What does matter and antimatter annihilate into? How do we know what happened before the CMB? Is outer space dirty? And in Q&A+, initial thoughts about Seestar S50 pro.
00:00 Intro 00:48 [@SirIke49] What do matter and antimatter annihilate into? 05:00 [@nitstyles13] How do we know what happened before the CMB? 12:36 [@Wackyg6] Question from a 6 yr old. Is outer space dirty? 15:17 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
What does matter and antimatter annihilate into? How do we know what happened before
the Cosmic Microwave Background? Is outer space dirty? And in Q&A Plus,
what are my initial thoughts about the Seastar S50 Pro? All this and more in this week's question
show. It's time for the question show your questions my answers as always wherever you
are across my channel. If a question pops in your brain just write it down I'll gather them up and
I will answer them here again. I am recording from a bird lip UK, which is I guess it means
bird flap where the place is so steep that only birds would be able to fly from here or something.
And it is like the most dog central place in the world. I'm surrounded by barking dogs,
but hopefully I can like just slip in a recording before we get more of it. All right,
let's get into the questions. Cirky, when matter and antimatter touch,
annihilate each other. Annihilate into what? As I understand E equals mc squared means that energy
and matter are the same thing. So wouldn't they still be there? They annihilate into energy. So
when you have a particle of matter and its corresponding particle of antimatter and they
touch, they annihilate into pure energy. And the amount that of energy that is released
is corresponding to the E equals mc squared. So you put in the E is the amount of energy,
I think in joules is equal to the mass of that is being annihilated times the speed of light
squared. And that tells you how much energy is produced. And it's produced in gamma radiation
in a very specific wavelength of life that is produced. And this idea of energy and matter
being the same thing or being equivalent, right, this is this idea that Einstein figured out.
And we can sort of go at this in two different ways. As you said, we can take matter, we can
take antimatter, you have mass, you touch them together, they annihilate into pure energy. But
we can also take energy and we can feed it into a particle accelerator. We can speed up particles
that are going round and round. You have them going 99.9999% the speed of light. You've
injected a ton of energy into these particles, say protons that are going around in this particle
accelerator, and then you smash them together, you're generating new particles that are much
heavier than a proton, because you are turning all of that energy that that kinetic energy that
you've imbued into the particle into mass into matter. And you can use the equals mc squared to
get you there. So yeah, gamma radiation is the result. There is this gamma radiation that's
coming from the center of the Milky Way. And there doesn't seem to be anything in the center of the
Milky Way that could explain this additional gamma radiation. It looks like it is from matter
antimatter collisions happening at the center of the Milky Way. And the question is why,
like what is the cause of this? And so there's a bunch of ideas. One is that you've got this
supermassive black hole, and it's a very energetic environment. And so theoretically,
you could be getting particles of antimatter that are being generated in the magnetic fields that
are around the supermassive black hole. Another idea is that there are a lot of pulsars at the
center of the Milky Way. And again, these pulsars, they're rapidly spinning, they are,
they have these magnetic fields and the magnetic fields can generate particles of of antimatter
that then find particles of matter and then you get this gamma radiations coming from the center
of the Milky Way. And the other idea is that there could be particles of dark matter that are
being compressed very tightly, maybe around the supermassive black hole at the center of the
Milky Way. And these particles of dark matter are annihilating with each other, and they are
generating the same kind of gamma radiation that you might get from annihilating matter and
antimatter. So we see this, we see this out there in the universe, we detect this telltale glow
of gamma radiation and that tells us that you've got matter and antimatter. And this is the kind
of thing you would use to find a spacecraft, right? We know that antimatter is sort of the only
type of dense energy storage that could be used to be able to move spacecraft from star system to
star system. And so we can look out into the universe and look for this very specific
sources of gamma radiation. And that would tell us that there are spacecraft out there
using their antimatter drives to move from star system to star system.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above. Thomas Pergle, Patrick Dietz,
Stephen Kay, Commander Tycho Yamada, Rich Sowa, Derek Kelly, Michael Wolfe, Jeff,
Matt Estabrook, and Juan Madrigal. Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Nick Stiles, recent astronomy cast episode on the beginning of the universe had me wondering how we
know what happened during the initial seconds after the Big Bang, if we only have data from
the CMB 300,000 years after the Big Bang. Yeah, so the cosmic microwave background radiation,
this is also known as the time of last scattering. And this is the time when the universe had
finally cooled down, that it became transparent, that photons emitted by the ionized plasma that
was the entire universe could finally move and not just be reabsorbed into another particle and
then re-emitted and reabsorbed and so on. They could actually move. And in fact, when we look
out into space in all directions, we're seeing this time of last scattering. We're seeing these
photons that were emitted the moment the universe had cooled down to this very important temperature.
