A physics professor ran the energy budget on the Nimitz tic-tac. The maneuver needs about a thousand gigawatts, more than ten times every nuclear plant in the United States combined. Nothing we build survives its own waste heat at that scale. So what was flying?
Kevin Knuth is a professor of physics at the University at Albany and a former NASA scientist who now applies Bayesian statistics to UAP sensor data.
We cover: why a 5,400 g maneuver would turn a pilot into soup, where the energy went when the object stopped and no explosion followed, the 1954 radar measurements nobody wants to talk about, the New Zealand frigate that went dark and adrift in three seconds, and why the records from that deployment stay classified until 2062.
Knuth says the power numbers alone rule out human technology. I push back on whether the sensors agree.
Newsletter, full transcript, and my Monday M.A.G.I.C. Message: briankeating.com/aliens
CHAPTERS 00:00 Why this field needs gatekeepers 03:50 How anomalous is anomalous? 06:40 The UFO photo that was a seagull 10:40 Radar clocked them at 19 km/s in 1954 15:00 5,400 g and a body weighing 227 tonnes 19:00 The radar return problem he had not considered 21:45 A gigawatt of waste heat and nowhere to put it 24:30 The 747 chased by something carrier sized 29:00 Why a number without an error bar is worthless 34:30 The NASA job he was not qualified for 37:00 Proxima Centauri in a day and a half 41:00 The warship that lost all power in 3 seconds 46:30 Pushing a column of water that cannot compress 48:45 The light that burned bark off the trees 53:00 What the power numbers rule out 56:00 The 95 percent problem
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
A physicist applies academic rigor to analyze Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP), focusing on the energy and power requirements of reported maneuvers. By calculating extreme accelerations and power outputs that far exceed human technological capabilities, the speaker argues that these phenomena suggest non-human technology or physics beyond current human understanding.
This is a two-part episode. We're discussing today a fascinating lecture that summarizes a lot of the
current cutting-edge research and investigations that you've done as a physicist. And the reason
that I'm having you on for this in a podcast as well is because I think you're doing really
important and heroic work in terms of bringing scientific rigor to this problem. And one of the
problems that I see most in afflicting the UAP phenomenon is that there are very few actual real
scientists, professors. Yes, I'm sorry to be a gatekeeper, but sometimes we need gatekeeping.
You and I met through a chat thread with about 300 other people, some accusing others of different
nefarious things. And everyone's saying that they have their own truth. Well, no, there's only one
scientific truth. It's our job to investigate it, interrogate nature. And you do that through the
lens of a practicing professional scientist. And you're also a professor. And these things matter.
Yes, it's important to have other people and voices as well. But we need people from agencies,
from industry, from the military. But we certainly do need from the professoriate. And that's why I
think it's really important what you're doing. So today, you're going to describe the research
that you've gone into in terms of a presentation you made at a very important conference you gave
over the summer. And you're gracious enough to provide it here. And then we're going to have a
nice long conversation, depending on which order you're watching this in. You may have already seen
the conversation with Kevin on the Into the Impossible podcast. This shows you I'm dedicating
two hours to this phenomenon, because I think it's so important. And it's so prescient that
Kevin's been involved in this, bringing scientific rigor, bringing academic rigor. We hear a lot about
peer review is broken, science is broken, Fauci's this, lock up string theorist. And you know,
I'm guilty of some of it too. But the reality is, Kevin's a working professor. You can check out
his website, I'll have all of his links below. And just really grateful for your presence today,
Kevin. So if you wouldn't mind, you could take us through this presentation. I might interrupt
here and there. But just to ask clarifying questions that the audience might be interested in,
unable to ask at this point. Absolutely. And thank you for the very, very kind introduction.
Yeah, I gave I've gave this talk at the Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies meeting,
this last summer and in Toronto. And I think one of the there's a few things that
characterize academic scientists and make them different than others, and perhaps in this field
more useful, is we study things, and we're trained to study things. And we're trained to be skeptical.
And we're, I don't know how many times I'm told by somebody, I'm skeptical. Well, I am too. I mean,
I'm, I'm skeptical of my own ideas. And most people aren't. That's a sign of a good scientist.
Yeah, that's a sign of a system works both ways, you have to be able to catch mistakes.
And the fastest way to catch mistakes is for you to catch them.
And then in addition to that, physicists think about things differently than other people.
And so I can't say that that's the only good way to think about it. I know that it's not.
But physicists often bring a unique perspective that's that you can't get anywhere else. And so
this talk is basically that. I'm asking the question, how anomalous is anomalous?
And when it comes to UAP, and I'm going to focus on energy and power. And I think the reasons for
focusing on energy and power are that, in some cases, we can estimate the energies and powers
involved in a sighting or in interaction with these objects. And very often, those energies
or powers are as much, much greater than humans are capable of dealing with. And I think this is
the real evidence that we have that we're dealing with non-human tech in many of these cases. And
and when I go through some of these cases, it'll be pretty obvious that this cannot possibly be
human technology. I know Lockheed Martin can do some pretty cool things, but there's a lot
of things that they can't do. So I think it's also difficult for people to remember that UAP
are a class of phenomena, not a single thing. There are very certainly different types of UAP.
