if we detect, you know, which we which we have not so far, or as you say,
just in the in the near future, we will. But but we have not detected any targeted
signals coming from any advanced civilizations in this region.
Does that start to give us a sense of how empty the universe might be?
Oh, yeah, definitely. In the radio band, there have a fair fraction of the radio band,
but not a majority of it has already been searched. Sorry, has already been
surveyed with very sensitive radio telescopes, such as the one at the National Radio Astronomy
Observatory, the whole sky surveys that are looking for signals from extra galactic sources.
But they'll also since they're doing the whole sky, they'll also cover all the old nearby
stars, solar like stars. So and part of the radio band, the measurements that need to be
made have already been made. And part of the radio band, nothing has been done, basically.
Very little, if anything, has been done in infrared wavelengths and optical wavelengths,
because optical astronomers have been studying the sky going back 100 years.
I'd say if somebody did a careful study of all the various studies and surveys optically,
they'd come to the conclusion that the extraterrestrials are not sending signals
optically towards the Earth. So but in order to make a really definitive statement, you have to
cover the infrared band and the part of the radio band that has not yet been covered. But once you
do that, say you do all that, you cover all the reasonable wavelengths, and you don't receive,
no signal has been received, because again, we can go back and look at records optically,
at least to go back 100 years. If no signal has been received or is received in future surveys in
these various wave bands, then out to some distance, you can say that there is no purposely
communicative technological civilization. And you can actually start to put numbers then on
the number or upper limits on the number that might exist in the galaxy. So I do that in this
paper. I say that if when we are convinced that nobody is sending us a signal in any of these
wave bands, out to six, in this case, 650 light years, nothing sacred about that,
then you can say that the likelihood is there are less than 100,000 technological civilizations
in the galaxy by just taking the ratio of the volume you've studied and comparing it to the
entire volume of the disk of our Milky Way galaxy. This is sort of a little bit like Jill's bathtub
analogy. So in this case, the bathtub is the size of our local sphere going out to about 650 light
years, and the oceans are the total volume of the disk of our Milky Way galaxy. So you can do that,
and you come up with an upper limit, I estimate, for the various assumptions I made of about 100,000
technological civilizations. Now that doesn't sound necessarily like a very high upper limit,
but back in the days of Carl Sagan and Frank Drake, people, especially Drake,
were tossing around numbers like millions of technological civilizations. So even 100,000
put some limits on how many might be out there through the whole galaxy.
And then there's one section in the paper where I talk not about radio transmissions, but about
the extraterrestrials actually sending probes or themselves during the past few billion years.
And if you go through the arguments I went through in that section, I think you can actually put a
somewhat lower limit on this, what I call... And that's the Hart-Tipler conjecture, right?
That sending robots is the easiest way to reach every part, to communicate with every part of the
galaxy. You send self-replicating robots, the von Neumann probes, they go from world to world,
they make copies of themselves, they go to other worlds. That if there were 100,000 civilizations
in the Milky Way, that each one of them decided it was a good idea to send out self-replicating
robot probes to explore and meet other civilizations, 10 million years later,
there would be 100,000 self-replicating robot factories here in the solar system,
and so far we have found zero. Yeah, well, Tipler and before him Hart's
estimates are a little different than what I did, because they were interested in explaining
Fermi's paradox, why is the universe so quiet, why haven't we heard anything?
My goal is a little more limited, is I'm not talking about colonizing the galaxy or anything
like that. All I was referring to is, all I refer to is if there is a technological civilization
that passed within a hundred, a different distance, within a hundred light years of Earth,
because if they have to come here, they can't come here at the speed of light. So I
assumed one percent of the speed of light, so that cuts down the volume that you have to think
about. So instead of 650 light years, I assumed a radius of 100 light years, and so I basically asked
if any technological civilization had passed in the last few billion years within 100 light years
of Earth, they would have recognized that the Earth was a living world, had life here because
of our oxygenic atmosphere, which has been around for billions of years now, and would have been
motivated, even if they didn't know or think there was a technological civilization here,
to send these kind of probes, von Neumann probes, whatever you want to call them, send probes to
investigate our Earth. It's like, Fraser, it's like when we studied, our species studied the
nearby, our own solar system, starting with the time of Galileo and the invention of the optical
telescope. We did whatever we could from the surface of the Earth with our telescope, but once
we had the technological capability to send out rocket ships like Voyager and Viking and stuff
like that to the other worlds in our solar system, we did that. And I expect that the same thing is
going to happen with the extraterrestrials, that once they discover, and they could
have discovered this billions of years ago, the Earth is a living world, they will be curious
enough to send their probes to Earth, to our solar system. They'll put them in orbit around
the Earth because that's the only really interesting planet in the solar system.
