Why Is the United States Really 12 Different Nations?

Geography By Geoff
3 followers
Sep 25, 2026
One nation is how the United States refers to itself. But in reality, this isn't correct.
In fact, within the United States, there are 12 competing regions that have their own cultures,
values, and priorities. And these regions really act more like independent nations
under a single flag. So what are the 12 nations of America?
The United States has long been viewed as a single nation, a union of states under one flag
But beneath the surface lies something deeper. America isn't one nation. It's 12.
I'm not the first person to notice this either. Journalist Colin Woodard originally proposed 11
American nations in his book, American Nations. But what I've done is expanded his nations to
reflect two major changes. The inclusion of Hawaii as its own unique nation, and the creation of a
Spanish Caribbean nation that includes both southern Florida and Puerto Rico. Both areas
that are distinct from the nearby regions. So with that said, let's get to the nations.
If you were to look at a cultural map of the United States, you'd see something very different
from the one you learned in school. Instead of state lines, you'd see 12 fluid, overlapping
territories stretching across traditional borders and sometimes even national ones.
But for this video, we're going to focus just on the nations within the United States,
starting in the northeast. Rooted in New England and stretching into upstate New York, Michigan,
Wisconsin, and parts of Minnesota is the nation of Yankeedom. On a map, it hugs the northeastern
part of the US and most of the Great Lakes. Centered around New York City and parts of
northern New Jersey and the Hudson Valley is the nation of New Netherlands. Moving south
in central Pennsylvania and heading westward across Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and parts of
Iowa and Missouri is the Midlands. Found along the Chesapeake Bay in eastern Virginia and parts
of Maryland and North Carolina is the nation of Tidewater. It resembles the remnant of old
colonies along the Atlantic. West of Tidewater is Greater Appalachia, a broad, rugged band that
stretches from the hills of western Pennsylvania down through West Virginia, eastern Kentucky,
and Tennessee into Arkansas and parts of Texas. Moving south once more and dominating much of
Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, and parts of Louisiana and Texas is the Deep South.
In the far south and consisting of southern Florida, especially Miami, and Puerto Rico is
the Spanish Caribbean nation. Tucked in between the Gulf of Mexico and the Deep South nation
is the nation of New France. Moving westward, spanning from southern California and Arizona
across New Mexico and into West Texas is the nation of El Norte. North of El Norte and covering a vast
swath of interior California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, parts of western Texas,
and the Dakotas, and much of mainland Alaska is the Far West nation. In the far north and west
is the Left Coast, a narrow but powerful strip along the Pacific, stretching from the San Francisco
Bay area up through Portland and Seattle and into the Alaska archipelago. And finally, thousands of
miles away from the mainland is the nation of Hawaii. These 12 nations have different politics,
cultures, values, and social trends, and they don't follow state boundaries, which were often
arbitrarily made at the time and didn't really factor in how actual cultures might develop.
For this reason, the American nations expand beyond in ways that we're not really accustomed to.
Which brings us to the geography and history of each nation. Before we dive deeper into the 12
nations of America, it's worth asking, how can we all live in the same country and yet see the world
so differently? That's where today's sponsor, Ground News, comes in. Ground News is an app and website
made by a former NASA engineer who saw how news outlets and social algorithms often feed false
biases. Ground News counters that by gathering all of the world's news in one place so you can see
what's being reported on and how it's being reported across the political spectrum. Take this
headline with 30 different sources. Walking faster may reduce the risk of abnormal heart rhythms.
Sounds simple, right? What's wild is that even something as simple as walking can become
regionally charged. In places like Yankee Dome with denser walkable cities, it might be framed
as common sense. In the Deep South, however, it's more of a lifestyle shift. Ground News helps me
explore these coverage divides in real time and understand the bias baked into our national
discourse. Something that's never been more important in a country this culturally fractured.
So if you're looking for a way to see through the politics of news reporting, go to groundnews.com
slash GeoByJeff to get 40% off their Vantage plan for unlimited access. Remember to subscribe by
using my link in the description or by scanning the QR code to get this discount for a limited time
so you can cut through the biases. Where people settled and how they came to shape the land
are at the heart of how each nation came to be. The cultural lines that define these 12 nations
don't align with modern state borders. Because that's not how nations are actually formed.