Not all of them are alien spacecraft. In fact, most of them probably aren't. And
in this slide, I actually show several pictures of UAPs. One of them is actually identified.
And it's the one here in the lower left. Can you see my cursor moving?
Yep, that's perfect. You can see this one in the lower left.
Excuse me. When I first saw this image, I got very excited because I had recognized several
other images that looked similar. And I thought, wow, maybe it's the same type of craft.
And I pulled all those images together and looked at them at the same time and realized,
no, it's a bird. It's a seagull. Which is precisely why the photographer didn't notice
it while he took the pictures because he was taking a picture of the boats in the background
that I have covered up with the text. And that's actually a seagull. I'm going to try to jump over
to another set of slides and I can show you that. Just one second. Frank, can you see this new set?
All right. Yeah, I see it. Yep. Here we go. I'll go to full screen mode here too.
All right. So this is from an earlier talk. This is the same picture and the person was
taking a picture of the ships here. I've cropped it a bit. We can zoom in and maybe it's still not
obvious what it is. It's not obvious until I do that. Now it's pretty obvious what this is. It's
a seagull. I feel bad about raining on this guy's parade of his cool UAP photo. But that's my job
as a scientist. We've been ruining all the fun for 400 years now. So I joke with people. I tell
them I'm here to ruin the fun. And that's really what we've been doing. It's very funny. I work
very closely with Matthew Shadagas and Cecilia Levy, both professors at the University at Albany
and work with them under UAPX and our UAPX group. And we've looked at many cases at this point,
looked at photographs. Matthew's been analyzing materials. And we have discovered more,
as Matthew puts it, he puts it quite well. He's looked at all sorts of materials,
crash debris. And he says he's discovered more earth dirt than he ever expected. And of course,
no one's happy to find out that their UFO debris is actually just earth dirt or airplane parts,
which we have found. But we're here to figure out the truth. And that's another thing we
academics are good at, getting at the truth. That's right. So I'm going to focus here first
on speeds and accelerations. There are many cases where we can measure speeds and accelerations and
sometimes with radar. Hermann Oberth, this grumpy looking gentleman here at the bottom of the
picture, was a German father of modern rocketry. He was a mentor to Wernher von Braun, which is
just to the right. And Hermann Oberth gave a lecture on flying saucers in 1954.
And he notes in the lecture, their speed is sometimes very high. 19 kilometers a second
has been measured with wireless measuring instruments radar. This is 1954. Radar was new.
So, and then accelerations are so high that no man could stand it.
This is not what comes up as an understatement. Actually, it turns out he would be pressed to
the wall and bruised. No, they'd be turned into jelly in some cases. The accuracy of such
measurements has been doubted. If there would be only three or four measurements, I would not rely
upon them and would wait for further measurements. But there is existing more than 50 such measurements,
50 radar measurements of UAP existing in 1954. And the wireless sets of the American Air Force
and Navy, which are used in all fighters, cannot be so inaccurate that the information obtained
with them can be doubted completely. So, I find this presentation, while he doesn't actually
provide us with that radar evidence, he clearly notes it. 19 kilometers a second is extremely
fast. That's about 42,000 miles an hour. That's approximately the speed of the New Horizons probe,
which is currently flying through the Kuiper belt in the outer solar system.
It flew past Pluto in 2015. So, these things are flying, have been measured to fly at spacecraft
speeds. And this has been known since 1954. And I think this is a big deal. And so, where are
these 50 radar measurements? And how is it that we're still going back to saying, well, what about
the Russians and the Chinese? Well, these things weren't Russian and Chinese back in 1954. That's
for sure. They weren't American either. In 1954, the airspeed record was something like 760 miles
an hour. So, you're looking at a huge difference in speeds. And he told people about this back in
1954. And I like to say this is why he's so grumpy, because nobody's listening to him.
We're paying any attention. It's pretty obvious what the situation is.
Excuse me. The NUETS case was an excellent case in which one can estimate speeds and
accelerations. There's three events that allow you to do that. This one gives you the greatest
acceleration. This is when Kevin Day reported that he recorded on radar that these objects
were dropping from 28,000 feet to sea level in 0.78 seconds. So, now you can estimate this
acceleration. It comes out to something like 5,400 Gs. This is the distribution of probability
distributions of acceleration. So, how far off can you be? Well, it isn't less than 3,000 Gs,
and it certainly probably isn't much more than 10,000 Gs. But it's somewhere in between. And
most probably around 5,500 Gs. So, we can estimate the... We know it's acceleration. 5,000 Gs is
you're not going to be just pressed against the wall and bruised. Somebody who weighs 100 pounds
normally under 5,000 Gs is going to weigh 500,000 pounds. Yeah, under that acceleration.