Yeah, they could do that. Arthur C. Clarke, I think, had it right.
Yeah, you could do that. So that's the kind of picture I investigate or consider. I'm not really
trying to be really speculative and start going through all the arguments that Tipler or Hart
went through in their papers 50 years ago by now. Yeah, I find that paper really compelling.
I mean, the original Hart paper, where he just runs through this thought experiment that if
you just send self-replicating robot probes, then there should be monoliths on the Moon.
If by your math, it's 100,000 civilizations currently operating at any one time,
and then you think about the history of the galaxy, how many of those civilizations could
have risen and fallen over various periods of time? It feels like there's been a lot of
opportunities for someone to go, huh, I wonder if we can just send a self-replicating probe,
gather data on the entire galaxy, send back where all the habitable worlds are today,
and then let's point the big beam at just those worlds, the best candidates, and then just send
the signal, send them the instructions for the contact wormhole device so that we can join them
at the galactic nexus. And so you say that it actually makes the constraints even less
favorable. I think I estimated an upper limit of about 10,000 using these arguments with the
probes and with the extraterrestrials themselves coming here. I mean, the easiest thing is send
a probe, but it's also probably possible to send, the creatures could actually come themselves if
they wanted to, just be more difficult probably. Yeah, I mean, if you set that constraint at 1%
the speed of light. Well, I'm just guessing at how fast an advanced civilization could design
a rocket spaceship to go. We don't really know. Some people have assumed much faster velocities.
I thought 1% of speed of light was moderately conservative. I mean, it's faster than anything
we can do today. On the other hand, as you may remember from our discussion five years ago,
Brad Hansen and I wrote a paper then in pointing out that if you wait long enough, if you are
patient, say wait hundreds of millions of years or a billion years, then another star is going to come
close enough to our, another star, presumably with its own planetary system, will come close
enough to our planetary system so that you can make a jump from our planetary system to this
other planetary system at speeds far slower than 1% of the speed of light in a reasonable length
and reasonable amount of time. I loved that paper because if I remember correctly, you know,
we know that we have like, say, there's a glyza that is coming within half a light year of us
within the next 100,000 years and that these come even closer. If you just wait, you know,
wait a million years and one's going to come within. Well, we went through just how long you
have to wait to have them come just so close. And again, to have them come close so it really
becomes relatively easy to make these jumps. I think we're talking about hundreds of millions
of years, maybe a billion years. But still, on shorter timescales, there's definitely
when stars have come closer to make things easier than they are now. Right now,
the separation of the stars and the solar vicinity is about one parsec or three light years or so.
And that's still, that's a long way to go. But if you cut it down by a factor of 100,
which will happen someday in the future and has happened in the past, it's not so far anymore
and that you can average that out if you wait on each world for the ideal. And maybe this was your
paper. There's another paper that I think this was David Kipping worked on this one, but that if you
wait and just wait for this, these minimum jumps that it all averages out, it only adds a few
million years to to exploring the entire galaxy that did because you get the averages like it
might not be good for you today, but it's going to be good for that star over there today. And it
might be good for that star over there today. And that then if you sort of run those numbers,
then it actually only adds a little bit to the time it takes for you to fully explore the entire
galaxy. I'd like to go back then and talk about, you know, you said that we have sort of
haphazardly through existing optical radio and infrared surveys, actually done a pretty
comprehensive job of observing the universe in the kinds of ways that an advanced civilization
might want to communicate with us. But if you were to go back and go, let's do this right,
let's imagine that we instead wanted to do a comprehensive survey. What would that look like
compared to what was accidentally cobbled together by astronomers as they were doing other very
important jobs? Well, we would target in our searches, the nearest few hundred thousand,
again, how many stars you want to target depends on how far out you want to go from the Earth,
what the radius of your search sphere is going to be. But if you want to target the few hundred
thousand nearest old solar-like stars. So the surveys have been done already,
have not done, neither in the optical nor the radio have done this. They've been surveys for
other purposes, where they've been including all sky surveys, where you're interested in
extragalactic objects, galaxies and quasars and whatnot. So the targeted search of nearby
old sun-like stars I don't think has ever been done at any wavelength, radio or optical,
and certainly not in the infrared. There have been surveys by the SETI people in the radio,
for example, where some of them talk about much larger numbers than a few hundred thousand,
up to a million or more. But most of the stars they're talking about that they've looked at in
their surveys are way further away than the 650 light years I'm talking about. They're thousands,
if not 10,000 light years away. And it's nice to look at such distant stars,
but they're not going to have any idea that we're here. So they're definitely not going
to be sending beam directional transmissions in our direction. And that's why power starvation
is relevant. They're just going to be transmitting isotropically or something in all directions.