And this time corresponds to 380,000 years after the Big Bang. And so the question you're asking
is like, well, how do we know what came before that? And there's only two answers. One answer
is that we can't know because the universe was opaque. We cannot observe the universe directly
at a time that was earlier than when it was opaque. Now, there are other multi-messenger astronomy
techniques for us to be able to look earlier than that. One is neutrinos. We know that neutrinos
can escape from a star as it's in the process of going supernova. And so neutrinos were emitted
during the Big Bang and shortly after the Big Bang and while nucleosynthesis was happening in
the universe. And those neutrinos could get out. And so when we build that next generation
neutrino detector, the one capable of detecting the primordial neutrinos, we should be able to
beyond that barrier that we can't see in the visible light. The other one is gravitational
waves. That the Big Bang, the expansion of spacetime, these were colossal events and
there would have been these ripples in spacetime that would have happened from that moment. And
that those also would have gone through this opaque contents of the universe and would be
detectable. But we're going to require, again, totally next generation gravitational wave
observatories. So how do we know the first few fractions of a second after the Big Bang and
leading up to that 380,000 years? And the answer is that particle physicists have done the experiments
that mimic the conditions of the universe at these various times. So the first number that you get
is the ratio of hydrogen to helium in the universe. And we know that the universe is roughly
75% hydrogen, 25% helium. And the only way that you can get that is that if you had a time when
the universe was kind of like the interior of a star. So, so compressed that the universe was
kind of like a star and that you would essentially have the same kind of nucleosynthesis, same kind
fusion that was going on inside, say a star like the sun, but it was the entire universe. Now the,
the actual fusion process is like a little bit different than what you get inside of a star,
but roughly you've got hydrogen being smashed into and creating helium as well as a fraction of other
kinds of elements, a little bit of lithium, a little bit of beryllium. And you can sort of
fine tune and know that, okay, we know the universe was opaque so that you could get the
cosmic microwave background radiation. And we know that like from the three minute mark
to the 12 minute mark, the entire universe was like the inside of a star. So that tells you
that next part. And then we also know that the various fundamental forces of the universe were
once single forces. So we know that like right now we have gravity, we have the strong force,
the weak force and electromagnetism. And there was a time when electromagnetism and the weak
force were one force and that we can mimic that time with particle colliders. Essentially,
there are giant labs on earth where they can mimic these conditions. And that gives you a sense of
what the universe was like at that time. And that there was a time when the strong force and the
weak force and electromagnetism were all one force. And again, we can kind of mimic that
in the lab. You essentially smash particles together and you can get a sense of what the
universe was like when those forces were all one force. And that gets you to just a fraction of a
second after the Big Bang. Now, it's assumed that there was also some time when gravity was part of
that as well. There was just one unified force that contained gravity, the strong force, the
weak force, electromagnetism. Researchers have not been able to generate that in the lab yet.
And and that all of those sort of pieces of the puzzle explain the universe that we find
ourselves in today. We see that cosmic microwave background radiation. We see the the relative
ratios of those various elements. We even can see the the large scale structure of the universe,
which is arranged into these sort of echoes of when the universe was much, much denser.
What is today giant walls of galaxies, huge voids in between those used to be ripples of density
in the early universe. And so there's always independent lines of evidence that tells the
Big Bang happened. And then the sort of the one that takes you right to the very beginning,
that part where you go like the universe started off the size of a proton and then it ended up
being the size of a grapefruit is this idea of inflation. And this comes from a way to explain
some problems with the Big Bang, that the Big Bang was the flattest problem and the sort of
the ability for parts of the universe to to communicate with itself. The only way you could
explain this is if there was a really rapid expansion early on. And so this was largely
hypothetical, but there is some evidence that this actually you can see these echoes of this
rapid expansion in the large scale structure of the universe today. You can see that the
background radiation. So it's this sort of really interesting detective work that's been done
looking along multiple lines of evidence. And it's the same process. How do we know
that plate tectonics happens on Earth? How do we know that Africa and South America were once
joined? And you have a bunch of lines of evidence. You can measure the movement of the plates. You
can see how they're moving apart from each other. You can find lines of of mineral deposits that are
on one continent and then you find them on the other continent and they perfectly line up. Or
you can find fossils of an animal on one continent and then fossils of the animal on the other
continent at roughly the same spot. And so you could just tell that at one point in the past
they were connected and that they were now sort of separating apart. So, you know, it's the same
thing. There isn't this direct evidence yet. There sure will be when the next generation
gravitational wave observatories and the neutrino observatories come online. But there is all of this
these separate lines of evidence that build up the story of what the early universe was like.