So, 500,000, your body weighing 500,000 pounds, you're going to just turn into soup at the bottom
on the floor. We can try to estimate the power involved in its maneuver,
assuming that it accelerated halfway and then decelerated the other half to stop
moving at zero feet at sea level. And if you use that acceleration where it accelerates at 5,400
Gs halfway and then decelerates the other half, you can try to estimate its power, but you need
to know its mass. We don't know its mass. We know its approximate size. David Fravor described
it as being about the size of an F-18. And so, what I did here is I just took one-tenth of the
mass of an F-18. So, let's say it's one-tenth as light as... It only weighs 10% of the weight of
an F-18. So, it weighs... So, I'm trying to lowball it here in a reasonable way. And if we do that
and calculate the power, this is a graph of the power over time required for this maneuver,
the maximum power needed is 1,100 gigawatts. And that's really, really a lot of power.
This is more than 10 times the total nuclear power output of the United States.
Kevin, before we go on, I'm a physicist. I studied the cosmic microwave background,
which was pioneered by Bob Dickey at MIT Rad Labs, and then later at Princeton University.
And his colleague, his fellow professor there was David Wilkinson, who was my grand advisor.
And so, I'm very conversant with the radar technology and so forth. And I'm also a pilot,
a private pilot, although I do have a jet type rating in several classes of jets and
commercial pilot, instrument pilot, et cetera. Now, I'm not anywhere near the courage. I said
David Fravor has more courage in his left cuticle than I have in my whole body. I couldn't get into
the military, let alone be as good a pilot as he is. I'll stipulate that all. But I know a lot
about radar, and I know a lot about microwave energy and returns. So, in order for this to be
true, the returns matter much more to me than even Fravor, as great as an eyewitness he may be.
And that I'll stipulate, even though I have counter examples that I can present later.
But for radar to return, it has to reflect off something. So, that can be any form of dielectric.
It could be anything with a relatively large or small cross-section. You're assuming that it's
actually smaller than the visible cross-section of the same encounter by a factor of 10 or
something like that, which I think is more than fair, because you're trying to get a lower limit.
You're trying to have some credulity in this and not go to the extremes. But for this to
simultaneously reflect and also be visible in the visible light spectrum and reflected, that puts a
bound on the dielectric constants that are permissible. And I'm wondering if, we don't know
what it was made of, but we certainly know that any material object that will make that return
will have these ancillary characteristics, sonic booms, extreme thermal heating. I mean, 10x,
the nuclear reactor output is not insubstantial. How do you rectify that as a scientist? How do you
square the circle that this can't be something, some unknown material. It can't be a materials
problem. It has to be reflective and it has to be reflective in the visible and in the millimeter
wave or microwave. How do you reconcile those facts? I haven't thought about the radar return
problem. And I haven't thought about it that way in being able to say something about the
dielectric constants of the hull of the object or the surface. So that's an interesting question.
That's something I hadn't even considered. All right. Maybe it's something we can work
on together at some point. So go on, Kevin. Yeah, I didn't want to derail you, but-
Yeah, no. And with regard to the power output, yeah, 10 times the total nuclear power output
in the United States, that's shocking. I mean, here's the real problem. And this is going to come
up again when I talk about luminosities, which are also incredibly high. But you're talking about
1000 gigawatts of power, right? And no engineered object is 100% efficient, right? So let's say,
the things we make are usually, at best, you're looking at 30% efficient for machinery, right?
And so let's say that these guys are really good at what they do, and they can get it down to
an efficiency of 99.9% efficient, right? So you've only got a 0.1% inefficiency. Let's
say they're really very, very good. Even if you have a 0.1% inefficiency, that means that
0.1% of 1000 gigawatts is going to be leaking out in waste heat.
That means a gigawatt of power in waste heat, you'd have to deal with.
That would melt any craft in a very short order.
Clearly, something strange is going on. We're missing something, and it's not quite clear
exactly what that is. And could it be that these are not moving the way we think they're moving?
Of course, we have ideas about space-time warping, and these are rather far out ideas
that we don't actually have a lot of evidence for. But it's hard to reconcile
these high Gs and having any machinery or living beings on top of it being able to
survive accelerations like that. That's a whole different problem.
And then there's other questions that a physicist comes up with. I mean,
the things that bother you. So this thing accelerates to about 40,000 miles an hour
at the midpoint, and then decelerates to zero. Where did that energy go when it decelerated?
Energy doesn't disappear. When this thing comes to a stop, that energy had to go somewhere. And
this power is correct. There should have been an explosion, about 250 Tomahawk
cruise missiles worth of explosion when the thing just stopped. That should have been catastrophic
and wasn't. So these things don't make sonic booms. We have a lot of...
I try to think about this as a detective. We have a lot of clues,
but they're not fitting together very well. It's very odd.