So the fact you've covered a lot of stars doesn't necessarily mean they're the right kind of stars.
You have to look at the nearest old sun-like stars. But I just gave you the budget for
the telescopes of your choosing, directed with as much budget as you require, with as much staff,
as many telescopes, pointing in as many directions, across as many wavelengths as you would like.
What does this space-based or worldwide network of infrared visible and radio telescopes look like?
Well, in the radio band and optically too, you don't have to go into space.
And everything that you need, I think, pretty much already exists. You just need to take time on a
moderately big telescope. You don't even need the biggest telescopes, just a moderately large
telescope. And again, survey the right targets. In the infrared, it's trickier, Fraser, because
a large fraction of the infrared band is blocked by the Earth's atmosphere. So to do a proper job
in the infrared, you really want to do it from space. There are some wavelength ranges that you
can survey from the ground in the infrared. But even there, the atmosphere is sort of
getting in the way to a certain degree. So you want to go above the atmosphere for the infrared.
Right. But let's imagine, say, for the visible light. And what are you looking for? I mean,
are you looking for a very specific wavelength? Or are you looking for something to change?
Because Vera Rubin would find things that are going to change in your night sky. And one of
those could be a laser pointed towards us. And that could be they're flashing the light on and
off to let us know that they're there. And we're watching a star that's blinking in brightness.
And then maybe they're blinking it slowly enough that they can also be transmitting
some kind of message as a secondary carrier or something like that. I don't know. Right.
So I'm just wondering, are you looking for a variation? Are you looking for a wavelength?
What are you looking for? That's a good question, Tony. Optical,
because we don't know quite how the extraterrestrials are going to be transmitting
optically. My guess is that they'll probably transmit at some weird optical wavelength
for which there are no known major sources of natural light, of molecules or atoms or ions or
whatever. However, this could be pretty much anywhere in the optical spectrum. So that's why
I emphasize in my paper, you've got to cover the entire optical, infrared and radio band,
because you don't know which wavelength they're actually going to transmit at. But I think
they're going to pick some unusual, they would pick some unusual wavelength and they might
modulate it the way you're describing sort of with pulses or on off or something like that,
just to attract attention. In the radio band, it's much easier, I think. And I actually just
basically about the radio searches and I leave the optical to somebody else doing a second paper.
But in the radio band, it's actually relatively easy, I think, because no known old solar-like
star other than the Sun itself has ever been detected as a radio source. So if you point
your radio telescope at some old Sun-like star that's, say, a hundred light years from the Earth
and you get a signal from that star, you may not know right off the top that it's coming from the
extraterrestrials, but you're not going to ignore it because you know you've made an interesting
discovery. You were the first person to ever discover a radio signal from an old Sun-like
star. So you're going to pay attention, even if it's not an extraterrestrial signal.
I had no idea. I thought that there was some level of radio transmission coming from stars.
Well, there is, but it's undetectable from Earth.
Right, at that distance. Okay, okay. Oh, that's really interesting.
See, one of the things that the SETI people, the ones who are doing the actual SETI programs,
argue is one advantage of their searches is they're searching for very narrow signals.
They're assuming the extraterrestrials are going to transmit only over a very narrow
range of wavelengths, a few cycles per second, a few hertz. The reason they're assuming that is
because if your power is starved and you want to achieve the best signal and noise at the receiving
end, i.e. us, and you're the transmitter, you want to jam all your energy into the narrowest possible
band of wavelengths. That maximizes the signal noise at the receiving end.
