Milwaukee sells a drill kit for $329. The two batteries and charger inside it cost $397 bought separately — more than the kit that comes with the drill.
In cordless tools the battery is the product and the tool is the bait. The badge on the front tells you which price tier a licensing department put you in, not how hard the thing pulls. This video runs five platforms most people walk straight past — Ryobi, RIDGID, Hercules, Bauer and Craftsman V20 — through the same four tests I run on every product on this channel.
No brand deals. Nobody sends me tools. Every number comes off a manufacturer product page, a warranty document or a printed manual, and all of it is linked in the pinned comment.
The video argues that in the cordless tool market, the battery platform is the primary product, while tools act as \"bait.\" It advises consumers to prioritize the cost and longevity of the battery ecosystem over brand names, providing a framework to evaluate tools based on nominal voltage, real costs, and warranty terms to avoid marketing traps.
Milwaukee sells a drill kit for $329. The batteries and charger inside it,
bought separately, cost $397. Same store, same day, same two batteries, same charger.
The only difference is that the cheaper one comes with a drill in the box. You pay $68 more to not
get the tool. That is not a typo and it is not a sale gone sideways. It is what happens when the
battery is the product and the tool is the bait. If you work on your own car, you have stood in
that aisle and done the math backwards. You pick a brand and then you find out the brand is really
a battery platform and the platform is where all the money is. So today we pick the platform first.
Five cordless platforms that most people walk straight past in the tool aisle and that are
quietly the best money you can spend on garage work. I am not here to tell you cheap tools are
secretly as good as expensive ones. Some of them are not and I will say so. What I am going to show
you is where the price of a cordless tool actually comes from because it is almost never the part you
are holding. Here is what you get in the next 10 minutes. Five brands, what each one really costs
to live with, who actually builds it, and the exact catch on every single one. Because all five have a
catch and I will give you the catch before I give you the reason it is still worth buying.
No brand deals. Nobody sends me tools. Every number in this video comes off a manufacturer
product page, a warranty document, or a printed manual and all of it is linked in the pinned
comment so you can check me instead of trusting me. Before the brands, the four tests. Same four
tests I run on every product on this channel. Once you have them, you do not need me, you can walk
into any store and sort that aisle yourself in about 90 seconds. Every video on this channel runs
these same four tests. No brand deals. No sponsorships. If that is useful to you, subscribe.
The four tests, test one. Read the spec, not the label. DeWalt calls its platform 20 volt max.
Craftsman calls its platform V20. Milwaukee calls its platform M18. Ryobi calls its platform
18 volt 1 plus. Two of those brands are honest in the name. The other two are honest in the footnote.
Here is DeWalt's footnote printed on DeWalt's own product pages. Quote, maximum initial battery
voltage measured without a workload is 20 volts. Nominal voltage is 18. Craftsman prints that same
sentence on the V20 pages. Word for word. Stanley Black and Decker owns both brands and runs the
same disclaimer on both of them. Nominal voltage is the number that describes the battery while it
is actually doing work. Every one of those four platforms is an 18 volt battery. Two of them are
named after a number you see for about one second after you pull the pack off the charger. So test
one, find the footnote. The label is marketing, the footnote is the specification, and the company wrote
it themselves because they had to. Test two, price. It per use, not per purchase. With cordless tools,
the per use number is the battery because the battery is the part you buy again. At Harbor
Freight right now, a Bauer 20 volt 2 amp hour battery is $37.99. A Bauer brushless half-inch
drill, tool only, is $39.99. The battery and the drill are within two dollars of each other. Now go
back to the number from the top of this video. $329 for the Milwaukee kit, $397 for two of the
same batteries and a charger with no tool at all. The tool is not what you are buying. The platform
is what you are buying and you are going to buy into it more than once. So test two, before you
compare drills, price two batteries and a charger on each platform and compare those instead. That
is the real cost of walking through that door. Test three, check whether the claim has a standard
behind it. Cordless tools are covered by a standard called UL 62841. Read the title out loud,
electric motor operated handheld tools safety. It governs whether the tool hurts you. It says
nothing about how hard it pulls. There was an attempt to fix that. In 2008, the Power Tool
Institute published a common procedure for measuring drill torque and the member companies
voted unanimously to adopt it. A year later, a trade publication counted how many actually had.