So this isn't normal technology, clearly. But I think the power alone makes it clear that this
is not human tech if what we think is going on. So this is one example. We have another example
where we have radar data. This is from the Japanese Airlines case in 1986, where you've had
a Japanese cargo plane, a 747, was flying from Tokyo, or it was actually going from Paris to
Tokyo. I have that backwards. It was going from Paris to Tokyo when it encountered several UFOs
over Alaska. And the event culminated with a large UFO that was shaped like a walnut. There's
a drawing on the right here from the pilot. And the pilot estimated to be about the size of four
747s. So this thing's about the size of an aircraft carrier. When the pilot had said when
it was in front of the plane, that was all he could see out the windscreen. How wrong can a
pilot be about this, right? So the object's there. I think that's pretty clear. And it followed him
for 45 minutes. They had military height-finding radar had detected this and was collected by
the FAA. And the FAA Chief for Accidents and Investigations, John Callahan, actually made
copies of the radar data and kept them in a box under his desk until he retired, at which point
he made them public. But he kept copies because President Reagan's science team came and took all
the data. They confiscated it. So he actually released the copies publicly. Let's see,
Daniel Kumbay, who was at the Niels Bohr Institute for some time, had analyzed this radar data
and looked at the acceleration made by several jumps. So this UFO basically stayed about
seven kilometers away from the airplane. It just, with every sweep of the, it basically moved
around the plane. And with every sweep of the radar, it would be on one side of the plane. And
then the next sweep of the radar would be at the other side of the plane. So you can estimate the
minimum accelerations here. And you can see here on this table,
we've got the 11 jumps. The accelerations you're looking at, there are several,
three cases where the acceleration's coming up on 10,000 Gs, which is really, really insane,
right? You've got something the size of an aircraft carrier accelerating at 10,000 Gs.
The maximum speeds here, the maximum speed would be Mach 350. And that's basically
close to 2,000, or 269,000 miles an hour. At that speed, you can get to the moon in 53 minutes.
So if this is going to be a two-hour podcast and all, we could have left for the moon on this craft
and gotten there and come right back in the amount of time that it'll take you to watch this two-hour
podcast. So two questions before just continuing. So one is there are error bars here, which is very
rare in this pseudo-industry or, you know, kind of this field of study, you know, that you have error
bars. Well, that's what happens when you get scientists involved, academic scientists involved.
And that's why we need more. I mean, I hear a lot of things about, oh, well,
NASA's suppressing this and astronomer, you know, my friend, Sarah Scholes wrote a book that,
you know, they're already here about, you know, sightings and so forth. And she just estimated,
you know, how much time do astronomers like me and my colleagues spend looking at all domains
from longest wave radio waves to, you know, gamma rays in space? How much time are we observing,
you know, so many steradians on the sky? And it's a huge amount. And for a UFO enthusiast,
you know, to kind of besmirch a scientist and say that, like, oh, you're just paid off by NASA.
I mean, I worked for NASA once, you work for NASA, but I think it's more.
I would love to be paid off by NASA. I know, exactly.
Or have somebody, anybody to pay me off would be great.
It was like, you know, are you getting paid by, you know, Galileo project? Nope,
you're not getting any. You're not getting a dime from it, as far as I understand.
So this is a canard. I think that people are sloppy thinkers that are true believers. They
do their cause a disservice because they don't include error bars. An error bar,
I always tell my students, Kevin, I know you teach a lot about Bayesian statistics. I've
gone through your lecturing. You're an award-winning lecturer. I've gone through your
lectures. I've watched them. You know, my take is that I don't care if you get the answer right.
Like, I don't care if you get the central value, you know, you measure G and you get it 9.8 meters
per second squared. But you don't tell me that your error bar is a hundred meters per second
squared plus or minus, you know, on the plus side and minus 10 meters per second. That's my
problem with the Drake equation. It's always presented as an equation for a number as if
that's what we do. No, no. The sign of a good scientist is what error bar he or she can assign
to it and the breakdown in that error in terms of systematic and statistical errors. My first
question is, what are those errors? Are they statistical? Are they systematic? And my second
question is, this thing was flying at, you know, for an hour at 747 speeds, call it 500 miles an
hour, pretty much. Let's round up round numbers. And so this thing was tracked over what? I mean,
Alaska is not that big. So, you know, how are they tracking this thing for that long,
getting this data and what can we ascribe these errors bars to first?
Right. Well, when you calculate errors like this, but what you're doing is you are characterizing
the, you can't actually estimate the systematic error because you would need to know what the
true value is to estimate that, right? You'd have to have some handle on what the true value is.
So you can never really estimate systematic error. So what you're doing is you're basically
looking at the error of the, you're basically, you're calculating a probability distribution
of the acceleration, which is what I showed on this previous slide. This is actually what this
is giving you. And this was done by sampling, which is why it's fuzzy. But this is the
probability distribution for the acceleration. That's, that's the answer that Bayesian statistics
would give you. Right. And, and I can report, you know, so what do you want to report? Well,
I can report the mode is a peak. I can find the peak. I can fit this to a curve and I found the
peak. I can report the mode. I can report the mean. So I can calculate the average value,
which is not going to be quite at the same place that the mode is. So you could, so you actually
have multiple numbers you can report. And then you have your uncertainties, which you can estimate
another way. And uncertainty is a way of estimating the width of the distribution. So it's typically
done is once you find the mode, you, you know, where the mode is the peak. Once you know where
the peak is, you can then, you can look at the curvature of the peak. And basically you're
fitting a Gaussian distribution to this and that, and you take the, the standard deviation of that
Gaussian distribution fit to the peak. You use that as the measure of the width of this distribution.