So that's why they use such narrow filters in their searches.
And so they say, well, an advantage of what we're doing is that since nature can't produce
on its own a signal that's only a few cycles per second wide, once we detect such a signal,
we know it's an extraterrestrial. Well, that's great. And you give that up if using broadband
receivers, so that instead of having one or a few cycles per second as your filter width,
it's, say, a megahertz, a million cycles per second. If you detect a signal, you're not going
to know it's from an extraterrestrial, but if it's from an old solar-like star, you will know
you found something interesting. And then you'll go and investigate the signal further and you'll
discover it is from the extraterrestrials. And that if you set optical astronomers at this task,
or infrared astronomers, they will come up with a similar smoking gun for all the different
wavelengths. Well, they will, except again, in the case of the optical and the infrared,
the old solar-like stars are optical and infrared sources. So that in itself,
we detect these stars all the time in the solar vicinity, optically in the infrared.
So you have to have some other sign, other flag that's saying, hey, there's something
interesting going on here. And that's why I mentioned transmit at a weird wavelength
that you don't expect anything, any molecule or atom or ion or whatever to be sending a signal at.
And that should do the trick, but you have to be paying attention to your, if you're covering a
range of wavelengths, you have to be paying attention to wavelengths that you weren't
necessarily interested in when you started your program. See, the thing with the existing optical
surveys is they were not searching, except for a few people like Jeff Morrissey, for example,
they specifically doing optical SETI, but 99.9% of optical astronomers are not doing SETI searches.
They're looking for something else. And so they have to be alert enough to see if that there's
something in their spectrometer, in the wave band they're covering that they didn't expect to be
there and is unusual, and they would go follow it up. And that's the paper that needs to be written,
that I'm too old now at 83. But if someone's listening. But hopefully there's a postdoc
or a graduate student. To me, it's just an obvious paper to write that you just go back and look at
a hundred years. And now with AI, it should be much easier to do this too, to a large degree.
You go back and look at a hundred years of optical data have been accumulated.
So you don't even have to go out and do new measurements, Fraser. That already makes it
harder. If you just go back and survey the optical literature for the last hundred years or so,
and just see how many of these studies were designed so they might have detected
a strong signal from an extraterrestrial civilization. And then the question is,
would the astronomer who's doing that survey actually notice that there's something unusual
in his or her bandpass? And one of the things I say in my paper, one of the unique things about
doing an optical paper on all this stuff, going back a hundred years, is many of the people who
have carried out some of the major optical surveys are still alive. You could go and interview them
and actually find out, would you have seen the signal of such and such nature if it had been
in your spectrometer band? I mean, it seems like to me, it'd be a lot of fun to do something like
that. Well, the example that I always think of is like green stars. People always ask me like,
why are there no green stars? And it's, you know, that even though the sun is emitting sort of the
most of its photons in the green, it's blackbody radiation, and as you sort of average it out,
it looks white. But if you actually saw a star that was white, and then it turned green,
and then it turned white, and then it turned green, you would go, something there,
something's weird about that star, that it's that it's going green. It is the only star in the sky
that is green. That would be peculiar. So there you go. There's there's one idea.
I'd like to so so before we shift gears, you think I mean, you think a lot about the search for for
extraterrestrials. What is the answer to the Fermi paradox that you find the most satisfying?
I've always believed that the answer is that we are unique, or almost unique, in our Milky Way
galaxy. That capital N, the number of currently existing technological civilizations in in our
galaxy, is either one, us, or maybe a handful at most, and the nearest one is so far away there's
little chance for detection of it, or them detecting us. Also, particularly since we're
such a baby civilization, nobody would know there was technology here if they weren't within,
you know, 50 light years or so. So at any rate, that to me is the simplest way to explain the
so-called paradox, and there's no paradox anymore. Then all one has to do is explain
why are technological civilizations so rare? And actually, in this paper I wrote,
I go through some arguments as to why planets, Earth-sized and temperatured planets,
will be few, and also planets that have comparable amounts of liquid water, surface water, and land.
