Watch Our Car Buying Coach Negotiate a Used Car Deal in 3 recorded calls. Watch a real used car negotiation unfold. The Homework Guy’s car buying coach John Melby calls the dealer, works toward a better price, and shows what can happen when an experienced negotiator handles the conversation for the buyer.
John’s work didn’t end with the price: the vehicle also went through a pre-purchase inspection before Dave and Gretchen bought it. Their banker independently confirmed that they got an excellent deal. The end price was well below the vehicle Loan Value! That's as good as a Private Party purchase of the car!
Listen to a real negotiation by Homework Guy coach John Melby—“The Dealer Whisperer.” John stays calm, asks the right questions, ignores monthly Payment pitches and keeps bringing the dealer back to the out-the-door price.
The result? John negotiates a price below the vehicle’s loan value—and even better than a good private-party sale price. You’ll hear how he handles the dealer’s numbers and works toward a deal our buyers can feel confident about.
We negotiate used cars, too. If you’ve found a vehicle you want, talk with Kevin about having The Homework Guy team go to work for you.
👉 Learn more at thehomeworkguy.com 👉 Homework Guy Car Buying Service available
Do you happen to be on Facebook? If so, would you do us a big favor? Go to our facebook page and click on "Follow." We would greatly appreciate it! https://www.facebook.com/thehomeworkguy/followers
This video demonstrates a professional car-buying negotiation for a 2024 Acura MDX and introduces a specialized car-buying consultancy service. It highlights the importance of focusing on \"out-the-door\" pricing, utilizing independent inspections, and maintaining a firm yet polite stance to avoid common dealership tactics and secure the best possible deal.
Hello, everyone. Kevin Hunter, the homework guy here. As we
recently promised we would do today, you're going to hear a
real used car negotiation for Dave and Gretchen on a low
mileage 2024 Acura MDX. These are customers who ultimately
bought the vehicle. On these calls, we will only feature
negotiations done for real car buying customers. Some car
buying services say used cars are too hard to negotiate. That
makes me laugh because I say that's where homework matters
the most. Before this call, John had already gathered comparable
out-the-door quotes from other dealers. In fact, he batted
1,000. He got an OTD quote from every single dealer he called.
Meet John Melby, one of our finest coaches. We call him the
dealer whisperer. He stays calm, asks the right questions, and
never needs to get rude to move the numbers. I spoke with Dave
and Gretchen the day before this call. John was already
negotiating their 2024 Acura MDX the next day. That's how
quickly we can get moving here at the homework guy. This is an
opportunity for you to learn from a pro today, so listen up.
The dealer's claim discount, the repeated shift to monthly
payments, and what happens when John holds his ground on the
out-the-door price. I'll pause and jump in at the moments that
you really need to learn from. Now, let's hear the dealer
whisperer go to work.
Hello, this is John.
Hey, John, this is Ted.
Hey, how's it going?
Good, man. Sorry about that. I was with a customer on a test
drive. I wasn't able to pick up the phone call.
Okay, no worries. Yeah, I saw the video. It looks good. I
think you were going to get me an OTD as well.
I will get it on that right now. I just finished up with a
customer, so I'll send everything to you. Are you
trading your vehicle in or just buying?
No trades, just outright.
Alright, and were you planning to write a check for it or are
you financing it?
We'd be open to financing. I don't know if it was you or
another salesperson was talking about a potential rebate.
Like incentive for financing from a bank.
Okay, I will look into that for you. I will show you out the
door number. No problem. And I will run into finance aside
things to you. If you were to finance, what would you be okay
putting down and how many months you want to do just so I
can show you the numbers, but I will show you the other door
too. No problem.
It's 20% down 36 months.
36 months?
Yeah, that'd be fine.
Okay.
Or potentially for your note would be okay too.
48 months.
Okay. 8% down 48 months. Okay. Alright. I will run those
numbers to you and then I will give you a call right back.
Okay, but it'll have the out the door total as well or is it
going to be?
Of course you need it.
Yeah.
Nope. I'll get you. I'll get you at the door too. Not a
problem. You do live in PA, right? You're a PA resident?
Washington, New Jersey.
Oh, okay. Washington, New Jersey.
Notice that John isn't refusing to discuss financing.
He's making sure the total price doesn't disappear behind
a monthly payment.
Can you send me over your license so I can match the exact
address and then I'll run the numbers for you.
Okay.
You need the license for getting the price of the vehicle
or?
John doesn't pick a fight.
He simply asked whether Ted needs the license to price the
vehicle.
Address.
Yeah.
I'm talking household and taxes.
Oh, you could just do it.
Or you can just text me your address.
It's for Warren County.
Will that work?
Let me just check.
One second.
Washington, New Jersey is 07882, right?
Yeah, exactly.
The tax will be for that.
And let's say everything works out, John.
When would you be able to come in?
Just right away.