Now, in this case, it's asymmetric. It's clearly an asymmetric distribution. So what I did is I,
I actually fit a one Gaussian to the left side and a second Gaussian to the right side.
And then I use the, the standard deviation of the each Gaussian is the plus or minus. So it
has a different plus or minus, whether you're on the plus side or the minus side. And that's
basically what's happening here with the, with the accelerations. So you're, so that, so
conceptually what the uncertainty is telling you is it gives you the, an idea of the precision
of your estimation procedure. Yes. And that's really what the uncertainty means. And that's
what the uncertainties in pretty much any scientific calculation actually give you,
you can't, you can't easily estimate uncertainty in any, any kind of bias unless you know what that
bias is. And, and, and the uncertainties are important because it tells you how well you
know the answer, right? Right. So when you, when I, when, when I get as an answer to this
distribution, I tell you 5,400 G's. I don't know that it's exactly 5,400 G's. It's probably
somewhere in here. And that's what that uncertainty tells you. And I didn't list the
uncertainty on this slide because it just will make it more busy than it already is.
But in the research paper that you can find online, I have the uncertainties listed there.
Got it. Okay. Yep. So let's go on. Yeah. And in fact when I worked at NASA
I tell, I tell my students, you have to be willing to learn new things when you're
actually working as a scientist. And you know, cause many times students, especially when they
get into graduate school, they think, well, I'm all done taking classes. I don't have to learn
anything else. Like that's actually not true. It's backwards. You've got it backwards. Exactly.
And when I worked at NASA, we were, it was the early 2000s and, and NASA was producing
information about climate change. And Congress came back and said, they pushed back and said,
look, what is your, what are your uncertainties about? How certain are you about these results?
And NASA needed to go back and redo some of the work to produce those uncertainties.
And, and so I actually got called into my boss's office and they said, Kevin,
we have to do some work on estimating uncertainties for climate change. And
you're one of the only experts we have in this department that can calculate those uncertainties.
So I need you to work on climate problems. I was like, wait, I do astrophysics. I'm not a
climate scientist. I don't know anything about climate. He goes, yeah, that's why you're going
to learn. He goes, we're going to send you to NASA GISS in New York City and you're going to train
with them for six months. And like, yep, I'm going to learn for the whole, you know, for the whole
next two years about climate, earth planet climates and this. So yeah, that happens and you have to,
you have to do it. And that's how you, that's how you become successful.
And so what did I do that night? I panicked. I went to the bookstore to find a book on
atmospheres or climate or something. And I was poking around and the most useful book I found
was my little golden book on clouds. And it was through cloud types. And I just bought it. I
thought, I don't even know what kinds of clouds there are. So I should maybe learn this first.
It was literally a kid's book. I thought, I'm going to start with a kid's book tonight.
Build up. Okay, great. All right. So yes. So, so these accelerations are insane. And
what can you do with these acceleration? What if this is actually a spacecraft? I mentioned here,
you can get to the moon in 53 minutes. What if you were traveling further? So now,
and I make this point in the paper, not only do these objects have flight characteristics
necessary for interstellar travel, excuse me, they would make excellent interstellar craft.
So a 1000 G acceleration, one fifth of the, one fifth of what the Nimitz case was observed doing
and one 10th of the acceleration that was observed at JAL,
you can get to 90% the speed of light in about 17 hours.
Once you're going 90% the speed of light, relativity kicks in, time slows down,
distances change, you can actually travel much, much further. So yeah, so if these objects can
sustain an acceleration in space, 1000 G acceleration will get you to 30% the speed
of light in 2.7 hours. How far could you go? Well, here's some examples. The Nimitz
Tic Tacs could get to the nearest star Proxima Centauri in less than one and a half days.
It's a day trip. And actually could make it to, out to Zeta Reticuli, which is in Trappist-1,
which is about 40 light years away in less than two days. Yeah, this is the amount of time it'll
take you to drive from New York to Florida. You could get to the nearest stars, right,
within 40 light years. And there's what, there's probably 80 sun-like stars in the 40 light year
range. I don't know the exact number. Yeah, a lot, way more than that, I think.
Yeah, it's a radius. Right. So, and those were just, I think I was just thinking about sun-like
stars. You've got red dwarfs, which are good. Trappist-1 is a red dwarf. It goes around a red
dwarf star. So there's plenty of, plenty of places to go. Yeah. So these craft now, now granted,
and you'll hear, you'll hear scientists say this all the time when they complain about interstellar
travel and say, oh, even if you can go fast, it'll still take you, you know, 40 years to get to
Zeta Reticuli. Well, it'll take you 40 years in the frame of the galaxy. For everybody in the
galaxy, it takes 40 years. For the traveler, it takes less than two days. That's right.
There's a time difference and just because time slows down. Now, what that means is that you can't,
you can't fly from Zeta Reticuli to the sun, hang out for an afternoon and then fly back to
Zeta Reticuli and make it home for dinner. For you, it'll be a four-day trip. For everybody
on Zeta Reticuli or Earth, it'll be an 80-year trip. Right. So, so this is what makes, this is
what makes interstellar travel hard. Not the fact that you can do it. Do you want to is the question.