When you put all these things together, it seems to me that even life is not going to be
very common, and then to make the extra step to technology is even harder. I mentioned the origin
of life, for example. I think the origin of life is probably very difficult, and one observation
that's consistent with that is the fact that life is chiral, that we have our two hands,
and they're mirror images of one another, and you can divide a whole biology, biochemistry,
based on one chirality and based on the other one, and we only have one of these chiralities
in Earth life, and the easiest way to explain this absence of the other chirality, it's not
necessarily the only way, but it's certainly the easiest way, is to assume that life originated
only once in the entire history of life on Earth. It happened to be our chirality. It could have
just as well been the other, but it was ours, and so if that's the case, in the billions of years
that have been life on Earth, it managed to arise only once. That means just the origin of life is
very difficult, and then you have to have life survive all the catastrophes that could go on
through billions of years to a planet that's orbiting around some star. Anyway, when you go
through all this, it seems to me that the easiest way to explain the so-called Pyramid Paradox is
capital N is a very small number. Yeah, I personally go one step beyond you, and I say
one in the observable universe. Well, Mike Hart actually argued that in one of his papers,
but even for me, that's a disgrace. I know, I know. People would just say, that's crazy,
but Hart makes the case. I read Hart's paper, and I was like, I'm convinced, right? Done,
nailed it. Obviously, you're familiar with Robin Hanson's Great Filter argument,
but then this sort of other idea of grabby aliens, that an advanced technological civilization,
perhaps even kind of post-biological, they've gone Borg, they've gone full Borg, and they are
in the process of creating an empire at close to the speed of light, that that is a thing that
would be visible for hundreds, millions, potentially even billions of light years away,
that we would see this event happening. As long as they weren't actually going the speed of light,
we would see this occurring. And so the volume of space that we can perceive is gigantic. It's
just that the events that need to be happening in those distant places have to be scaled up.
So we would see the air traffic control system on Alpha Centauri, we would see a directed beam
pointing towards us from a thousand light years away, and we would see
stars being turned into Dyson spheres across an entire galaxy group 10 million light years away.
And we see none of these. At any scale, it is always silence. It is always wilderness
from our perspective. And so personally, I find that very compelling. Now, I mostly have to keep
my mouth shut when I talk to people, but it's just us here, so we can talk about it.
There are papers that have been published, people searching in other galaxies for
Kardashev type 3 civilizations, where the effects that you just alluded to are so,
and really advanced technological civilization can have such large effects on their surroundings,
that their constructs or whatever they're doing could be visible even through across
extragalactic distances. So again, there have been papers written and published
searching for these Kardashev type 3 civilizations, but needless to say, without success.
Yeah, yeah. Well, and that's the thing. And so, obviously a null result doesn't tell us
the true answer, but still, it makes you think. That's why I just find it so much fun to think
about it, just because you're like, on the one hand, but on the other hand, but on the one hand,
but on the other hand, you sort of chase yourself in tail, you know, in a circle,
you chase your own tail. And, and although that is not actually a paradox, it does definitely
feel like a thing that you're, you sort of chase a line of arguments, you end up at your starting
point again. So Ben, the question I always ask my guests, what are you obsessed with right now?
Maybe just staying alive. I just had my 83rd birthday yesterday.
Congratulations.
Thanks. And, well, I've always been interested in, in life in the universe and technological
life in the universe. As I mentioned, probably when we spoke five years ago, when I was in grad
school at Harvard, Carl Sagan's office was just down the hall from mine. He was an assistant
professor and I was a graduate student. And at the end of the, some days or in the weekends,
I used to wander down his office and we used to schmooze about life in the universe, technological
life in the universe. So I've been fascinated by this kind of stuff going back even before
when I was in graduate school, but that just helped, having Carl around just helped to
amplify my interest. At any rate it's, it's been my main, everything I've done in astronomy in
my regular career, not worrying about SETI per se, has had some connection to life in the universe.