Wacky G. Question from a six-year-old. She wants to know if outer space is dirty. Kind of. Yeah. So
space itself, if you're just like out in outer space, you're in the void between stars, you're in
the interplanetary void, the interstellar void, then you're in a hard vacuum, a harder vacuum
than anything we have here on Earth. There is literally nothing there, but there's like not
totally nothing. There's mostly nothing, but there is a little bit of something. And that is in every
meter there are a couple of particles of dust. There is a handful of atoms and there's more here
in the solar system than there is in interstellar space. And if you're out in the very, the total
depths of the voids in between galaxies, then there's just really a handful of particles.
But one of the things that we see a lot of around galaxies is dust. And this is this term,
we use this term dust here on the channel all the time. We'll talk about how you've got gas and dust
that is surrounding a new star system, that it's going to form planets. But what is that dust?
Well, the dust is kind of soot. It's kind of like smoke that has been ejected from exploding stars
or stars near the end of their lives, or supermassive black holes that are actively
feeding and crunching up material and blowing out these streams of this dust. And that if you could
actually touch it, it would be like smoke coming off of a fire. And so you can decide, is that
dirty? It kind of is, but it's just that the individual particles are going to be really,
really far apart. If you're beside smoke, then there's millions of particles per, I don't know,
cubic centimeter. And yet if you're out in interstellar, intergalactic space, then you're
going to have just a couple of particles every cubic meter. But when you look at these really
big spaces, then enough of those dust particles are out there that they are obscuring our view.
When we try to look to the center of the Milky Way, we can't see it because of this dust,
because of this smoke, because of this soot that would make your hands dirty if you could
collect enough of it and rub it between your fingers. Man, I love questions from six-year-olds,
that's the best. Did you know you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question
over on Patreon completely for free? We call it Q&A Plus. This week's bonus question,
what do I think about the Seastar S50 Pro? I'm going to put a link down in the show notes.
All right, those are all the questions that we had this episode. Thank you everyone who asked
your questions into the YouTube comments, everybody who joined me for the live show.
I'm going to respond to a comment about science and politics,
but first I'd like to thank our Patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, André Pedretti, Balthazar, GalacticInvader, Brian Bode,
Cairdwen, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Bayluck, David Gilton, David Matts, Evan.pro, James Clark,
Jeremy Madden, Jim Burke, Marcel, Spencer, Michael Purcell, NASAOceanGuide, NordSpace,
OneStepRadarModels.org, Weyla.Travel, please follow my nephew at vbrick699,
Forben, Kaidi, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Team49, TelescopesCanada, Vlad Shipplin, Wolfgang
Klotz, Zelda Fraser. No, getting involved is what he wants. Who support us? At the Master
of the Universe level and all our Patrons. All your support means the universe to us.
So I got this comment on a recent video from Thomas A.
Scientists are not objective on any politically sensitive matter. Very little trust in scientists
today. Obviously, I disagree. And I think, you know, that there is a narrative out there that
there is money being spent by companies, by lobbyists that are trying to erode the public's
science in this exact way that you are describing. To take issues which are scientific in nature,
and then push them to frame them as being political in nature. And I think a great example
of this would be, say, climate change, right? Climate change is not a political question.
It is a scientific question. Either the planet is warming up and humans are responsible for it,
or it's not, and we're not. That is a scientific question. Now, what we're going to do about it,
what kind of actions we need to take, when should we start, where should we spend our money
to best battle this, or not, whatever. These are all, can be political questions, for sure.
But to question the scientific veracity of whether or not this is happening, and the work that the
scientists are doing, is a political move. Is a way to try and undermine the work of scientists
so that you can continue selling oil for longer, or make more money, or whatever, right? And then
see this across the board. We're seeing this, we saw this with COVID, we see this with a lot of
other places where scientific expertise runs directly into the money, the political preferences
of certain groups. And this is where the power move is to cast aspersions on the scientists,
to say they're getting political. When they're not getting political, they're just doing good science
and people can decide how they want to interpret or not. And the ramifications is that we are now
in a world where there is a deep distrust in science and expertise, and a lot of the stuff
that got us to this place where we're at today. I'm standing in the middle of a field, holding a
camera that is the size of a remote control for a television, smaller. And I am recording this
through the internet, or transferring this through the internet, from halfway around the world.
And you're watching this on a computer, while satellites are overhead, right? Science. And yet,
where it is sort of politically expedient, where there's money to be made, you can increase the
distrust in science. And like, I'm sure in the comments, there's going to be all of these comments
from people who are like, yeah, I agree with you, except for this one thing that I don't think is
real. That thing is also probably real, probably done by scientists, and that someone out there
is making a lot of money, making you distrust the work that they do. And so, just before you
automatically believe the narrative, you know, do your own research to figure out who maybe
is being financially incentivized to cause you to distrust the work of scientists.
All right, we'll see you next time.