And actually, I gave a talk at SCU, one of the first SCU meetings where I, I noted that if you
actually had a nomadic society, so that you had a society that lived on their spaceships, didn't
live on a planet, they lived on spaceships. They then could do this easily because you would just
meet up. So, so you and I will meet up on Earth. I'll go visit Zeta Reticuli. You want to go to
Trappist-1. We take off and go there and then say, we'll meet back in two weeks. We come back two
weeks later and it's literally 80 weeks later on Earth. But for us, it's only two weeks later.
That's, that's how you could do it. And, and there are not as many nomadic societies on Earth now as
there used to be, but there still are nomadic societies. And in fact, in Southeast Asia,
there's a society that lives, they live entirely on their boats and that's what they do.
All right. So transmedium travel and unidentified submerged objects.
So we'll now look at another class, another set of data. So I've looked at these accelerations.
These are much higher than humans could, could make. You already saw that this little Tic-Tac,
a thousand kilogram Tic-Tac would, in doing its 5,000 gene maneuver, would put out,
would require a thousand gigawatts. I can't even guess what an aircraft carrier size craft would
require to do a 10,000 G acceleration. You're looking at something way, way,
orders of magnitude beyond that. And now, let's see here, something's happened. There we go.
All right. So underwater objects. This is a, this is the Aguadilla object.
And, and Doug Bettner gave a talk at SCU and argued that, that a lot of the strangeness of
this object was actually due to the fact that you had a lot of video compression going on.
And so, so this may not be, this isn't my good power example. It was just an example of
transmedium travel. UFOs have been observed going from air into water and from water into air
pretty seamlessly. And humans can't do that very well. The one of the craft that we have that does
this is a, is a seaplane, a seaplane. I love that example because a seaplane is neither a good plane
nor a good boat. That's the worst of all worlds. That's the worst of all worlds, but it can do
both. And that's, that's where we're at. Now, of course, there's new drones that can probably go
in and out of water more easily. I'm sure we're working on things like this. The one encounter
that I find fascinating is from February of 1987, where the New Zealand frigate, the HMNZS Southland
was involved in daily exercises from November to February, where they were
basically trying to lure USOs in from the Pacific Ocean into the Hauraki Gulf.
So they basically would go out into the, go up north out of Auckland through the Hauraki Gulf
out into the Pacific Ocean, then turn around and come back and watch on their sonar to see if
they're followed and then try to study these objects. In February of 1987, they were followed
by a large underwater object, which they measured to be 150 feet wide and 800 feet long.
This is 30% longer than the Typhoon-class submarine, which is the largest submarine in
the world, the Russian Typhoon-class. And they noted that they did not detect propeller wash
on any of these objects. So they couldn't identify whether they were Russian or American.
If they were submarines, they weren't typical submarines, there was no propeller wash.
It does not escape me that the movie Hunt for Red October came out the same year, basically.
And I know about this. And that's an interesting fact. So they were followed by this
USO for some time, they tried to shake it. And at one point, the USO was 22.5 kilometers away.
And they were trying to shake this and it closed the distance in about three seconds.
So this underwater object accelerated to the ship, passed under the ship in about three seconds,
and actually took all the power out on the ship. The power went out on the ship, drained the
batteries so they couldn't restart the engines and they were adrift and had to be rescued.
They had, so you can do this calculation, this rough calculation, it closed a 2.5
kilometer distance in about three seconds. So you get a minimum speed of 1800 miles an hour.
Or if you have it accelerating, it would have a minimum acceleration of
57 G's with a top speed of 37,000 miles, 3700 miles an hour.
So this is a really interesting case. And in fact, I was on a Zoom call with David Barnett
last night, we talked, we talked for almost two and a half hours, I was really grateful for his
time. Going over the time, I actually have a printout of the raw sonar data, the raw sonar
basically, there's a stylus that was moving across the sheet of papers, the papers printing,
showing the actual sonar returns. So I actually have a scan of that. Sadly, it is,
that sheet of paper is 40 years old at this point, and it's faded a great deal because the stylus
was actually burning into the paper, and it's not a very powerful burn. So it's all very faint. And
I'm not sure I can actually pull the speeds and accelerations out of it out of that sonar data yet.
But we were talking last night about how to go about doing that.
Now, what's amazing is since then, and since since I first noted this, I first talked about
this case in the Seoul meeting in 2023. And since then, a number of people have tried to
get information about the Southlands activities in November through February of 86, 87.
And it's all classified, their activities are classified. But people have learned other things,
there were other ships involved. There was an Australian ship that was there. And I don't have
my notes with me, my notes are in the other room, because I just learned this all last night. And I
haven't transcribed them yet. But the Australian ship traveled with them for some time and then
left and then disappeared, dropped out of communication, just before this event happened.
And they dropped out of communication and then put out a distress call. And they had had some
kind of encounter and had to, they made it back to Sydney, and then had to go in for refitting.