All the various research areas I've worked in have some connection to life in the universe. So that,
that's my, my thing. And it'll always be my thing until I die. I think life is just so incredibly
interesting. The fact that what's so sad is there are all these amazing creatures on earth that
have evolved with all their capabilities. They don't, they don't have the big brains we have,
but they have so many abilities just to take one, the dog's nose, which is so much more
sensitive than ours, but, but eyesight and hearing and detection of magnetic fields,
all kinds of things. And we're just wiping these creatures out. And it's just so sad after it's
taken so many billions of years to evolve. And, and I don't know, we're going to, we're already
in a bio, biologically impoverished world compared to what there, there was before our
species arrived. And it's just going to be a lot worse before things finally turn around and start
getting, getting bad. So anyway, that's my, my major interest and it'll be my major interest till
I die. I mean, you know, the three main areas in astronomy, I think that are of interest to
the public are cosmology, black holes, and life in the universe. And I just think life in the
universe for me, at least is the most interesting of these three to know the reason it's so
complicated. Life is just, you think about how complex our bodies are. It's just unbelievable
that, that, that evolution could produce something like, like us or like all these other creatures
that share the earth with us now. Yeah. I mean, I feel like it is the most important
question that humanity has ever asked. And, and the answer is, is binary, right? Like either we're
alone in the universe or we're not. And in the words of Arthur C. Clarke, each result would be
equally terrifying. But, but it, but it is an answer. And, and, and, and when people sort of,
I don't know, they, they express frustration at the search, or they don't feel why we would bother.
And I say, well, if I just gave you an envelope, and, and I knew the, I knew the answer to this
question, I'd, you know, I wrote the answer to the question, but, you know, we are alone,
or we're not alone. And how many civilizations are out there and blah, blah, blah. And I closed up
the envelope, and I just gave it to you. Would you have any curiosity to open up that envelope to see
the answer? And if the answer is yes, then you care about this as much as we do. Right? You're
curious to know the answer. And now we can argue about how difficult it is to get to the answer
to that question. But it is worth doing the... Ben, thank you so much for your time.
Thank you, Fraser, for having me again. Maybe in, if I'm still alive another five years,
maybe there'll be another paper we can talk about.
That sounds great. I'm sure you will be. I hope you enjoyed this conversation with Dr. Ben
Zuckerman. As always, we extended the conversation, took it into other areas. And this was
really interesting and kind of opened my eyes. And that is sort of his other work is examining
the metal pollution in white dwarf stars. Essentially, you can learn about planetary
systems because they smashed into the white dwarf at the center. That might actually give
us a better understanding of what is inside planets like the Earth than what we can derive
just from being on the surface of the planet. If you just take the Earth and you splat it against
the surface of a white dwarf star, you can find out quite a bit. And we actually have observed
many white dwarf stars and the pollution in their atmospheres. And we're starting to learn
about what's inside planets like the Earth. So if you want that longer version of the
conversation, it's available over on Patreon completely for free. Don't subscribe. Don't
pay anything. You can watch that right now. I'll put a link down in the show notes.
I'm going to give you some final thoughts. But first, I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, Brian Bode, Caridin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Balock,
Dark Figured, David Gilton, David Matz, Enthralder Reading and Math for Toddlers, Evan.pro,
James Clark, Jerry Mattern, Jim Burke, Marcel Smith, Mike Purcell, NASA Ocean Guide,
Nordspace, oncejeffanimals.org. Please follow my nephew at vbrick6994, Rain Kaidu, Richard
Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Feilman, Team49, Telescope Canada, Vlad Sheplin, Wolfgang Klotz,
and Zelda Galactic Defender who support us at the Master of the Universe level.
And all our patrons, all your support means the Universe to us.
So at the very beginning of this episode, I referenced the video that Matt O'Dowd from the
PBS Space Time channel had done on Ben's paper. I'm going to put a link down in the show notes.
You can go and watch that video next. And it's great. I mean, like you heard the words coming
out of Ben's mouth, but it is great to see Matt cover it. He's a scientist. He's able to sort of
break it down and present it in a way that is very understandable. And so if you want, you know,
there's some pieces of it that you feel were missing. You should definitely go and watch
Matt's video. And then another channel that I want to link to you that is very similar as well
is Dr. David Kipping. That's the Cool Worlds Lab. And again, like there's no way you don't know
about Dr. David Kipping, but if you don't, he has covered a lot of very similar topics, including
ideas like how common should life be if life formed very early on in the Universe and other
ideas about the Fermi Paradox, in addition to his work searching for exomoon. So I'm going to put
links to both of those channels and videos down in the show notes down below. So you've got a lot
of places to go after watching this. All right. We'll see you next time.