If the numbers all look good, we'll come and get the vehicle.
Okay.
Let me just check.
Okay.
Give me a couple of minutes.
I'll run you the numbers and I'll give you a call back.
Okay.
Thank you.
Hello.
Hey, John.
It's Ted.
Hey, Ted.
So, yeah.
Did some numbers here for you.
Looks pretty good.
So did some different options.
So out the door with Jersey tax and everything.
Obviously, we're not adding anything on top of it.
Just state fees and everything like that.
You're at $44,515.
20% down.
$8,000 down.
60 months.
You're at $734,000.
Yeah.
$8,000 down.
60 months.
You're at $34,000.
Out the door, you're at $44,515 with everything included.
Okay.
Our budget was actually $40,000 out the door.
Are you able to bring that offer to your manager?
We already have it discounted $4,000 into this deal.
We have this card for quite a bit of time.
So it's heavily discounted.
Don't have $4,000 into this deal.
How can I know that?
How can I see that?
Can you send me the out the door in writing?
Because I have no way to know that you discounted it $4,000.
Like, what is your reference?
That's a terrific question.
$4,000 off.
Of course, I'll show you right now.
Give me one second.
While you're on the call, I'll text it to you.
So as you see, we have the original price when we got the car, MSRP,
and then discounts with rebate, and then the current selling price.
This includes, you will see in the picture, the dock fee, the state fee,
plates and everything.
And then it shows you everything, all the information.
Okay.
Hold on.
I'm going to see what you sent me here.
Okay.
But yeah, we are under the market value for the car.
It's heavily discounted because we had the car for a long time.
It's priced very well.
So the discount is, it's a used vehicle,
and your discount is from MSRP as if it was a brand new vehicle?
No, no.
MSRP, to translate it into our world is how much we priced the car when we first got it.
It's not the actual MSRP when the car was brand new.
It's MSRP.
It's meaning of how much we priced the car when we first got it online.
Okay.
But I will also send you this.
This is not from us.
This is from Carfax.
The Carfax value, the market value of the car is $43,050.
And we have a price that 40, 40, lower than 41, actually.
Okay.
What was your car max again?
Yeah.
So it's $43,000 is a Carfax value.
I sent you the proof.
We have a price $1,500 under, which I think I have a price under the 41,479.
Okay.
Yeah, I do.
I have a price that 40,989.
So it's actually $2,000 less than the value of what it's worth on the market.
Ted explains that the figure labeled MSRP is the dealer's original asking price for this used MDX.
A dealer created starting price is not the vehicle's original manufacturer MSRP.
Ted clarifies it himself.
On this sheet, MSRP means what the dealership first listed the used car for.
And that changes how you would read the claimed discount.
Okay.
I'll tell you what, um, our current offer is 40,000 out the door.
Right.
As of right now, if you want to take that to your manager and let him know and see if he
will accept that.
If not, I'm going to keep shopping, but we may come back to you guys.
Does that sound okay?
I mean, I can talk to them about getting you guys, you know, between like 500 to a thousand,
but 4,500 bucks on a car that's already discounted for a brand.
It's not realistic for us.
Okay.
Well, I mean, I can try to, I can try to meet you.
We'll come by the vehicle now.
If you can, if you can do that price.
40.
We can do 40, but I can, I'll work with you.
I'm not going to tell you that I can't, I can't help you out.
I'll help you out as much as I can, but it's not going to be $4,500.
There's no way they will do that.
But could you guys meet me somewhere like in the middle and try to get you guys a little
Like I said, if you can do 40, we'll come in and get the vehicle right now.
If you have better offers, we'll definitely consider it.
It's just a little above our budget for what we're looking for.
And we're actually looking at some comparable vehicles in the market right now.
And we have other options.
So just give me some time to shop around and see if I can work a different deal.
To get us to come and get it right now is $40,000 out the door.
Yeah, we wouldn't be able to do 40, but I will.
We're at $44,500.
I would try to get you close to like $44,000, $43,500 to get you like $500,000 off.
Even that would be hard for me because it's already discounted significantly.
Like I said, I would love to help, you know, make the deal more attractive, but
we can't discount the car $4,500.
That's $8,000 discount on a pre-owned car.
We just can't.
No, I understand.
And that's okay.
If you want to just get us your best offer and we'll consider it.
And we'll get back to you on it.
Okay.
All right.
Sounds good.
All right.
We really appreciate it.
Thank you.
Of course.
Bye.
Okay.
Take care.
Bye.
This is why we call John the dealer whisperer.
John gives Ted a number, a reason to take it to the manager and then room to come back.
Hello.
Hey, John.
It's Ted.
Hey, Ted.
Hey, so I have very, very good news for you.
So my manager is willing to work with you here.
I also looked at the service records on this car.
So one thing you have to think about in this car is, uh, you won't need.
You know, to service or maintenance anytime soon.