And, and then there was also an American aircraft carrier involved that the Americans,
the American records say that it was that it was docked in Alameda, California. But no,
it was not, it was actually out in the Pacific Ocean in the same area. So what they were doing
is they were they were going out north of Auckland along the Kermetic Trench. So the Kermetic Trench
is a very long trench that goes from, it's an undersea subduction zone. The trench goes from
the north northern part of New Zealand all the way up to Tonga. And at its deepest, it's 33,000
feet deep. So, so there was a lot going on. And then there was also another New Zealand ship
involved that the HMNZS Tui. And I think that was the one that was fitted with the, the at the time
modern British toll ray sonar, and they were actually mapping areas of the trench. So,
this apparently was an activity to study these USOs, these underwater objects,
that was a collaboration between the New Zealanders, the Australians and the Americans.
And a lot of this is classified, one of the, he showed me a screenshot, one of the records from
what the HMNZS Southland was doing is was classified for 75 years. You're not getting
that data. We're not getting that until 2062 or something. It's like worse than the Kennedy
assassination. It's worse than the Kennedy assassination. What are they doing in the
Kermetic Trench? It's a good question. All right. So, so let's go back to the points of energy and
power, right? So, we've got speeds and accelerations. So, how do you move at 3,700
miles an hour underwater? And this isn't a small object. Basically, you've got this object that's
got to push a cylinder of water out of the way, right? And this, this is a what 2.5 kilometers,
that's a mile, a mile long cylinder of water with 150 foot diameter has to be pushed out of
the way. Now, water is not compressible. Anybody who's done a belly flop off of a low dive or high
dive knows this. Water is not compressible. You can't compress it. So, you have to lift up the
water, right? Yeah. You have to lift up the water. So, you can estimate, now you can estimate the
power, the amount of energy it takes, because you've got to basically lift up one mile long
column of water. You've got to lift it up about 150 feet, right? And what was it? How many seconds?
It was what? 30 seconds, right? 30 seconds. Yeah. 30 seconds. So, now we can calculate the amount
of power here. I actually work out this calculation. So, how much mass was involved?
Well, first, first, let's figure out the mass of the object and mass of the object. I don't know
the mass of the object, but it's underwater. So, it has to at least have the mass of the water.
It's at least as dense as the water. If it wasn't as dense as the water, it would be floating. So, as a
lower limit, you can figure out the size of the object and because they know it was 150 foot
in diameter and 800 feet long. So, you've got a mass of about 4 times 10 to the 8th kilograms.
This thing had to accelerate. So, you can figure out the power from its motion. That's going to be
the mass times the acceleration squared times the time. That's how I'll calculate that.
And then now it also has to lift up a one mile long column of water and you have to do this
in 30 seconds. So, this is basically the calculation for that. Now we can look at the
amount of power it takes for this to happen. As it's speeding up, it's doing more, it's taking
more power. So, you're, you know, the top power is you're looking at something like
something on the order of 10 to the 8th megawatts. Let's see, is that right or is it,
let me go back. I'm worried that I have messed up the units on my, I may have messed up the units
on my chart here because I'm thinking if it's, if this is 10 to the 8th megawatts, 10 to the 8th
megawatts is 10 to the 14th, which is more than insane. So, so I've got to double check that,
but you can, you can do the math here. How's that for that? So, you're dealing with,
you're, you're dealing again with megawatts, you know, many, many megawatts of power
to be able to pull this up. You've got to take power to move the, move the object and you've
got to displace the water. Insane amount of power. So, what other evidence do we have?
We have luminosities. Some of these things are really crazy bright. This is one thing that,
one of the many things that Steven Spielberg got right in Close Encounters of the Third Kind.
Yes, people get sunburned from these things. Right. That happens. So, some of them are
extremely luminous and so much so that the photographs are difficult to interpret. So,
these are all photographs of UFOs where they're just glowing in white. They're very, very bright.
The, this image here taken in 1956 over the Canadian Rockies in Alberta, we can,
Bruce McAbee and Jacques Vallée actually had access to the actual film and counted silver
grains to basically figure out how much, what the intensity of light was hitting the camera.
So, you can actually, yeah, so Dr. Bruce McAbee did study this and Jacques Vallée has
also summarized and reported. So, you can look at the radiance of the object
and how that's going to relate to camera parameters.
And basically, they measure the exposure levels and the shutter times and estimated the radiance to
be this much. So, it's, yeah, well, there's interesting units there. Luminosity units
are hard anyway or radiance units. Two watts per steradian centimeter squared, right?
So, for an isotropic source, so if, what do you mean by isotropic? If this thing is radiating
uniformly in all directions, then the distance for the distance between the plane and the object,
which was estimated to be between 6 and 20 kilometers, you're looking at a power of
2,500 to 30,000 megawatts. That's a lot of light.
And I have a bit of a problem with that because if it's putting out that much light and it's
close to the clouds, the clouds should be illuminated pretty much as much as the sun
is illuminating them. Yeah, that's weird. So, I then thought, well, let's redo the calculation
assuming that it's a directed light. So, it's shining a light on the airplanes.