Look at Europe for example. Each country looks organic rather than the artificial straight lines
that make up the individual states. This is because they follow linguistic and cultural
borders that were formed over hundreds of years. Because of this, each nation in the United States
similarly grew from a distinct historic root, which was influenced by its surrounding landscape.
Here's how the geography and history shaped each nation.
Yankeedom emerged from the Puritan colonies of New England. Settlers arrived seeking a religious
utopia and quickly organized around towns, churches, and schools. The geography, rocky soil,
dense forests, and harsh winters wasn't ideal for large plantations, but perfect for close-knit,
self-sufficient communities. This created a legacy of town halls, universities, and civic
institutions that still defines the region today, even as far west as the state of Minnesota.
Meanwhile, New Netherlands was originally founded by the Dutch as a commercial trading post
and grew in the sheltered natural harbor around modern-day New York City. Because of its unique
geography, New Netherlands encouraged maritime trade, immigration, and urban density. The Dutch
legacy of religious tolerance, multiculturalism, and commerce remains central to its character
today. And then there's the Midlands, with its rolling hills, fertile farmland, and navigable
rivers. The Midlands were settled by English Quakers and German immigrants who envisioned a
pluralistic, agrarian, middle-class society primarily focused on the colony of Pennsylvania,
but encompassing places as far west as Missouri and Iowa. Its geography lent itself to family farms,
and its central location helped it evolve into the political swing region of the United States.
Tidewater developed along the Chesapeake Bay and eastern North Carolina. Its wide,
navigable rivers and access to the Atlantic made it ideal for plantation agriculture
and transatlantic trade. This region was settled by English gentry, and its flat,
coastal plains supported a hierarchical society based on tobacco, enslavement,
and exporting agriculture for wealth. The rugged Appalachian Mountains, of course,
define Greater Appalachia. This nation is isolated, and heavily forested in the east,
but rich in natural resources. Originally settled by Scot-Irish frontiersmen,
Greater Appalachia developed a fiercely independent culture shaped by subsistence
farming and clan loyalty. The mountains both isolated the region and protected its traditions.
This rough and tough rural mentality extended as far west as northern Texas.
Formed by slaveholding elites in the south, the deep south's flat, humid coastal plains
and river deltas were perfect for cotton and sugar plantations. This geography enabled a brutal
plantation economy supported by enslavement, which in turn gave it its distinct African-American
culture today. Its original aristocratic culture, racial caste system, and economic inequality
can be traced back to this colonial foundation. Southern Florida and Puerto Rico form the Spanish
Caribbean nation. This region is tropical, coastal, and deeply influenced by Caribbean
migration and trade, and the Spanish language. Spanish colonial roots, Catholicism, and African
Caribbean cultural influences are strong here, especially in cities like Miami and San Juan.
This geography makes it the prime gateway between the US and Latin America.
New France is tucked geographically at the mouth of the Mississippi, making it unusually small but
united by its French heritage. The Mississippi River and bayous enabled trade and settlement
by the French and later Creoles. Because of this historic settlement pattern, Catholicism,
language, and cuisine make it distinct from the deep south. Spanning deserts, mountains,
and the fertile valleys from Southern California to Texas and into Southern Colorado is El Norte.
Because of its geographic location, the Spanish were actually the first Europeans here,
establishing missions, presidios, and ranches long before English settlers arrived on the east
coast. Its borderland identity is shaped by bilingualism, Catholicism, and resilience to
an overwhelmingly arid environment. Dominated by the Rocky Mountains, the Great Basin deserts,
and Arctic tundras of Alaska, the far west was the last American region to be settled in large
numbers. Its harsh environment required massive government infrastructure from dams and railroads
to military bases and eventual airports to support human settlements. Even today,
it's a land of low population and high federal presence because the federal government actually
owns most of its land. The left coast is where rugged mountains meet the mighty Pacific Ocean
and encompass the coastal areas of Northern California, Oregon, Washington, and the Alaskan
Panhandle. Settled first by Yankees and later by global immigrants, its culture fuses Eastern
Reformism with Western Libertarianism, and its geography, temperate climate, seismic activity,
fertile valleys, and vast forests encourage experimentation, progressivism, and innovation.
And finally, as an isolated volcanic archipelago, Hawaii's geography is unlike any other US region.