Out of 13, Hilti and Makita. That procedure is not on the Power Tool Institute's published
guidelines page today. DeWalt does not publish torque at all. It publishes its own number called
UWO, unit watts out. Their own support article says, and I am quoting it, we don't disclose
torque. They also do not disclose how UWO is measured. So test three, when a tool advertises
a performance number, ask who measured it. On cordless torque, the honest answer is the company
selling it using a method it will not show you. Test four, the time test warranty length is the
cheapest honest signal a manufacturer gives you because it is the only claim on the box that
costs them real money if it turns out to be wrong. Harbor Freight sells two of its own brands in the
same aisle. Bower's warranty is 90 days. Hercules is a five-year tool warranty with three years on
the battery. Same store, same voltage, same shelf. And one of them is backed 20 times longer than the
other. Milwaukee is five years on the tool and three years on the battery, not five on both.
People repeat that wrong constantly, and it matters because the battery is the part that
dies. So test four, find the warranty page before you find the reviews. Reviews tell you how a tool
felt in week one. The warranty tells you what the company thinks happens in year three.
The five brands. Five platforms. Cheapest catch first. Every one of these has something wrong
with it, and you are going to hear it before you hear anything good. One. Ryobi. 18 volts.
OnePlus Ryobi launched the OnePlus platform in 1996. Their own support page still claims that
the newest batteries fit the original Ryobi tools from 1996, and they list over 200 tools on the
system. 30 years on one battery mount. Nothing else in the aisle is close to that. Who actually makes
it is the part people get wrong. Ryobi power tools are built and sold by Tektronik Industries
under license. The Japanese company whose name is on the tool, Ryobi Limited, said in its own
announcement that Tektronik has, quote, no capital relationship with Ryobi Limited. Two separate
companies, one name. The catch. That 30-year promise is about the battery fitting, not about
the tool performing. A 1996 drill with a brand new packet in it is still a 1996 drill. Why it is still
a goldmine for car work? The catalog is enormous. The batteries are everywhere used, and for the
jobs that actually fill a home garage, trim panels, interior screws, a drill you leave in a toolbox
for a year, you are buying into the widest, cheapest platform that exists. Two. Rigid Home Depot's
platform, and the one with the strangest deal attached to it. Open a Rigid cordless manual,
and it says the brand is a registered trademark of Rigid Incorporated, used under license, and it
names the manufacturer as One World Technologies in Pickens, South Carolina. That is the same
operation that builds Ryobi. Two badges, two price tiers, one building. Now the deal. Rigid's lifetime
service agreement covers worn parts in a properly maintained tool, and their own page says it covers
quote, even cordless batteries. The catch. And it is a real one. You have to register within 90 days
of purchase with proof of purchase, and Rigid's own registration FAQ excludes accessory batteries
and chargers bought separately. Only the batteries that came inside the kit you registered are covered.
Miss the 90 days and you have a three-year warranty like everyone else. Why it is a goldmine.
Batteries are the single biggest recurring cost in cordless. If you register the day you buy it,
that cost goes to zero for as long as you own the tool. Nobody else in the aisle offers that.
Three. Hercules Harbor Freight's upper tier, and the one most people skip because of the
building it is sold in. A Hercules brushless half-inch drill tool only is $69.99. Batteries
run from about $30 for a compact 2 amp hour up to $135 for a 12 amp hour pack. The number that
matters is the warranty. Five years on the tool, three years on the battery. That is the same tool
warranty Milwaukee offers at a fraction of the entry price. The catch. It is a store-exclusive
platform. If Harbor Freight ever walks away from it, your batteries are orphaned. There is no third
party keeping that mount alive, and there is no independent torque data on it. Although as we
covered in test three, there is no independent torque data on anything. Why it is a goldmine.