You know, he has fresh tires.
He has the break, fresh breaks.
Like everything is pretty much fresh in the car.
So you would not have to put any money in the car for most likely the next year or two.
Obviously when we service the car here, we'll do the oil change and everything.
So the car, the car is well-balanced and well-serviced.
So that's something they will not have to worry about for a little bit.
So you're saving money on that.
With that being said, now let's get to the numbers part.
He is willing to work with you a good amount.
He's meeting you halfway there.
We were at 44.5.
Okay.
We're at 44.5.
Originally, we're willing to do that.
That's our best offer.
That's as well.
That's pretty much what we got the car for with, with the service and everything that
we put into it.
It's at 42, 383 out the door.
That's the best we'll go to.
That's the, that's the, yeah.
And even then.
Yeah.
Okay.
Well, it's slightly over budget still.
That is a much better deal.
I do appreciate that.
If you are, and if you're going to end up financing, I mean, I know it's still $2,000.
Ted calls back at 42,383 out the door.
The first we're already heavily discounted response was not the final number.
Good learning lesson there.
That's 2132 below the first out the door quote.
John got there without arguing about whether Ted was telling the truth or not.
Totally non-confrontational.
But like I said, the one thing you don't have to worry about is service.
Servicing a vehicle in today's world is not cheap.
Tires are not cheap.
Brakes are not cheap and everything you'll be taking care of in this car.
Like when you buy a car from us, we service a car so well, we changed a lot of things
on it and you're not going to have to put any money into the car for a pretty small
time.
So you're saving money on that, on that side.
And then you'll, and again, I have never seen my manager go this low and he dropped it like
another two grand, giving you under 42,500, you're going to have 42,383.
Okay.
If you are financing, if you are end up financing, it's most likely going to be like two, you
want to be a 40.
I understand that, but it's probably going to be like 40 bucks a month difference.
I would not miss out on this car, especially with this price right now for 40 bucks a month.
Ted has given us two things to verify.
The service work and the vehicle itself and the 2383 gap between John's 40,000 target.
And this offer is still real money, even when it's described as a monthly amount by Ted.
Okay.
I do appreciate that.
It's not exactly what we were hoping for.
So I do need a little bit of time to consider the offer, but I do notice it is a, you know,
it's a slightly newer vehicle and it's a little bit lower mileage, which we like.
So if you want to just give us a little bit to think about it, because it's just a little
bit over our budget.
So I still got to take some time to think about it.
Please.
No pressure.
If you do that, if you are, we do close at seven.
If you are able to talk to your wife and, you know, give it, give it some time.
If you're able to give me a call before we end, I would love to secure the car for you,
at least with a deposit.
And then after that, we can schedule a time for you to pick it up.
That way nobody will touch the car and nobody will sell the car.
Okay.
All right.
Well, yeah, it definitely has potential.
We'll let you know what we come to as far as a decision.
Okay.
Sounds good.
You have my phone number.
Just shoot me a text.
Whatever you make up with, if it's a yes or no, my offer stands on the table.
We'd love to get it done for you.
So just let me know.
Like I said, I'm here till seven today.
So if you end up getting towards a yes on this car, let me know.
I'll take a refundable deposit on it from you and it will be secured for you.
Nobody will touch the car.
I'll take the keys and I'll keep the keys.
You said the deposit is refundable?
It is refundable, sir.
Yes.
I do appreciate that.
Okay.
All right.
That sounds good.
In PA, it's legal to not do that.
So it is refundable.
No, that's awesome.
I appreciate that.
Okay.
Well, it's a pleasure.
We'll get back with you when we decide.
So sounds good.
You have my phone number.
Shoot me a text.
Yes.
All right.
I do.
Yep.
Thank you.
All right, John.
Remember how confidently Ted talked about the MDX during the negotiation
when we required an independent pre-purchase inspection before Dave and Gretchen bought it?
He got a little nervous about that, but a lot of dealers do.
That's why we asked for the inspection.
A great price only matters if the vehicle checks out.
And this one did.
The MDX passed with flying colors.
Dave and Gretchen bought it and their own banker independently confirmed
that they were surprised by what a great deal this was.
We can do this for you too, whether you're buying new or used.
We get moving quickly and I stay available by text or phone
while your coach works on your deal.
I never unplug from your situation.
We also understand that your plans can change once you start shopping.
Some services charge $500 if you change vehicles or 250 bucks if you change trim levels.
If you haven't seen this on other car buying services,
make sure you scroll all the way down to their bottom of their page and you'll see it.
We don't charge that.
If a different vehicle or trim is the better choice for you,
you shouldn't be penalized for choosing it.
To see how our car buying service works, visit thehomeworkguy.com
and click on the big red button on the homepage.
We'd love to help you get your next deal done.
I'm Kevin Hunter, The Homework Guy.
Thank you for watching.
You guys rock and God bless you all.