Settled by Polynesians and later transformed by American missionaries and Asian laborers,
its culture reflects Pacific traditions, Asian fusion, and deep ties to the ocean. The island's
isolation helped preserve indigenous identity even amid colonization, meaning Hawaiian is a
common language to this day. Geography and history is embedded within each nation, and each continues
to evolve because of these lines today. The United States has always struggled to define what it is.
A melting pot, a patchwork, a union, an experiment. But one thing is increasingly clear,
it has never truly been one single nation. It's a federation of cultures, worldviews,
and identities that have coexisted, sometimes uneasily, under the same flag. That reality
becomes easier to see when you stop thinking in terms of states or party lines and start thinking
in terms of deep-rooted cultural regions. Take a look at the way Americans behave politically as
an example. National elections often hinge on so-called swing states. But when you zoom in
closer, it's the swing regions within those states that actually move the needle. The blue cities of
Yankeedom clash with the red, rural counties of Greater Appalachia, sometimes within the same
state. Southern Florida historically voted nothing like the Florida Panhandle, though that trend has
changed recently due to shifting political ideologies of Cuban migrants and a growing
retiree population. And far northern California has little in common with Los Angeles. It's this
cultural geography that tells the real story. These nations are not based on modern trends or
media bubbles. They're grounded in centuries of history. And these differences aren't superficial
either. They explain why Americans often seem to be speaking past each other, locked in a cultural
cold war. The fights over guns, healthcare, education, and religion aren't just political,
they're geographic. The left coast and the far west may both be part of California,
but one is progressive and coastal with a desire to restrict gun rights and advance universal
healthcare, while the other is libertarian and inland with a passion for low taxes and less
government intervention in their lives. Meanwhile, El Norte sees the border not as a dividing line,
but as a zone of shared identity with Mexico, contrasted with Greater Appalachia, which sees
the border as something that needs to be hardened and made less permeable. Meanwhile, the Spanish
Caribbean, anchored in places like Miami and San Juan, functions with a bilingual, bicultural,
Spanish-inspired rhythm distinct from anything in the Deep South or Yankeedom. None of this
is just a cultural quirk. It affects the governance of each nation. Trying to craft
one-size-fits-all federal policy in a country this fragmented is like trying to sew a quilt
from 12 different fabrics using a single thread. You see it in the endless political gridlock,
in states suing the federal government over mandates, in regions going their own way on
issues like abortion, climate, and immigration. The culture wars aren't a glitch in the system,
they're the system playing out across an invisible map that very few people acknowledge. But when you
do acknowledge that map and see the United States as these 12 nations, it explains so much. It
explains why San Francisco, California, and Los Angeles, California, look and feel so different.
Or why New Orleans, Louisiana, is so different from Mobile, Alabama, despite their geographic
proximity. It explains why some states feel like they're being governed by outsiders. It also
explains why unity is hard and why division comes so easily. The idea of the United States as a
single people has always been more aspiration than reality. What holds the country together
isn't shared culture, but shared infrastructure. Roads, currency, federal programs, a military. But
culturally and politically, the US operates more like a loosely bound confederation. Not red and
blue, but a mosaic of nations that coexist, cooperate, compete, and sometimes clash. Understanding
the country through this lens doesn't solve the problems, but it at least makes them less
intimidating. In fact, it offers a way to reframe political conflict not as irrational partisanship,
but as the natural friction between fundamentally different regional identities. And so, with all
that said, if these nations did actually exist, what would they look like today? Which would be
most populous, and which would be the wealthiest? If the United States were to break apart, not just
politically, but culturally and geographically, it probably wouldn't fracture into red and blue
states. It would likely splinter along the lines of these 12 nations, or something close to it.
During that time, some would thrive, others would struggle, and a few would quickly seek
alliances with the others to stay afloat. Yankeedom, with a population of nearly 58 million
and a median income close to $57,000, would be a powerful nation. It would inherit much of the
intellectual, educational, and technological infrastructure of the Northeast and the Great
Lakes. With elite universities, corporate headquarters, and deep ties to Canada and
Western Europe, Yankeedom would function as a progressive, internationally-oriented republic.
Yankeedom would find a natural ally in the Left Coast. A smaller nation in terms of population,
but wealthier per capita, and similarly forward-thinking in tech, sustainability,
and civil liberties. A Yankeedom-Left Coast alliance would be a powerful and progressive
counterweight to the other blocs. Greater Appalachia, on the other hand, would be one of
largest nations by population and land, but lower in income and higher in internal division.