A five-year tool warranty at that price is the single biggest outlier in the aisle,
and it is sitting in the store everybody assumes is the cheap one. Four. Bauer. Same store,
one shelf down, and I am going to be blunt about this one. A Bauer brushless half-inch
drill tool only is $39.99. A two amp hour battery is $37.99. That is the lowest cost of entry to a
brushless platform anywhere in the country. The catch is the worst number in this entire video.
90 days. That is the whole warranty. 90 days on the tool and 90 days on the battery. So here is
the decision stated plainly. Because both of these are on the same wall in the same shop.
Bauer brushless drill, $40, 90-day warranty. Hercules brushless drill, $70, five-year
warranty. $30 is the price of the difference between three months of backing and five years
of it. Why Bauer is still on this list. There is one honest use case, and it is a good one.
You have a single job, a suspension refresh, a break weekend, one interior teardown,
and you need a tool for it now. Going in knowing the warranty is 90 days is completely different
from finding out afterwards. That is the only rule. Buy it with your eyes open.
5. Craftsman 5, 20. And this one is on the list purely because of a footnote.
Go to the Craftsman 580 pages and read the small print. It says 20 volt max battery,
maximum initial battery voltage measured without a workload is 20 volts. Nominal voltage is 18.
That is DeWalt's sentence on a Craftsman page. Stanley Black and Decker owns both brands,
and it is telling you in its own legal disclaimer that both platforms describe the same
nominal voltage. One of them is the yellow one and costs more. The catch, and this one trips
people up constantly, the packs are not interchangeable. Same nominal voltage,
different mount, no crossfit. Same company, two walls, and they are not going to build you a
bridge between them. Why it is a goldmine. If you do not already own a platform and you want a
mainstream brand with a parts network behind it, V20 is the cheaper badge on the disclaimer that
the expensive badge also carries. The pattern. Look at what those five actually had in common.
Two of them are built by the same company in the same place and sold at different prices.
Two more are house brands in the same store with warranties that differ by a factor of 20.
And the fifth is on the list because its own parent company prints the same disclaimer on
the cheap brand and the expensive one. Not one of those facts is about how the tool performs.
All of them are about how the tool is sold. That is the whole thing. In cordless tools,
the badge is not telling you about the motor. It is telling you which price tier a licensing
department put you in. Where the money is actually worth it. Now the other side,
because I am not going to pretend the expensive platforms are a con. Milwaukee's five-year tool
warranty is real and they honor it. There is a service network, there are parts, and there is
a shop that will take the tool over a counter. If the tool is how you earn money, downtime costs
more than the tool does and that is exactly what you are paying for. Every one of those premium
platforms is also genuinely deeper. More tools on the mount, better cold weather behavior,
better dust and water sealing on the professional lines. None of that is fake. It is just not what
most people in a home garage are actually buying and it is definitely not what the voltage number
on the front is telling them. If you have exactly one job to do and no platform yet, Bauer. $40,
90-day warranty, and you knew that going in. If you do your own maintenance a few weekends a year,
Ryobi. Biggest catalog, cheapest batteries, 30 years of one mount. If you want to buy once and
stop thinking about it, RIDGID, and register it the same day you bring it home with the receipt,
inside 90 days. That is not optional. That is the entire reason it is on this list.
If you want a five-year tool warranty without a professional price, Hercules. And if you already
own DeWalt, stay on DeWalt. Craftsman is not your shortcut because the packs do not cross.
The cheapest platform is almost always the one already sitting on your shelf.
Four tests. Read the footnote, not the label. Price the batteries, not the tool. Ask who measured
the performance number. Read the warranty before the reviews. That is not a tool opinion. That is
a way of reading a shelf and it works the same in the tool aisle, the parts aisle, and the detailing
aisle. Nobody pays me to say any of this and nobody is going to. So tell me in the comments,
which platform are you actually on and did you choose it or did you just end up there because
of one tool you bought years ago? Because that second one is how most of us got here
and it is the most expensive way to pick.