And if you do this, you'd come down to a lesser power of 1.7 kilowatts. That's not as shocking,
but it's still a kilowatt of light is a lot of light. And that's pretty amazing.
Now, Jacques Vallée, Luc Denis, and Geoffrey Meschersky had published a paper in Progress
in Aerospace Sciences last year where they estimated the radiative energy in ground level
observations based on bark being burnt. So, this is the Haynesville, Louisiana case
where a physicist actually was driving with his family and they witnessed a pulsating light in
the forest, which started as a red-orange glow and became brilliant white flash eliminating the
woods and it drowned out the headlights. And what Professor Galloway noted is when it drowned out
the headlights, he knew the amount of power in the headlights and he was able to estimate
that the light coming from this thing in the forest had to be megawatts of power.
And that worried him. He actually turned the car around and went the other way
and drove away from it, which was probably a smart idea.
So, the object itself wasn't seen. They were able to locate where it had landed. It had landed in
a clearing in the forest, and the trees around the clearing were all scorched from the light
from this object. And so, this was actually described in the Condon Report, and the Condon
Report actually recalculated some of these power and actually had a higher amount of power.
They did not have a good explanation for what happened and they left it as an uncertain event.
When Jacques Vallée and Luc Digny and Jeffrey Mischersky looked at this, they were able to
get power estimates closer to 500 megawatts of light. So, that's, again, a crazy amount of light.
Humans don't make things that—that's a nuclear power plant's worth of light,
right? So, this is not a human-made object. So, Kevin, I don't want to go past the half hour,
but we haven't done the podcast yet. Oh, right. I'm basically on my conclusion slide, I think.
Yeah, okay, great. Yeah, let's finish this up and then switch to the podcast. Yeah, go for it.
Yeah, so the minimal power estimates that we're making here, and basically in radar-recorded
maneuvers, sonar-recorded maneuvers, greatly exceed the power produced by nuclear power plants.
And the minimal power estimates in the luminosity alone are on the order of nuclear power plants.
So, I think this, to me, is the strongest evidence that we have that we're
not dealing with human technology. Humans don't make vehicles that exhibit the amount of power
of a nuclear power plant. It just doesn't happen. It's dangerous. It would be dangerous for us to
do that. And it could be catastrophic. And in fact, here is an interesting point. It suggests,
I mentioned this earlier, it's just an exceptional engineering since even if you had a 1%
inefficiency of a 1 gigawatt system, that would give you 10 megawatts of waste heat,
which would be catastrophic. Now, we do have a few cases where you have UFOs having trouble,
right? You've got the Ubatuba incident in Brazil where the UFO was clearly,
was wobbling and all over the place. And the people observing it noted that they thought
it was in trouble, and then it just exploded. And some of that debris and material has been
collected and has been studied. And then you have the case in Council Bluffs, Iowa, where you've got
the UFO that basically was dumping molten metal in the forest. And that also happened in Puget
Sound in 1947. So could it be that in those UFOs, they had a problem with their engineering system,
and they were basically melting the inside of their craft? That's very possible. That could
be what's going on. But these aren't, you know, these are not human made objects. And the power
estimates in propulsion, plus the fact that the objects do not seem to be interacting with their
environment suggests that we're observing non-Newtonian propulsion or motion. They're
not moving in the way that we move. What that means exactly, I don't know. But it opens the
door to new, you know, is this new engineering or new physics? That's debatable. And we don't have
enough evidence to decide on those things yet. But some of these UAP are extremely anomalous
when it comes to energy and power. I think that's important to keep in mind.
Well, Kevin, this is great. I would like to push back as much as I can respectfully,
as I have a tremendous amount of respect. I think the key gripping question that I cannot
really let go of, you know, just despite how much I love your work and respect you and resonate with
a lot of what you've said is that, you know, these cannot be, I agree, these cannot be human
technology, but that's predicated that all of these, you know, sensors all agree that these are
actually true signals. In other words, they're not artifacts and they're not hallucinations. They're
not, you know, the reports of, you know, planets and swamp gas. And the key thing I keep coming
back to is my friend, David Spergel, a member of the National Academy of Sciences. He is the
president of the Simons Foundation. He led NASA's Blue Ribbon Panel a couple of years back with my
colleague here at UCSD, Shelly Wright, who's also a legitimate hardcore scientist, but also
is investigating extraterrestrial intelligence using pulses of light and other modes. She won
the Drake Medal. She's an esteemed scientist. That commission found, you know, basically 95%
of the things reported then had explanations. And we can never, as scientists, expect 100%
lack of residuals. And I think the anomalous residuals create, you know, it's like the Pareto
principle, 80-20 principle, except it's 95-5. And that's what I want to talk to you about on the
podcast. So if you haven't watched the podcast, go over to check out the podcast with Kevin Knuth,
and we'll see you over there. And we'll get into some of the debate between two, you know, friendly
debate, gentlemanly debate between two physicists that are seeking the truth. And I think that's
what I love most about what Kevin does. So Kevin, thank you for this lecture.