Culturally rugged and libertarian-leaning, it might resist federal-style unity altogether,
opting instead for a loosely aligned federation or even full decentralization. After all,
how do you tie Appalachia to Oklahoma and Northern Texas? Culturally, it would likely have deep ties
to the Far West, another vast and sparsely populated nation, and could lead to a rural
alliance focused on resource extraction, states' rights, and small government.
The Deep South, with 45 million people and a median income below $44,000, would likely emerge
as a conservative powerhouse with strong emphasis on tradition, religion, and business-friendly
policies. Its historic distrust of centralized government might persist, but its internal
cohesion would make it a formidable independent entity. It would also be the region with the
highest African-American population, perhaps shifting it politically in ways not expected.
It could easily ally itself with Greater Appalachia and parts of the Far West on cultural
issues, forming a socially conservative coalition. El Norte would be uniquely positioned. With over
34 million people, a relatively young population, and a bilingual workforce, it could become a
bridge not just culturally, but economically, between North and Central America. Its economic
would come from cross-border trade, agriculture, and a strong labor ethic. El Norte would likely
partner with the Spanish-speaking Spanish Caribbean, which includes Southern Florida
and Puerto Rico. Though separated by geography, their shared language, religion, and cultural
foundations could build a pan-Caribbean coalition with strong ties to Latin America and Spain.
New Netherlands, anchored by New York City, would be small in size, but a global giant in finance,
media, and international diplomacy. With the highest population density,
high income, and global reach, it would likely function more like a city-state
such as Singapore. It would also have close ties to Yankeedom, though due to its status
as a global center for finance and trade, it may wish to remain politically neutral overall.
Speaking of smaller nations, Tidewater, with a relatively small and aging population,
might find itself squeezed between the ambitions of its neighbors. Historically aristocratic and
now a region of retirees, it might depend on alliances with either the Deep South or New
Netherlands for economic and political stability. The Midlands, straddling the cultural middle,
would face a hard choice. Politically moderate with about 37 million people and middling income,
it could swing either way, joining the Yankeedom Left Coast Progressive Coalition or partnering
with the Deep South or Greater Appalachia for pragmatic reasons. Its fate might hinge on
leadership and external pressure. Of all regions, the Midlands are the most likely to swing between
the different nations. New France, with only about 3 million people, might also struggle to see where
it fits in. New France would likely align with the Deep South, though culturally it stands apart in
language, cuisine, and worldview. Of all nations, New France would leave the biggest question mark
for how it would evolve as a nation. Finally, Hawaii would be small but uniquely
positioned geopolitically. Its high income and strong ties to Asia and the Pacific would make
it a diplomatic and military keystone in the Pacific. While isolated, it could remain neutral,
non-aligned, or form a Pacific alliance with the Left Coast. In raw numbers, the largest
nations by population would be Greater Appalachia, Yankeedom, and the Deep South, while the smallest
would be Hawaii, New France, and the Spanish Caribbean. The largest by area size would be
the Far West, Greater Appalachia, and Yankeedom, while the smallest would be New Netherlands,
Hawaii, and the Spanish Caribbean. The wealthiest per capita would be New Netherlands, Hawaii,
and the Left Coast, while the poorest would be the Spanish Caribbean, the Deep South,
and El Norte. Finally, the youngest would be El Norte, New France, and New Netherlands,
while the oldest would be Hawaii, Yankeedom, and the Spanish Caribbean.
If the United States were to divide, it wouldn't do so evenly. Power would consolidate around
urban cores, ports, and cultural hubs, just like it does with every nation. Border regions
might become flashpoints or bridges. Long-simmering tensions could ignite or be resolved. But what's
clear is this. A split United States wouldn't just be 50 smaller pieces. It would more likely
become 12 vastly different nations, each with its own priorities, challenges, and sense of identity.
And in some ways, it already is. The U.S. is a single country, of course. But culturally,
it is broken up into different nations. And honestly, you can say the same for basically
every country that exists today. Speaking of different countries,
this week I'm exploring the ancient ruins of the Khmer Empire's capital city, Angkor.
So if that sounds interesting to you, come join me over on my other channel.
I hope you enjoyed learning all about the American nations and my unique spin on it.
If you did, maybe you should check out this video all about 15
amazing geography facts of the United States. Thanks for watching, see you next time.
